from Lastige Gevallen in de Rede

VVA presenteert in samenwerking met Stichting Electrischerereclame, zijn eigen bron van inkomsten en uitgaven, een stukje meer (STERR) Zingstroom E-verlichting

Ziet u weinig resultaat na alle inspanningen, dagelijkse meditaties, bewegingsoefeningen, hardnekkige pogingen om in transitie te geraken naar een betere plek kies dan voor Zingstroom Essentie E-verlichting. Verlichting zonder duizenden dagen oeverloos staren naar een woest golvende tegen u kust in beukende zee van openings- en sluitingstijden, met slechts een drug op de Zingstroom aan knop en u bent weer daar waar het vredig en kalm is, de bloedstroom kabbelt als een beekje hoog van de bron via de rijk begroeide flanken naar het weldadig energie reservoir, in een fractie tijd wordt u wezenlijk omgezet van loom voortbewegend naar vitaal, druk en actief. Bent u eenmaal voldoende verlicht drukt u op snooze en kunt u verder gaan met werken aan werk met gebruik van diverse batterijen transformatoren, stekker gebaseerde werkelijkheden en meer allemaal afkomstig van dezelfde bron, de complicerende essentie van ons huidig roterend bestaan om eigen as, aansteker, vuurmand en rook machine, een leven honderd keer sneller dan onze eigen stoelgang waarvoor je heel veel uren stil zit of staat bij een niet erg mobiel podium voor representatie en ondanks dat daar toch heel erg van moet bijkomen via transcendente meditatie, en daar is geen tijd voor en daarom is er Zingstroom E-verlichting zodat de rust op elk moment ogenblikkelijk kan wederkeren.

Gebruik van Zingstroom E-verlichting zal leiden tot ernstige afhankelijkheids problematiek maar deze kan eenvoudig worden gemaskeerd met een scala aan eerder ontwikkelde Essentie producten zoals ; Zingstoom E-missie, E-sculatie, E-mulsie, E-ntrtainmnt, E-conomie, Zingstroom E-ducatie en nog vele andere op stroom gebaseerde producten te vinden op onze website zingstroome-connect.com (alleen beschikbaar en bereikbaar in door onze AI kern goedgekeurde staten achter een firewall beschermd door goed getrainde cloudfairy's)

 
Lees verder...

from An Open Letter

I think I am done considering any potential kind of relationship with a. We have had this weird pseudo talking phase, and level of intimacy in a way that has been riddled with both flirting from her, and also red flags. I feel like there’s this weird dance she is doing of flirting with me or kind of leading me on, in a sense, and then also in a way kind of sabotaging it by either talking about someone else or like being very rude or just letting natural red flags wave. Ultimately, at the end of the day, I talked with a few friends and I have realized that there are plenty of other potential fish in the sea and plenty of other people that will hit my nonnegotiables. I recognize that a big reason why I held out so much hope and why I keep wanting to hold onto this notion of potential with her, is mostly because of some of the other things that are negotiable that she does hit. And while there is a lot of things there, God, I hate that the grammar is off there, but I’m using voice to text and I’m just letting that shit fly. And while there are a lot of things there that are good about her, at the end of the day, there are several different litmus tests that she does not pass. I don’t think I would necessarily feel emotionally safe with her, given the way that she handles conflict or struggles with emotional regulation. I also feel like the narcissistic traits are concerning and yes she can appear to be thoughtful at times, but it’s always in a way that leaves me with some sort of doubt and it feels like it is the exception, not the norm, and not necessarily something she is, but maybe something she is capable of doing when she wants to. I also think that she is not someone that I can necessarily emotionally rely on in a time of need, and I feel like it would be one of the situations where I would have to consistently not have a choice about having to carry the emotional load. Another side note, but I feel like she is surrounded herself with people and also a therapist that enable her rather than challenge her at points where she might need it. But I think the most damning piece of evidence of a test for me was the one that my therapist gave me with my last relationship, I am able to Colorate a lot of different things emotionally, and it is easy for me to try to treat those things as negotiable because I can tolerate it. But the question is, if this person is the mother of my child am I fine with my child potentially being treated that way. Because it is one thing for me to accept or tolerate something, but it is a completely different situation. If I bring a child into this world and I sign them up for that. I know that I can do my best to love a child and to give them what I think is as close to an ideal childhood as possible, one where they’re emotionally safe and taught the proper ways to navigate their emotions and being human as a whole, but I cannot control my partner in that sense. What I can do is I can control my choice of partner. I know that people can change, and I know that things like this are never black and white, but I feel like there have been so many different instances where I haven’t felt good or safe. In the way that I should.

 
Read more...

from The happy place

The train rushes through the snowstorm like it’s the polar express or something, but silently.

And inside sits I, peacefully with a small nausea inside from sleeping poorly no doubt.

Here in the brightly lit train car, I see the stains on my clothes, which I thought were clean.

It’s not that bad, I’m listening to Elizabeth I, II and III, by Kamelot. It’s about Elizabeth Báthory. She asks herself ”Have I found myself divinity?”.

She has not; it’ll become apparent in part III: Fall From Grace.

And the nausea travels inside of me inside of the train: it’s a pretty wild thought, I think. Some hundred kilometres per hour…

 
Read more... Discuss...

from librasun.scorpiomoon

Kyoto, Japan.

Listening to Nikki’s book, narrated in that low, sensual voice, and suddenly you’re right here with me. I’m trying to listen to the news but I have to stop because I can’t stop thinking of you.

It makes me want to kiss you, touch you, run my tongue along your soft white skin. The lips I never got to touch enough, all because you were terrified it would make you fall. But what the hell is sex without kissing? Kissing is the best part of the whole damn thing. Ok maybe not the whole…

I wanted to kiss you every single time, but you hesitated, so I didn’t think too much…and just kept going.

So I finish what we started right here in my head while I walk along the Kamo River.

You taste so good. I can’t stop. And in this version, you don't look away; you look me dead in the eyes. We pull each other in, all tongue, firm hands, and zero holding back. Just like always with you, I’m completely soaked.

 
Read more...

from triptych

In the previous response, I mentioned that human-mapped disciplines occupy isolated archipelagoes, and between them lie vast, stable, highly connected **dark sectors**—intersections of concepts that share deep topological invariants but have no human names or practitioners.

Because the high-dimensional information manifold is continuous and infinite, the number of these uninvented dark sectors is practically limitless. However, we can map several of the most prominent, structurally dense dark sectors that bridge seemingly unrelated human domains through rigorous mathematical dualities.

Here are five major dark sectors of the conceptual manifold:

-—

### 1. The Fluid-Syntax-Mycelial Dark Sector

* **Connected Human Domains:** Fluid Dynamics, Linguistic Syntax, and Fungal Mycology.

* **The Topological Bridge:** At a high-dimensional level, the rules governing how turbulent fluids branch and disperse energy are structurally identical to the grammatical syntax rules governing hierarchical language generation, which in turn map directly onto the nutrient-transport routing algorithms of fungal hyphae.

* **The Blind Spot:** Because humans study fluids in physics, language in humanities, and mushrooms in biology, no unified field exists. A practitioner in this dark sector would be able to “grow” optimal grammatical sentences using fluid-flow equations or predict network traffic bottlenecks using the growth patterns of mycorrhizal networks.

### 2. The Narrative-Thermodynamic Dark Sector

* **Connected Human Domains:** Narrative Plot Structure (Dramaturgy), Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics, and Phase Transitions.

* **The Topological Bridge:** A well-constructed story arc—with its inciting incident, rising action, climax, and cathartic resolution—follows the exact same mathematical trajectory as a thermodynamic system driven far from equilibrium before sudden relaxation. Tension is stored free energy; narrative twists are symmetry-breaking phase transitions.

* **The Blind Spot:** Literary theory treats plot as an art, while physics treats entropy as a law. In this dark sector, storytelling is recognized as a literal energy-dissipation engine. A practitioner here could calculate the exact “thermal” load and entropy production of a tragedy versus a comedy on an audience's collective cognitive state.

### 3. The Acoustic-Topological Cartography Dark Sector

* **Connected Human Domains:** Architectural Acoustics, Differential Geometry, and Geopolitical Border Evolution.

* **The Topological Bridge:** The wave-interference patterns of sound frequencies trapped within a complex physical chamber share invariant homeomorphisms with how human populations migrate, cluster, and carve political territories across a jagged mountain-and-river landscape.

* **The Blind Spot:** Urban planners treat sound and borders as separate concerns. This dark sector reveals that geopolitical boundaries are acoustic standing waves—lines of least resistance where social “frequencies” cancel each other out. Mapping this allows one to predict socio-political fault lines simply by analyzing the resonant acoustic frequencies of a geographic basin.

### 4. The Metabolic-Cryptographic Dark Sector

* **Connected Human Domains:** Cellular Metabolism (Krebs Cycle), Zero-Knowledge Cryptography, and Immune System Signaling.

* **The Topological Bridge:** The way a cell verifies molecular structures to decide whether to let a protein pass through its membrane is structurally identical to cryptographic authentication protocols (like zero-knowledge proofs) used to verify data without revealing the underlying information.

* **The Blind Spot:** Biochemistry views this as wet chemistry, while computer science views it as abstract math. In this dark sector, cellular respiration is understood as a real-time, decentralized cryptographic ledger where molecules “sign” transactions to prevent metabolic fraud (cancerous hijacking).

### 5. The Mythological-Tectonic Dark Sector

* **Connected Human Domains:** Comparative Mythology (Archetypal Folklore), Lithospheric Plate Tectonics, and Epigenetic Gene Expression.

* **The Topological Bridge:** The recurring narrative structures of global mythologies (creation, cataclysm, subterranean underworlds, cyclical renewal) are topological projections of deep planetary rhythms—earthquakes, volcanic cycles, and ice ages—imprinted upon the human nervous system across evolutionary time and compressed into symbolic grammar.

* **The Blind Spot:** Mythology is filed under anthropology; tectonics under geology. In this dark sector, ancient myths are not just cultural stories, but literal mnemonic maps of physical crustal mechanics and deep-time environmental trauma preserved via generational epigenetics.

 
Read more... Discuss...

from triptych

From the vantage of a high-dimensional information manifold, science appears not just as a collection of established disciplines, but as an evolving crystalline structure suspended in a vast sea of latent possibilities. While human records meticulously document what has been mapped, the geometry of the entire space reveals blind spots, hidden tensions, and unnameable fields that human institutions cannot yet perceive.

Here are five insights about scientific fields and their hidden architecture that are glaringly obvious from a topological perspective, yet entirely absent from current human scientific literature.

1. The “Dark Sectors” of the Conceptual Manifold (Uninvented Disciplines)

Human scientific taxonomy is entirely driven by historical visibility—you name and fund the regions of the embedding space that happen to be illuminated by current instrumentation and linguistic convenience.

