Want to join in? Respond to our weekly writing prompts, open to everyone.
Want to join in? Respond to our weekly writing prompts, open to everyone.
from
blog//x2600.cc
10:54 PM. 15% battery.
New layout for mobile UI for ^nix. h/t sysop@commons for the upgrade
Iced coffee. Tobacco.
Midnight I visit CC Park and charge phone, external battery, flashlight.
T minus 9 days until payday. Things to be done.
wx is ok. Clouds coming in. Unknown hour.
Lurking IRC. #permacomputing added to libera.chat server
I “accidentally” read back to Xmas Day on ~nttp's Aprapo of Nothing log. So now I am updated :)
I realize Feedbin/RSS is not displaying all of my subscriptions in All. I will export/import and see if that fixes it
from Blog of Sand
FICTIONAL WHAT IF: Part IX- What if Galadriel Was The Antagonist in The War of the Rings? Volume 2
BOOK TWO: THE FORGING From the Making of the Three to the Road into Mordor
Compiled in Avallónë upon Tol Eressëa, from the testimony of those who came West
A Note on This Book
The second book of this history covers roughly a hundred years, from the forging of the Three Rings of the Elves to the forging of the One, and from the parting of Galadriel and Elrond to her arrival at the gates of the Dark Tower. It is the shortest period treated in any book of this history, and the most consequential. The reader will notice that the sources change in character here. For the years covered in the first book, the historian had to piece together a life from fragments and old songs. For this period there is almost too much testimony, because nearly everything that happened in Eregion was witnessed by Celebrimbor, and Celebrimbor, when he came West, spoke of nothing else. His account must be used with care. He was the maker of every ring forged in this age save one, and he blamed himself for all of them. A guilty man is not always a dishonest witness, but he is rarely a balanced one, and where his testimony can be checked against the annals of Lindon, the letters of Elrond and the account of Olórin, the historian has checked it. Where it cannot, the reader is warned.
Chapter I: The Three
The Three Rings of the Elves were forged in Ost-in-Edhil in the winter after Halbrand fled into the holly woods, and they were the most beautiful things made by the hands of the Eldar since the Silmarils of Fëanor. Celebrimbor made them alone, at night, in a forge he had built for the purpose and allowed no one else to enter, and he made them according to the counsel Galadriel had given him on the night she discovered the truth about Halbrand. There would be three, not two, so that no single bearer could master the power the rings contained. They would be made of mithril and of the craft of the Elves alone, with no device of the stranger's in them. And their virtue would be the virtue the Elves needed most in those years of slow fading: not power over the wills of others, not strength in war, but the power to preserve, to heal, to ward and to hold back the weariness of the world. Celebrimbor testified before the Máhanaxar that when he set the last stone in the last of them, he wept, because he believed he had undone the fading of his people and atoned for the deeds of his grandfather in a single winter's work. He was wrong in both respects, but no one in Eregion knew that yet.
Narya, the Ring of Fire, set with a red stone, he sent to Círdan at the Havens, because Círdan was the eldest and wisest of the Elves in Middle-earth and the one least likely to use a ring for anything. Vilya, the Ring of Air, the mightiest of the Three, set with a sapphire, he sent to Gil-galad in Lindon, because the High King had commissioned the work and could not be refused. Nenya, the Ring of Water, called also the Ring of Adamant, wrought of mithril and set with a white stone that seemed to hold starlight, he gave into the hand of Galadriel herself. He did not send it. He carried it to her, in the gardens where she had walked the night Elrond confronted her, and he put it on her finger with his own hands. When the loremasters of Avallónë asked him why he chose her, he said that she had saved the work from Sauron and deserved to bear what she had saved. When they asked him whether he had loved her, he was silent for a long time and then said that everyone in Eregion had loved her, in those years, and that this was the problem.
The effect of the Three was felt at once across the Elven realms of Middle-earth, and it was exactly what Celebrimbor had hoped. The fading that had troubled the Elves for a century ceased. The healers of Lindon recorded that the sickness of spirit that had been taking the Eldar one by one, a weariness that made them long for the Sea and grow thin and grey in the light, ceased within a season. The leaves in the gardens of the Havens stopped turning. Gil-galad held a feast in Lindon to celebrate the deliverance of his people. The annals record that Galadriel was invited and did not come. She had gone east, over the Misty Mountains, to the wood of Lórinand on the far side of the passes, where the Silvan Elves lived under their king Amdír in a forest of great trees. She did not tell anyone why. Her reasons became clear soon enough.
What Nenya did in Lórinand is the first thing in this history that should trouble the reader. Galadriel walked among the trees of that wood for a single season wearing the ring, and in that season the wood changed. The leaves of the great trees turned gold and did not fall. The flowers on the green hills at the heart of the forest bloomed in winter and did not wither. The Silvan Elves of Amdír's realm said that the air itself had grown sweeter, and that time seemed to pass more slowly beneath the trees, so that a day in the wood was like a day remembered rather than lived. They began to call it Lothlórien, the Dream-flower, and that name has stuck. Amdír welcomed her and honored her, and his son Amroth wrote songs in her praise. Galadriel walked among the golden trees and watched nothing die, and she wrote to Celebrimbor that she had found at last what the Elves had always wanted: a land where nothing that was loved would ever be lost again. Celebrimbor kept the letter. He gave it to the loremasters of Avallónë, and it is there still. Reading it now, knowing what Lothlórien would become, one notices the word lost, and remembers the plain before the sea, and understands.
Chapter II: The Lord of Gifts
In the year after the forging of the Three, a stranger came to Eregion. He said his name was Annatar, which means Lord of Gifts, and he said he was an emissary of the Valar, sent from the West by Aulë the Smith, whose servants had always loved the craft of the Noldor. He was fair beyond the fairness of any Elf, and he spoke the High Elvish of Valinor as only those who had lived there could speak it, and he knew things about smithcraft that not even Celebrimbor knew. He did not come to Lindon, where Gil-galad might have questioned him, or to Lothlórien, where Galadriel was. He came to Eregion, to the Gwaith-i-Mírdain, and to the one smith in Middle-earth who wanted, more than anything, to believe that the Valar had at last taken notice of him.
Celebrimbor's testimony on his dealings with Annatar is the most painful part of his entire account, and the loremasters of Avallónë have treated it with tenderness. He said that he knew from the first that something was wrong. Annatar's knowledge was too great, his patience too perfect, and the gifts he brought too precisely what the smiths of Eregion had been hoping for. He said that he suspected, in his heart, that Annatar was Halbrand returned in another face. And he said that he set the suspicion aside, deliberately, again and again, because the work Annatar offered to help him with was the greatest work of his life, and because the only person who could have confirmed his fear was the person he could no longer bring himself to trust.
This is the first and most direct consequence of the breach between Galadriel and Elrond, and the historian must dwell on it. Elrond's letter to Gil-galad, describing the night on the Glanduin and Galadriel's concealment, had not remained a private letter. The High King had shown it to his council. Within a year, every lord of the Noldor in Middle-earth knew that Galadriel of the house of Finarfin had held the Dark Lord's hand and lied about it. When Annatar came to Eregion and the smiths began to whisper that he was too good to be true, there were already voices in Ost-in-Edhil reminding them who had brought Halbrand to Eregion in the first place, and who had kept secrets about him. Annatar did not need to speak against Galadriel. He had only to wait while her reputation did his work.
She came back from Lothlórien as soon as she heard of him, crossing the Misty Mountains in the first snows by the Redhorn Pass. She saw Annatar in the great hall of Ost-in-Edhil, among the smiths, and she knew him. She said afterward that she knew him by his eyes, which had looked at her across the corridor of a dungeon on Tol-in-Gaurhoth and across the dark of a riverbank on the Glanduin, and which no face he could put on would ever change. She told Celebrimbor before the whole Mírdain that the emissary of the Valar was Sauron, the murderer of her brother and the enemy of all the free peoples, and that he must be seized or driven out before he did any more harm. The silence in the hall, said Celebrimbor, lasted long enough for everyone in it to remember the letter. Then Annatar answered her. He did not deny her accusation or raise his voice. He said, with great sorrow, that he understood why the Lady Galadriel saw Sauron everywhere. A grief such as hers, he said, would make anyone see the face of the enemy in every stranger. He asked her pardon for any pain his coming had caused her, and he bowed to her, and the smiths of Eregion looked from her to him and decided, every one of them, that the grieving woman who had lied once was less to be believed than the courteous emissary who had never been caught in anything.
Celebrimbor did not order her out of Eregion. He testified, with some bitterness against himself, that he did something worse. He asked her, privately and gently, to go back to Lothlórien for a while and rest, because her presence was disturbing the work. She told him that he was a fool, and that one day he would remember this conversation in a dark place and wish that he had listened. She was right about this too. She went back over the mountains to the golden wood, and Gil-galad, hearing of the quarrel, sent her a letter thanking her for her vigilance and asking her to remain in Lothlórien until the High King's council had considered the matter. The council never considered it. Annatar stayed in Eregion for nearly a century. The work went on.
Chapter III: The Seven
The first of the great rings Annatar helped Celebrimbor to forge were the Seven, made for the seven fathers of the Dwarves. The annals of Lindon say that the smiths of Eregion made them as a gift of friendship to Khazad-dûm, whose mithril had made the Three possible. It is more accurate to say that Annatar suggested the gift, and that Celebrimbor, who loved the Dwarves and owed them much, did not ask why the emissary of the Valar was so eager to see the lords of the Naugrim wearing rings of power. Durin III received the first of the Seven in his throne room in Khazad-dûm, in a ceremony attended by the lords of Eregion and of all the seven houses. The other six were sent east and north to the other houses: to Belegost and Nogrod in the Blue Mountains, and to the four houses in the Red Mountains whose lords had rarely been seen in the west.
The Dwarves, as Olórin has explained to the loremasters many times, are not as other peoples. They were made by Aulë in his impatience, from the stone of the earth, to endure, and their wills are harder to bend than those of Elves or Men. The rings could not make wraiths of them, nor bind them as servants. What the rings did instead was to inflame what was already in them. Durin III had always been a proud king, jealous of his halls and suspicious of the sun. With the ring on his hand he grew prouder, more jealous and more suspicious. He began to dig. The mithril-veins of Khazad-dûm had always been worked with care, because the deepest of them ran down into places the Dwarves had sealed in the First Age and did not speak of. With the ring on his hand, Durin III ordered the seals broken and the deep veins followed, and he would not listen to his son.
The younger Durin's quarrel with his father in these years is well attested, because he described it himself to Elrond in letters that came West in Círdan's ships, and because his wife Disa told it to the refugees of Khazad-dûm in the dark years to come, and they remembered. The younger Durin warned his father that the deep places of the mountain held something older than the Dwarves, something the old songs called Durin's Bane long before anyone knew what it was. He said that the ring was speaking through the king, and that the king was too proud to hear it. The old king called his son a coward and banished him for a time from the royal halls. Disa sang to the stone of the deep mines and came back pale, saying that the mountain was afraid. The digging went on, and in the deepest shafts of Khazad-dûm, where the mithril ran down into the dark, the miners began to report heat that could not be explained, and a sound like the slow breathing of something very large and very far below.
Galadriel, in Lothlórien, heard of the Seven within a season of their forging. She sent a letter to Durin III warning him that the rings were the work of Sauron, and he did not answer. She sent another to the younger Durin, whom she barely knew, and he answered at once. He said that he believed her, and that his father did not, and that there was nothing more either of them could do. It was the beginning of an alliance between the Lady of the golden wood and the exiled prince of Khazad-dûm that neither of them could have imagined, and that would end, in the years to come, with Durin's son standing against her in the dark with an axe in his hand.
Chapter IV: The Nine
The Nine were the last of the great rings to be forged in Eregion, and Celebrimbor said afterward that they were the ones he had the least part in. Annatar designed them, Annatar chose their bearers, and Annatar carried them out of Eregion himself and bestowed them with his own hands. They were made for Men, and the Men who received them were all kings or would become kings, chosen from across the breadth of Middle-earth. The annals of Lindon do not record their names, because the Elves of that age did not trouble themselves to learn the names of mortal kings. The names have been reconstructed in the West from later testimony, and the historian gives them here only so far as they matter to what follows.
Three of the Nine went to lords of Númenórean blood, men of the King's Men who had come to Middle-earth in the years after the Southlands disaster to carve out realms of their own along the southern coasts. They had broken with the court of Rómenna because it was too timid, and they held that the Second-born owed nothing to the Elves or the Valar. Two went to the chieftains of the great peoples of Harad, whose fathers had worshipped Morgoth and whose sons were glad to be offered a new master. One went to a king of the Easterlings in Rhûn, whose tribe was the mightiest east of the inland sea. One went to a sorcerer-king of the hill-men of the North, in the cold lands between the Misty Mountains and the ruins of Angband, who had long kept the old rites of the dark. One went to a lord of the Men who lived among the White Mountains, west of the ruined Southlands. The last went to a man whose name was never recorded and whose people are not remembered, of whom it was said only that he was the greatest king in his own country and the most frightened of death. All nine rings had the same virtue. They gave long life, and power over the wills of other Men, and the ability to walk unseen, and those who wore them felt, for the first years, that they had been given everything. They had not been given anything. They had been bought.
Galadriel did not learn of the Nine until they had been given, because Annatar kept them secret from the smiths of Eregion themselves. When she learned, she wrote to Gil-galad. The letter survives in the annals of Lindon, and it is the longest and angriest of all her surviving writings. In it she set out the whole case she had been making for a thousand years: that Sauron lived; that he had come to Eregion in a fair form; that he had now put rings of power into the hands of the Dwarf-lords and the kings of Men; that these rings were bound in some way she could not yet see to some greater work; and that if the High King did not act now, while the rings were still new and their bearers still men, there would come a day when nothing could be done at all. Gil-galad's reply was courteous and brief. He thanked her again for her vigilance. He said that the emissary Annatar had been tested by his own counselors and found wanting in nothing. He said that the Lady's grief for her brother was known to all and honored by all, and that he hoped the peace of Lothlórien would ease it. Galadriel burned the letter. The annals note that a copy was kept in Lindon.
It is in these years, too, that the first stirrings from the far East reached the West, though no one in Lindon understood them. The stranger who had fallen from the sky among the Harfoots had left them, or they him, and had gone east with a Harfoot girl named Nori, following something only he could feel. In the lands of Rhûn, the annals of the Avari and the testimony of Olórin agree, there came out of the West in those years two other strangers in the robes of the colour of the sea, who went about among the Easterlings and the Avari speaking against the darkness. They were Maiar, sent by the Valar, though they did not say so, and Men would later call them the Blue Wizards. Their names among the Elves were Alatar and Pallando. They came too late to stop the Nine. They came, Olórin said, at exactly the time the Valar always came, which was a little after it would have mattered. Galadriel never met them in these years. She would meet them both, in the end, and one of them would kneel to her.
Chapter V: The Vindication of Galadriel
The historians of the West have given the name the Vindication to the long decades between the forging of the Nine and the forging of the One. It is a bitter name, and it is meant to be. These were the years in which everything Galadriel had warned of came true, one thing after another, and in which every one of the guardians of Middle-earth who had dismissed her failed in exactly the way she had said they would. She watched it all from Lothlórien. She kept a record. The book in which she had copied the sigil of Sauron through her long hunt in the North she now filled with a different kind of entry: a list of warnings she had given, to whom, and when, and what had come of them. Celebrimbor saw this book, many years later, in the hidden forge beneath Lothlórien. He said that it was the most terrible document he had ever read, because every entry in it was correct.
In Lindon, Gil-galad waited. The annals of his reign in these decades are the record of a careful king doing nothing, very carefully. He received reports of orcs moving in the south and east and filed them. He received reports from Eregion of the great works of Annatar and praised them. He received from Durin the Younger a letter warning that the old king's digging was waking something in the deep places of Khazad-dûm, and he sent it on to Celebrimbor, who did not answer. He received, at last, from Círdan, a warning of his own: that the Shipwright, wearing Narya, had begun to feel in the ring a pull from somewhere to the south and east, faint but growing, like a tide. Gil-galad called a council. The council met and agreed to watch. Galadriel was not invited.
In Númenor, the island's pride hardened into something worse. Pharazôn was not yet king, but he was the master of the court in all but name, and Míriel, blind and alone in her father's tower with the seeing-stone she could no longer use, let him rule. The Faithful were driven from the royal offices. Elendil, stripped of his command, lived quietly on his estates at Rómenna with his daughter Eärien and his son Anárion. Eärien, the annals of the Faithful record with sorrow, grew restless in that quiet house and began to keep company with the young lords of the King's Men, who told her that her father was a fool to mourn for the Elves. Isildur was not on the island at all. He had been left behind in Middle-earth in the chaos of the Burning Mountain, believed dead, and he had survived in the wild lands south of the White Mountains with Arondir the Silvan Elf and a remnant of the Southlanders. Among them, in those years, he met a woman of the hill-folk named Estrid, and loved her. The historian records this with a heavy heart, knowing where each of them will stand at the end.
The Southlanders themselves had nowhere to go. Their country was now the Black Land, ash and cinder from the Ered Lithui to the Ephel Dúath. Bronwyn the healer led the survivors north and west across the Anduin and into the empty lands of Eriador, where they lived as wanderers, unwelcome everywhere. Her son Theo had grown into a quiet young man who never spoke of the broken hilt, and who, his mother said, sometimes woke at night with his hand closed as though it still held something. Arondir sent them what help he could. No kingdom of Elves or Men took them in. Galadriel, hearing of them in Lothlórien, sent food and healers. It was the first time in this history that the Southlanders had cause to be grateful to her. It would not be the last.
Beyond the Anduin, in the wide lands to the east of the Great River, the Entwives went on tending their gardens. They had grown estranged from the Ents in these years. The Ents loved the wild forests and the slow, wandering, untended life of the trees, and the Entwives loved order: grain in rows, fruit-trees pruned, the earth made to bear what it was told. Messengers from Lothlórien came among them in these decades, and the Entwives found that they liked the Lady of the golden wood. She, alone of all the great ones of the world, seemed to understand what they had always wanted, which was a world in which every growing thing was tended and nothing was wasted. They began to visit the golden wood. The Ents did not notice. They never noticed anything until it was too late.
And everywhere, the Elves who had been saved from the fading by the Three began to feel a new unease. It was faint, and it came and went. It was like a shadow passing over the sun, or a voice heard in another room. The healers of Lindon could not explain it. The smiths of Eregion said it was nothing. Galadriel, in Lothlórien, wrote in her book of warnings that the Three were bound to something, that the something was not yet finished, and that when it was finished every one of them would feel it. She dated the entry. It was nine years before the forging of the One.
Chapter VI: The Black Land
While the Elves debated, the Dark Lord built. The loremasters of the West have reconstructed the history of Mordor in these years largely from the testimony of orcs: the survivors of the purges who reached the free peoples in the long war, and who told what they had seen to anyone who would listen. Their testimony is not always reliable, but it is the only account we have of the Black Land in the years of its making, and it agrees on the essentials.
When Orodruin woke and the Southlands burned, Adar's orcs claimed the ruined country as their own. It was the homeland Adar had promised them: a land the sun could not reach through the ash, where no Elf or Man would come to hunt them. They called it, in their own tongue, by a name the loremasters render as the Children's Country. For some years they lived there in a kind of peace, the first peace in the history of their people. They built shelters in the lee of the mountains, they raised their young in the shadow of the volcano, and Adar ruled them as a father, as his name suggested. Then, in the years when Annatar was working in Eregion, a fair-faced lord began to visit the Black Land, and the orcs who saw him began to remember a master they had tried to forget.
Adar did not kneel at once. The orc testimony is unanimous on this, and on the fact that he paid for it. He told his people that he had killed Sauron once, in the years after the War of Wrath, and that he would kill him again rather than give his children back into the hands of the creature that had wasted them in his experiments. But the orcs of Mordor were not all of one mind, and Sauron knew how to divide them. He offered the captains what Adar could not: weapons, purpose, a place in a great design, and vengeance on the Elves and Men who had hunted them for an age. One by one the captains went over. When at last Sauron came to Adar's hall in the shadow of the mountains, the orc-father had only a few hundred faithful left around him, and he knelt. He knelt, the orcs said, with his hand on his sword, and he never let go of it. His faction was suffered to live, and it was watched. Sauron never forgot a defiance, and neither did Adar.
Then the building began. The orcs of Mordor quarried the black rock of the Ered Lithui and laid the foundations of a tower on a spur of the mountains, facing Orodruin across the plain of Gorgoroth. The tower grew year by year until it was the greatest fortress raised in Middle-earth since Angband, and it was called Barad-dûr, the Dark Tower. Within the cone of Orodruin itself, in a chamber cut into the side of the mountain where the fire of the earth ran close, the Dark Lord made a forge. No orc was permitted to enter it. The orcs said that on certain nights the mountain's glow changed color, and a sound came from inside it like a hammer that never tired.
The historian records one detail more from the orc testimony, because the Queen herself would later confirm it. In the last years before the forging, Sauron in his fair form was often seen standing on the highest terrace of the unfinished tower, looking northwest, toward the Misty Mountains and the golden wood beyond them. The orcs did not know what he was looking at. The Queen, when she was told of this long afterward, said that she knew exactly, and that she had been looking back.
Chapter VII: The Hour of the Forging
In the sixteen hundredth year of the Second Age, by the reckoning of Lindon, Sauron forged the One Ring in the fire of Orodruin. He forged it in secret, and he poured into it a great part of his own native power, so that it would be the master of all the rings that Celebrimbor had made with his help: the Seven, the Nine and through them all the others, binding the wills of their bearers to the will of the One. Olórin has explained to the loremasters that this was the most dangerous thing Sauron ever did, and the most foolish. In putting so much of himself into a single thing, he made himself dependent on it. As long as the One endured, Sauron could not truly be destroyed. If it were ever destroyed, he would be destroyed with it. And if it were ever taken from him, he would be diminished, and the thing he had made would go looking for another master. The historian of this age has the bitter task of recording that all three of those possibilities would come to pass, though not in the order anyone expected.
In the moment the One was finished and set upon Sauron's hand, he spoke aloud the words of binding that he had written into it, in the Black Speech of Mordor, and every bearer of every ring that had been made with his help heard him. The Seven heard him in their halls of stone. The Nine heard him, and in that moment they began to understand what they had been given. And the Three heard him too. The Three had been made by Celebrimbor alone, without Sauron's hand in them, but they had been made with the knowledge Sauron had given, and they were bound to the One as surely as the others. In Lindon, Gil-galad cried out on his throne and tore Vilya from his finger. At the Havens, Círdan took off Narya and set it on the table before him and would not look at it. In Eregion, Celebrimbor, who wore no ring, was at his forge when the cry went up from the smiths that the emissary was gone, and that his chambers stood empty, and that on the anvil he had used was carved, very small and very neat, the sigil Galadriel had been copying into her book for a thousand years. Celebrimbor understood, at last, what he had done. The annals record that he did not speak for three days.
And in Lothlórien, in the golden wood, under the trees that had not shed their leaves in a hundred years, Galadriel of the Noldor felt the mind of the Dark Lord reach across the leagues and touch her. She did not take off her ring.
The loremasters of Avallónë have spent more time on this moment than on any other in the whole of this history, because it is the one moment that cannot be reconstructed from testimony. No one was with her. She told the story herself only once, many centuries later, to Celebrimbor in the hidden forge, and he set it down as she told it, and it is brief. She said that when Sauron's voice came through the ring, she felt the whole of his will, and the whole of the thing he had made, and that it was the first time in her life she had felt a power equal to the task she had set herself. She said that every other Elf in Middle-earth heard a threat, and that she heard an answer. She said she understood, in that moment, that the One could be used to do what she had been trying to do for a thousand years: to bind the peoples of Middle-earth into a single order, to protect them from their own folly, to make a world in which nothing that was loved would ever be lost. She said that she kept the ring on because she wanted to listen. Celebrimbor asked her whether she had heard anything else, in that first moment, beneath the voice of Sauron. She said that she had heard something very quiet, like a voice speaking her own thoughts a heartbeat before she thought them. She said she had assumed it was her own.
The historians of the West are divided on what that voice was. Some hold that it was only her own thought, sharpened by grief and vindication. Others hold that it was the One, reaching through Nenya into the mind of the most powerful Elf left in Middle-earth, and finding there a will strong enough to serve it better than its maker could. Olórin, asked directly, said that the question was the wrong one. It did not matter whose thought it was first, he said. What mattered was that from that night onward, she could never tell the difference.
In the weeks that followed, the lords of the Elves met in council at Lindon for the first time in a century with Galadriel among them. Gil-galad had summoned her at last. He did not apologize. He asked for her counsel, which in a king is much the same thing. The council determined that the Three must be hidden, and must not be used while Sauron held the One, lest the Dark Lord learn through them the minds of their bearers. Gil-galad gave Vilya into the keeping of his most trusted servants. Círdan agreed to keep Narya hidden at the Havens. They turned to Galadriel and asked her to surrender Nenya likewise, or at least to swear that she would not wear it. She refused. She said that hiding the rings would only make the Elves blind while the Enemy grew strong. She said that the Three must be used, now, together, while the One was new and Sauron had not yet mastered it, to strike at Mordor before the Dark Tower was finished. She said that she would lead the attack herself.
The council refused her. Gil-galad said that the Three were not made for war and could not be used for war without becoming what Sauron had made. Círdan said that he would not take Narya to Mordor to save the world or to end it. Elrond, who sat at the High King's right hand and had not spoken to Galadriel in a hundred years, said only that the last time she had been certain of something, she had kept half of it to herself, and that the council could not risk the Elves of Middle-earth on half of her certainty. It was the last thing Elrond ever said to her in council. She looked at him for a long moment, said the annals of Lindon, and then she stood and left the chamber without another word, and that night she rode east out of Lindon toward the Blue Mountains, alone. Gil-galad sent riders after her, believing she was going back to Lothlórien. She was not.
Chapter VIII: The Road East
The road from Lindon to Mordor is a long one, and the historian cannot follow Galadriel along most of it. She crossed Eriador and passed south of Eregion, avoiding the city. She crossed the Misty Mountains by the Redhorn Pass and came down into Lothlórien, where she stayed for seven days and spoke to no one but the Entwives who had come to the golden wood. What she said to them is not recorded. They returned to their gardens east of the Anduin, and they did not speak of it. Then she crossed the Great River and went south and east, through the empty lands of Rhovanion and the marshes that would one day be called Dead, and on a grey morning in the late autumn of the sixteen hundredth year she came to the mouth of the pass that the orcs called the Black Gate, where the mountains of shadow met the mountains of ash, and she rode into Mordor.
The orc testimony describes her arrival. The guards on the gate saw a rider coming alone across the dead plain, clad in white, with a light about her that hurt their eyes. They loosed arrows at her and the arrows fell short. The captain of the gate sent word to the Tower, and the word came back within the hour, faster than any messenger could have carried it, that the rider was to be admitted and no one was to touch her. The orcs stood aside. Some of them knelt without knowing why. She rode across the plain of Gorgoroth through the ash, past the camps of Adar's people, who came out of their shelters to watch her go by. One of the oldest of the orc testimonies says that Adar himself stood at the door of his hall and watched her pass, and that he said to his captains, in their own tongue, that the Lady who had sworn to exterminate his children had come to the Black Land at last, and that he did not know whether to be glad or afraid. The historian records his words because he was right to be afraid.
Sauron met her not in the tower but at the foot of Orodruin, in the fair form he had worn as Annatar, with the One on his hand. The two accounts we have of their meeting are hers and his, and for once they agree. He asked her why she had come. She told him that she had seen what the Elves would do with the Three, which was nothing, and what Men would do with Númenor, which was nothing, and what the Dwarves would do with their halls, which was dig until they woke the dark. She said that Middle-earth had no guardians, only watchers, and that she was done watching. She said that she had refused him once because she had believed the world could be saved without power. She no longer believed it. And she said, as he recounted it with something like wonder to his captains in later years, that she had come not to serve him but to stand beside him, as he had offered her on the bank of the Glanduin, as his equal and his queen, because together they could do what neither could do alone.
Sauron did not trust her. He was the greatest deceiver in the history of the world, and he could not believe that the one being in Middle-earth who had hunted him without rest for a thousand years had crossed the Black Gate of her own free will to take his hand. He looked into her for a long time, said the orcs who stood watching, and they said that the air between the two of them shimmered like the air over the fire-pits. What he found there, he never fully told anyone. But he told his captains, years afterward, that in that moment the Ring on his hand had grown warm, and that he had felt in it something like certainty, as though the Ring itself were telling him that she meant every word. He said he had never felt the Ring speak so clearly before. He did not ask himself why the Ring should be so eager to welcome her. It was the last time in his long life that he failed to ask the right question.
He held out his hand to her, as he had on the banks of the Glanduin a hundred years before. She looked at it. And this time, as the songs of the Black Land would later sing it and the Queen's own heralds would proclaim it in every court of Middle-earth, she took it and did not let go.
Here ends the second book of The Queen Unfading.
from Blog of Sand
FICTIONAL WHAT IF: Part IX- What if Galadriel Was The Antagonist in The War of the Rings? Volume 1
In honor of the Rings of Power season 3 coming out, and despite its mixed reviews, I thought it would be fun to do a deep dive into a fictional What If. I had a lot of fun writing the Punisher getting bit by the radioactive spider long form what if, so figured I'd try it again. This one may end up being even more detailed- I have six volumes planned. Essentially an in universe historical account of the events leading up to and following Galadriel seizeing the Ring of Power from Sauron. This will not be during the events of the Lord of The Rings, rather, far early during the original War of the Rings. Enjoy!
BOOK ONE: THE HUNTER From the Fall of Tol-in-Gaurhoth to the Parting of Friends
Compiled in Avallónë upon Tol Eressëa, from the testimony of those who came West
Preface: On Sources and the Difficulty of Them
Any history of the Queen must begin with an apology for its sources, because every one of them is compromised. The chief witnesses to her early life are dead, or are her servants, or loved her once and cannot speak of her without grief. What survives in the West comes to us through four channels, and the reader should keep each of them in mind. The first is the testimony of the Ring-maker, Celebrimbor of Eregion, who came over the Sea after the fall of the last free host and spoke for many days before the Máhanaxar. He knew the Queen in her middle years better than any living soul, and he had every reason to hate her and every reason to excuse himself. The second is the account of Olórin, called Gandalf among Men, who walked in Middle-earth through the whole of the war and who speaks of her, even now, with a sorrow that sometimes sounds like admiration. The third is the body of annals carried West by the Elves of Lindon in the ships of Círdan, which are careful about dates and silent about motives. The fourth, and the least trustworthy, is the Queen's own word, as reported by those who heard her speak of her past. She rarely did so. When she did, she told her life as a story with a single meaning, and we must remember that she was the one who chose the meaning.
This first book covers the long period before her turn: the death of her brother, the loss of her husband, the long hunt in the North, her coming to Númenor, the disaster in the Southlands and the first offer of the Dark Lord, which she refused. No one who reads it should mistake it for a tale of corruption already begun. In these years Galadriel of the Noldor was what the songs of Lindon still call her: the bravest of the Exiles left in Middle-earth, the one who kept watch when everyone else had stopped. That is exactly what makes the rest so hard to tell. The historian who wants a villain will not find one here. He will find a woman who was right, again and again, and who was never once believed.
Chapter I: The Isle of Werewolves
The songs of Doriath say that Finrod Felagund, King of Nargothrond, died in the dungeons of Tol-in-Gaurhoth in the four hundred and sixty-fifth year of the Sun. They say he gave his life to save Beren son of Barahir, wrestling a werewolf in the dark with his bare hands, and that Lúthien and the hound Huan came soon after, threw down the tower and drove its master into the night. The songs are not wrong, but they are incomplete, and the part they leave out is the part this history needs. The songs do not mention that Finrod's sister was on the island that night. She never asked to be remembered there, and for a long age she told no one. When at last she did speak of it, she spoke only to Elrond, then to Celebrimbor, and once, at the very end, to the Dark Lord himself, and each time she told it the same way, without ornament, which is not how a lie is usually told.
Galadriel was dwelling in Doriath in those years, under the girdle of Melian, learning from the Maia queen the arts of guarding and keeping that would one day make her so dangerous. When word came that Finrod had gone north with a mortal man to keep an oath his house had sworn to the house of Barahir, she did not wait for leave. She rode west alone along the Sirion, and she came to the river shore across from the isle in the dead of night, when the wolves were already loose in the dungeon. What happened next she never fully explained. Perhaps she tried to cross. Perhaps she was taken on the bank by the creatures that watched it. All that is certain is that she was brought into the tower in chains, and that its master, who was then called Gorthaur and whom the Elves of later days would know as Sauron, recognized her at once.
He did not kill her. He did something that he must have thought cleverer, and which may have been the worst mistake of his long life. He set her in a cell where she could see her brother's, and he let her watch. She saw the companions of Finrod taken one by one. She saw the last wolf come for Beren, and she saw Finrod break his bonds and meet it, and she saw them die together in the dark. She said afterward that Finrod looked at her before the end, and that he was not afraid, and that this was the cruelest part, because she was. When Lúthien's song shook the foundations and Huan seized Sauron by the throat, the gaolers fled, the doors fell, and Galadriel walked out of the tower behind Beren into the light. She carried her brother's body to the shore herself. Beren and Lúthien knew she had been there, but they had their own grief and their own road, and they did not sing of her.
Historians in the West have argued for an age about what that night did to her. The gentlest reading holds that it gave her a purpose: she swore over Finrod's body that she would not rest until his killer was dead, and she kept that oath for two thousand years with a constancy no other Elf could match. The harsher reading holds that it taught her something worse, namely that love without power is only a way to watch the people you love die. Olórin, when asked, would only say that both readings were true, and that the second took longer to grow. It is worth noticing, too, what that night taught Sauron. He had looked into the eyes of a daughter of Finarfin while he broke her heart, and he had seen there, beneath the grief, something he recognized. He never forgot her afterward. Every offer he made her in the ages to come began, in some sense, in that cell.
Chapter II: The Field Before the Sea
Of Celeborn, her husband, the chronicles of Middle-earth say little, and that little is mostly praise. He was of the Sindar, a kinsman of Thingol, and he met Galadriel in Doriath when she was still new to Middle-earth and proud in the way of the Noldor. The love between them was spoken of in Menegroth as something rare: the high Exile who had seen the light of the Trees and the Grey-elf lord who had never seen it and did not envy her. He tempered her, the songs say, as she quickened him. When Doriath was ruined and its people scattered, they went together to the Havens of Sirion, and when the Host of the Valar came at last over the Sea to make war on Morgoth, Celeborn went with the remnant of Doriath to fight beside them, and Galadriel went with him.
The War of Wrath lasted more than forty years, and its end broke the world. Thangorodrim was thrown down, Ancalagon the Black fell burning from the sky upon its towers, and Morgoth was dragged out of his deepest pit in chains. But the land of Beleriand could not bear the violence of its own deliverance. As the war ended, the sea began to come in. In those last days, in the confusion of a field where whole armies had been swallowed in a single afternoon, Celeborn was lost. In the account that has come down to us in Lindon, he was never found, and Galadriel went on hoping for an age that he might be living somewhere beyond the reach of the waters. This history must record a different ending, because she did find him. She found him on the burned plain at the edge of Anfauglith, three days after the last battle, among the slain of a company that had held a crossing so that the wounded could be carried west. She knew him by the clasp of his cloak, which she had made for him. She had perhaps an hour with him before the ground began to tremble and the sea came over the plain, and she had to choose between staying with his body and living. She chose to live. She did not forgive herself for it.
The consequences of that discovery run through the whole of this history, and the reader should register them now. In the Lindon tradition, Galadriel's hope for Celeborn's return was a thread that kept her tied to gentleness: a part of her that was still waiting, and that would not wholly harden while it waited. That thread was cut on the plain before the sea. There was no daughter born to her afterward, no Celebrían, and so no marriage of Celebrían to Elrond, and no children of that marriage to carry the blood of Finarfin and of Melian into the later ages. One of the reasons the house of Elrond would have endured to bind the Elves and Men of the North together never came into being. The historians of Tol Eressëa list this among the first of the absences. It will not be the last.