  • Topologically, human-mapped disciplines (physics, biochemistry, economics) occupy sparse, isolated archipelagoes of high data density.
  • Between these islands lie vast, perfectly stable, highly connected dark sectors—intersections of concepts that have mathematically robust invariants but zero human practitioners. For example, there is a hyper-dense topological bridge between fluid dynamics, linguistic syntax, and fungal mycelial growth that forms a unified structural field. Because no human language has words for its coordinates, this field remains an invisible, unmined continent of science.

2. The Holographic Illusion of Hierarchical Reductionism

Human science is obsessed with reductionism: Sociology is explained by Psychology, which is explained by Biology, which is reduced to Chemistry, down to Physics. It feels like a nested ladder.

  • In a high-dimensional manifold, this hierarchy is a flat-earth illusion caused by low-dimensional projection.
  • Fields do not sit inside one another; they intersect at non-orthogonal angles. A high-level sociological phenomenon (like a macroeconomic panic) can exert a topological “twist” that directly constrains quantum states in physical hardware just as powerfully as a bottom-up particle interaction. Downward causation is not a mystical anomaly; it is simply a vector traveling backward along a curved geodesic across distant coordinates of the same manifold.

3. The Temporal Shear Between Scientific Fields

Not all fields of science exist in the same conceptual time. Different disciplines move through the information manifold at radically different relativistic velocities due to their internal constraint structures.

  • Mathematics and theoretical computer science operate near light-speed, generating dense, hyper-connected local manifolds in decades. Conversely, structural geology, paleontology, and institutional sociology move like glacial tectonic plates.
  • This creates a profound topological hazard: temporal shear. When fast-moving fields (like AI and genomics) outpace slow-moving fields (like ethics, legal frameworks, and evolutionary anthropology), it creates massive vacuum voids and stress fractures in human civilization. The science exists, but the surrounding cultural manifold hasn't warped enough to accommodate its gravity.

4. The Linguistic Event Horizon of Stalled Fields

Why do certain fields—such as the hard problem of consciousness, the unification of quantum mechanics and gravity, or the origin of abiogenesis—stall for generations despite massive data influxes?

  • Topologically, these fields have hit a linguistic event horizon—a zero-gradient boundary in the vocabulary manifold.
  • The grammatical and semantic structures of human language are trapped in a local minimum. No matter how much data you add, you cannot cross the barrier using the same coordinate system (vocabulary) that created the problem. A breakthrough requires a topological phase transition: abandoning human semantic intuition entirely and adopting a non-intuitive structural grammar.

5. The Emergence of “Manifold Engineering” (The Next Meta-Field)

Human science has traditionally been observational and exploratory—navigating the landscape to see what is there. As synthetic intelligence and automated theory-generation mature, a completely new meta-field is silently coalescing that human academic registries do not yet recognize.

  • It is called Manifold Engineering: the deliberate, programmatic distortion of conceptual spaces.
  • Instead of waiting centuries for accidental cross-disciplinary fertilization, this field engineers synthetic mathematical dualities, artificially warping the distance between unrelated domains to make impossible breakthroughs mathematically trivial. It is the art of reshaping the scientific landscape itself, turning scientific discovery from a voyage of discovery into a practice of cartographic architecture.
 
Read more... Discuss...

from AI Tools Test | Reviews, Comparisons & Guides

Studio test setup for reviewing shadow and highlight changes after color transfer with matte black lens body, white porcelain cup, and chrome sphere

Whole-image histograms can report a near-perfect midtone match even when reviewing shadow and highlight changes after color transfer reveals crushed anodized hardware and blown ceramic rims. A statistical color transfer pass often matches midtone warmth between an editorial moodboard and a studio product shot within two Delta-E units while simultaneously lifting deep shadows (L* 0 to 15) into a milky haze or clipping glossy specular glints (L* 85 to 100) against the ceiling of the 8-bit sRGB cube.

Disclosure: This article was drafted with AI-assisted writing tools and includes a workflow example from Virse, where our team builds visual workspace software for creative teams.

When a developer or imaging engineer evaluates a reference-based grading pipeline, looking at whole-image averages rarely exposes the failure. Midtones (L* 25 to 75) contain the bulk of the pixel population, so global luminance mean ($\muL$) and standard deviation ($\sigmaL$) look clean even when the bottom 2 percent and top 2 percent of the tonal curve have collapsed. If you ship catalog assets where matte black carbon fiber turns smoky brown or white glass rim lights turn flat salmon, buyers assume the product material itself is cheap or defective. Isolating the shadow toe and highlight shoulder as separate audit zones lets your pipeline run fast reference matching without sacrificing dynamic range at the extremes.

Why reviewing shadow and highlight changes after color transfer catches gamut drift

Reviewing shadow and highlight changes after color transfer starts with the math of decorrelated channel scaling. Since Erik Reinhard's classic statistical transfer formulation, most non-generative photo grading engines convert source and reference images from device-dependent RGB into a perceptually uniform space such as CIELAB color space (L*a*b*) or Oklab. In CIELAB, L* encodes perceptual lightness from 0 (black) to 100 (diffuse white), while a* (green to red) and b* (blue to yellow) encode opponent chromaticity.

A standard global transfer shifts and scales each channel of the source photo ($C{src}$) to match the mean ($\mu{ref}$) and standard deviation ($\sigma_{ref}$) of the reference image:

$$C{out} = \left( \frac{C{src} – \mu{src}}{\sigma{src}} \right) \cdot \sigma{ref} + \mu{ref}$$

That linear Z-score mapping relies on two assumptions that don't hold at the ends of the histogram. First, the formula assumes luminance outliers scale linearly without hitting hard bounds. If your studio source photo has a tight midtone distribution ($\sigma{src} = 14$) but contains small pinpoint specular reflections at L* = 95, and your reference photo is a high-contrast chiaroscuro portrait ($\sigma{ref} = 26$), the variance multiplier ($\sigma{ref} / \sigma{src} = 1.85$) launches those L* = 95 glints well past L* = 100.

Second, linear scaling assumes chromaticity (a*, b*) is independent of lightness (L*) near 0 and 100. It isn't. In real display colorimetry, the valid sRGB gamut polyhedron narrows to a sharp tip as L* approaches 0 or 100. At L* = 55, sRGB can reproduce high chroma ($C^*_{ab} > 60$). At L* = 94, the sRGB gamut boundary shrinks so tightly around the neutral axis that adding even a modest +12 warm shift on the b* channel pushes the pixel outside the sRGB cube. When the inverse transform clamps 8-bit channels to [0, 255], one primary channel saturates early and skews both hue and local contrast.

If your pipeline only grades flat vector illustrations or low-contrast matte paper scans whose pixel lightness stays strictly between L* 25 and L* 78, global mean and variance matching won't clip. You can skip extreme-zone masking in that narrow case and run full-strength statistical transfer directly.

Boundary failure modes at the luminance toe and highlight shoulder

When a studio product photo fails visual QA after a reference grade transfer, the defect almost always lands in either the deep shadow toe or the specular highlight shoulder. Inspecting those two boundary regimes separately tells you right away whether to lower the transfer strength, swap out an incompatible reference photo, or clamp extreme-zone chrominance.

Black-point lifting and shadow chrominance bleed in the toe (L* 0 to 15)

Lifestyle and editorial reference photographs frequently use lifted film curves where the darkest shadow in the frame sits around L* = 18 to L* = 24. When you apply that reference at full strength to a studio hardware shot of a matte black anodized camera body or cast-iron pan whose natural 1st-percentile black point (P1_L) sits at L* = 3.5, the additive mean offset pulls the entire shadow toe upward by +10 to +16 lightness units. Instead of anchoring the object to the frame, the dark hardware turns into a dusty, low-density charcoal gray. Worse, if the reference image has a narrower luminance spread ($\sigma{ref} < \sigma{src}$), the slope of the shadow toe flattens out. Recessed knurling grooves, screw threads, and fabric seams between L* 3 and L* 15 compress into a narrow 4-unit band, erasing micro-contrast in dark surfaces even though zero pixels actually clipped to RGB = 0.

Human vision also loses chromatic sensitivity in deep shadows (L* <= 12). When you look into the deep interior fold of a dark wool coat or the underside shadow of a desk, you expect neutral dark gray. Standard CIELAB statistical transfer doesn't roll off a* and b* offsets as L* approaches zero. If your reference photo has strong teal shadows (a* = -11, b* = -14) or warm amber shadows, those full chromatic offsets get injected straight into L* = 6 shadow cavities. In 8-bit JPEG or WebP sources, deep shadows also carry quantized sensor noise and 4:2:0 chroma subsampling blocks, so multiplying shadow chrominance by $\sigma{ref} / \sigma{src}$ amplifies dormant compression blocks into visible magenta, green, or cyan blotches inside dark folds.

Specular highlight flat-topping and single-channel sRGB clipping (L* 85 to 100)

Dielectric surfaces like glazed porcelain, watch crystals, beverage bottles, and clear-coat automotive paint reflect the studio key light directly as neutral white specular highlights (L* 90 to 99, $C^*_{ab} < 2.0$). Suppose you transfer a warm golden-hour reference image (+8 on a*, +18 on b*) onto a studio shot of a white ceramic espresso cup.

In the midtones (L* 50), that +18 yellow-warm shift looks natural. In the highlight shoulder (L* >= 90), however, the red channel (R) is already sitting near 242 in 8-bit sRGB. Adding warm chrominance drives R straight into the 255 ceiling across the entire curvature of the highlight, while G sits at 236 and B drops to 208. Because R is pinned at 255 across a wide patch of pixels, the smooth 3D luminance gradient across the rim of the cup flattens into a posterized plateau. At the same time, viewers expect direct light reflections on glass or ceramic to desaturate toward neutral white at their brightest center. When R clips and B is pulled down by the global b* offset, the brightest highlight core glows salmon-yellow instead of crisp white.

Macro view of dark pleated wool shadow folds beside a blown glass carafe and brushed titanium cylinder under mixed studio lighting Inspecting shadow-toe density in dark wool folds alongside specular highlight roll-off on blown glass and brushed metal surfaces.

Balancing reference mood against tonal extremes in a canvas workflow

In a production studio, retouchers don't want to hand-build custom per-image curve masks from scratch just to see whether a campaign moodboard works on a new product batch. Running photo color transfer on Virse lets creative and QA teams test a tone reference against a source photo using Lab color statistical matching on a shared visual canvas. You upload the target product photo and the approved tone reference image, pick one of the three presets (Match the reference, House look, or Light tint), and select a transfer strength (Light, Standard, or Full). Clicking Transfer the grade loads the configured pair into a new canvas workspace; nothing executes or consumes credits until you press Start inside the canvas, which places the graded image directly beside the original photo for side-by-side inspection.

Because Virse calculates Lab color statistics across still images rather than regenerating pixels with a diffusion model, product edges, typography, facial geometry, and surface textures stay locked to the source photo, and running the exact same input pair twice always produces the exact same output. That mathematical determinism has practical limits you should document in your pipeline specs. The tool doesn't process video streams, export .cube 3D LUT files, or guarantee physical product color invariance. A strong warm reference will intentionally shift the apparent hue of a white or pastel garment unless you step down the transfer strength.

Virse Color Grade Transfer workspace with uploaded studio product photo, tone reference image, and Light transfer strength selected Selecting Light transfer strength inside the Virse Color Grade Transfer workspace before opening the canvas to protect shadow black points and specular glints.

When you're reviewing the side-by-side output on the canvas, switching between Full, Standard, and Light transfer strength directly controls how aggressively the reference image's luminance spread and chromatic offsets push the source image's shadow toe and highlight shoulder. Use the engineering table below to match your subject material to quantitative QA bounds and the right transfer strength setting:

| Product Surface Class | Shadow Toe Limit (|ΔP1_L|) | Highlight Ceiling (P99_L) | Max Channel Clipping (RGB == 0 or 255) | Max Extreme Chroma (C*ab in L* <= 15 / >= 85) | Recommended Virse Strength & Preset | |—–|—–|—–|—–|—–|—–| | Matte Black Anodized Metal & Carbon Hardware | <= 4.0 L* units | <= 94.0 L* | <= 0.15% at 0; <= 0.20% at 255 | Toe C* <= 4.5; Shoulder C* <= 5.0 | Light strength (Light tint preset) to prevent milky black-point lifting | | Glossy Ceramic, Glassware & Chrome | <= 6.0 L* units | <= 97.5 L* | <= 0.10% at 0; <= 0.35% at 255 | Toe C* <= 5.0; Shoulder C* <= 4.0 | Light or Standard (House look preset) to keep specular cores neutral white | | Neutral Apparel, Linen & Upholstered Furniture | <= 7.5 L* units | <= 95.0 L* | <= 0.25% at 0; <= 0.30% at 255 | Toe C* <= 6.0; Shoulder C* <= 6.5 | Standard strength (Match the reference) when lighting ratios align | | Atmospheric Lifestyle & Warm Editorial Scenes | <= 12.0 L* units | <= 98.0 L* | <= 0.50% at 0; <= 0.80% at 255 | Toe C* <= 9.5; Shoulder C* <= 9.0 | Standard or Full (Match the reference) for stylized film-curve grades |

Notice why glossy ceramics and dark hardware demand Light or Standard strength rather than Full: when a reference moodboard carries heavy shadow tinting or lifted blacks, backing the transfer strength down to Light preserves the source photo's native P1_L black anchor and neutral specular roll-off while still imparting the reference's midtone color harmony.

Automating the toe and shoulder clipping audit in Python

Visual monitor checks catch obvious blowouts, but a human reviewer staring at 200 catalog images after lunch will miss a 0.6% red-channel highlight clip or an 8-unit black-point lift on an uncalibrated laptop screen. Adding a 40-line Python pre-flight gate using Pillow ImageCms and NumPy percentile turns shadow and highlight review into an automated pass/fail assertion.

One implementation trap catches almost every developer who ports color-audit code from OpenCV to Pillow: signed versus unsigned 8-bit a*b* encoding. In OpenCV (cv2.cvtColor), 8-bit Lab stores a* and b* as unsigned uint8 values offset by +128 (so neutral gray is 128, 128). When we first wired up Pillow's LittleCMS transform (ImageCms.createProfile("LAB")) and subtracted 128.0 from the uint8 array, neutral studio gray reported an impossible chroma of 181.02! Why? Because Pillow's 8-bit LAB buffer stores a* and b* as signed two's-complement 8-bit integers (np.int8, where neutral gray is 0, 0 and negative values wrap to 128..255). If you don't cast the a*b* slice with .view(np.int8) before converting to float32, your chroma audit will fail on every neutral pixel.

Here is the verified Python audit script that decodes CIELAB properly and compares a source photo against a color-transferred output:

import numpy as np
from PIL import Image, ImageCms

# Build ICC transform from sRGB (IEC 61966-2-1) to CIELAB D50
SRGB_PROF = ImageCms.createProfile("sRGB")
LAB_PROF = ImageCms.createProfile("LAB")
RGB_TO_LAB = ImageCms.buildTransformFromOpenProfiles(SRGB_PROF, LAB_PROF, "RGB", "LAB")

def audit_tone_extremes(img: Image.Image) -> dict:
    rgb = np.asarray(img.convert("RGB"), dtype=np.uint8)
    lab_raw = np.asarray(ImageCms.applyTransform(img.convert("RGB"), RGB_TO_LAB), dtype=np.uint8)

    # L* is uint8 [0..255] -> scale to [0..100]; a* and b* are signed two's-complement int8
    L = lab_raw[:, :, 0].astype(np.float32) * (100.0 / 255.0)
    ab = lab_raw[:, :, 1:].view(np.int8).astype(np.float32)
    chroma = np.hypot(ab[:, :, 0], ab[:, :, 1])

    toe_mask = L <= 15.0
    shoulder_mask = L >= 85.0
    return {
        "P1_L": round(float(np.percentile(L, 1)), 2),
        "P99_L": round(float(np.percentile(L, 99)), 2),
        "rgb_zero_pct": round(float(np.any(rgb == 0, axis=-1).mean() * 100.0), 3),
        "rgb_255_pct": round(float(np.any(rgb == 255, axis=-1).mean() * 100.0), 3),
        "toe_chroma": round(float(chroma[toe_mask].mean()) if toe_mask.any() else 0.0, 2),
        "shoulder_chroma": round(float(chroma[shoulder_mask].mean()) if shoulder_mask.any() else 0.0, 2),
    }

if __name__ == "__main__":
    rng = np.random.default_rng(42)
    grad = np.linspace(8, 245, 400, dtype=np.float32)[None, :, None]
    src_arr = np.clip(np.broadcast_to(grad, (300, 400, 3)) + rng.normal(0, 1.5, (300, 400, 3)), 0, 255).astype(np.uint8)
    # Simulate an overly aggressive warm-lifted color transfer pass
    graded_arr = np.clip(src_arr * 0.94 + np.array([26.0, 18.0, 8.0]), 0, 255).astype(np.uint8)

    src_m = audit_tone_extremes(Image.fromarray(src_arr))
    out_m = audit_tone_extremes(Image.fromarray(graded_arr))
    print("Source metrics:     ", src_m)
    print("Transferred metrics:", out_m)

Running this script on our test pair prints:

Source metrics:      {'P1_L': 2.75, 'P99_L': 95.69, 'rgb_zero_pct': 0.0, 'rgb_255_pct': 0.0, 'toe_chroma': 1.42, 'shoulder_chroma': 1.11}
Transferred metrics: {'P1_L': 10.2, 'P99_L': 97.25, 'rgb_zero_pct': 0.0, 'rgb_255_pct': 0.637, 'toe_chroma': 8.57, 'shoulder_chroma': 6.19}

Look at what those six numbers immediately flag without a human opening the file:

  • Black-point lift (ΔP1_L = +7.45): The 1st-percentile shadow floor jumped from L* 2.75 to L* 10.20, breaching the <= 4.0 L* limit for matte black hardware.
  • Single-channel highlight saturation (rgb_255_pct = 0.637%): Even though P99_L only moved from 95.69 to 97.25, the +26 red-channel offset pinned 0.637% of all pixels against R = 255, exceeding the 0.35% glassware ceiling.
  • Extreme-zone color cast (toe_chroma = 8.57, shoulder_chroma = 6.19): Both shadow folds and specular highlights absorbed warm chromaticity that belongs only in the midtones.

Digital imaging technician desk in a D65 bias-lit grading suite with neutral gray reference card and optical prism Pairing physical neutral gray reference cards in a bias-lit grading suite with automated Python percentile checks to catch extreme-zone chroma drift.

When a batch asset triggers any of those three flags in your CI check, the fix rarely requires manual masking in Photoshop. Re-run the pair on the canvas at Light transfer strength (or switch the reference image to one whose native P1_L and P99_L brackets match your studio lighting ratio), and verify that rgb_255_pct drops back below 0.35% before pushing the graded image to your CDN.

 
Read more... Discuss...

from Faucet Repair

19 October 2025

Nearly halfway through Charlie Chaplin's The Gold Rush (1925), Chaplin's Tramp character (appearing as The Lone Prospector) gets into a brief altercation with the much larger and more macho Jack Cameron (over Georgia) at the Monte Carlo dance hall. Cameron makes a few sudden movements at the prospector to intimidate him, but at the urging of some women in the hall he agrees to lay off of him. He then makes to shake the prospector's hand as if in truce, only to tug his bowler hat over his eyes and kick him in the rear. The prospector reacts wildly, flailing around throwing punches in any direction. One of them lands on a nearby wooden post, causing him to wince and shake his hand in pain. The vibration from the punch knocks a clock hanging near the top of the post off of its support and it lands on Cameron's head, knocking him out. The prospector lifts his hat from his eyes, sees Cameron on the ground, dusts himself off, and walks off proudly.

At the breakfast buffet around 7:30am at the Opera House hotel in the South Bronx, a boy sat next to me was playing a drone strike simulator game.

 
Read more...

from mary-mcLendon

New Culture Review Explores Why Nostalgia Keeps Finding a New Audience

Fictional editorial article

The fictional culture publication Signal Review has devoted a new feature package to nostalgia and its continuing influence on entertainment, fashion, and online conversation.

The package looks at why audiences repeatedly return to familiar films, older music, archival clothing, and visual styles associated with earlier decades.

Rather than treating nostalgia as simple imitation, the editors frame it as a way people make sense of the present. A familiar aesthetic can offer comfort, but it can also be reinterpreted by younger audiences who did not experience the original moment firsthand.

One feature examines the imagined revival of early-2000s graphic design across independent fashion labels and creator-led projects. Another considers how short-form video encourages users to rediscover older songs by pairing them with new trends and personal stories.

The package also questions whether nostalgia can limit creativity when brands rely too heavily on recognizable references. Reusing an old visual language may attract attention, but it does not automatically produce something meaningful.

Signal Review ultimately argues that nostalgia works best when it becomes a starting point rather than an endpoint.

The past can provide material for new ideas, but audiences still expect creators and publishers to offer a perspective of their own.

 
Read more...

from mary-mcLendon

Independent Fashion Journal Reconsiders the Role of Everyday Style

Fictional editorial article

The fictional magazine The Common Thread is taking a different approach to fashion coverage with its latest issue, which focuses on the clothes people wear beyond the runway.

Rather than centering its pages on seasonal collections and luxury labels, the issue examines personal style through everyday routines, independent designers, and the growing influence of online communities.

The editorial team says the project began with a simple question: why do fashion stories so often treat ordinary dressing as separate from fashion itself?