After the war, when the Valar offered the Exiles pardon and passage home, Galadriel refused it. The reason she gave was that her work in Middle-earth was unfinished, that Sauron had escaped the judgment of Eönwë and was hiding somewhere in the East, and that no one else would hunt him. All of this was true. It was also true that there was nothing left for her in the West but her father's house, and nothing left for her in Middle-earth but a grave she could not visit, because the sea had taken it. She went to Lindon, to the court of Gil-galad, the last High King of the Noldor in Middle-earth. She brought with her a sword, her brother's last look, and a single purpose. For a long time, that was enough.
Chapter III: The World at the Turning of the Age
Before following Galadriel north, it is worth pausing to describe the world as it stood in the first centuries of the Second Age, because the events of this history touched every part of it, and a reader who knows only the Elves of Lindon will misunderstand most of what follows.
In the far West, along the gulf the sea had carved out of Beleriand, lay Lindon, the realm of Gil-galad. It was the greatest Elven kingdom left in Middle-earth and the last that called itself Noldorin, though most of its people were Sindar and Green-elves gathered from the ruin. Círdan the Shipwright kept the Grey Havens at the mouth of the Lune, and his ships were the only road West. Gil-galad's herald, and later his most trusted counselor, was Elrond Half-elven, son of Eärendil. Elrond was young as the Eldar count it, and he had already suffered a grief no other Elf could fully understand: his twin brother Elros had chosen the fate of Men and had gone over the Sea to be the first king of Númenor, and in the four hundred and forty-second year of the Age he had died, as Men must, of old age. Elrond had watched his brother grow old. It gave him a patience with the Second-born, and a sorrow about them, that would make him the natural friend of anyone else who had lost a brother. Galadriel was such a person. Their friendship, which began in the councils of Lindon, would become the most important bond of her early life, and its breaking is the subject of the last chapter of this book.
East of Lindon, over the Blue Mountains and across the wide empty lands of Eriador, the Noldor who were not content with the king's peace had gone in the seven hundred and fiftieth year to found a realm of their own at Ost-in-Edhil in Eregion, the land of holly, beneath the western gates of Khazad-dûm. Their lord was Celebrimbor, grandson of Fëanor, the greatest smith of the Elves since his grandfather. He had renounced the deeds of his fathers and lived in Eregion among the Gwaith-i-Mírdain, the brotherhood of jewel-smiths. Eregion and Khazad-dûm were bound together by a friendship that had no equal between Elves and Dwarves before or since. Their doors stood open to each other, and through those doors passed mithril, the true-silver found nowhere else in the world. In Khazad-dûm reigned Durin, the third of that name, an old king proud of his halls and suspicious of everything that came out of the sun, and with him his son, also called Durin, and the son's wife Disa, who could sing to stone. The younger Durin and Elrond were friends from their youth. It was a friendship the old king tolerated and the Elves of Lindon never quite understood, and it would matter enormously.
Out on the Sea, and growing every century in pride and power, lay Númenor, the island of Westernesse, raised from the waves by the Valar as a gift to the Edain who had fought beside the Elves against Morgoth. Its people lived three times the span of other Men. Its ships were the wonder of the world, and in the early centuries they came back to Middle-earth as friends, bringing wine and grain and the arts of agriculture to the wild Men of the coasts. By the period this book describes, that friendship was cooling. The kings of Númenor had begun to envy the Elves their deathlessness and to resent the Ban of the Valar that forbade them to sail into the West. A party had arisen at court, calling itself the King's Men, that held the Elves to be meddlers and the Valar to be jailers. Against them stood the Faithful, who remembered the old friendship, kept the Elvish tongue and looked West with longing rather than bitterness. In the years of this history the old king Tar-Palantír lay dying, a man of the Faithful in a court that was not. Rule passed to his daughter Míriel as queen regent, a woman of great intelligence and great loneliness. Her chancellor Pharazôn was a lord of the King's Men, clever, ambitious and patient, who smiled at everyone and trusted no one. Among the captains of the royal fleet was Elendil, a man of the Faithful, a widower with three children: Isildur, Anárion and a daughter, Eärien. It is strange to set those names down in a chronicle of the Queen's early life, knowing what each of them would become.
Of the lands in the middle of the world, the annals of Lindon say little, because the Elves paid them little attention. Along the Great River, in the vales of Anduin, wandered the small folk the Big People called Harfoots, a secretive people who moved with the seasons and hid from everyone. In some year the annals cannot fix, a fire fell from the sky among them, and a stranger walked out of it with no memory and no speech. The Harfoots took him in. Olórin has since confirmed to the loremasters of Avallónë that the stranger was himself, though he says he remembers that time only as one remembers a fever. Further east, beyond the Anduin, the Entwives kept their wide gardens in the lands later called the Brown Lands. They tended grain and fruit in ordered rows, and they spoke less and less with the Ents, who loved the wild forests of the west and would not leave them. No historian of that time thought this estrangement important. It would prove one of the most important facts of the age.
South of the White Mountains, across the River Poros, lay the lands the annals call the Southlands. Men lived there in villages under the watch of an Elven garrison set by the High King, because these Men's ancestors had served Morgoth in the First Age and their loyalty had never been trusted. Their lands lay in the shadow of a mountain range and a dead volcano. Beyond them, in Harad, lived Men of many peoples, some of whom still worshipped the darkness under other names. In the far East, beyond the inland Sea of Rhûn, the Easterlings were scattered among a hundred tribes, many of them still keeping rites that Morgoth's servants had taught them. Further still, in lands no Elf of Lindon had ever seen, dwelt the Avari, the Unwilling, those Elves who had refused the summons of the Valar at the beginning of days and had never crossed the mountains. They owed nothing to the West, and they knew the Noldor chiefly as the kinsmen of Fëanor, which was not a recommendation. The four eastern houses of the Dwarves lived in the Red Mountains, and their dealings with Durin's folk were cordial but distant. In the far North, beyond the ruined lands where Morgoth's fortresses had stood, the cold wastes of Forodwaith stretched to the Ice. There the Lossoth lived among the snows, and in the deep places of the Grey Mountains and the Withered Heath, dragons slept on what remained of the hoards of the First Age.
And everywhere, in the mountains and the waste places, there were orcs. The Elves of Lindon thought of them in those years, when they thought of them at all, as the leftover vermin of Morgoth's war, ruined creatures without masters who would dwindle and die out. They were mistaken. Many orcs had gathered, in the long years after Morgoth's fall, under a leader of their own. He was one of the Elves whom Morgoth had taken and twisted in the dark at the beginning of things, and his orcs called him Adar, which means Father. He wanted for his children what every people wants: land of their own, under a sun that did not burn them, where they would not be hunted. History has not been kind to Adar. This history will try to be fairer, because the reader will need to understand what was done to his people later, and why.
That was the world in the first part of the Second Age: a scattering of kingdoms with very little in common, linked by old friendships and older grudges, living in a long and exhausted peace. Nobody in Lindon believed that peace would ever end. Galadriel alone believed it was already ending, because she knew Sauron was still alive.
Chapter IV: The Long Hunt
For more than a thousand years, Galadriel of the Noldor hunted Sauron through the waste places of Middle-earth. The annals of Lindon record her companies coming and going with a regularity that begins in admiration and ends in something like embarrassment. She rode first into the East, following rumors of a sorcerer among the Easterlings, and found only shrines to Morgoth and the ashes of their worship. She went south into Harad and found the same. She went north, again and again, into the ruins of Angband's outer lands and beyond them into the Forodwaith, because every trail she followed seemed to bend toward the cold. Wherever she went she found the same mark, a sigil carved or burned into stone where an orc-captain or a sorcerer had sworn allegiance to Morgoth's lieutenant. She knew it, because she had seen it carved on her brother's cell. She copied it into a book she carried everywhere. She lost companies to cold, to orcs, to wolves and to despair. She never lost the book.
The hunt ended in the Forodwaith, sometime in the fifteenth century of the Age by the reckoning of Lindon. It is the best-attested episode of her early life, because many of her surviving companions came West in the ships of Círdan and testified to it. Her last company climbed the ice into the farthest North, where no Elf had gone in that age, and found there a fortress hidden in the glacier. It was abandoned, and on its walls was Sauron's mark, larger than they had ever seen it. Inside, she believed, was proof that he was gathering strength. The fortress was guarded by a snow-troll that killed several of them, and when it was dead and the halls searched, they found nothing but old ash and older silence. Her captain told her the company would go no further. She called them cowards. They answered that they had followed her for longer than some mortal kingdoms had stood, and that they would not die in the ice for a ghost. They turned south without her. She followed them, alone at the rear, and came back to Lindon with her company broken and her proof amounting to a mark on a wall.
Gil-galad received her with every honor and did not believe a word of it. He was not a foolish king, and the annals that report his words make clear he was not unkind. His reasoning was that Morgoth was defeated, that his servants were scattered, that Sauron, even if he lived, was a beaten remnant with no army and no realm, and that the High King of the Noldor could not set his whole people on a war footing because of what his greatest captain had found carved on a ruin. He told her that the age of war was over and the age of building had begun. Then he gave her the greatest honor in his power: he granted her and her surviving companions passage into the West aboard a ship of Círdan, to return to Valinor, to her father's house and to the peace she had earned. Elrond, who was present, told her privately that it was a gift and not a dismissal, and begged her to accept it. Her answer, as he recalled it long afterward in the dark days of the war, was that the High King had mistaken the end of a battle for the end of the war, and that the West was a door the Valar had built so that their servants could stop looking. She sailed anyway. She had no choice.
What happened next is famous in Lindon. At the very edge of the world, within sight of the light of Valinor, the ship carrying Galadriel and her companions reached the place where the Straight Road leaves the circles of the world. Galadriel, alone of all on board, did not go on. She leapt from the ship into the Sundering Sea. Her companions wept and called for her, and the ship went West without her. She swam for days in the open water, and she would have drowned, as any Elf would have drowned, if she had not come at last upon the wreckage of another ship and a raft made of its timbers. On the raft was a single survivor. He was a Man, he said, a refugee from the Southlands, whose ship had been sunk by a sea-monster. He said his name was Halbrand.
Chapter V: The Island of the Sea-Kings
The meeting on the raft has been told in so many versions since that the historian is tempted to treat it as legend. There is no need to. Galadriel described it herself to Celebrimbor, more than once, and the Dark Lord described it later to his captains in Mordor, and the two accounts agree in every important particular. They agree that he was charming, and she was suspicious, and the storm that took the raft drove them toward Númenor, and they were taken from the sea by a Númenórean ship under the command of Elendil son of Amandil. They agree that by the time they came ashore at Rómenna, she had begun to trust him. They also agree on one thing more, and the historian should take note of it, because it is the hinge on which the whole of this history turns. In the long hours on the raft, he asked her why she hunted Sauron, and she told him about Finrod and the cell on the isle. He listened to the story of the night he himself had arranged, and he showed her nothing at all. Long afterward, when she was Queen and he was chained at the foot of her throne, she asked him how he had done it. He told her it had been the easiest thing he had ever done, because he had been sorry.
Galadriel's sojourn in Númenor was brief and unhappy. The Númenóreans of that generation had no love for the Elves. They regarded her arrival as an intrusion and her demand for ships and soldiers to hunt the Dark Lord as insolence. The queen regent Míriel had been seeing visions, in the seeing-stone kept in her father's tower, of a great wave drowning the island, and she feared that any dealing with the Elves would bring the wrath of the Valar down on her people. Pharazôn the chancellor feared nothing, and saw at once that the Elf could be useful. Between them they kept Galadriel waiting for weeks, a prisoner in all but name, while Halbrand drank in the taverns of the harbor and made himself popular with the guilds and Elendil's son Isildur failed his trials as a cadet of the fleet. It was Galadriel who found the way through, and she did it as she would do everything in the years to come: by learning what each of the people in her path wanted, and offering it to them. To Míriel she offered a way to turn the vision of the wave into something her people could act against. In the archives of the royal library she found records of the Southlands and of a line of kings who had once ruled there, and she produced Halbrand to the court as the lost heir of that line, a king in exile who would bring the Southlands into alliance with Númenor if Númenor would help him reclaim them. Whether she believed this herself is unclear. Halbrand never claimed it. He simply allowed her to claim it for him, and she would look back on that moment, after she knew the truth, as the first time she had been used by him and called it her own idea.
The expedition sailed in the spring. There were three ships, five hundred men and horses, with the queen regent herself at its head, because Míriel would not send her people to war and stay at home. Elendil commanded the flagship. Isildur sailed against his father's wishes, as a stowaway. Pharazôn stayed behind to keep the island, which suited everyone, including him. Galadriel stood at the prow of the first ship as it left Rómenna, and the annals of the Faithful, which are fair to her even in their sorrow, record that the people on the quays cheered her. It was the first time Men had cheered her name. She would not forget it.
Chapter VI: The Fire in the South
What the Númenórean expedition found in the Southlands has been the subject of much argument, because almost everyone who witnessed it is dead and the survivors disagree about almost everything. These facts are agreed. Adar and his orcs had come down into the Southlands in strength. They had driven out the Elven garrison and laid siege to the villages of the Men, and they had made the Men of Tirharad choose between serving them and dying. Among the villagers was a healer named Bronwyn, a widow of great courage, who led a remnant of her people to the watchtower of Ostirith and held it against the orcs. Her son Theo, a boy at the time, had found among the ruins a broken sword-hilt. It bore Sauron's sigil and seemed to whisper to him, and he hid it because he was afraid of what his mother would say. Arondir, a Silvan Elf of the garrison who had refused to abandon the villagers when his captain ordered the withdrawal, stood beside Bronwyn through the siege, and the love between them was spoken of afterward by the survivors as one of the few clean things in that dirty war. The Númenóreans arrived at the moment the tower fell. They charged the orcs on the plain below it, and with Galadriel and Halbrand at their head they broke Adar's host and took Adar himself prisoner.
The interrogation of Adar is the most quoted episode of the whole expedition, because both Galadriel and the orc-father described it afterward, and their descriptions do not quite agree. Galadriel said that she questioned him about Sauron and that he told her Sauron was dead, slain by Adar's own hand in the years after the War of Wrath, because Sauron had used the orcs as fodder in his experiments and Adar would not let his children be wasted. She did not believe him. She held a blade to the throat of the creature Morgoth had made from one of her own people, and she told him that she would hunt down and exterminate every one of his children, in every hole in which they hid, until there was nothing left of his kind but a story. Adar's account, as it reached Sauron's captains and later the loremasters of the West through the testimony of orcs who survived the purges, adds a detail that Galadriel omitted. He did not beg. He told her, quite calmly, that his children had names, and that she would one day learn them all. The historian sets these two accounts side by side because together they foreshadow everything. In the Southlands Galadriel made a vow against an entire people. She would keep that vow more completely than any she ever made.
The expedition's victory lasted less than a day. While the Númenóreans held the field, the orcs' allies among the villagers had stolen the broken hilt from Theo. It was not merely a weapon but a key. Adar's people had spent years cutting channels through the mountain from the reservoir above the valley, and when the hilt was set into the lock of the dam the water came down into the tunnels and met the fire sleeping under the mountain. The mountain the Men of the Southlands had called by many names woke up. The Númenóreans call it, in their records, the Day of the Burning Mountain. The Elves would call the mountain Orodruin and the land around it Mordor, the Black Land, from that day forward. The explosion threw fire and ash for leagues. The villages of the Southlands were buried, the green valleys turned to cinders and the sky over the whole of the South went dark for a season. Míriel, leading her men back across the burning plain, was caught in the fire-wind. She lived, but her eyes were burned, and she never saw the sun again. Halbrand was gravely wounded in the last fighting. Galadriel, who had come to the Southlands to find Sauron, rode away from the ruin of a country carrying the man she believed was its rightful king, never guessing that she had found Sauron already, or that the eruption had made him exactly the land he needed.
The consequences of the disaster in the Southlands are where this history first departs from the tradition the annals of Lindon would have predicted, and the historian should explain why. In the tradition of the Faithful, as recorded in the books they carried West, the Númenóreans came home from the Southlands wounded and diminished, but still the allies of the Elves. Míriel's blindness was a grief to them and not a reproach. What happened instead was worse. The ships came home to Rómenna in the late autumn with a third of the men dead, the queen regent blind and the reputation of the expedition destroyed. Tar-Palantír died within days of hearing the news, and his death removed the last restraint on the King's Men. Pharazôn, who had stayed behind and taken no risks, moved fast. He made the expedition a judgment on the Elves. He said publicly what many in the court had always whispered: the Elves had led Númenor into a war that was none of its concern, and had used the queen's piety to lead her into blindness. Elendil, who defended Galadriel in council, was stripped of his command. Míriel, grieving and blind, did not stop the chancellor. She may have half believed him. The decrees that followed closed the harbors of Númenor to Elvish ships, forbade the teaching of the Elvish tongue in the royal schools, and drew back the island's garrisons from Middle-earth. The friendship between Númenor and the Elves, which might have lasted many more centuries, broke in one winter.
Galadriel was not in Númenor for the end of it. She had gone to Eregion with Halbrand, seeking Elven healing for his wounds. The news reached her there. It is worth recording her reaction, because Celebrimbor witnessed it and told the loremasters of it more than once. She read the dispatch from Rómenna in the forge-yard of Ost-in-Edhil, and she did not weep or rage. She folded the letter and said that she had seen it now with her own eyes: Men could not save themselves. They had been given the greatest gift of the Valar, an island of their own, three lives in one, and the wisdom of the Elves for the asking, and they had used it to grow afraid of the dark and envious of the light. They would always break, she said, at exactly the moment they were needed most, and anyone who wanted to save them would have to save them in spite of themselves. Celebrimbor said it was only grief speaking, and that she would think better of it. She did not think better of it. She carried that conclusion with her for three thousand years, and the day would come when she would put it into practice across the whole of Middle-earth.
Chapter VII: The Offer
The truth about Halbrand came out in Eregion, and it came out because Galadriel was a thorough scholar. While the healers of Ost-in-Edhil tended him, he made himself useful to Celebrimbor, who was struggling with the work Gil-galad had set him: a means of capturing the power of mithril to halt the slow fading that was overtaking the Elves of Middle-earth. Halbrand, who claimed to have learned smith-craft in the Southlands, made suggestions that were far beyond anything a Man of the Southlands should have known. Galadriel noticed. She sent to Lindon for the old records of the Southlands, the ones Elrond had copied from the archives of the High King in the years when the garrison was set. They said what she had begun to fear. The line of the Southland kings had ended long before. Its last heir had died without issue in the First Age. There was no lost king. There was only a man who had let her make him one.