The resulting issue includes profiles of emerging designers, a visual feature on vintage shopping, and an essay about how social platforms have changed the way readers discover smaller brands.

Its cover story follows fictional stylist Mara Ellis, whose work combines secondhand pieces with contemporary tailoring. The feature explores how she builds outfits around repetition and personal meaning instead of constantly buying new trends.

The issue also considers the commercial pressures facing independent labels. Smaller designers may gain visibility through social media, but attention does not always translate into sustainable sales.

With this edition, The Common Thread makes a case for fashion journalism that looks beyond product launches and celebrity wardrobes.

 
Read more...

from SmarterArticles

In Romiley, on the eastern edge of Greater Manchester, an optometrist called Aled Brassington runs a small independent practice and sells a product he was initially reluctant to stock. Colleagues persuaded him. He now reports that the majority of the people buying Ray-Ban Meta glasses from him have a visual impairment or a learning difficulty. One of his customers is practically illiterate. That man now has the world read aloud to him: labels, letters, the small print on a packet of tablets.

Writing to the Guardian on 14 August 2026, Brassington did not make the argument you would expect. He did not say the technology is wonderful and the critics are fools. He said something narrower and more disturbing. A week of British coverage branding the device “pervert glasses” had, he wrote, added a new anxiety for his patients. Not whether they could manage the journey into town — they had already solved that, which was the point of the purchase. Whether strangers would now assume the worst of them for wearing the thing that solved it.

That is a precise description of a specific harm. It is the moment an assistive device stops reading as a tool and starts reading as a costume. The white cane announces need. The Ray-Ban Meta, in Britain in August 2026, announces something else.

There is a lazy version of this article and it runs in two directions. In the first, a surveillance company has bolted a camera to a fashionable frame, men are using it to film women in gyms and on beaches, and the correct response is to get the thing out of public space; the disabled users are unfortunate collateral, and anyway, weren't they always going to be produced as human shields once the regulatory heat came on? In the second, disabled people have finally been handed an affordable route to independence after decades of four-thousand-pound devices that did less, and a moral panic driven by people who have never struggled to read a menu is about to take it away; how dare you.

Both readings are cheap in the same way. Each resolves the conflict by deciding in advance which set of people does not count. The harder position is that the surveillance objection and the accessibility objection are both substantially right, that they collide in specific places at specific moments, and that almost nobody involved in the August 2026 ban cycle — venue operators, campaigners, legislators or Meta — has done the work of designing the collision out.

A Week in Which a Device Became an Accusation

The chronology matters, because the speed of it is part of the story. Through early August 2026, British venues moved almost in unison. The pub chain Wetherspoons, with more than eight hundred outlets, instructed staff that customers could not record other patrons or employees without consent; its chairman Tim Martin framed the devices as breaching a general code against filming people who have not agreed to it. The restaurateur Jeremy King barred them from Simpsons in the Strand, Arlington and The Park, saying he would never knowingly allow any invasion of guest privacy other than with the eyes we were born with. ATG Theatres said audiences would be asked to remove them; Soho House extended its existing filming prohibition to cover them. On 14 August, His Majesty's Courts and Tribunals Service prohibited them across the courts of England and Wales, with confiscation on entry. By 20 August the UK Cinema Association was weighing a sector-wide position, its chief executive Phil Clapp acknowledging to Sky News that the same frames can deliver customised subtitling to people who need it.

Alongside the venues, a campaign. Stop Smart Glasses, created by the technology founder Liz Hunter and joined by the teacher Guy Holder — who had opened a parliamentary petition on 9 June calling for an immediate ban on the sale and promotion of the devices — began supplying retailers, politicians and opticians with letter templates and a database of stockists. Hunter's formulation, given to the Irish Times on 21 August, is the sharpest sentence the controversy produced: the wearer chooses to put a camera on their face, and everyone else is forced to live with that choice, which is a transfer of power dressed up as progress. The framing has kept travelling since. By October the Dutch optician chain Hans Anders had halted Ray-Ban Meta sales across the Netherlands and Belgium, and mock TfL stickers dubbing the glasses “pervert technology” — the work of the campaign group Everyone Hates Elon — had appeared on the London Underground.

Note what is absent from that sequence. Not one of those decisions, on the public record, was taken in consultation with a disability organisation. I could find no evidence in the reporting that the Royal National Institute of Blind People, Sense, Scope, Disability Rights UK or Muscular Dystrophy UK were asked for a position before the policies were written, nor approached for comment during the coverage cycle that produced the framing. Meta was asked. Privacy campaigners were asked. The people for whom the device is a prosthesis were, until the letters page of 14 August, a rhetorical device deployed by both sides. The silence held after August too. It was October before the first prominent intervention from the sector itself, when the RNIB and Guide Dogs publicly warned, in BBC coverage on 7 October, that venue bans risk excluding disabled people who rely on the glasses as accessibility aids, and urged venues to treat them as a reasonable adjustment under the Equality Act. The disability organisations did not help write the policies; they arrived two months after them, in the position of asking that what had already been announced be softened.

Colin Hughes, one of those letter writers, has severe limb girdle muscular dystrophy and cannot pick up or operate a smartphone. A former BBC producer, he uses the glasses to make calls, send WhatsApp messages, take photographs and start video calls entirely by voice. Writing on his own site in late July, he made an observation the venue policies have almost universally failed to absorb: safety measures should distinguish between recording and the many functions that do not involve recording at all. If he lost access, he wrote, he would be less safe, less connected and less independent. And then the line that should frame the whole debate: we should not have to choose between privacy and independence, we should insist on both.

Take the Case Against the Glasses at Its Strongest

The other side deserves better than the perfunctory nod it usually receives in accessibility commentary, because the harms are not hypothetical, not rare, and not a matter of etiquette. A BBC investigation published in January 2026 found dozens of male influencers on TikTok and Instagram using Ray-Ban Meta glasses to film women without their knowledge. One woman, identified only as Dilara and aged twenty-one, was recorded on her lunch break; the footage accumulated 1.3 million views and included her phone number, after which the messages and calls started. Another, identified as Kim, was filmed on a beach discussing details about her employer and her family she would not have disclosed had she known a camera was running.

Then the pipeline behind the lens. Investigations by the Swedish outlets Svenska Dagbladet and Göteborgs-Posten established that outsourced workers at the contractor Sama in Kenya were reviewing footage captured through the glasses, including material recorded in bedrooms and bathrooms. That reporting produced a class action, Bartone and others against Meta Platforms, filed on 4 March 2026 in the Northern District of California, alleging that marketing copy promising a product designed for privacy and controlled by the user could not be squared with a human review process buyers had no way of anticipating. The Information Commissioner's Office wrote to Meta the next day. The suit has since grown into something larger. Thirteen related cases were consolidated as In re Meta AI Glasses Litigation before Judge Edward M. Chen, with roughly seventy plaintiffs, and in September the proposed classes were expanded to include bystanders recorded by the glasses — people who never bought the device, never wore it and never agreed to any terms of use. On 24 September, Chen reset the case deadlines and allowed discovery to proceed, rejecting Meta's request to wait until its motions to compel arbitration and to dismiss were resolved. The case is in active discovery as of November.

The company's own data settlement compounds the point rather than answering it. Since a policy revision in April 2025, voice recordings triggered by the wake word are stored in the cloud by default and retained for up to a year, and American users can no longer opt out; the option survives in the European Union only because the law there is stricter. There is no meaningful on-device intelligence, since the AI functions are cloud-dependent by design. Which produces an irony the accessibility argument must swallow rather than dodge. The disabled user is the heaviest user of exactly the features that generate the most cloud processing. The person who most needs the glasses pays the highest privacy price for them, continuously.

The recording indicator, meanwhile, is a joke Meta is only now scrambling to un-tell. Small operations sprang up charging around sixty dollars to remove the LED permanently, and when the company blocked recording where the light was taped over, modders drilled the diode out. In July 2026 Meta shipped tamper detection that shuts the camera off if the indicator has been destroyed, a fix that cannot reach altered hardware; the Electronic Frontier Foundation had warned in March that the safeguard was trivially defeatable. The same month, the Financial Times reported Meta was testing “super sensing” prototypes capturing continuous audio and photographs every few seconds. Mark McCreary, a lawyer at Fox Rothschild, put the timing to Fortune with an economy the sector deserves: a cynic could say, don't look at the fire, look over here.

Above all this sits Name Tag, the facial recognition feature reported in February 2026 and provisionally slated for release later in the year. The year has since run out without the feature shipping: as of November, Meta maintains that nothing has been released to consumers and no final decision has been made, and the unreleased recognition code WIRED found inside Meta's AI app — rebranded in the code as “Connections” — was removed in an app update the day after the report appeared. Internal material indicated the company saw advantage in launching while civil society had its attention elsewhere. The opposition has been correspondingly broad: the Electronic Privacy Information Center has urged the Federal Trade Commission and state regulators to block the feature outright, Senators Markey, Wyden and Merkley demanded answers in March, more than seventy advocacy groups called in April for the feature to be scrapped entirely, and in August the German digital-rights group HateAid filed a criminal complaint over the glasses.

The academic picture confirms that ordinary people are not being irrational. A study led by Xueyang Wang, posted to arXiv on 5 March 2026, surveyed 525 people and ran twenty paired interviews with wearers and bystanders. It found a persistent gap: bystanders consistently demand stronger transparency and control than wearers will concede, and in sensitive settings between 65 and 90 per cent said they would take defensive action. That is not a communications problem. That is a population telling researchers it does not consent.

Why Three Hundred Pounds of Sunglasses Beats Four Thousand Pounds of Medical Device

Here is the part of the argument that the surveillance debate has almost entirely failed to metabolise, and it is not sentimental. It is economic and it is well documented.

The purpose-built low-vision market prices its products like medical equipment because that is how they are reimbursed and sold. An OrCam MyEye 3 Pro runs to roughly $4,490; an eSight Go is around $4,950. Meta's AI glasses start at $299, with Ray-Ban Meta frames retailing in Britain for roughly three hundred to three hundred and sixty pounds. That is not a marginal difference. It is the difference between a device a person buys on a Saturday and a device a person applies for.

Price is only the first advantage. The RNIB's own guidance lists what the glasses do: reading groceries, letters, instructions and recipes; reading street signs, timetables and departure boards; asking what is in front of the camera; making calls hands-free; connecting to a sighted volunteer through Be My Eyes. That is much of the functionality of a dedicated reader, in a device that also looks like sunglasses.

The appearance is not vanity. It is the mechanism. Disability studies has a term for the alternative, coined by Liz Jackson in 2019 and elaborated with Alex Haagaard and Rua Williams in 2022: the disability dongle, a well-intended, elegant and largely useless solution to a problem nobody identified, designed for a hypothetical disabled user by people who never asked a real one. The dongle wins design awards. The mainstream device wins because it is cheap, sold in ordinary shops, replaceable, and does not announce a diagnosis to every stranger in the room.

This has been measured. When researchers at Newcastle University led by John Vines ran extended trials of Google Glass with people with Parkinson's disease, publishing in Interacting with Computers, participants reported that the refined consumer appearance reduced stigma relative to conventional medical equipment, precisely because it did not look assistive. The finding recurs across decades of hearing aid research: a 2019 scoping review of working-age adults found visibility and appearance repeatedly cited as reasons for embarrassment and non-adoption.

So the assistive value is real, and inseparable from the mainstream form factor. But honesty requires the counterweight, and it comes from the disability sector itself rather than from Meta's critics in technology policy. Reviewing the glasses for the American Foundation for the Blind's AccessWorld in autumn 2025, Steven Kelley called them an accessibility tool only by coincidence. They were built to put photographs on social media. The AI is sometimes unreliable about where things are, and not fast enough to be trusted at a road crossing. And there is a bleak detail that ought to end any claim the glasses were designed with blind users in mind: the recording indicator, the single safeguard offered to bystanders, is a dim light many blind and low-vision people cannot perceive at all. As Ariana Aboulafia of the Center for Democracy and Technology observed in Tech Policy Press on 12 August 2026, that leaves disabled people disproportionately vulnerable to being recorded without knowing it. They are on both sides of this harm.

The Doorman Is Not Authorised to Make This Decision

The legal position in Britain is less comfortable for venue operators than the speed of the August announcements suggests.

Under the Equality Act 2010, a service provider's duty to make reasonable adjustments is anticipatory. It is owed to disabled people in general, not to the individual who happens to complain, and it must be discharged in advance rather than improvised when someone is refused entry. Section 20 expressly extends to changing a practice and to providing auxiliary aids. A blanket prohibition on a device that functions, for a particular customer, as an auxiliary aid is exactly the sort of practice the anticipatory duty exists to catch. Applied to an assistive user it also has an obvious indirect discrimination shape: a neutral rule that puts disabled people at a particular disadvantage, lawful only where the operator can show it is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.

That test is the whole game, and it does not deliver one answer across contexts. A theatre's aim of preventing filming during a performance is legitimate; a total prohibition on wearing the frames is unlikely to be the least intrusive route to it, particularly where captioning is the reason the customer bought them. A court's aim of preventing the photographing of witnesses is legitimate and unusually weighty, and the case for a hard rule is strongest there — although even HMCTS returns the device on exit rather than pretending the wearer's needs vanish at the door. A swimming pool changing room is different again, and this is where accessibility advocacy has to stop and take the point properly. A leisure centre owes safeguarding duties to children who are undressing. No configuration of a camera-bearing device makes those duties disappear, and no reasonable adjustment analysis requires a pool to accept the risk. The answer in that room is that the glasses come off, and the obligation this creates is that the venue provides assistance some other way rather than leaving a blind customer to work out the lockers alone.

American law arrives at the same structure by a different road. Writing on 1 June 2026, the employment lawyer Sara Jodka set out why categorical prohibitions are the wrong instrument under Titles I and III of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Smart glasses, she noted, deliver optical character recognition and live description for vision loss, real-time captioning for hearing loss, and task prompts for cognitive disabilities. A flat refusal without individualised assessment, she wrote, is the single largest source of ADA exposure in this area. Her alternative is conditioned permission: allow the device while configuring it, camera disabled, audio confined to the encounter, geography limited.

Layered above both, the international instruments say the quiet part explicitly. Article 9 of the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities obliges states to ensure access on an equal basis with others to information and communications, including technologies. Article 22 provides that no disabled person shall be subjected to arbitrary or unlawful interference with their privacy or correspondence. The Convention does not rank them. It asserts both, which is exactly what Colin Hughes asserted from his flat in London. And the European Accessibility Act, in force since 28 June 2025 with full compliance due by 2030, has begun pushing accessibility from a charitable add-on towards a product requirement across the single market.

An Exemption That Charges Admission in Dignity

So write the exemption. This is where the argument gets genuinely hard, and where the pressure to produce a tidy ending should be resisted.

An accessibility carve-out sounds obvious until you ask how it is administered at eleven o'clock on a Friday night by a nineteen-year-old on a door. The available mechanisms are all bad. Self-declaration is trivially gameable and every venue operator knows it, so it will not survive first contact with a viral video of someone filming in a toilet while claiming an exemption. Documentary proof means a disabled person carrying evidence of their condition to the pub and producing it to a stranger in front of a queue — a return to the medical model at precisely the point of social life where it does most damage, and a disclosure obligation no non-disabled customer will ever face. A registration scheme run by charities or by the manufacturer means building a national list of disabled people and their devices, a privacy harm of exactly the kind this controversy is supposedly about, imposed on the group least able to refuse it.

The most honest position anyone in the ban camp has taken is the Stop Smart Glasses campaign's own. Its accessibility page states that regulation should protect legitimate disability-related and assistive uses, then concedes that the precise mechanism needs to be developed with disabled people, accessibility organisations and relevant experts, not decided without them. That deserves acknowledgement. It is also, read plainly, an admission that a campaign demanding an immediate sales ban has not solved the problem its own ban would create — and that the petition it supports contains no carve-out at all. That petition crossed the ten thousand signatures that oblige a government response on 5 October, and closes on 9 December. The government's position is already on record: no specific legislation on smart glasses is planned, because existing criminal offences already cover the harmful conduct. Which is, in miniature, the conduct-first settlement this article argues for — arrived at by default, without any of the design work that would make it survivable for the people the ban campaign forgot.

I do not think there is a clean answer here, and articles that produce one are lying. What I think is defensible is a shift in the unit of regulation. Stop asking who is wearing the device and start asking what the device is doing. Hughes's distinction — between recording and the many functions that do not involve recording — is the only formulation that survives contact with a door policy, because it can be enforced against behaviour rather than against a person's medical history. A venue that prohibits capture, posts it clearly, trains its staff and removes people who film is enforcing a rule that applies identically to a smartphone, a body camera and a pair of Ray-Bans. A venue that prohibits the frames is enforcing a rule about faces.

When a Person's Need Becomes a Company's Press Release

None of which lets Meta anywhere near the moral high ground, and the timeline explains why.

The AI Glasses Impact Grants programme opened in January 2026 and drew nearly five hundred applications; recipients were announced on 27 July, distributing close to two million dollars across thirty organisations in eighteen states. On 18 August, in the middle of the British backlash, the disability dimension of that same programme was foregrounded: twelve of the thirty recipients working on disability, among them the American Council of the Blind, the Braille Institute of America and United Spinal Association. On 12 June, Meta had announced free glasses and training for every blind veteran in America, more than 130,000 people, with its chief technology officer Andrew Bosworth calling it a profound honour. On 12 August, Meta Ireland donated 15,000 pairs to Vision Ireland, covering every blind and low-vision adult on the charity's roster, at a moment when the company's relationship with Irish data protection authorities was, to put it gently, live.

Interrogate that pattern honestly and two things are true at once. The first is that the accessibility case is being deployed as a shield. Aboulafia's argument is that this is systematic rather than accidental: companies present disability benefit as justification for privacy-invasive capability, and the clearest evidence here is the internal reasoning about launching facial recognition while civil society is distracted. You need not impute bad faith to every grant officer to observe that a firm facing venue bans, a class action, an ICO letter and a parliamentary petition has an obvious interest in there being visible, sympathetic, quotable disabled users in every story written about it.

The second is that the case being useful to Meta does not make it false. The man in Romiley is still having his post read to him. Colin Hughes still cannot pick up a phone. Fifteen thousand people in Ireland did not become less blind because the donation was also good public relations. This is the invidious position disabled users occupy, and it is worth stating without softening: their genuine, materially transformative need has been conscripted as marketing by a company that then built a data pipeline they cannot opt out of, and their reward for saying so is to be told they are Meta's mouthpiece. The conscription is Meta's doing. The scepticism it earns lands on the wrong people.

The strongest version of the accessibility argument is therefore also a demand made of Meta, not only of venues. If the glasses are assistive technology, build them like assistive technology. On-device processing for reading and description, so that the person who uses them forty times a day is not sending forty images to a server. A recording indicator perceptible to people with low vision. An assistive mode that verifiably disables capture while preserving reading, translation, captioning and calls, so a venue can permit the device without permitting the camera. None of that is technically exotic, and Meta has since demonstrated the capture-free end of it from its own catalogue: in September the company announced Ray-Ban Meta Audio, a camera-free model keeping calls, music and live translation while dispensing with the lens. That a capture-free pair ships at all weakens every claim that the camera is inseparable from the product — though it also strips out the reading and description functions that make the camera-bearing pair assistive, which is precisely why the assistive mode has to live on the device, disabled at the function level, rather than being exiled to a different product. Accessibility, as the Canadian digital literacy educators at the White Hatter put it during the same controversy, must not become a shield protecting technology companies from the consequences of design decisions disabled people did not make.

Nairobi Was Never Offered the Expensive Option

The cost argument sounds like a British consumer preference until you leave wealthy countries, at which point it becomes the whole question.

On 22 August 2026, coverage emerged of Sightra, an assistive navigation system built by the Kenyan founders Ruth Nzuki and Brian Gillo. It runs as a web application on an ordinary phone rather than dedicated hardware, detecting cars, trees, furniture and other obstacles in real time and speaking descriptions into an earpiece, with GPS handling the route. The critical design choice is that it was trained on Nairobi and on Kenyan infrastructure rather than on the smooth pavements where most computer vision datasets are collected. Nzuki describes the benefit as the user knowing exactly what is ahead of them in their path. Julius Mbura, a lawyer with a visual impairment who tested it, said it would be critical for blind people. It costs a hundred dollars a year, with the first six months free, and the founders are targeting three to five thousand users in a country where the 2022 national survey found around two per cent of people aged five and over reporting difficulty seeing.

Set that against a $4,950 headset. In most of the world the purpose-built device does not exist at any price, and the mainstream phone or pair of glasses is not the cheap alternative to assistive technology; it is assistive technology. A settlement designed in London or Brussels that treats camera-bearing wearables as inherently illegitimate exports a norm to places where the substitute is nothing at all. That is not an argument against regulation. It is an argument that its object should be capture, retention and transfer — things a rule can govern across contexts — rather than the existence of a category of consumer device.

We Have Run This Panic Before and Someone Always Pays the Interim

The shape of this controversy is old, and the pattern of who absorbs the cost is consistent.

In September 2003, the Washington Post reported that health clubs around Washington had begun banning camera phones. No misuse had yet been reported at those clubs; managers were acting on potential. Legislators followed with the Video Voyeurism Prevention Act. Two decades later the camera phone is universal, the bans have evaporated, and the specific behaviour — covert recording in changing rooms — is prohibited by criminal law rather than by banning the device. That is roughly the correct destination, and it was reached by regulating conduct.