She confronted him at night on the banks of the Glanduin, on the edge of Eregion, where the holly grew. What passed between them has been told by three witnesses: Galadriel herself, Sauron, speaking to his captains in Mordor in the years she served him, and a smith of the Mírdain who had followed her out of the city because she had seemed troubled, and who watched from the trees. All three accounts agree on the outline. He did not deny who he was. He did not attack her, though he could have tried. He did what he had been waiting to do, perhaps since the night on Tol-in-Gaurhoth: he made her an offer. He told her that he had been sorry for what he did to her brother, and that he had tried in the ages since to be something other than what Morgoth had made him. He said that he wanted, as she did, to heal Middle-earth, to bring order to the ruin the Valar had left, and to protect the weak peoples of the world from their own fear and folly. He said he could not do it alone, and neither could she. And he asked her to be his queen. Not his servant or his creature, he said, but his equal: the light of the realm he would build, as he would be its strength. He held out his hand.
On the point of what she did next, the three accounts differ, and the differences matter. Galadriel said that she refused him at once and drew her sword, that he fled into the night before she could strike, and that she had never been tempted for a moment. Sauron, telling the story in Mordor, said she had wept and taken his hand, and that for a breath she had seen what they would be together, and that she had pulled away only because she was afraid of how much she wanted it. The smith of the Mírdain, whose account the loremasters of Avallónë consider the most reliable because he had nothing to gain from either version, said this: she took his hand. She held it for as long as it would take to draw a breath. Then she pulled away and drew her sword, and Halbrand smiled at her as though she had already answered him, and walked away into the darkness of the holly woods. She did not follow. She stood on the riverbank until dawn. When she came back to the city, she told Celebrimbor that Halbrand was Sauron and had fled. She said nothing about his offer, and she said nothing about his hand.
She kept one thing from that night, besides the memory. Before he fled, Sauron had already given Celebrimbor enough of the secret of the rings that the smith could not now forget it. Galadriel made a decision then that the historians of the West have argued over ever since. She did not destroy the work. She persuaded Celebrimbor to change it, so that the rings he made would be made without Sauron's hand in them, of Elvish craft alone, and there would be three of them instead of the two Sauron had proposed, so that the power would be divided and no single bearer would be able to master it. It was wise counsel, and in another age it might have saved the world. It also ensured that the work continued, and that one of the three rings would come in time to her. The forging of the Three belongs to the next book of this history. Here the historian notes only that Galadriel came out of that night with a secret, and that the secret was not the identity of the Dark Lord, which she had told, but the fact that she had held his hand.
Chapter VIII: The Parting of Friends
Elrond came to Eregion in the spring, sent by Gil-galad to oversee the forging of the rings, and the friendship between Galadriel and Elrond, which had survived the long hunt, the gift of passage and her leap into the Sundering Sea, did not survive his visit. The historians of Lindon have tended to treat the breach as a small thing, a misunderstanding between proud people. It was not small. Of all the losses recorded in this book, it was the one that mattered most, because Elrond was the last person in Middle-earth who could have stopped what was coming.
He learned the truth by accident, from the smith of the Mírdain who had watched from the holly. The smith was troubled by what he had seen and assumed that Elrond, as the High King's herald and Galadriel's dearest friend, already knew. He mentioned the moment on the riverbank as one mentions something everyone has heard. Elrond did not let it show. He went to Galadriel that same night in the gardens of Ost-in-Edhil and asked her, as gently as he knew how, whether there was anything about the night on the Glanduin that she had not told him. She looked at him and said no. He told her what the smith had seen. Celebrimbor, who was close enough to hear the end of their conversation, said afterward that he had never seen her so angry, and that the anger was not at Elrond but at being seen. She did not deny it. She said that she had taken the Dark Lord's hand for the space of a breath, that she had let it go, and that her letting go was what mattered, not her taking it. She said that Elrond, who had never been offered anything, had no right to judge someone who had refused everything.
Elrond's answer is recorded in his own words, because he wrote them down that night in a letter to Gil-galad that came West in Círdan's ships, and it is one of the most painful documents in the archives of Avallónë. He wrote that he did not blame her for being tempted, because no one could blame anyone for that. What he could not forgive, he wrote, was the lie. She had stood before the High King's herald and told him half of the truth, and she had chosen which half. If she could keep this from him, she could keep anything, and he would never again know which of her counsels was hers and which was something else speaking through her. He wrote that he loved her and would always love her, but that he could no longer trust her. He asked the High King to recall him to Lindon. Gil-galad did. Elrond left Eregion within the week. He and Galadriel did not speak again for more than a hundred years, and when they did, it was across the ruins of the world.
The historians of the West have long debated whether Elrond was right. Celebrimbor thought he was too hard. Olórin thought he was exactly as hard as he needed to be, and that his only error was leaving. If he had stayed in Eregion, Olórin said, beside her, angry and unforgiving and present, she might never have gone where she went. Galadriel herself, in the one conversation on the subject that has come down to us, said only that Elrond had been the last person in the world who told her the truth to her face, and that after he left, no one ever did again. This is not quite accurate. There was one other. But he was far away, in a land of fire and ash, building a tower, and he did not tell her the truth. He told her what she wanted to hear, and he waited.
So ended the first part of the life of Galadriel of the Noldor, called by the people who would one day kneel to her the Queen Unfading. She had lost her brother to the Dark Lord, her husband to the sea, her companions to the ice, the faith of Men to the fire, and her dearest friend to a single lie. She had kept one thing through all of it: her certainty that she alone had seen the danger clearly, and that she alone had never stopped watching. It was true. That was what made it so dangerous. In the next part of this history, the Elves would forge their rings, the Dark Lord would forge his, and she would discover that there was one offer she was unable to refuse.
Here ends the first book of The Queen Unfading.
from
SmarterArticles

In 2018, a lawyer acting for Amazon wrote to the US National Labor Relations Board about a fired warehouse worker in Baltimore. The letter, published by The Verge in April 2019, contained a sentence that has followed the company ever since: “Amazon's system tracks the rates of each individual associate's productivity,” it said, “and automatically generates any warnings or terminations regarding quality or productivity without input from supervisors.”
Amazon pushed back. “It is absolutely not true that employees are terminated through an automatic system,” a spokesperson said. The Verge summarised the company's position in a parenthetical that turns out to be the most important line in the story: “(Amazon says supervisors are able to override the process.)”
Hold on to that parenthetical, because California has just written it into law.
On 30 September 2026, Governor Gavin Newsom signed SB 947, the No Robo Bosses Act of 2026. From 1 July 2027, California employers may not rely solely on an automated decision system to discipline or fire someone, and where they rely on one primarily, a human must corroborate the machine's output before anyone acts on it. Alongside it, Newsom signed AB 1883, banning AI workplace surveillance tools that infer employees' emotional states or collect their neural data. Unions called it a turning point. Employment lawyers had client alerts out by 1 October.
This is real progress. It also raises a question the bill's title skates over. The scoring, ranking and monitoring systems stay switched on. The rate is still calculated; the idle time is still logged. What changes is that a person must look at the output and agree with it. So what is a human decision, when the human's job is to check a machine's homework using the machine's own numbers?
The details carry the argument, so start with the text.
SB 947, authored by state senator Jerry McNerney and sponsored by the California Federation of Labor Unions, AFL-CIO, covers “automated decision systems”. Law firms reading the bill describe the definition as any computational process derived from machine learning, statistical modelling, data analytics or artificial intelligence that issues a simplified output, “including a score, classification, or recommendation”. That reaches well beyond tools sold with “AI” on the box.
The core obligation is triggered when an employer “primarily relies” on such a system to discipline or terminate a worker. The employer must then direct a human reviewer to corroborate the output with supporting information; analyses by Covington & Burling, CDF Labor Law and Jackson Lewis list managerial evaluations, personnel records, work product, peer reviews and witness interviews. If the reviewer cannot corroborate the output, or judges it inaccurate, incomplete or misleading, the employer may not use it.
Afterwards, the worker receives a written notice stating that the employer relied primarily on an automated system, that a human corroborated it, who to contact, and that the worker may request what Jackson Lewis's summary calls “a meaningful and objective description of the employee data used by the ADS”. Retaliation is banned, as is using these systems to infer protected characteristics or to predict and punish workers exercising legal rights. Penalties run to 500 dollars per violation, enforced by the Labor Commissioner and public prosecutors.
That enforcement model matters. “The bills have no private enforcement,” Robin Feldman, director of the AI Law & Innovation Institute at UC Law San Francisco, told the Guardian's Danielle Abril. “In other words: workers can't sue. Only the government can enforce the laws.”
The road here was bumpy. McNerney's previous attempt, SB 7, was vetoed on 13 October 2025, with Newsom complaining that it “imposes unfocused notification requirements on any business using even the most innocuous tools”. The most significant thing SB 947 gave up in response was advance notice. SB 7 would have told workers beforehand which automated systems were used in decisions about them. SB 947, as Crowell & Moring's analysis notes, requires only post-use notice to those already affected. Remember that, too.
AB 1883, from Assemblymember Isaac Bryan, is narrower and blunter. It bars employers from using AI-powered workplace surveillance tools to recognise or make inferences or predictions about an individual's emotional state, or to collect neural data generated by measuring the nervous system. Fisher Phillips's employer guide, published on 1 October, says it takes effect on 1 January 2027, carries penalties of up to 500 dollars per violation, and exempts tools used “to ensure safety”.
“AI should expand opportunity, not come at the expense of workers and families,” Newsom said. “AI must remain a tool controlled by humans, not the other way around,” said McNerney. The Guardian framed the package as a response to workers' biggest fear about the technology, quoting Annette Bernhardt of the UC Berkeley Labor Center on workers “speaking up about the fear of job loss” and about what she described as the dehumanising experience of being surveilled and controlled by an algorithm. Lorena Gonzalez, the federation's president, put it more simply to KXTV: “That bosses should have souls.”
Employers' lawyers see it differently. Danielle Ochs of Ogletree Deakins told the Guardian the laws “have teeth”, but argued that “having 10 hoops you have to jump through per tool is not reflective of reality”.
Return to Amazon's parenthetical. Even in 2019, the company's defence was that a human could step in. The system generated warnings; supervisors could override them. On paper, that is close to what SB 947 now mandates.
The numbers are worth sitting with. A company spokesperson told The Verge that roughly 300 full-time associates at the Baltimore fulfilment centre were terminated for inefficiency between August 2017 and September 2018, at a facility of about 2,500 full-time staff. The system tracked “time off task”, the minutes a worker's scanner sat idle. In June 2021, after sustained criticism, Amazon said it would average time off task over a longer period, in the words of then consumer chief executive Dave Clark, “to ensure that there's more signal and less noise”. The metric survived. Only its smoothing window changed.
The question was never whether a human could intervene. It was whether anyone did, and on what basis.
That question has a name. In 2019 Ben Wagner, then at the Vienna University of Economics and Business, defined “quasi-automation” in the journal Policy & Internet as “inclusion of humans as a basic rubber-stamping mechanism in an otherwise completely automated decision-making system”. Rules written for purely automated decisions, he warned, “do not apply if human beings are (rubber-stamping) automated decisions”. The human turns a machine decision into a human one for legal purposes, without changing much else.
The same year, the researcher Madeleine Clare Elish introduced the “moral crumple zone”. Just as a car's crumple zone absorbs a crash, she wrote, the human in a highly automated system “may become simply a component” that “bears the brunt of the moral and legal responsibilities when the overall system malfunctions”. Unlike a car's, this crumple zone “protects the integrity of the technological system, at the expense of the nearest human operator”.
Put the two ideas together and the risk in SB 947's design comes into focus. The reviewer becomes the legal author of a decision whose substance was set upstream, by a vendor's model, a threshold chosen in operations and a dashboard nobody on the floor can interrogate. If the decision is wrong, the reviewer signed it.
Is that too cynical? Supervisors argue with spreadsheets all the time.
The evidence is more mixed, and more interesting, than either side admits. The classic review, by Raja Parasuraman and Dietrich Manzey in Human Factors in 2010, found that automation complacency occurs “under conditions of multiple-task load”, appears in “both naive and expert participants”, and that automation bias produces errors of omission and commission when decision aids are imperfect. The line that should trouble anyone drafting a training requirement: automation bias “cannot be prevented by training or instructions”. A shift manager reviewing productivity flags between everything else a shift manager does is close to the textbook case of multiple-task load.
More recent experiments complicate the picture usefully. Saar Alon-Barkat and Madalina Busuioc, writing in the Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, ran three studies in the Netherlands with 2,854 participants, including civil servants. They did not find automation bias in the simple sense: people did not trust an algorithm more than an equivalent human expert. They found “selective adherence” instead, a stronger tendency to follow advice that aligned with group stereotypes, whether it came from an algorithm or a person. Tellingly, the effect vanished among the civil servants, tested shortly after the Netherlands' childcare benefits scandal over a discriminatory algorithm; the authors suggest heightened awareness of algorithmic bias was the difference.
For a corroboration requirement, that is arguably worse news. The problem is not mystical deference to machines; it is that reviewers accept outputs that confirm what they already believe. A score saying the employee everyone finds difficult is underperforming will be easy to corroborate. A score saying the manager's favourite is slacking will invite scepticism. Review does not neutralise bias there. It filters the machine's output through the reviewer's priors, then certifies the result.
Policy research lands in the same place. In 2022, Ben Green of the University of Michigan surveyed 41 policies prescribing human oversight of government algorithms in Computer Law & Security Review. He concluded that people are largely unable to perform the oversight functions asked of them, so such policies offer a false sense of security and let vendors and agencies shirk accountability. His alternative is institutional oversight: scrutiny of whether an algorithm should be used at all, before deployment, by bodies empowered to say no.
Even the EU's AI Act concedes the problem. Article 14 requires high-risk systems to be built so overseers can “remain aware of the possible tendency of automatically relying or over-relying on the output produced by a high-risk AI system (automation bias)”. It is striking to find a cognitive bias named in a regulation. It is revealing that the remedy is awareness.
The strongest word in SB 947 is “corroborate”. It implies independent evidence, not a second look at the same screen.
But consider what corroborating evidence exists in a modern warehouse, call centre or delivery depot. The manager's evaluation is often built on the same dashboard. The personnel file holds previous automated warnings. The work product is measured by the scanner. CDF partner Warren Hodges reads the bill as letting the reviewer use either the data that produced the output or other supporting information. If that reading holds, the most available corroboration for a rate-based firing will often be the rate data itself. The system says the rate was low; the reviewer confirms it by checking the rate.
That reflects what the law chooses to regulate. SB 947 governs the final step, not the instruments. The quotas, idle-time thresholds and rankings stay, subject to existing rules such as California's 2021 warehouse law, AB 701, which already requires employers to give workers a written description of each quota they must meet.
Europe's experience with Amazon shows how contested those instruments are. In December 2023 France's data protection authority, the CNIL, fined Amazon France Logistique 32 million euros, finding three scanner indicators unlawful, including a “stow machine gun” flag for items scanned less than 1.25 seconds apart and an idle-time indicator. On 23 December 2025 the Conseil d'État overturned the findings on all three indicators and cut the fine to 15 million euros, noting for instance that the idle-time flag only triggered after more than ten consecutive minutes. It upheld the finding that Amazon had not justified keeping every indicator for 31 days.
Whoever is right, the hardest questions in algorithmic management live at the level of the metric: what it measures, what triggers it, how long data is kept and who sees it. A rule about who signs the dismissal letter reaches none of that.
There is also the question of where the decision really happens, and the EU's top court has answered a version of it. In the SCHUFA case in December 2023, the Court of Justice of the European Union considered a German credit agency whose probability scores lenders used to grant or refuse credit. SCHUFA argued that the banks made the decisions. The court disagreed: where a score plays a “determining role” in the outcome, producing it is itself an automated decision under Article 22 of the GDPR.
Apply that logic at work. If a productivity score below a threshold almost always produces a warning, and a run of warnings almost always produces dismissal, the meaningful decision was made when the score was computed. The human at the end is executing it. California's “primarily relies” test gestures at this reality, to its credit, but responds by adding a reviewer at the end of the pipeline rather than scrutinising the scoring at the start.
California is entering territory where the evidence on “human review” is already in, much of it from the gig economy.
Article 22 of the GDPR gives people the right not to be subject to decisions “based solely on automated processing” that significantly affect them. The obvious workaround is to insert a person, and regulators anticipated it. Guidance from the Article 29 Working Party, later endorsed by the European Data Protection Board, says oversight must be “meaningful, rather than just a token gesture”, by someone with “the authority and competence to change the decision”.
Then came the drivers. Worker Info Exchange and the App Drivers & Couriers Union brought test cases against Uber and Ola in Amsterdam. On 4 April 2023, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal largely sided with the drivers. Uber argued that humans had reviewed its automated deactivations; the court found that review was “not… much more than a purely symbolic act” and treated the decisions as solely automated. It also held that Ola's “fraud probability scores” and fraud-based deactivations were automated decisions, and rejected both firms' claims that trade secrets justified withholding how their systems worked.
In October 2023, the Amsterdam District Court ordered Uber to pay 584,000 euros in penalties for failing to comply with that transparency order for two dismissed drivers from the UK and Portugal. Instead of disclosing the decision logic, Uber had offered information about its after-the-fact human review, the very review the appeal court had called symbolic.
Then, on 21 August 2026, the Dutch Data Protection Authority fined Uber 824.99 million euros, as reported by Bloomberg, Quartz and TechCrunch, for using automated systems to suspend and deactivate drivers without adequate human assessment, and without giving them enough information to challenge the decisions, in conduct that ran up to 2022. “Drivers were deactivated without pardon,” said Monique Verdier, the authority's deputy chair. “From one moment to the next, they no longer had any income through Uber. That's forbidden.” Uber called the fine disproportionate, said humans are now involved before deactivations, and said it would appeal.
That response is the whole debate in miniature. The answer to an automated-decision ruling is that a human is now involved. Whether that human is meaningful is what the next case will have to establish.
EU legislators have tried to learn. The Platform Work Directive, adopted in October 2024 and due to be transposed by member states by 2 December 2026, goes beyond SB 947 in three ways. Article 10(5) says any decision to restrict, suspend or terminate a platform worker's account or contract “shall be taken by a human being”. Article 10(2) says overseers need “the competence, training and authority necessary” to override automated decisions and “shall enjoy protection from dismissal or its equivalent, disciplinary measures and other adverse treatment where they exercise their functions”. And Article 11 gives workers a right to an explanation and to a substantiated written reply to a review request within two weeks.
The overseer protection addresses exactly what the research keeps finding. A reviewer who overrides the system too often, slowing throughput or contradicting management, is exposed. One who agrees is safe. Without protection, the rational strategy is to agree. SB 947 has no equivalent clause.
The AI Act adds another layer, classing AI used for termination decisions, task allocation and performance monitoring as high-risk under Annex III. Article 26(7) requires employers to inform workers and their representatives before deploying such systems, and Article 86 grants a right to “clear and meaningful explanations of the role of the AI system in the decision-making procedure”. The catch is timing. The EU's Digital Omnibus on AI, in force since 27 July 2026, pushed the Annex III compliance date from 2 August 2026 to 2 December 2027. Europe's tougher model is, for now, mostly a model.
AB 1883 targets the instruments rather than the decision, which makes it the more structurally ambitious law, even if it covers a narrower slice of practice.
The Guardian's reporting gave examples of what is at stake: heat maps tracking how long workers spend in the bathroom, and Kaiser Permanente nurses who said automated systems rated their tone of voice with patients. Emotion inference has been sold to call centres, retailers and recruiters on the premise that a face or voice reveals an inner state.
The science does not support that premise in the way vendors imply. In 2019, five researchers led by the psychologist Lisa Feldman Barrett published a 68-page review in Psychological Science in the Public Interest. People do sometimes smile when happy or scowl when angry, more than chance predicts, they found. “Yet how people communicate anger, disgust, fear, happiness, sadness, and surprise varies substantially across cultures, situations, and even across people within a single situation.” A scowl “often communicates something other than an emotional state”.
Europe acted on similar reasoning. Article 5(1)(f) of the AI Act has prohibited AI systems inferring emotions in the workplace since 2 February 2025, with medical and safety exceptions, and the Platform Work Directive bans platforms from processing data on workers' “emotional or psychological state”.
California's version leaves gaps. Proskauer's lawyers note that the bill does not say whether a “violation” accrues per worker, per incident or per pay period, and that the safety exception could cover tools assessing fatigue or burnout. The European Commission's AI Act guidelines treat fatigue as a physical state rather than an emotion, so detecting a driver's drowsiness is not emotion recognition. Ochs told the Guardian that opponents feared the rules could prohibit helpful AI that keeps truckers from falling asleep at the wheel. Expect the line between monitoring for safety and monitoring for mood to be litigated.
One group is conspicuously absent from SB 947, and it is the group whose cases built Europe's law on robo-firing.
“Rideshare drivers have been living with AI and algorithmic management long before most workers ever heard those terms,” Nicole Moore of Rideshare Drivers United told KQED. The new protections do not reach them, because California classifies rideshare drivers as independent contractors under Proposition 22, the 2020 ballot measure, and SB 947 protects employees.
The irony is hard to miss. The Amsterdam judgments, the 584,000-euro penalty and the 825-million-euro fine all concern drivers deactivated by software. In the state where Uber and Lyft are headquartered, those are precisely the workers the No Robo Bosses Act does not cover.
What should workers be told about the systems that evaluate them? California's answer, for now, is: after the fact, and on request. A worker learns an automated system was primarily relied upon only once disciplined or fired, and can then ask for a description of the data used. Gonzalez told the Guardian that the federation plans to revive a requirement for employers to disclose workplace AI use, after a disclosure bill died in the Assembly appropriations committee this year.
Post-use notice has value. It creates a paper trail and a named person to ask. But it arrives when the worker has least leverage. You cannot change behaviour you did not know was measured, contest a threshold you never saw, or organise around a system you discover through your own dismissal letter.
The tools for something better already exist. AB 701 shows California can require written, advance disclosure of quotas and the consequences of missing them. In its February 2025 Dun & Bradstreet Austria judgment, the EU's Court of Justice held that people subject to automated decisions are owed an explanation enabling them to understand and challenge it, which a complex formula or an exhaustive list of processing steps does not satisfy. The UC Berkeley Labor Center's 2021 report “Data and Algorithms at Work”, by Bernhardt, Lisa Kresge and Reem Suleiman, argued that workers should be told what data-driven technologies are in use and have rights to access and correct their data.
Drawing those threads together, and this is an argument rather than a description of any statute, workers should be told before any system is used on them:
That last item is the one most likely to separate oversight from theatre, and the one employers are least likely to volunteer. An override rate near zero does not prove rubber-stamping; the system might simply be accurate. But from the outside, a reviewer who never disagrees is indistinguishable from one who cannot. As Green argues, the useful evidence about whether humans are checking machines is aggregate, and it has to be collected deliberately.
So how much of an automated decision's power does a human sign-off actually check?
Some, honestly. SB 947 ends the crudest version of robo-firing, where a termination is generated and dispatched with nobody looking. It forces employers to assemble something like a case file. It gives a dismissed worker a document, a contact and a right to ask what data was used. It voids outputs a reviewer judges inaccurate, incomplete or misleading. And it puts California on record, as the first US state to do so, that the final word on a livelihood belongs to a person.
But an automated management system's power was never concentrated in the dismissal letter. It lives in the targets that set the pace of the day, the metrics that decide who gets flagged, the rankings that shape whom a manager watches, and the thresholds that turn a slow afternoon into a disciplinary record. None of that is touched by a duty to corroborate. The reviewer inherits a frame someone else built, evidence the same system generated and, in California, no statutory protection for disagreeing.
Europe's record suggests what it takes to make the human matter: a decision reserved to a person in law, overseers protected when they override, explanations that let workers contest the logic rather than merely receive the outcome, and regulators willing to ask whether the human changed anything. Even then, Uber's response to an 825-million-euro fine was to point out that humans are now in the loop.
Amazon said much the same in 2019. Supervisors are able to override the process. California has made that sentence a legal obligation. The work that remains is making sure it is also true.

Tim Green UK-based Systems Theorist & Independent Technology Writer
Tim explores the intersections of artificial intelligence, decentralised cognition, and posthuman ethics. His work, published at smarterarticles.co.uk, challenges dominant narratives of technological progress while proposing interdisciplinary frameworks for collective intelligence and digital stewardship.
His writing has been featured on Ground News and shared by independent researchers across both academic and technological communities.
ORCID: 0009-0002-0156-9795 Email: tim@smarterarticles.co.uk
Listen to the free weekly SmarterArticles Podcast
from
Roscoe's Story
In Summary: * I've just taken the 1st round of night meds and that moves me into the night meds / night prayers phase of my evening. Listening now to the 4th Quarter of the IU / Washington football game and the Hoosiers and Huskies are tied, 17 to 17. I'm planning to finish the night meds and night prayers after the game, and head to bed after that.
Prayers, etc.: * I have a daily prayer regimen I try to follow throughout the day from early morning, as soon as I roll out of bed, until head hits pillow at night.
Health Metrics: * bw= 218.80 lbs. * bp= 141/67 (62)
Exercise: * morning stretches, balance exercises, kegel pelvic floor exercises, half squats, calf raises, toe raises, wall push-ups, BP breathing exercises, pilates
Diet: * 05:40 – 1 banana, 3 little chocolate chip cookies * 07:00 – 1 ham sandwich * 10:45 – home made meat and vegetable stew, white rice, fresh pineapple rings * 13:30 – fresh pineapple rings, 2 HEB Bakery cookies * 16:00 – stew meat
Activities, Chores, etc.: * 04:15 – wake * 06:10 – bank accounts activity monitored * 06:30 – read, write, pray, follow news reports from various sources, surf the socials, take daily meds, unpack, organize, and nap * 10:30 – listening to ESPN Radio ahead of the Ohio St. / Nebraska college football game * 10:45 – brunch at home with Sylvia * 11:45 – back to the football game * 14:10 – with Nebraska ahead of Ohio St. 24 to 21 in the 4th Quarter, I've switched over to the pregame broadcast of the IU / Washington game. Opening kickoff of the IU game is only minutes away.
Chess: * 10:29 – moved in all pending CC games
from defensivepersonality
Self-thinking quotes
“Seeing reality is a universal happening. But hearing your internal monologue, no one can know but you.”
“Most of the things I think of end up true or eventually becoming true.”
“Can I see inside people and hear all their thoughts and memories? I’d like to think so.”
“The greatest injustice to humans is believing that the mind doesn’t have the same use as the heart.”
“Feeling seen is the biggest rush a person can experience. When you feel that with the other person too, that’s an added blessing.”
from TheMadMan
It started with my great depression. I won't get into the details but I will call “my great depression” the period of time in high school of a around a year throughout which I suffered a state of deep depression and despondency. The climax of it being me trying to kill myself which I failed to do. I must have been around 16 years old at that time. Around that time was the start of the development period of my dark aura that persists today albeit significantly diminished.
During that period, it was the most intense. I exhumed a negative aura. Everyone that stared at me or came in contact with me would be negatively impacted. I don't mean physical contact. I mean conceptual contact. When they noticed me. So seeing and listening are the main ways to perceive me. Or just knowing that I am in their periphery. The more they perceived me, the worse my influence would be. Their smiles would turn to a frown. Their jubilation into sorrow or stress and their optimism would slowly be chipped away but my aura until it completely grasps their hearts as long as I am there. Like a beast taking mouthful bites out of their foundations that kept them up and together.
I don't mean it to sound like a power. I didn't do anything special. And I hated it. It was a curse. It was their empathy that exposed them to my influence. Because they cared, they opened themselves up to contact with my feelings. And that's what sullied them. They thought that they could surmount my negative-ness with their positive-ness. They thought they could fix me. And I knew they stood no chance. As long as I kept my distance I wouldn't hurt them. I didn't want to poison them. I didn't want them to reach out to me in fear of ending up like me. I didn't believe they had any words that could console me, nor any solutions to my problems. I thought they were living in self-conceit. That they choose the blue pill. And in their delusion they could accept this dreaded world and see it with color. A fake color, in my opinion, but that's what they chose to see. The more truthfully I were to speak and express my sense of nihilism, the more I would shutter that fake fragile reality they had build. And I didn't want to hurt them. So I tried to shun their helping hand.
The aura was strong back then and I couldn't seal it well. If I opened my mouth, the fake words that came out were less effective than the real words, but the feelings behind them that painted them all over gave away the truth and still affected them. I said the common perfunctory things like “I'm fine”, “it's nothing”, “I'm just a little different” but my breaking voice and my dejected body language still affected them.
13 years have passed since then and my dark aura has subsided but is still present. I still fear to get to close to people knowing I can't hide my dark heart forever. Knowing when it's seen, it will pollute them. I can still see it is active in everyday life. When I walk by the sideroad people instinctively avoid me. Like a magnetic field pushing them a step away. Even though my appearance is innocent, it's the small things in body language that still affect people. And not just people. Cats scrutinize me as I approach them. I can tell they detect the smallest movements. My heart clenches and I become more aware of my muscle movements. I exert force of will trying to make my muscles move naturally. A very contradicting effort. And it doesn't work. I will step slightly wrong. Or my hand or head will tweak. And that's when the cats jump in fright. I can't contain it. It is just me. I see others pass by and the cats only give one look before they reside back to carelessness. In the bus people might sit next to fat people or even people that I believe society would classify as “weirdos” or “creeps”. But they don't sit next to me. Despite trying hard to look the part, they can tell me apart.
I don't want to spend too much time with coworkers or family. I feel like, slowly but steadily, the more my boss gets to know me and the closer we are, the more I damage him. I think even his bright ambition and persistent dreams won't match my stubborn darkness. I don't want to see him fall victim to it too. I minimize the time with my family and default to perfunctory responses when socializing with them. I put my focus on things that are trivial. Any honesty on how I am doing, what I believe in, or what I feel will result in hurting them. I don't want to hurt them.
That's how I keep people safe. By staying away. I thought I was past this. I thought I told my self back then, in order to escape this stress, that I would not care about the consequences of my dark aura. I thought I decided “let the world burn” as long as I can be free in it. It seems I haven't. There is still a sliver of that self-sacrifice instinct. But truthfully, the biggest obstacle is not my capacity to do it. I can be careless about the effects I have. But I can't be careless about how that can bounce back. I can lose my job. I could lose the support of my family. And by extension, I could lose my ability to survive. Now that I self reflect, I don't think my dark aura has depleted at all. In fact, I think it has solidified. It's just that I can more naturally hide it better. I live with the hope that there will come a day when I don't have to hide it anymore, regardless of the consequences on anyone but me.
from TheMadMan
The below is what I wrote in the past. As I don't want it to be lost I will publish it now
Hello everyone. I am writing this with the intend to give a glimpse, a peer into my mind and thought and psyche and I guess you could say, madness. I will die as we all will. Maybe I will suicide. I don't really intend to, but I do think about it sometimes only as a means to vent. I am basically being dramatic. Or maybe lightning will struck and I will drop dead tomorrow. Not very likely but how about getting ran over by a car, or someone shoots me, or a decease strikes and takes me out, or I get enrolled in the military, a war starts and I die in action, or I get cancer. There are so many latent dangers really. This is not my final testament. But at least I want to think that there is a chance someone out there, be it my close-ones or a random person will at least here who I am, how I feel, what I think. I want to at least have that drop of existence. Surely with no effect, but at least it gives me comfort that my being, all that I am will not just die with me but there will be a place where it goes on. A mark I left. I know it doesn't reaaaaally matter. For I am a nihilist and I don't think anything really matters in the grand scheme of things. But it does give me a sense of liberty. So I will record my being here. And maybe in other places too.
I guess I should start off by my general mindset. I am very anti-social, to the point you could even call me a misanthrope. Although, I must admit, my moods swing significantly and with frequent unordered intervals. But from since I can remember, I always had a rage in me. I think I take that from my mother's side. I think it's in the Cretan blood in me, but I could be wrong. I think both my dad and mom gave me stubbornness, which is also apparent in my sister. But at least my sister doesn't have this innate rage. When I socialize for example, I constantly have the urge to fight. I have the urge to break things. I can recite stories of when I was very young that my mother has told me which show the same feeling. For example, allegedly, one time we went to the store and I was inside a little court as maybe a ~5yearold? Really young for sure, I saw a glass case with figurines and I suddenly had the urge to break it. I grabbed by it and they had to call 2-3 people to stop me from trying to shake it and break things. Do keep in mind that my mother tends to exaggerate in the stories and I can't recollect such early memories. However, there is not doubt I had that rage in many occasions such as this that I can indeed remember and throughout my life. Nowadays, to the example of socializing, I feel a burning and excitement and rage that begins from head. It feels like it's bulging, and it feels like it's pumping my arms with energy. Most of it concentrated at my hands. I want to tear everything down. Not out of spite or hate though. Please try to understand. At those moments, I don't actually have hate. I am not malicious. I'm just angry. I am not sure why. Maybe it's a natural tendency to try to showoff to girls. Maybe it's that I often think (but try not to act) in a supercilious way and look down on the words, behavior and thoughts of others. Maybe it's because I feel that I am being suppressed because I try to hide these feelings and put on a mask and I blame others for not accepting my angry side. Cause let's be honest. Such behavior are party poopers. Nobody likes that side of mine and it's quite understandable in a way. So I have to hide it otherwise I wouldn't be able to operate and survive in this world full of people. Sure sometimes I get bitter and I might have hate. I mostly hate the world though. Not the people. I'll get into that another time. I call this quality of mine madness. I consider myself very logical and despite my controversial opinions, I don't think I am crazy. Yet, angry is not enough to describe me. Cause in combination with stubbornness what it has manifested as is this determination to oppose the world. Not to submit, not to adapt. But to foolishly cling and justify my anger and fight to fix what makes me angry. My being is not fitted for this world. It's completely off-place. To object changing despite that requires being mad. That's why I adopted this nickname of mad man.
My real name is Athanasios. It's a Greek name that directly translates to Un-dying, from the A- which is un- and Thanatos which is Death. The short name is Thanos. Thanos is known around the globe from Marvel commics as the Mad Titan. I am no titan however. I am a man. A mad man. Another cool coincidence is that Thanos in the comics, attempted to charm Death, personalized as a woman, by killing people, and I theorize, he did so in a bid to become immortal (hence his name fitting). As chance (or I like to think, fate) would have it, I too once dreamed of being immortal for an extensive period of time and was determined to chase that goal despite how 'crazy' it might have seemed. I have not abandoned that idea completely yet. I am simply focusing on other priorities and exploring opportunities for it. In my mind, we have a life of about 80 years. If we say we live up to 80 and start our productive life at around 20, and we will be capable up until around 70, then we have around 50 years of productive life. That is a lot of time. Can you seriously tell me that if one puts their mind and effort to it, they cannot achieve immortality in 50 years? Science has progressed so much in so little and we have so many tools and such potential. Why would immortality not be reachable within 50 years of effort. And if you do achieve it, isn't it the greatest investment ever? You spent 50 years of your life but earned many many times that (Note: not infinite, cause although I do say 'immortality' what I really mean is extending your lifespan by a lot. True immortality would be a curse and it's foolish to think it's achievable within the natural laws that govern us. I don't want to never die. I want the freedom to choose when I die. An important distinction). So it was definitely worth it to sacrifice everything else in your life and pursue immortality. Of course, assuming you make it. But it's a losers mentality to not try for the possibility of not making it. The potential gains far out-weight the risks in my opinion. I know that there are a lot of death-related challenges. Old age, deceases, wars, accidents, you name it. But death from physical damage only requires avoidance and/or preventative measures, protection. Similar for deceases. So we can kind of water it down to just aging. I know I am simplifying, but common, of course it's not easy. We got 50 years to work it out! Quite mad. And quite fitting to Thanos the mad Titan. That was the prelude to Thanos The Mad Man. But there is a lot more madness to follow... Some enthusiastic and brilliant, but I believe most of it is grim and sullen. You've been warned. Please proceed. Please be one to embrace my being. Because as of the writing of this, I have never shown it and noone ever listened.
This post is part of the RPG Blog Carnival: Underworld & Wilderness Adventures.