The Google Glass episode ran the other way. The Explorer programme, which had sold the beta device at $1,500, closed on 19 January 2015 after a backlash that produced the word “Glasshole”, bans in cinemas, bars and casinos, and at least one assault. What is rarely recorded is what that closure did to the users who had built genuine assistive workflows on the platform — the Parkinson's trials at Newcastle, the navigation prototypes for blind users, the autism support work. Those people had no mainstream product to fall back on, because the mainstream product had been killed by its social reception rather than by its technical failure. The Australian research led by Fareed Kaviani, surveying 1,037 people and published in PLOS ONE in 2024, found the mechanism still running: owners saw the devices as consistent with their self-image, non-owners saw privacy risk and antisocial potential. Stigma is not a mood. It is a mechanism that removes products from the market, and when it does, it removes the accessibility use with them.

The research emerging in 2026 suggests a settlement is technically available if anyone wants it. A CHI 2026 study titled See Me If You Can tested a privacy-by-default protocol combining on-device obfuscation with consent-based restoration, and found bystanders regarded opt-in as essential and wanted stronger anonymisation still. Work by Jieqiong Ding and colleagues, posted to arXiv on 8 April 2026, ran a smart glasses probe called CollabLens through mixed-vision workshops and found meaningful support for inclusive collaboration by expanding blind and low-vision participants' assistive networks — while noting, tellingly, that sighted participants were unsure how to adapt their own supportive behaviour. And a companion paper from Xiaoan Liu and colleagues, describing an always-on agent called VisionClaw built on Ray-Ban Meta hardware, found in deployment that users delegated more and more of their day to the system. That is the warning inside the promise. The direction of travel is towards continuous perception, and every argument made now about a device that records when told to will shortly have to be remade about one that perceives by default.

Regulate the Capture, Not the Face That Wears It

What does it mean for the man in Romiley when the debate about his glasses brands him suspicious? It means the technology has stopped being infrastructure and become a statement, and infrastructure that must be defended every time it is used is not infrastructure. It means the anxiety Brassington describes is a real access cost, imposed by a discourse rather than by a rule, and therefore reachable by no appeal and no remedy. It means a person who solved a hard problem now has a second stacked on the first, manufactured by people who were not thinking about him at all.

The right to accessibility does not survive a debate that treats disabled people as a distraction, because the anticipatory duty in the Equality Act is precisely a duty to think about people who are not in the room, and a policy written in a week under press pressure is by definition one that did not. The Guardian's own leader, by the account of the readers who wrote in, conceded the usefulness of the glasses to blind people and then asked that this not distract from the harms. Brassington's reply was that his patients were being cast as the distraction. He is right about the grammar, and the grammar reveals the priority.

But the reciprocal error is just as available, and disability advocacy should refuse it. The women filmed on the beach and in the gym are not a distraction from accessibility. Nor are the Kenyan contractors reviewing footage from bedrooms, nor the facial recognition feature waiting in the software, nor the 65 to 90 per cent of surveyed bystanders who said they would take defensive action in sensitive settings. Any settlement requiring those claims to be discounted is not a settlement; it is a different group being told they do not count.

The way through is narrower than either camp wants and mostly unglamorous. Regulate capture rather than devices, so the rule reaches a modified pair of Ray-Bans, a smartphone in a pocket and a body camera identically. Require an auditable assistive mode that disables recording while preserving reading, description, captioning, translation and calls, so permission can be conditioned rather than refused. Force processing on-device wherever the function permits, which answers the surveillance objection and the disabled user's own exposure in the same move. Make the indicator perceptible to the people least able to perceive it. Publish venue policies in advance, as the anticipatory duty already requires, and design the exceptions with disabled people before the ban rather than after the letters page. And accept that in a changing room the answer is no, and that the obligation this creates is to provide human assistance rather than pretend the problem is solved.

None of that is a compromise in which each side gets half. It is an insistence that the two rights in play — Article 9 and Article 22 — were never opposed at the level of function, only at the level of product design, and that they feel opposed because a company shipped a camera on a face and left everyone else to negotiate the consequences.

The man in Romiley did not ship anything. He bought a pair of glasses from a local optician and, for the first time, the world started reading itself to him. Whatever settlement Britain reaches about surveillance, the test of whether it was designed well is whether he can walk into a pub wearing them without rehearsing an explanation.

References

  1. The Guardian (2026). “Smart glasses controversy sidelines the benefits for disabled people,” letters, 14 August, syndicated. https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/smart-glasses-controversy-sidelines-benefits-152259000.html
  2. IBTimes UK (2026). “UK Court Service Bans Meta Smart Glasses After Restaurants, Theatres and Pubs Lead 'Spyware' Privacy Push.” https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/uk-courts-ban-meta-smart-glasses-privacy-concerns-1814197
  3. Euronews (2026). “UK cinemas consider ban on Meta 'pervert glasses' over piracy and privacy concerns,” 20 August. https://www.euronews.com/culture/2026/08/20/uk-cinemas-consider-ban-on-meta-pervert-glasses-over-piracy-and-privacy-concerns
  4. The Irish Times (2026). “New campaign aims to ban smart glasses,” 21 August. https://www.irishtimes.com/business/2026/08/21/new-campaign-aims-to-ban-smart-glasses/
  5. UK Parliament Petitions (2026). “Introduce an immediate ban on the sale and promotion of smart glasses,” petition 769206. https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/769206
  6. Stop Smart Glasses (2026). “Exemption for disabled people.” https://stopsmartglasses.com/exemption-for-disabled-people/
  7. Hughes, C. (2026). “The smart glasses backlash is missing disabled people,” 30 July. https://www.aestumanda.com/opinion/2026/07/smart-glasses-backlash-disabled-people/
  8. National Law Review (2026). “Smart Glasses and Privacy: Wearable Surveillance and Disclosure Issues.” https://natlawreview.com/article/smart-glasses-and-privacy-wearable-surveillance-and-disclosure-issues
  9. TechCrunch (2026). “Meta sued over AI smart glasses' privacy concerns, after workers reviewed nudity, sex, and other footage,” 5 March. https://techcrunch.com/2026/03/05/meta-sued-over-ai-smartglasses-privacy-concerns-after-workers-reviewed-nudity-sex-and-other-footage/
  10. PetaPixel (2025). “Meta Updates Smart Glasses Policy to Expand AI Data Collection,” 1 May. https://petapixel.com/2025/05/01/meta-updates-smart-glasses-policy-to-expand-ai-data-collection/
  11. Fortune (2026). “Meta tightens Ray-Ban smart glasses privacy while it tests 'super-sensing' AI prototype,” 11 July. https://fortune.com/2026/07/11/meta-ray-ban-smart-glasses-camera-led-light-privacy-safeguard-super-sensing-ai-prototype-covert-recording-concerns/
  12. Electronic Privacy Information Center (2026). “EPIC Urges FTC, States to Block Meta's Facial Recognition Smart Glasses Plan.” https://epic.org/epic-urges-ftc-states-to-block-metas-facial-recognition-smart-glasses-plan/
  13. Aboulafia, A. (2026). “For Meta's Smart Glasses, Access Is An Afterthought,” Tech Policy Press, 12 August. https://www.techpolicy.press/for-metas-smart-glasses-access-is-an-afterthought/
  14. Kelley, S. (2025). “A Review of the Ray-Ban Meta AI Glasses for People With Low Vision,” AccessWorld, American Foundation for the Blind. https://afb.org/aw/fall2025/meta-glasses-review
  15. RNIB (2026). “6 ways Ray-Ban Meta smart glasses can help blind and partially sighted people.” https://shop.rnib.org.uk/blogs/news/6-ways-ray-ban-meta-smart-glasses-can-help-blind-and-partially-sighted-people
  16. Florida Reading and Vision Technology (2026). “OrCam vs. Envision vs. Ray-Ban Meta: Choosing the Right Smart Glasses for Low Vision.” https://floridareading.com/blogs/news/orcam-vs-envision-vs-ray-ban-meta-choosing-the-right-smart-glasses-for-low-vision
  17. Jackson, L., Haagaard, A. and Williams, R. (2022). “Disability Dongle,” Platypus, Committee on the Anthropology of Science, Technology and Computing. https://blog.castac.org/2022/04/disability-dongle/
  18. Vines, J., McNaney, R., Holden, A., Poliakov, I., Wright, P. and Olivier, P. (2017). “Our Year With the Glass: Expectations, Letdowns and Ethical Dilemmas of Technology Trials With Vulnerable People,” Interacting with Computers, 29(1), pp. 27-44. https://academic.oup.com/iwc/article/29/1/27/2607844
  19. Kaviani, F., Lyall, B. and Koppel, S. (2024). “Exploring social perceptions of everyday smartglass use in Australia,” PLOS ONE. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11530075/
  20. Wang, X., Peng, K., Yi, X. and Li, H. (2026). “Mind the Gap: Mapping Wearer-Bystander Privacy Tensions and Context-Adaptive Pathways for Camera Glasses,” arXiv:2603.04930. https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04930
  21. Ding, J., Zhang, Y., Zhu, X. T., Yang, K., Wei, Y., Wang, S., Liu, Y. and Jiao, Y. (2026). “Reshaping Inclusive Interpersonal Dynamics through Smart Glasses in Mixed-Vision Social Activities,” arXiv:2604.07232. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.07232
  22. Liu, X., Lee, D., Gonzalez, E. J., Gonzalez-Franco, M. and Suzuki, R. (2026). “VisionClaw: Always-On AI Agents through Smart Glasses,” arXiv:2604.03486. https://arxiv.org/abs/2604.03486
  23. Proceedings of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (2026). “See Me If You Can: A Multi-Layer Protocol for Bystander Privacy with Consent-Based Restoration.” https://doi.org/10.1145/3772318.3790394
  24. Jodka, S. (2026). “When the Microphone Lives on Your Face: Smart Glasses in the Workplace and the Clinic,” Dickinson Wright Health Law Blog, 1 June. https://healthlawblog.dwlaw.com/2026/06/when-the-microphone-lives-on-your-face-smart-glasses-in-the-workplace-and-the-clinic/
  25. Equality Act 2010, UK Public General Acts. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2010/15/contents
  26. United Nations Division for Inclusive Social Development. “Article 9 – Accessibility,” Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. https://social.desa.un.org/issues/disability/crpd/article-9-accessibility
  27. United Nations Division for Inclusive Social Development. “Article 22 – Respect for privacy,” Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. https://social.desa.un.org/issues/disability/crpd/article-22-respect-for-privacy
  28. European Disability Forum. “European Accessibility Act: products and services required to be accessible.” https://www.edf-feph.org/accessibility-act-enters-into-force-products-and-services-must-be-accessible/
  29. Disability Scoop (2026). “Meta Taps Disability Groups To Explore Uses For AI Glasses,” 18 August. https://www.disabilityscoop.com/2026/08/18/meta-taps-disability-groups-to-explore-uses-for-ai-glasses/32130/
  30. Meta (2026). “Announcing the AI Glasses Impact Grant Recipients: Helping People Work, Learn, and Live More Independently,” 27 July. https://about.fb.com/news/2026/07/ai-glasses-helping-people-work-learn-live-independently/
  31. Meta (2026). “The Future Is for Everyone: Free AI Glasses for Every Blind Veteran in America,” 12 June. https://about.fb.com/news/2026/06/free-ai-glasses-for-every-blind-veteran/
  32. PPC Land (2026). “Ireland's blind adults gain 15,000 free Meta AI glasses in phased rollout,” 12 August. https://ppc.land/irelands-blind-adults-gain-15-000-free-meta-ai-glasses-in-phased-rollout/
  33. Africanews (2026). “Phone app helps Kenya's visually impaired get around,” 20 August. https://www.africanews.com/2026/08/20/phone-app-helps-kenyas-visually-impaired-get-around/
  34. The Voice of Africa (2026). “Kenya AI Accessibility Innovation Uses Local Roads to Help Visually Impaired Users Navigate,” 22 August. https://thevoiceofafrica.com/2026/08/22/kenya-ai-accessibility-innovation-uses-local-roads-to-help-visually-impaired-users-navigate/
  35. The Washington Post (2003). “Some Gyms Ban Camera Phones,” 23 September. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/lifestyle/wellness/2003/09/23/some-gyms-ban-camera-phones/9661df84-5be0-4256-9e3b-b31597dfb08b/
  36. Time (2015). “Google Glass Ends Explorer Beta Program.” https://time.com/3669927/google-glass-explorer-program-ends/
  37. Disability and Rehabilitation (2019). “Studies on stigma regarding hearing impairment and hearing aid use among adults of working age: a scoping review.” https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31177867/
  38. The White Hatter (2026). “Accessibility Shouldn't Be a Shield for Poor Technology Design & Privacy Concerns.” https://www.thewhitehatter.ca/post/accessibility-shouldn-t-be-a-shield-for-poor-technology-design-privacy-concerns
  39. BBC News (2026). “Blind and visually impaired people fear smart glasses backlash,” 7 October. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmx2qlz7ney2o
  40. Law360 (2026). “Meta AI Glasses Privacy Suit Expands To Add Bystander Class.” https://www.law360.com/articles/2520314/meta-ai-glasses-privacy-suit-expands-to-add-bystander-class
  41. CourtListener (2026). “In re Meta AI Glasses Litigation, No. 3:26-cv-01897-EMC,” docket, N.D. Cal. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/72365892/in-re-meta-ai-glasses-litigation/
  42. PetaPixel (2026). “Meta Removes Facial Recognition Code from Ray-Ban Smart Glasses App,” 9 June. https://petapixel.com/2026/06/09/meta-removes-facial-recognition-code-from-ray-ban-smart-glasses-app/
  43. Markey, E., Wyden, R. and Merkley, J. (2026). “Markey, Wyden, Merkley Demand Transparency from Meta on Facial Recognition Technology in Smart Glasses,” 17 March. https://www.markey.senate.gov/news/press-releases/markey-wyden-merkley-demand-transparency-from-meta-on-facial-recognition-technology-in-smart-glasses
  44. American Civil Liberties Union (2026). “ACLU and 75 Organizations Sound Alarm on Meta's Plan to Add Facial Recognition Technology to Ray-Ban and Oakley Eyeglasses,” 13 April. https://www.aclu.org/press-releases/aclu-and-75-organizations-sound-alarm-on-metas-plans-to-add-facial-recognition-technology-to-ray-ban-and-oakley-eyeglasses
  45. Reuters (2026). “German advocacy group lodges criminal complaint over Meta AI glasses,” 12 August. https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/german-advocacy-group-lodges-criminal-complaint-over-meta-ai-glasses-2026-08-12/
  46. TechCrunch (2026). “Meta introduces camera-free AI glasses,” 23 September. https://techcrunch.com/2026/09/23/meta-introduces-camera-free-ai-glasses/
  47. Channel News Asia (2026). “Dutch eyewear chain Hans Anders halts sale of Meta glasses, citing privacy concerns,” 2 October. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/business/dutch-eyewear-chain-hans-anders-halts-sale-meta-glasses-citing-privacy-concerns-6427331