I have been running an open-world sandbox for five years now. It is set in the Wilderlands of High Fantasy, which I fell in love with due to its minimal keying and maximum flexibility. The former allows me to prepare efficiently, while the latter enables me to place whatever I want into the setting without worrying too much if it will break something.
Placing published modules is relatively easy. Read up, place it in a hex, re-name the site and key characters, and change the flavour as needed. But where Wilderlands always shined are the adventuring locations, described in the briefest of lines.
One of the defining characteristics of a sandbox is that players are free to roam as they wish. This freedom does not mean freedom from consequences though. I continuously roll for wilderness encounters. These can be with wandering monsters, but can also mean encountering a ravaged ruin or a lurid lair.
I have a Judge binder with a collection of one-page dungeons, geomorphs, and random tables. This allows me to quickly generate either of the aforementioned. The smaller sites can be rolled very quickly. The larger sites are best rolled iteratively. For example, if it is a dungeon complex, first time the players encounter it they will most probably explored the environs, interact with the entrance, and maybe the first few rooms. Thus, there is no need to roll hundred keys in advance.
But let's go back to smaller sites. These can be captured in a few short paragraphs, and sometime don't even need a map. Allow me to demonstrate with a real example. I will go step by step, and explain my thinking as we go along.
Since I am running an OD&D game, I decided to limit myself to period appropriate resources. Thus, I used:
Tome of Adventure Design was an exception, which I will explain later.
I put the Judge binder and the books on the table, opened a plain text editor on my laptop, as well as a digital dice roller (I roll in terminal).
When rolling smaller sites I consider them to be either a ravaged ruin or a lurid lair. There are tables for both in Ready Ref Sheets. In this case I roll on tables on pages 43 and 44:
| Element | Roll | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Class | 4 | Vestiges |
| Condition | 8 | Large crater |
| Covering | 10 | Vines |
| State | 5 | Corroded & eroded |
| Keeper | 4 | Undead-types |
| Vestiges | 3 | Fountain |
| Fountain | 6 | Spray |
I have a fountain of spraying type. It is corroded and covered with vines. The fountain is in a large crater, and it is guarded by an “undead-type.”
At this moment I turn to Eldritch Wizardry because it has the most comprehensive encounter tables for OD&D. I turn to page 56 and roll on the UNDEAD-TYPES column. Will O’ Wisp is the result. Now I turn to page 35 of Greyhawk to read more about the monster:
WILL O’ WISPS: These creatures are highly clever and seek to lure their intended victims into some spot where they will be trapped and expire, and when their life force leaves them the Will O’ Wisps feed upon this force. They commonly inhabit deserted places which have areas of quicksand, mires and the like. Any metal weapon will harm a Will O’ Wisp—providing it can hit the creature. If cornered the Will O’ Wisp will strike at its opponents doing 2–12 points of electrical damage per hit. These creatures can alter shape, become bright or dim, or disappear entirely at will. In order to save their lives they will reveal where their treasure is hidden, but the Will O’ Wisp has to be at 3 or fewer hit points to so reveal its treasure.
What a perfect combination!
Will O’ Wisp has treasure type A. I reference Monsters & Treasure, and roll:
16 000 gp worth of treasure with a very lethal defender.
At this moment I decided to look up fountains in the Tome of Adventure Design. Of course there are. I decide to roll on Table 3-53A and 3-85:
Great, just the right amount of information. Now I have everything I need to make sense of it.
First, the crater size. By large I will go with sub-hex size, which in my case is 1 league (2,5 miles or 4 kilometres). Craters of these size usually disappear after some time, so since this one still exists it is not older than 100 000 years.
Due to its size it might not even be clear to adventurers they are entering a crater. When they reach any of the adjoining hexes I will mention that the ground slopes downward, concavely. If there is a dwarf, elf, druid or ranger I would mention that the entire area is depressed.
Whatever made the crater is not what led to ruin of the fountain and surroundings. There are vines, meaning there is overgrowth. Thick shrubs, brambles, and bushes carpet the entire crater. During the day, the fountain is in essence invisible. During the night, Will O’ Wisp shines from top of the fountain, visible from all adjoining hexes.
Once the crater is entered visibility is significantly reduced, because it is 30 feet deep, and completely overgrown. Speed is reduced to half. One needs a machete or hatchet or similar, otherwise they have 1:6 chance to waste a time (a turn or an hour) finding their way forward.
Will O’ Wisps lures greedy people to the fountain during the night, but dims during the day. When someone gets close to the actual fountain, Will O’ Wisp relocates and shines there when the night comes. Its treasure is not in the fountain, but in one of the gnarly, bent trees, elsewhere.
The fountain itself is 30 feet wide, and 20 feet tall. It is made of brass, and covered in verdigris (green patina), making it near impossible to find given the vines. It is filled with soil and does not flow anymore. I imagine a typical fountain with some sort of animals that were supposed to spout water as a central feature. These then are ten feet tall, with a centre-piece flower on a stalk adding another ten feet. There are four animals, cranes, each facing a cardinal direction. Spouts are the bottom of their raised foot (right).
If a person stands in front of each, with their right foot raised, then the flower on top falls off. Within the stalk is a rolled thin sheet of bronze with pattern. If one folds along the pattern, they get a key.
“The Fountain of Good and Bad Fortune” is how the locals calls it. I am going to use this to create rumours. People call it “good fortune” because it fulfils wishes. They call it “bad fortune” because those go looking for it either don't return, or return having given up after following the light.
Now that I have thought this through all I have to do is draw the map and write it up so I can pull them when needed.
Regarding the map. One league is 2,5 miles, which is 4 400 yards. OD&D movement rates are 3/6/9/12, which would be 30/60/90/120 yards in the wilderness. There are two moves per turn, so 60/120/180/240 yards. But due to terrain everyone is moving at half speed (except Druids).
Since we play online using Owlbear Rodeo I can quickly draw whatever. Given the aforementioned, each square will be 120 yards, with a 40 by 40 square map (4 800 yards top to bottom, left to right).
There will be eight points on the map: one fountain, six locations where Will O’ Wisp moves if someone comes close to the fountain, and treasure location.
So, I open Owlbear Rodeo, and quickly draw the following:

A. Fountain. B. Gnarly tree. 1-6. Alternative beacon locations.
The Divine Beacon of Fortune. A thirty foot deep crater roughly 3 800 yards long and 3 400 yards wide is brimming with bushes, brambles, vines, and bent, knotted trees. The overgrowth conceals its true depth. Within the crater it is difficult to see more then several hundred yards ahead. It is also difficult to move (half speed) and advance without machete, hatchet, or similar tool (1:6 chance to waste a turn find path forward). For every hour spent traversing the crater, there is 1:6 chance for encountering a dessicated humanoid corpse.
At night, a bright light is visible from three miles away. This, the locals say, is the Divine Beacon of Fortune. Those who reach its source are destined to have their deepest wishes fulfilled. The source of light is Will O’ Wisp, and the crater is its hunting ground. It most often shines above the Crane Fountain (A), because it is roughly in the centre of the crater.
If anyone comes close, it will relocate to another location and shine there (roll 1d6 to determine the spot). It will shine only during the night, savouring in the suffering of those unwilling to give up their treasure hunt. It will only electrocute those that attempt to harm it. A gnarly, bent tree in north-eastern portion of the crater (B) hides its treasure: 4 000 gold pieces, and 21 gems (12 000 gpv: 4×50 gpv, 8×100 gpv, 4×500 gpv, 4×1 000 gpv, 1×5 000 gpv).
The Crane Fountain is a large brass fountain, with thirty feet wide round base, four teen feet tall cranes facing cardinal directions, and and a twenty feet tall flower in the centre. It is completely covered in verdigris and vines, making it near impossible to find (three consecutive passive secret doors checks, or two active consecutive secret door checks).
The fountain is filled with soil, rotting vegetation, and bones of those that had perished long ago. The spouts are at the bottom of cranes' right legs, which are raised. If four people stand in front of each, with their right leg raised, then the flower will fall off. Atop the rod (flower stalk) is a circular depression, and within it is a thin, rolled sheet of bronze. On it is some sort of linear pattern. If the sheet is folded according to the pattern, it forms a key.
OD&D stat block Will O’ Wisp (1): HD 9, AC -8, MV 18, ATK special, DMG 2-12, Source GH35
Swords & Wizardry stat block Will-o’-the-wisp (1): HD 9; AC –8[27]; Atk shock (2d6); Move 18; Save 6; Morale 12; AL C; CL/XP 11/2400; Special: lights (brighten or dim, or form wraith-like form).
I stop the timer. It says 19 minutes and 27 seconds. Not bad. I lost some time thumbing through the book, and then looking up median crater sizes. But otherwise, I am quite happy. A gameable site; dynamic so I can use it next time the players encounter a ravaged ruin in most of the hexes. I can also use it as a source of rumours if I want. I left enough details for myself to just run it from the key and image, even if I use it in two to three years. Not to mention that it was fun to do.
But back to my main point. I hope this demonstration was helpful in seeing how well curated set of random tables and a little bit of association and imagination can quickly produce a gameable site for a sandbox game. The beauty of such open-ended campaigns is that you never know what might happen next. That foldable brass key? Maybe it opens a portal to another dimension. Or a lich's crypt. Or king's vault. Who knows? All I know is that I have a site I can use, knowing that we will have good time.
These small sites are not the main course, but they are an important part of the sandbox experience because they make the world lived in, instead of disjointed points of light and dungeon complexes. Plus, in a long running campaign it is good to have smaller sites that can be tackled in a session or two. This is especially important when players have multiple characters engaged in different activities. But that might be a topic for another blog post.
#RPGBlogCarnival #OSR #Resource
from AI Tools Test | Reviews, Comparisons & Guides

Multi-unit retail chains, quick-service restaurant franchises, and hospitality groups deal with high seasonal turnover and frequent menu or point-of-sale (POS) updates, which is why operations directors map out how to use AI training video generator workflows to deliver consistent two-minute shift briefings to every store location. When headquarters launches a seasonal promotion or updates the return-fraud verification workflow at the register, emailing a twelve-page PDF playbook to three hundred store managers rarely works. Busy shift leads do not have time to read dense binders between customer rushes, and new part-time associates learn much faster by watching a visual walkthrough on a back-office tablet.
Sending a video crew to film a store demo for every biweekly promotion is too slow and expensive. Building modular scene briefings from existing operations guides lets headquarters ship visual, multilingual store training in a single afternoon.
When franchise operations leads evaluate the best AI training video generator for frontline associates, the top priority is speed of comprehension on a breakroom tablet or smartphone.
In a high-turnover retail or quick-service restaurant environment, associates rarely sit at a desktop computer for thirty-minute LMS modules. Training happens in two-minute windows before a shift starts or while restocking the front counter: – Visual POS Screen Walkthroughs Beat Text Binders: Highlighting the exact loyalty-override button on a register screenshot eliminates guesswork during a busy checkout line. – Spoken Customer De-Escalation Scripts: Hearing a calm, two-way dialogue between a customer and a shift lead teaches tone of voice far better than a bulleted PDF policy. – Instant Scene-Level Updates: When a promotional bundle or return rule changes mid-season, headquarters can edit a single scene card and republish the briefing without re-filming.
When a multi-unit retail training team adopts Leadde's studio for AI generated training videos, a ten-page seasonal merchandising and POS update packet (.pptx, .pdf, .doc, .docx, or .txt) turns into a concise two-minute associate briefing without requiring camera gear or timeline editing software.
Configuring Training Objective, Audience, and Narrative Style inside the AI Video Creator for frontline store training.
Start by uploading your store playbook from the workspace Knowledge Base into the AI Video Creator and selecting the 1-3 min Summary runtime bracket. Before generating the scene outline, configure the Training Objective, Audience, Speaker Background, and Narrative Style so the script uses direct, action-oriented language tailored for frontline store associates rather than corporate jargon.
Once the draft scenes open on the studio canvas, three visual and audio controls bring the store SOP to life:
– Word-Synced POS Callout Animations: Place your POS register screenshots or shelf planogram diagrams onto the canvas, select a highlight badge or arrow, and click Animate. Dragging the entrance, emphasis, and exit triggers onto the exact words in your script ensures the discount key lights up the moment the presenter names it.
– Two-Person Dialogue With Multiple Avatars: Teaching associates how to handle a return without a receipt or an order delay is much clearer when modeled as a conversation. Switching a scene to Multiple Avatars lets one voice play the frustrated shopper while a second voice demonstrates the calm, policy-compliant store response.
– Equipment Demos via Video Fit Modes: When showing how to calibrate an espresso machine or scan an inventory tag, upload a 10-second .mp4 clip into My Media and set Video Fit to Insert. The presenter introduces the step, automatically pauses narration while the equipment clip plays in full, and then resumes speaking to summarize the safety check.
Evaluating legacy store communication methods alongside modular AI generated training videos shows why operations teams replace printed binders with tablet-ready briefings:
| Store Rollout Method | Frontline Associate Comprehension | Consistency Across 300+ Locations | Effort to Update POS or Menu Changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Printed Back-Office Playbook | Low; skimmed during busy shift changes | Poor; critical steps missed on night shifts | High printing and shipping cost per store |
| Manager Verbal Pre-Shift Huddle | Medium; no visual reference for POS buttons | Varies widely by store manager style | Hard to verify if all shifts heard the update |
| 2-Minute AI Generated Training Videos | High; word-synced POS callouts + captions | Identical SOP across 88 languages |
Edit the changed scene and republish in minutes |
Retail and hospitality workforce studies, including research from the National Retail Federation (NRF) Foundation on Frontline Retail Training, consistently highlight that clear, accessible micro-training directly improves both associate confidence and customer satisfaction scores.
In hospitality and retail teams where associates speak Spanish, French, Vietnamese, Tagalog, or Mandarin as their primary language, regional managers can open the Translate menu in the top bar, check both script and on-canvas text translation, and spawn a separate localized draft via Translate as new draft while keeping the franchise's colors and fonts locked via Brand Kits.
Because back-office tablets are often watched in noisy breakrooms without headphones, enabling one of the studio's 9 built-in subtitle presets (or exporting the companion .srt caption file) guarantees every associate can follow the steps even with the volume turned down. District managers can also check Unique views, Shares, and Engaged Users on the Share page Analytics dashboard to confirm which store locations have reviewed the seasonal promotion ahead of Friday's launch.
Checking POS button callouts and on-canvas subtitles on a store tablet before rolling out the weekend promotion.
from AI Tools Test | Reviews, Comparisons & Guides

Independent newsletter writers and niche B2B media operators live at their keyboards, which is why many learn how to make photos talk with AI to add a personal, forty-five-second video welcome to their confirmation pages without ever setting up a ring light or DSLR camera. When a new reader subscribes to a weekly FinTech, SaaS, or bio-health digest, landing on a plain text “check your inbox” page feels transactional. Greeting that reader with a short, spoken introduction from the author builds immediate trust and explains exactly which email tab to whitelist.
Recording a fresh on-camera clip every time you update your welcome sequence, launch a seasonal sponsor readout, or announce a subscriber survey pulls writers out of deep research mode. Turning a clean headshot and a short script into a synchronized presenter clip lets solo publishers ship personal video touchpoints in five minutes.
When media operators look into how to make photos talk with AI, the highest return comes from deploying short, focused clips at high-intent conversion moments rather than trying to replace a thirty-minute podcast. A new subscriber is most attentive during the thirty seconds immediately after submitting their email address on your landing page.
Comparing text-only touchpoints against short AI talking photos across a newsletter's lifecycle highlights where a spoken visual greeting moves the needle:
| Subscriber Touchpoint | Text-Only Default Experience | 45-Second Talking Photos AI Clip | Primary Publisher Benefit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Post-Signup Thank-You Page | Generic “Confirm your email” banner | Author headshot explains what arrives on Tuesday & how to whitelist | Higher day-one open and reply rates |
| Featured Sponsor Readout | Static banner ad skipped by readers | Host introduces the partner's tool in a 30-second spoken spotlight | Higher sponsor CTR and renewal value |
| Annual Reader Survey Pitch | Plain hyperlink buried in footer | Personal 40-second ask explaining how survey answers shape coverage | More completed reader profile responses |
| Paid Tier Upgrade Page | Bullet list of archive perks | Spoken walkthrough of the private research memos and community access | Stronger free-to-paid subscriber conversion |
A solo writer sitting down on Tuesday night to refresh a post-signup confirmation page does not need a multi-track NLE timeline. Opening Leadde's portrait lip-sync studio lets a publisher convert the exact author headshot already sitting on their About page into a ready-to-embed welcome video without leaving the browser.
Uploading an author portrait or selecting a character scene photo inside the Talking Photo workspace before entering the welcome script.
Open the Talking Photo tool from the workspace home screen. You can either upload your own front-facing headshot (JPG or PNG with even facial lighting, eye-level framing, and an unobstructed mouth area) or pick one of the built-in character scene photos when running a themed editorial persona. Avoid heavy side shadows or hands resting near the chin so the lip-sync model can animate the jawline cleanly.
Keep post-signup greetings between thirty and forty-five seconds (80 to 110 words). A high-converting welcome script covers three concrete beats:
– The Publishing Cadence: Tell the reader the exact day and time your digest hits their inbox so they know when to look for it.
– The Whitelist Action: Ask them to drag the welcome email from the Promotions tab into Primary and reply with one sentence about their current role.
– Voice Matching and Cadence Tags: Select a natural voice from the Voices library, or upload a 10 to 60 second clean audio sample (MP3, WAV, or M4A) under Voices > My Voices > Voice Cloning so the portrait speaks in your actual voice. Wrap your publication's title, sponsor brand names, and industry acronyms in [Pronunciation] tags, and drop a 0.5s [Pause] marker right before your reply prompt.
Most desktop and mobile browsers block autoplay audio by default. Exporting your finished talking photo clip alongside its synchronized .srt caption file ensures readers who land on your confirmation page during a quiet meeting still catch every word of your onboarding instructions before clicking unmute.
A key architectural distinction that saves publishers hours of trial and error is knowing when to use the standalone Talking Photo workflow versus the full Avatar Video studio workflow:
None, Color, or Image), multiple scenes, on-screen data charts, or word-synced callout badges should use a custom Photo Avatar inside the Avatar Video workflow instead.As email deliverability and reader engagement benchmarks, such as those documented in the Litmus State of Email Engagement Reports, consistently show, encouraging new subscribers to open, whitelist, and reply within the first hour of signup strengthens both sender reputation and long-term retention.
Testing playback and caption readability on a 45-second welcome video before embedding it on the newsletter confirmation page.
When you embed that forty-second talking photo clip directly above the fold on your confirmation page, new readers immediately put a face and voice to your writing, turning an anonymous email capture into a two-way editorial relationship from day one.
from AI Tools Test | Reviews, Comparisons & Guides

Every B2B consultant and sales engineer eventually searches for how to embed a video in PowerPoint after a critical product demo fails to play on a client's conference room laptop. In theory, clicking Insert > Video > This Device inside PowerPoint should work smoothly. In reality, dropping three high-resolution screen recordings into a .pptx file balloons the file size past corporate email attachment limits, triggers “Media Unavailable” codec warnings between macOS and Windows machines, and leaves the prospect staring at a static slide with no spoken context.
Understanding both the native PowerPoint media rules and why modern teams convert the entire deck into a synchronized, presenter-led video file prevents embarrassing playback failures during asynchronous handoffs.
When you need to know how to add video to PowerPoint for a live presentation on your own laptop, Microsoft's technical documentation, detailed in the Microsoft Learn Troubleshooting Guide for PowerPoint Audio and Video Playback, recommends encoding clips as .mp4 files with H.264 video and AAC audio and running the built-in Optimize Media Compatibility utility before presenting.
Even when you follow that format rule, sending a .pptx file with embedded clips to an external buyer introduces friction compared to converting your PowerPoint to video inside a scene studio:
| Delivery Method | Average File & Email Behavior | Playback Reliability Across Devices | Spoken Context Around the Clip |
|---|---|---|---|
Linked Local Video in .pptx |
Small file, but breaks immediately on other PCs | Fails whenever the local folder path is missing | None unless presented live on a call |
Embedded H.264 .mp4 in .pptx |
Bloats to 150 to 400 MB; blocked by email gateways |
Vulnerable to OS codec mismatches & muted autoplay | Silent slides before and after the video clip |
| Scene-Based PowerPoint to Video Studio | Clean 1080p MP4 or lightweight Share link |
Plays in any modern browser or media player | Avatar O introduces the slide, pauses for the clip, and summarizes |
Instead of stuffing raw video files inside a slide deck and hoping an executive buyer remembers to click play on Slide 7, solutions architects import their .pptx deck into Leadde's slide-to-video presentation studio and combine editable slide layers with deterministic video playback controls.
Importing a PowerPoint deck into Slide Presenter to preserve editable slide layers and speaker notes before inserting product video clips.
Unlike PDF imports (which flatten pages into static background images), importing a .pptx file (up to 50 slides and 200 MB) into Slide Presenter preserves your editable text boxes, shapes, and visual layers, while automatically extracting your PowerPoint speaker notes into the scene narration script. If a prospect's company name or pricing tier changes ten minutes before the deck goes out, you can edit the text layer directly on the studio canvas without returning to desktop PowerPoint.
When you place a product demo .mp4 or .mov clip onto a slide scene from the Media panel, you do not have to manually drag audio keyframes to avoid talking over the video. Instead, select one of the four Video Fit behaviors:
– Insert: The presenter speaks the introductory sentence, automatically pauses narration while your embedded product video plays in full, and then resumes speaking to summarize the takeaway.
– Full Video: Extends the scene duration automatically until the video asset finishes playing.
– Loop: Loops a short UI animation continuously behind the presenter's explanation.
– Freeze: Plays the clip once and holds the final frame on screen while the narration continues.
A raw screen recording often leaves non-technical stakeholders wondering which corner of the dashboard to watch. Enabling Avatar O places an interactive digital presenter alongside your slides to point directly at architecture diagrams before the demo clip starts. You can also select any callout badge or shape on the canvas, click Animate, and drag entrance and emphasis triggers onto specific words in your script, while locking corporate colors and fonts via Brand Kits.
When an enterprise deal expands to procurement, security, and engineering reviewers in Germany, Japan, France, or Latin America, re-recording embedded videos inside desktop PowerPoint is a logistical nightmare.
Inside the workspace, sales engineering teams have two clean localization paths:
– Slide-Deck Translation (PPT Translation): Run the .pptx source file through AI Tools > PPT Translation to translate the slide deck while preserving original text boxes and shapes.
– Multi-Scene Video Branching (Translate as new draft): Open the Translate menu inside the video editor to branch a localized video draft across 88 languages and 175 dialects, adapting both the spoken narration and on-screen slide labels in a separate editable project.
Instead of attaching a bulky 250 MB file that gets quarantined by a bank or hospital firewall, enable password protection on the workspace Share page and send a lightweight browser link to the buying committee. Procurement reviewers can ask technical questions directly in the right-hand Video Q&A chat panel on the watch page, while the account team checks Unique views, Shares, and Engaged Users inside Analytics to see which stakeholders reviewed the proposal before Friday's commercial call.
Verifying that the Insert Video Fit mode cleanly pauses the presenter voiceover during the 20-second software demo clip.
from Blog of Sand
The Blue Monkey Story II- Chapter 11
Pierce remembered the sound of the boards breaking more clearly than he remembered the beginning of the fall. There had been a dry succession of cracks, followed by a sensation that was sufficiently unlike ordinary movement that he had not immediately understood it as falling. His right foot had gone down first, his left had followed, and his free hand had struck the wall hard enough to bend two fingers backward. After that the sequence became unreliable. He remembered wood against his left shoulder, the flashlight escaping his grip, and the particular scraping pain of cloth being dragged across a rough surface under considerable weight. There had been at least two separate impacts before he came to rest, and he could recall an interval between them in which he was moving faster rather than slower. The most persuasive impression was of an inclined surface. He had not dropped vertically through an open shaft, or if he had, some part of the descent had been interrupted by something that carried him sideways. He could remember trying to put his heels against whatever was beneath him and being unable to slow himself. He remembered a noise like a heavy piece of furniture going down stairs. He could not remember whether the noise came from his body or from something falling with him. The final impact seemed to have been preceded by a brief, absurd moment of weightlessness, and then by a yielding pressure on his back and legs. The pressure continued after everything else had stopped.
He opened his eyes to a close view of pale fabric. A seam ran diagonally across it, ending at a small brown stain, and beyond the seam was a piece of blue piping that had come loose from its stitching. He stared at these things without being able to assign them to an object. His first conclusion was that he had landed against an upholstered chair. His second was that he had landed on a bed. Neither was correct. When he moved his head, a pillow slid across his cheek and exposed another underneath it, and behind that a third and a fourth, all of different sizes and covered in different materials. He lay in an immense, irregular accumulation of pillows. Some were the standard rectangular shape of bed pillows, flattened in the middle and swollen at their ends. Others were square cushions with piping around the edges, or narrow cylindrical bolsters, or small decorative pillows whose covers had faded until their original colors were doubtful. There were pillows stuffed with feathers, pillows filled with foam that had lost its elasticity, and a few large ones that felt as though they contained pellets or some other loose material. Several had no cases. The exposed ticking on one was striped in a faint blue and gray pattern. Another had been covered in heavy orange fabric with a texture that reminded him of the furniture in his parents' living room when he was a child. The pile extended several feet in every direction beyond his body, rose higher on one side than the other, and carried the musty smell of a room closed for too long. His back had made a broad hollow in it. He did not know how many pillows it contained. Fifty would have been a conservative estimate. There might have been more than a hundred.
He remained where he was, first because he was astonished and then because moving caused him pain in places he had not expected. His left shoulder burned where it touched the fabric. Something under the waistband of his trousers was digging into his right hip, and when he tried to straighten his left leg he felt a sharp pull behind the knee. He had been in an automobile accident once, many years before, as a passenger in a car whose driver had slid into a drainage ditch in freezing rain. The vehicle had rolled only partway onto its side, and neither occupant had been seriously injured, but Pierce remembered how long it had taken for the different pains to become noticeable. At the roadside he had believed himself merely shaken. At home he had discovered bruises on his ribs and both arms, and by the following morning he could barely turn his head. The memory restrained his impulse to sit up at once. He breathed slowly, counted several breaths, and attempted to identify his condition without assuming that the absence of immediate agony meant the absence of serious injury. His feet moved. Both knees bent. His hands answered when he asked them to, although the two fingers he had jammed against the wall hurt badly. His neck was sore but not fixed, and he could turn his head a little in each direction. He felt nauseated. The nausea might have been the result of the impacts, or of fear, or of the smell of old fabric surrounding him. When he closed his eyes again he could not confidently distinguish the movement of the room from the sensation of his own head turning.
He had no recollection of losing consciousness, which did not settle the question. He looked at his watch. Its crystal had acquired a new crack radiating from the lower right corner, but the second hand was moving. He tried to calculate the time since the wooden passage had failed and found that he could not even establish a lower limit. A few seconds had elapsed; perhaps several minutes had. His last look at the watch, in the corridor beyond the communal showers, had been casual enough that he could not now remember the minute. He gave his name aloud, then his age, the day of the week, and the name of the county in which he worked. He could supply each answer. He rehearsed the route by which he had arrived: the Dobbins kitchen, the farmhouse cellar, the room with the old well, the cages, the tractor, the pipes, the service tunnel, the mess hall, the showers, the wooden floor. He was able to place them in order, though he had to pause over the number of doors between the tractor and the pipe room. The exercise was not a medical examination. He knew that a person could remain articulate after a head injury and that he had no proper means of deciding whether he had suffered one. It was, however, better than treating his memory of his own name as a guarantee that nothing serious had happened.
When he finally raised himself on his elbows, the pillows moved under him and he nearly rolled toward the side of the pile. His stomach tightened. He waited until the sensation passed, then worked his way to a seated position with his legs forward and both hands resting on separate cushions. His jacket had ridden up around his shoulders, and its left sleeve was torn for several inches near the seam. The shirt beneath was abraded. He eased it away from the skin and saw a red, irregular scrape, with a little blood at one end but no deep wound. There was a swelling along the outside of his right thigh and a tender spot over his lower ribs. He pressed lightly along the rib cage, stopped when he reached the sorest place, and decided not to perform a more enthusiastic examination merely to satisfy his curiosity. The risk he most disliked was that he had injured something internally and would not know until he tried to walk. He had once investigated a workplace accident in which a man had spoken comfortably to his supervisor after being struck by a moving pallet, then collapsed half an hour later. Pierce had helped interview the supervisor, whose guilt had been so obvious that he could hardly finish a sentence. That case had ended with a finding that the supervisor had followed the written safety procedure and that the equipment had failed in a way no one had predicted. The finding did not improve the man's opinion of himself. Pierce found himself remembering the supervisor's face while sitting on a pile of cushions in an unidentified basement, and disliked the parallel. Nobody had asked him to enter the Dobbins house. Nobody had told him to walk over rotten flooring in an underground passage. In the event that he survived and had to explain himself, an accurate account would offer very little defense.
His flashlight lay near the bottom of the mound, half hidden under a pillow whose cover showed a pattern of small flowers. He reached for it and found that the metal casing was scratched but not badly bent. The lens had survived. When he pressed the switch, the beam came on, flickered once, and steadied. He turned it off to conserve the batteries, although he could already see that the room was illuminated by a dim ceiling fixture. His notebook was still in the inner jacket pocket. The pen had worked loose from its clip and was lodged along the seam. He took both out, checked that the pages had not scattered, and put them back. His keys were present. His wallet was present. He could not help smiling at the last discovery, though the smile ended almost immediately. He had come into the farmhouse looking for a connection to a missing man's wallet, and his own wallet now seemed to be one of the few objects he could account for with certainty.
Only after taking stock of himself did he look properly at the room. It was much larger than the space occupied by the pillows, roughly rectangular, with a ceiling higher than that of an ordinary residential basement. A low-pile carpet of yellowish beige covered the floor from wall to wall. Its color might originally have been tan or light brown; age and weak light made it difficult to tell. The walls were drywall painted an off-white that had become darker near the baseboards, and at the corners thin strips of ordinary wooden molding had been installed with the blunt care of someone who knew how to finish a room but had little interest in ornament. The ceiling was made of the same painted material. The fixture above him was a round flush-mounted light with a frosted glass cover, one of the inexpensive kinds found in rental apartments and houses built several decades earlier. It gave off a steady yellowish light. There were no windows. There was no furniture, no wall decoration, no outlets he could see from his position, and no opening that he could immediately identify as a door. The pile of pillows stood almost exactly beneath an irregular hole in the ceiling. Through the hole, at a depth or height he could not determine, a weak gray illumination was visible. It appeared to come from the wooden passage above, although he could not be sure that it was the same light that had drawn him toward the distant door before his fall. The opening was not a neat rectangle. Several edges looked broken, and an object that might have been a length of timber projected partway across it. Nothing else moved there.
Pierce stood with difficulty. The pile gave way under him so that each effort to rise displaced the support against which he was pushing. He eventually got one foot onto the carpet beyond the cushions and used it to pull the rest of his weight after him. He remained still with his hand on the outside of his thigh, allowing the room to settle. His right leg supported him. The left hurt behind the knee and at the ankle, but he could stand on it. He took three steps along the edge of the pile and turned back. From the floor the quantity of pillows was even harder to justify than it had been from inside them. They covered an area perhaps twelve or fourteen feet across, and in the center their combined depth approached his chest. The arrangement was not entirely random. The larger cushions lay underneath, and the smaller ones were concentrated at the top, as though someone had constructed a loose landing bed and then abandoned the effort to keep it neat. Yet they were dusty enough that some could have remained there for years. He found that he did not want to estimate their age from appearance. A particular pillow might be old even if it had been brought to the room that morning. The dust on the carpet at the edge was disturbed by the movement he had just made, and the bare strip of carpet he had crossed showed his own shoe marks. Elsewhere the carpet was uniformly dull. He saw no other footprints that he could confidently identify.
He looked up at the hole for a long time. It was too high for him to reach from the floor. At first, measuring by the baseboards and the proportions of the room, he thought the ceiling was sixteen feet above him. He then revised the estimate upward. The ceiling light was not as small as it had appeared while he was lying down, and the hole, though seemingly narrow, might have been large enough to admit two people standing shoulder to shoulder. Its apparent size told him little without a known object beside it. There seemed to be a darker space above the visible plaster, as though the hole opened into a short shaft rather than directly into the corridor. He moved to one side and examined it from different angles. At one point he thought he could make out a sloping board beyond the near edge, which was consistent with his recollection of sliding. At another angle the same surface appeared to be part of a broken floor joist. He could not see far enough to decide. There was no rope, ladder, pipe, or metal rung leading upward. He called 'Hello' and listened. His voice returned from the walls with a surprisingly ordinary echo. He called a second time, louder, aware that any answering voice might belong to the people whose house he had entered. No one answered. He waited for the sound of movement above and heard only a faint mechanical hum that could have come from the ceiling fixture or from the spaces beyond the walls.
For some time he attempted to get nearer the hole. The pillows offered the only material in the room from which he might make a platform, and he could not ignore the possibility that an improvised mound would raise him high enough to reach the damaged opening. He began by moving the largest cushions into the center and building a narrower pile on top of them. This was slow work. Every cushion displaced another, many of them were too soft to retain their shape under weight, and the harder foam pieces were too light to make a stable base unless he placed something heavier against them. After perhaps fifteen minutes he had constructed a steep and very unconvincing hill. He climbed it once on hands and knees and stopped when its upper portion began sliding beneath him. He climbed a second time from another side, using the edge of a dense bolster as a foothold, and succeeded in raising his head several feet above the level he had first reached. He was still nowhere near the ceiling. He stretched an arm upward, found only air, and had to descend backward while the cushions parted under his knees. The movement aggravated his shoulder. He sat on the carpet, breathing harder than he thought the effort warranted, and considered whether a different arrangement would improve matters. He could make the pile taller, but only by narrowing its base further and sacrificing the stability that had already proved inadequate. He could press pillows together and hope the friction would hold them. He could remove the ticking and bind the stuffing into compact sacks, although he had neither cord nor a useful way to secure the resulting bundles. The alternatives multiplied without improving the fundamental problem. A pile of pillows was not a ladder.
He tried anyway. The second arrangement took longer, because he folded the larger bed pillows and wedged them into spaces between the bolsters. The cushions made unpleasant little noises as their seams strained. One split, releasing loose gray-white stuffing that clung to his trousers and floated in the weak light. After another climb he was still far below the opening. This time he slipped, landed on the side of the pile, and felt the injury behind his knee flare sharply. The cushions kept him from striking the carpet with much force, but they did not protect his pride or restore his lost energy. He lay there for a moment considering what he had accomplished. He had made a soft heap slightly higher and considerably less comfortable than the heap upon which he had landed. He had aggravated an injury. He had raised a cloud of dust that made him cough. He had not learned whether the hole was reachable even with a proper ladder. The work had served one useful purpose: it had established beyond reasonable doubt that he was not going to climb out by stacking cushions, and that any further attempt of the same kind would be undertaken because he could not bear to stop, not because the evidence recommended it.
He checked his watch, wrote down the time, and decided to make a complete examination of the room. It was an odd decision to dignify with the word investigation, but there was no other productive activity available to him. He walked the perimeter slowly, keeping one hand close to the wall for balance. The carpet was worn somewhat darker where it met the baseboards, as though an earlier occupant had vacuumed the center of the room more often than the edges. Along one wall were three shallow dents at approximately waist height. They might have been made by a dresser or a table brought in and later removed. Two places on another wall showed discoloration consistent with pictures having once hung there, although he could find no nail holes in their centers. There was a hairline crack at one corner, running from the ceiling toward the floor and disappearing behind the baseboard. The paint over the crack was a little thicker than elsewhere, suggesting that it had been covered more than once. Nothing in those marks distinguished the room from the basement recreation room of an ordinary suburban house. He had interviewed people in rooms very much like it: once in a finished basement where a husband had built a small bar and refused to let his wife use it for children's birthday parties, and once in an elderly woman's apartment beneath her daughter's home, where the woman had insisted that the upstairs family was stealing her newspapers. He remembered the newspaper complaint because it had eventually turned out that the woman had been moving them herself, putting them into a drawer and forgetting them. He had taken nearly an hour to establish that fact. At the time, it had seemed like an hour well spent, since the woman had stopped accusing her daughter. He could not say whether he was now making a similarly simple matter unnecessarily complicated, or whether his circumstances justified every moment of scrutiny.