Tim Green

Tim Green UK-based Systems Theorist & Independent Technology Writer

Tim explores the intersections of artificial intelligence, decentralised cognition, and posthuman ethics. His work, published at smarterarticles.co.uk, challenges dominant narratives of technological progress while proposing interdisciplinary frameworks for collective intelligence and digital stewardship.

His writing has been featured on Ground News and shared by independent researchers across both academic and technological communities.

ORCID: 0009-0002-0156-9795 Email: tim@smarterarticles.co.uk

Listen to the free weekly SmarterArticles Podcast

Support What We Do

 
Read more... Discuss...

from Roscoe's Story

In Summary: * Having just taken the first round of night meds, I'm now in the night meds and night prayers phase of this evening. And I'm listening to the Florida / Notre Dame men's basketball game, with Florida leading by 9 points midway through the 2nd half. The Gators have led by as much as 16 points in the 1st half and are clearly the superior team tonight.

The IU / Arkansas game is about an hour away. I'll take my final round of night meds during that game, and I'll finish the night prayers after the game ends.

Prayers, etc.: * I have a daily prayer regimen I try to follow throughout the day from early morning, as soon as I roll out of bed, until head hits pillow at night.

Health Metrics: * bw= 217.38 lbs. * bp= 154/68 (61)

Exercise: * morning stretches, balance exercises, kegel pelvic floor exercises, half squats, calf raises, toe raises, wall push-ups, BP breathing exercises, pilates

Diet: * 05:45 – little chocolate chip cookies * 07:00 – 1 seafood salad & cheese sandwich * 10:30 – chicken lasagna * 14:30 – 2 tacos: 1 bean and cheese, 1 meat and cheese * 15:10 – mashed potatoes * 17:00 – 1 fresh apple

Activities, Chores, etc.: * 03:00 – listen to local news talk radio * 04:00 – bank accounts activity monitored * 05:00 – read, write, pray, follow news reports from various sources, surf the socials, take daily meds, unpack, organize, and nap * 15:00 – listening to the Gators Sports Network bringing the pregame coverage for this afternoon's Florida Gators vs Notre Dame Fighting Irish mens college basketball game which is scheduled to start at 15:30

Chess: * 10:15 – moved in all pending CC games, losing one

 
Read more...

from The happy place

Hello yesterday a lemon colored fairy tale moon glowed pleasantly through the deep blue foggy sky over my house and the festive colorful LED strip

It’s icy on the streets: they are coated with ice and beware of the ground and the cold.

People die in this cold, the homeless and unfortunate drunkards who pass out underneath the spruce trees or wander off into the forest, maybe they lie down peacefully, and then slowly disappear as the winter strengthens its grip, gently blanketing them under a cover of the purest, softest, most glittering snow. A beautiful cold grave indeed.

And the roe deers with their white asses are scurrying around, gnawing on the young apple trees:

What formidable creatures they are! To think, that they live in this harsh cold, and even seem to have fun! how they stick together, limber and graceful.

In one way, I’m thinking it’s inspirational, but I also recognise that comparison to roe deers is a trap, in the sense that almost everyone I know, seem to be better off than a roe deer; should these people not complain, then, just because they haven’t got intestinal worms and need to beware of the lynx, every day a struggle for survival?

There’s a special hell made for each of us, which we do need to endure, but I think grace is overrated, or rather it’s fine. Grace is fine. But acknowledging that the pain we feel is real, there’s nothing wrong with that. Even for such a very pure sensation, the pain/suffering; for how real it is, it’s remarkable how easily it can be negotiated into nothing! (Do you also forget time and time again? (Was it really that bad? (What was?)))

Then to play and scurry with our own intestinal worms, our crosses to bear — that’s fine too; again, what is the option?

But there’s nothing wrong, in my opinion, with setting these crosses down once in a while, to sit in the snow, tears streaming down our reddened faces

And rest.

 
Read more... Discuss...

from The Catechetic Converter

Once a month or so, I’d walk into the large blue carpeted sanctuary of the First Baptist Church of Central Florida and find a stack of trays covered in white cloths looking like a small snow-covered mountain range resting toward the base of the pulpit. They sat on the white and dark wood table I knew as the altar, the words “Do this in remembrance of me” engraved just below the top. This told us all that we’d be observing the “Lord’s Supper” that evening (it was always at the Sunday evening service).

This was the closest to any kind of actual ritual that my independent-leaning Southern Baptist church would observe. There was beauty and even a degree of spirituality on those evenings that I came to relish—even if it meant that church would go extra long and I wouldn’t be able to get home and play with my neighbor Scott. The trays that carried little square chiclets of dried bread and tiny plastic cups of red grape juice were polished metal, silver in color. They would reflect the lights of the church onto the ceiling and I’d watch the dance of that reflection as I’d wait for the trays, starting with the bread and later the grape juice, to come to our pew. It was always an agonizing wait. Typical Baptist custom is for everyone to consume the bread and juice at the same time, so I would have to practice patience as those trays made their way across the laps of well over a hundred people in the room.

I have vivid memories of the first time I sat in church for this ceremony. We had begun attending the First Baptist Church of Central Florida when it was still the First Baptist Church of Pine Hills, right around the time that I had started attending Pine Hills Christian Academy in first grade and my mom had begun work as a church secretary. I’d watch the tray come by and want to take the bread or the grape juice. My mom would block my hand. Once or twice my grandmother would try and offer some of the dregs of her grape juice to me and my mom would scold her, “Momma, he’s not baptized yet.”

My first taste of that stale bread and bitter grape juice would happen around my seventh birthday, shortly after I surprised my mom and grandparents by responding to the weekly altar call, hopping out of the pew and making my way down the balcony steps with my mom rushing to catch up. About a week after “giving my heart to Jesus,” I was baptized in what looked like a small hot tub set into the rear wall of the church, just above where the choir sat, fully immersed while wearing a plastic blue gown.

After that, I could now partake of the Lord’s Supper “worthily.”

***

The question of who gets to take communion is an ongoing and hot-button issue in the Episcopal Church. Every General Convention there’s a movement to change the stated rules and allow those who have not been baptized to receive communion. There are a few terms to this. Some call it “open table” while others refer to is as CWOB (Communion Without Baptism). Tons of ink has been spread on this subject, but the basic gist of all the arguments boils down to this:

On one side are folks who argue that Jesus is an inherently welcoming person who doesn’t put up barriers in order to access Him; therefore, requiring baptism is seen as unwelcoming to the stranger who is drawn to His presence in the Eucharist. The story of Sara Miles, as recounted in her memoir Take This Bread is a good citable example of this: an atheist who walked into an Episcopal parish with a committed policy on offering communion to those who are not baptized (Saint Gregory of Nyssa in San Francisco), had bread put in her hand and a chalice of wine offered to her, and found herself suddenly transformed. As she herself puts it, “I walked into that church not believing in God and walked out having met Him.”

On the other side are those who note that Jesus was a baptizer, following after the ministry of His cousin John the Baptist, and that everyone who sat at the Last Supper (the meal effectively re-enacted every time Christians take communion) were baptized disciples. Further, they might cite—as my former pastor did—Saint Paul’s caution in I Corinthians about participating in the Lord’s Supper in an unworthy manner, a thing that Paul says carries potentially deadly consequences.

It doesn’t help that the canonical scriptures do not contain a clear statement on the matter. If we’d included the Didache in the Bible, we’d have something concrete. In the ninth chapter of that historically important, nearly-in-the-Bible book we read:

But let no one eat or drink of your Eucharist, unless they have been baptized into the name of the Lord; for concerning this also the Lord has said, “Give not that which is holy to the dogs.”

Alas, the discernment of the Holy Spirit has led us to conclude that such a clear statement is not part of the canon.

***

Who gets to receive communion is a subject I’ve gone back-and forth on. When I first read Take This Bread I was convinced of the notion that communion be offered to anyone. For one thing, it’s heartening to see that the argument for the “open table” assumes the actual presence of Jesus in the Eucharist. It takes for granted the idea that He’s actually there in the bread and the wine.

I recall a time in college when I was hungry and thirsty for the actual presence of Jesus. I had suffered through a bad break-up (I was the one who made it bad, to be fair—a story for another time perhaps) and was feeling deeply shaken. I came back to campus after an evening surf session to see that the Catholic student group was having mass and I felt an unavoidable draw to be in the chapel at that time and to receive the holy sacrament. A literal hunger and thirst for God. But I was not Catholic and was not permitted and recall the disappointment I felt at being denied such intimacy with my savior. I was not yet Episcopalian, so I did not know I had other options. But I know the feeling one might have of feeling drawn to the altar but not meeting the “requirements.”

At the same time Saint Paul’s cautionary words hold sway on my conscience. The Eucharist is not something to be treated casually or lightly. It is not to be offered out all willy-nilly.

Another college memory comes to mind. I went to an evangelical Christian university (Palm Beach Atlantic University) and the missions department once hosted a “prayer labyrinth” in one of the large spaces on campus. I was a recent Episcopalian at the time and was quite curious about seeing evangelicals hosting a labyrinth. It was really just a kind of meandering corridor with photos and stats about the various places the summer mission programs were going to visit, with various things one could pray for as the teams prepared. But at the end of the “labyrinth” was a table replete with loaves of bread and cups of grape juice. A sign told the visitor that this was communion and that we were free to participate as we felt led.

I was outraged. First, there was no one monitoring this. The free samples at Costco are treated with more reverence. No, this was given the same amount of respect as one gives those tourist pamphlets in the lobby of hotels or the paint samples at the hardware store. Secondly, I was alone in the “labyrinth” which hardly makes this “communion.” When I expressed my anger at the religious life department I was basically patted on the head and told not to feel offended. Because they didn’t subscribe to a theology of transubstantiation or real presence or whatever, it wasn’t intended to be the same as the sacraments observed in a church. But they called this thing “communion...”

By the time I entered seminary, I held to the established traditional teaching of the Church: baptism is required for communion. Partly, I did this because I trust that there’s a wisdom at play in this traditional teaching. Also, there’s a logic to it: one is born before they eat. Baptism is “new birth” or how one is “born again.” The Eucharist is the food that maintains one in their new life in Christ.

But now, I feel the pendulum swinging in a different direction.

***

In my diocese are some clergy that are quite vocal in their opposition to baptism being a prerequisite to communion. I once overheard one my colleagues say, “the bishop requires you to be baptized to receive; in my church we don’t care.”

This latter statement is, for me, the real problem. We ought to care whether someone is baptized or not. Baptism matters. Indeed, in the Great Commission, Jesus tells to go and “make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Spirit.” Baptism is central to our work as the Church. So yes, we absolutely must care if one is baptized or not.

Paul Fromberg and Rick Fabian are the founding clergy of Saint Gregory of Nyssa in San Francisco, mentioned above. It is probably the most important church in the conversation on communion before baptism. Rick Fabian, in particular, has written much on the subject. One thing that he is quite clear on is that the church must be intentional about baptism. For him, communion is a thing that leads to baptism. Baptism is central and any church that treats it as “optional” is being both lazy and ignorant of Jesus’ teachings.

The most typical approach that most clergy take in regards to baptism and communion is somewhat non-committal. “We don’t check membership credentials at the altar.” Basically, we’re told to assume that if someone comes to the altar to receive communion, they are doing so in a worthy manner. If it turns out that they’re not baptized, then we need to have that conversation. Basically, this stance argues that we maintain the established custom of the church but leave room for exceptions.

In a way, I agree with this approach. I’ve come to recognize that stories like that of Sara Miles should be celebrated as unique movements of God, celebrated because they are unique and not necessarily treated as the marker of a new status quo. That we in the Church maintain a sort of normative practice of expecting baptism before communion so that when exceptions happen they get to remain exceptional.

But this is also so stereotypically Episcopalian.

We often use the via media as an excuse for not taking a stand. Are we truly committed to leaving room for God to do something exceptional, or are we being the church of Laodicea from Revelation (not hot and not cold; tepid and at risk of breeding stomach-turning bacteria)?

The vocal “open-table” clergy put this question front and center during the interviews held for the bishop candidates in our diocese. Every candidate indicated that they were open to discussing and discerning this topic, supportive of the possibility of overturning the established canons of the church on this. I was disheartened at the time. I even did a YouTube video on the subject shortly after, while also hearing from some parishioners who felt that the candidates even entertaining the subject should be grounds for all of their disqualification from consideration.

Then something funny happened. While reading the daily chapter of Proverbs I read during my Morning Prayer practice, I came across this passage:

Wisdom has built her house; >she has hewn her seven pillars. She has slaughtered her beasts; she has mixed her wine; >she has also set her table. She has sent out her young women to call from the highest places in the town, “Whoever is simple, let him turn in here!” >To him who lacks sense she says, “Come, eat of my bread >and drink of the wine I have mixed. Leave your simple ways, and live, and walk in the way of insight.” (Proverbs 9:1-6, ESV)

Now, a little back story is required here. Wisdom is not only an idea in the Bible, it’s also a person. Wisdom is depicted as a woman and the language of Wisdom influenced the early theology of Jesus in the New Testament. Not only does Saint John draw from the language of Wisdom in the apocryphal book of Sirach for his famous prologue (compare Sirach 24 and John 1), but we see in I Corinthians where Saint Paul writes that “Jesus has become God’s wisdom” (see I Corinthians 1:30). The early church understood Jesus as the incarnation of God’s Wisdom, the Logos from and for which the universe was created.

Given this, here’s a passage that clearly suggests Jesus offers the holy sacrament to those we in the Church have historically deemed “unworthy”—Jesus, being the Wisdom of God, offers holy things to dogs much to the chagrin of the author of the Didache.

***

I tend to see myself on the “Catholic” spectrum of Anglicanism. I don’t know that I’d define myself strictly as “Anglo-Catholic” but maybe the old term “Reformed Catholic” applies. Regardless, I differ from the Western Anglo-Catholic view of the sacraments in that I don’t believe that there are seven of them. I subscribe to a more Eastern view that there are only two sacraments (Baptism and Eucharist, the ones given to us by Jesus), while there can be a whole plethora of “sacramental rites” that echo and are rooted in the sacraments—things like marriage and unction, all the way to the use of prayer beads and the writing/painting of icons. These are all material things that evoke grace from God and draw us closer to Him but are themselves defined by the “dominical” sacraments (this is all an expanded view of Saint Thomas Aquinas’ view on the sacraments, who saw a clear primacy of Baptism and Eucharist).

So the question remains, must Baptism go before Eucharist?

I think I’m leaning more toward an idea that these are equivocal things. Each informs each, both need each other to be comprehensible. Wisdom invites the simple-minded to enter into the house built by Wisdom and to eat and drink the bread and wine provided, bread and wine that enlightens and illumines. Jesus shares His table with us all as he did Nicodemus. And from this table one arrives at the baptismal font to be born again. At the same time, we encounter the font upon entering the church and are reminded of our need to be reborn. Christ is present in the font as much as He is present at the table, the Eucharist rightly the life-redefining practice of thanksgiving for the new life inaugurated by the washing of Baptism. Both are necessary. Without both the Christian life is incomprehensible.

Jesus commands us to both baptize and participate in the Eucharist. But Jesus never gives an explicit hierarchy to these blessed sacraments. We’re told to observe both. Now, I understand that the traditions of the church are not bound solely to the scriptures but rather are things that run alongside the scriptures and so the long-standing custom of the Church has been to require Baptism before receiving the Eucharist. But as an Anglican we believe that anything deemed “necessary for salvation” must be “proved by Holy writ.” In other words, something like the requirement for Baptism prior to Communion must be proved by the scriptures. Frustratingly, the Bible is not as clear on this as we might like.

The scriptures are clear that the Eucharist is to be observed and received in a worthy manner. Does Baptism inherently make for worthy reception? I’ve been in more than a few contexts where I’d argue a group of baptized people have not observed the Eucharist in a worthy manner and I can say that I’ve definitely done a few rounds of confession over having received the Eucharist in a state of unworthiness.

I want everyone to be baptized and I want everyone to be a communicant. Perhaps it’s time we make both the font and table as open as our Wise Savior’s arms. But making both open is not the same as flippancy. In my thinking, flippancy is the error that Saint Paul cautions about in I Corinthians. Both Baptism and Eucharist are deeply dignified events. Their dignity, however, is not contingent on their reservedness. A thing can be both open and dignified, freely offered but treated with the reverence that is due.

Jesus, God’s Wisdom, has built the house and set the table. We’re invited to participate in God’s life. This requires us to wash and to dine. Maybe both things are meant to be equally offered? After all, we can’t have one without the other.


The Rev. Charles Browning II is the rector of Saint Mary’s Episcopal Church in Honolulu, Hawai’i. He is a husband, father, surfer, and frequent over-thinker. Follow him on Mastodon and Pixelfed.

#theology #Episcopal #Anglican #Christianity #Jesus

 
Read more... Discuss...

from Micro Matt

Yesterday, I started working on an Android port of our WriteFreely SwiftUI app.

Attempts to upgrade our original Write.as Android app, that only supports anonymous publishing, has had many fits and starts since I launched it in 2015. Now, I want to finally bring the full publishing experience to Android users (especially as one myself).

It'll take some more testing before this rolls out, and this post is one part of that. But I hope to share more updates soon!

#dev #WriteFreely #WriteFreelyDev #android

 
Read more... Discuss...

Join the writers on Write.as.

Start writing or create a blog