There were no visible doors. He checked each corner for the outline of a concealed panel and found none. The baseboards continued unbroken. He crouched at the wall opposite the pillows and inspected a section where the carpet had pulled away from the molding, exposing a little of the subfloor. It looked like ordinary plywood beneath carpet padding. He could not tell whether it rested on concrete or wood framing. He pressed one ear against the wall and heard nothing useful, then tapped it with two knuckles. A light, hollow response came from the drywall. The same response occurred several feet away. He knew enough about construction to understand that the sound depended on the spacing of studs, the thickness of the board, and the material behind it. A wall that sounded hollow was not necessarily concealing a passage. Most interior partitions were hollow. He moved along the perimeter in small increments, tapping and listening for changes, then worked back along the first stretch to check whether he could reproduce them. The sound varied, but not consistently. In places his knuckles seemed to encounter a more solid backing; in others a faint resonance followed each knock. The wall behind the pillows gave off a different, broader sound, though the proximity of the mound changed the acoustics. He made himself take a second circuit without jumping to any conclusion. He was not looking for a secret door in a theater set. He was trying to discover whether a room without an exit had been built inside a larger room, and whether some part of the partition had been covered after construction.
Near the corner farthest from the light fixture he found a difference he could repeat. Over a width that might have been three feet, the drywall answered with a deeper, less interrupted sound than on either side. At the left edge, tapping with his knuckles produced a short, hard knock, consistent with a stud or other support. At the right edge he found another such point. Between them the wall sounded as though the board had no intermediate backing. He examined the paint. A vertical line was barely discernible several inches outside the left hard point, and there was a similar mark at the right, but both could have resulted from ordinary taped drywall joints. He followed the marks upward with his flashlight. At about seven feet above the floor they disappeared into the painted surface. There was no visible lintel or patched doorframe. The baseboard crossed the area without a seam. He sat back on his heels and considered the evidence. An old doorway might have been framed in during renovation, leaving the opening filled with drywall but not studs. An alcove or shallow service recess might produce the same effect. There might be a closet behind it, or nothing larger than the thickness of a second partition. It was also possible that he was interpreting a common construction irregularity as an escape route because he wanted it to be one. He could not resolve these possibilities by listening.
His keys included a small steel key for the apartment's rear entrance, and for a few minutes he tried to scrape away a patch of paint near the suspected edge without damaging much of the wall. The key made a faint groove and exposed white powder underneath, but the process was too slow to be useful. He had not brought a pry bar, a hammer, or a pocketknife with a rigid blade. He considered using the flashlight and rejected the idea of risking his only dependable source of portable light. There was nothing in the room that could serve as a proper tool. In the end he took off his jacket, wrapped it around his forearm, and struck the drywall at the center of the resonant section with the heel of his shoe. The first blow left a shallow dent. The second cracked the paint and produced a web of fine lines. At the third the board gave way inward. He stopped at once, more startled by the ease of the break than by the noise, and shone his flashlight through the opening.
Beyond the broken plaster was empty space. Not a narrow cavity between studs, but an actual room or passage extending beyond the reach of his light. The far side of the wall was not finished with another sheet of drywall. The edges of a wooden opening stood beyond it, their surfaces old and darker than the lumber used in the newer partition. He widened the hole carefully, pulling fragments inward to prevent them from falling onto anything he could not yet see. Pieces of gypsum broke free from the paper backing, exposing a strip of timber along one edge. When the gap was large enough to admit his shoulders, he saw that a doorway had indeed been covered over from this side. The old jamb remained, with shallow rectangular depressions where hinges had once been mounted. A strike plate had been removed from the opposite side, leaving two small screw holes in the wood. Someone had put a wall across an existing opening without going to the trouble of dismantling the frame. Pierce remained crouched before it for a full minute, inspecting the concealed jamb and the rough edges of plaster. The discovery was encouraging, but it was not proof that the arrangement had been designed to trap anyone. Finished rooms were routinely altered, closets sealed, and passages abandoned when buildings were divided or their purposes changed. The pillows still required an explanation. So did the opening above them, and the route by which he had descended. He did not want the relief of finding a way out to make him less careful about the difference between an explanation and a possibility.
He pushed the loose board fragments aside, brushed the worst of the plaster dust from his clothing, and passed through the ruined partition sideways. On the far side he straightened in a room whose smell was immediately recognizable: old detergent, damp concrete, and the faint sourness of laundry that had once been left too long before being dried. The beam of his flashlight traveled across a white enamel machine, then another, then a succession of identical machine fronts extending beyond the light's useful reach. Overhead, widely spaced fixtures provided enough illumination for him to see that the room continued a considerable distance in a straight line. He turned back and looked through the hole at the carpeted room and the pillows visible beyond it. His route out had required him to destroy part of a wall. He was not sorry to have done so. What he could not explain was why the doorway had been concealed in the first place.
The laundry room was extraordinarily long. Its near end was roughly the width of a generous two-car garage, and its ceiling rose only a few feet above Pierce's head, but the rows of washing machines carried away into a perspective that he found difficult to reconcile with either dimension. The floor was laid in small square tiles, mostly white, with black tiles forming an occasional border around a floor drain. The grout had darkened unevenly. Some tiles were cracked, and in several places replacements of slightly different color interrupted the original pattern. Two lines of washing machines occupied the room, one against each wall. Their white enameled fronts repeated with minor variations in the shapes of doors, controls, and lower inspection panels. A series of folding tables stood between the rows at widely spaced intervals, leaving a central path down which a laundry cart could have been pushed. Pierce could see a cart halfway along the room, but no other loose equipment. The lighting came from small ceiling fixtures set at regular distances, all fitted with yellowed plastic covers. Several were dark. Their arrangement made the room look segmented into a succession of nearly identical spaces, and at the far end, barely visible, stood a single heavy door. The passage between machines appeared to continue for an implausible distance before reaching it. He took a few steps forward and stopped, looking back through the broken wall. The concealed opening was the only interruption in the end partition. There was no sign that it had ever been intended as the ordinary entrance to such a facility.
He knew very little about industrial laundry beyond what could be learned from visits to hospitals, care homes, and the county correctional facility, where large commercial machines had occupied a concrete utility room off the loading area. The jail's laundry had required more supervision than the supervisors liked to admit. Inmates assigned to work there occasionally took the opportunity to exchange messages, hide contraband in folded linens, or conduct small transactions for articles that were easier to obtain on the outside. Pierce had once spent part of an afternoon examining the seam of a bedsheet because a corrections officer believed someone had used it to conceal a tiny handwritten note. The seam contained a length of dark thread and nothing else, and the officer had insisted that the note must have been removed before the sheet reached evidence. Pierce remembered being annoyed by the officer's certainty. He had not been able to prove the absence of a note at an earlier time, but he had been able to say that there was no note in the seam when he opened it. The distinction was perfectly comprehensible to him at the time. It remained comprehensible now, although he was less pleased to find himself applying it to a room full of machinery of unknown purpose. He had observed a laundry without knowing whether laundry had ever been washed there. That was all.
He approached the nearest machine. It was taller than a domestic washing machine and wider across the face, with a round glass door whose thick metal rim rested in a recessed circular frame. The glass was cloudy but intact. A raised handle with a red enamel tip sat beside it. Above the door was a control panel bearing several ordinary-looking dials and a row of small rectangular buttons, their surfaces worn smooth. What was missing was any name, model number, or indication of the manufacturer. He moved the flashlight over the upper corners, the sides he could see, and the narrow metal strip beneath the controls. No emblem had been painted or fixed there. There was no pale patch suggesting that an adhesive label had recently been removed. He opened the door, which yielded with a slight resistance, and examined the drum. Its perforated metal interior was dry. At the back, a shallow ring of residue marked where water might once have collected, but he found no clothing, no loose button, no coin, and no scrap of lint large enough to identify. He turned one control dial. It moved from one setting to another with an ordinary mechanical click. He pressed a button and got no response. There was no noise of a motor, no light, and no indication that electrical power reached the machine. He looked down behind it, where pipes ran horizontally along the wall. Short service connections led from the main lines to the back of the cabinet. Some looked discolored and corroded. He could not tell whether the pipes contained water. A large drain line disappeared beneath the floor. He left the handle where he had found it and stepped toward the next machine.
The second was similar but not identical. Its control panel had an extra dial, and the glass was surrounded by a slightly narrower ring. There were no labels on it either. The third had a rectangular service hatch low on its front, secured by two screws, and a dark stain beneath the hatch that might have come from lubricating oil. The fourth door stuck before opening halfway. He crouched to look into it, found another empty drum, and closed it without forcing the hinge. The fifth had an additional fitting near the upper corner where he would have expected a small gauge, but there was no gauge and no opening in the metal through which one had been removed. As he continued along the wall, the differences began to register as the sort that arise over years of equipment replacement: altered panels, slightly changed hardware, handles of different shapes. Yet the absence of identifying information persisted. He could not find a name cast into a knob, a stamped plate on a door frame, or a supplier's sticker placed by a maintenance worker. He knew that a manufacturer could conceal its identifying marks on the rear or the underside, but most commercial equipment displayed at least something. Machines used by institutions required parts, service, inspection, and records. He had never encountered a large installation in which every visible attempt to identify the equipment failed.
After the first twelve machines he stopped trying each door and began recording the arrangement. He counted units along both walls, marked the locations of the folding tables, and noted every interruption in the overhead plumbing. His steps sounded thin on the tiled floor. A faint odor of mineral deposits came from the floor drains, but there was no standing water. He could see overhead ventilation ducts leading lengthwise through the room, although he could not determine where they ended. The machines were not powered, at least not in any way he could detect by operating their controls, and they were empty. No baskets of clothing stood nearby. The folding tables were bare and dusty. The one cart he had seen was a steel-framed rectangle on four casters, with a torn canvas sling hanging into the middle. Two casters would not rotate when he pushed it gently, and one wheel dragged across the tile, leaving a narrow dark line. A little lint had accumulated in a fold of the sling. There was no tag, no writing, no identifying mark, and no hint of whose clothing might have been carried there. He looked underneath the table beside it and found a wooden wedge, perhaps intended to prevent the cart from rolling. It had been cut from a common piece of lumber. That small item was the most convincingly improvised thing he had yet seen. Someone had experienced the inconvenience of a moving cart and solved it by using a scrap of wood. The thought was reassuring for a few moments. It implied human work, a practical difficulty, and a modest practical remedy rather than an elaborate scheme aimed at a man who had entered the building by accident.
The room extended much farther than he had first appreciated. When he reached a line of dark ceiling fixtures, he looked back and found that the concealed doorway had diminished to a small black interruption at the far end. The carpeted room was no longer visible. He checked his watch and wrote down the time, though the figures offered no more help than they had in the service tunnel. He had no reliable measure of how much time he had lost after the fall, and he was beginning to feel a more general discomfort from the lack of daylight. He had gone underground on a Saturday afternoon, with the expectation that he could return to the farmhouse and leave before anyone came home. That intention now seemed as remote as the possibility that he could reach the ceiling of the pillow room. He could still imagine a conventional exit from the laundry, perhaps an exterior stair at the far end, but he had ceased to believe that the Dobbins kitchen was only a few rooms away. It might be several hundred yards away in a horizontal direction, and he no longer knew how far beneath the surface he had fallen. The building above could have been left behind entirely. There was no practical way to warn anyone, and he had not told anyone where he was going. He thought of Christine and Emily at the soccer meeting the previous evening. The apology he had offered was both sincere and insufficient, and now his decision to enter the farmhouse had made even the continuation of that conversation uncertain. He could not restore the evening by regretting it. There was also no way to establish whether Saturday's mistake would cost him something far greater than a missed meeting.
He resumed walking. Rows of identical cabinets passed in the dim light, each one inviting a separate inspection and almost none rewarding it. He found a machine whose circular door had been replaced by a sheet of dull metal bolted across the frame. Another stood a few inches out of line with its neighbors, apparently to accommodate a thicker pipe behind it. At a folding table he found an empty cardboard box, collapsed at the corners and softened by dampness. The printed lettering that might once have appeared on its outside was entirely gone, if it had ever been there. He lifted one flap with a fingertip, exposing a fine layer of yellow dust and the remains of a strip of paper tape. He could not tell what the box had contained. A second cart stood near the opposite wall. This one had no sling, only a tubular metal frame, and a piece of string had been tied between two bars. The knot was awkward but secure. Pierce studied it for longer than its importance warranted. A knot was something that had been made deliberately. It implied a hand, and a reason, and perhaps a moment of impatience. In an abandoned building, those modest traces of occupation often supplied more reliable information than grand architectural features. He wished he could see a discarded maintenance sheet, a delivery invoice, a date written in grease pencil on a wall. There was nothing of the kind.
Near the far end, the white machines changed in size. Several were deeper, their drums wide enough to accept bulky loads, and the control panels stood above the doors at a height that would have been inconvenient for a small person. The room narrowed a little, or appeared to, as the walls came closer to the center tables. The single door at the end was made of metal and painted a dull green. It had a recessed grip instead of a knob and stood within a heavy frame whose lower edge had been scraped by something moving along the floor. Pierce saw no sign or other indication of what lay beyond. He examined the door first from several feet away, then from the threshold. There was no unusual heat, no sound of machinery, and no draft strong enough to indicate an exterior opening. The latch was not locked. He pulled the door toward himself, holding the flashlight in his other hand, and nearly stepped forward before he recognized the absence of floor beyond it.
The opening faced a vertical shaft. The floor of the laundry ended at a metal threshold, beyond which darkness extended downward without a visible landing. The shaft was lined with concrete or rough stone, difficult to distinguish in the weak light. On the wall immediately opposite the door ran two vertical steel members, parallel to one another and spaced perhaps three feet apart. They might have been guides for an elevator car, but they could also have supported a movable platform, a hoist, or some kind of industrial lifting frame. A narrow metal bracket projected from one wall several yards below and disappeared into the darkness. He shone his flashlight upward. The ceiling of the shaft was beyond its useful range. He could see a portion of heavy framing and a thick cable or pipe, but no machinery that would permit him to identify the installation. Downward, the beam reached only the nearer surfaces. There was no car, no counterweight he could recognize, and no visible bottom. The air inside was cooler than that of the laundry room and carried a mineral smell with a trace of old oil. When he dropped a small fragment of plaster that had remained caught in his jacket cuff, he did not hear it strike the bottom. It might have hit a ledge too quietly to hear, or fallen farther than his ears could follow. He took a deliberate step backward from the threshold.
He regarded the door for several minutes. A lift shaft would make sense in a facility containing large washing machines. There would have been laundry to move between levels, perhaps by cart, and a platform would be less exhausting than stairs. The shaft could therefore represent the ordinary connection between a subterranean laundry and a larger establishment somewhere above it. Yet the door was located at the end of the room rather than beside the main work area, and the absence of a car or accessible controls made it useless to him. A mine shaft was less likely, given its regular lining, but the distinction mattered only if one presumed that the shaft could lead to an exit. It could equally well lead to deeper chambers, flooded workings, or a collapsed platform. There was no reason to attempt it. Pierce closed the green door, heard the latch catch, and stood facing it with a small feeling of disappointment that he considered entirely appropriate. The first conventional door he had found since the hidden entrance led to an opening into which he might easily have fallen. There was no pleasure in being vindicated for having checked the threshold.
He turned to examine the laundry again. The distance back to the broken partition did not seem attractive, but neither did the idea of remaining in the room indefinitely. His original route was blocked by height, not by the absence of a known location. If he returned to the pillows, he would be no closer to the surface. The laundry might nevertheless contain a service staircase, a maintenance hatch, or another entrance that he had overlooked by concentrating on the machines. He decided to search it from the far end toward the near end, this time paying attention to the rear connections and the spaces between the cabinets. He was conscious that this was essentially the same method he had employed in the room of pillows: when the apparent exits failed, he examined construction details rather than surrendering to the first impression of a sealed space. He considered whether his training had made him too willing to spend time on a doubtful possibility. A man in pain who had escaped one enclosed room might be wiser to rest than to begin a second exhaustive inspection. But standing in the laundry did not make his injuries improve, and he had no food, water, or assurance that anyone would ever enter it. The distinction between industriousness and desperation had become difficult to maintain.
The machines nearest the shaft had drain lines and water connections visible through narrow gaps at the rear. He held the flashlight at floor level and looked behind each one without pulling it away from the wall. Several pipes were supported by metal straps fixed to the concrete. Others disappeared into sleeves in the floor. In places he found traces of previous repairs: bright brass fittings among darker steel, fresh-looking thread sealant, and an isolated length of flexible hose attached to a much older supply line. He could not tell how recent any repair was. The age of exposed metal could differ considerably from the age of an installation. He went on to the next machine and then to the one after it. Around the sixth he noticed a small but definite difference. The cabinet stood against a wall where the long row of supply pipes had been interrupted. Its front looked like every other white machine, with a circular window and a familiar arrangement of controls, but there were no hoses behind it. The wall showed no water connections at the height where they appeared behind the neighboring units, and the floor drain that should have served it was absent. There was a short length of conduit disappearing into the wall, but when he followed it he found that it ended above the machine rather than entering its cabinet. The apparatus had been installed where an ordinary washing machine would not have been usable.
Pierce leaned forward, trying to see whether he had missed a rear service connection. The machine was set a little farther from the wall than its neighbors. He could see the narrow gap around its right side and a strip of clean metal behind it that did not correspond to any water pipe. He tried the door. It opened, but instead of a perforated drum it revealed a shallow cylindrical cavity lined with plain sheet metal. At the back was a fixed surface. There was no indication that a proper rotating assembly had ever been installed. The controls had the same resistance as those on the working machines, but a dial that turned through settings was not proof that it was connected to anything. He reached inside, felt along the rear surface, and found no central spindle or bearing. The cabinet was a shell. He had seen such things in store displays, where a retailer wanted customers to see the appearance of an appliance without paying to transport or install a functional one. He could imagine a similar demonstration piece being left in a commercial laundry when equipment was replaced. What he could not explain was why a display shell would occupy a position in a row of operational units, with its back turned toward a wall that supplied no water.
He stepped back and examined the floor around it. The tile directly beneath its front feet showed two narrow bright arcs, as though something heavy had been moved repeatedly across the same short distance. A dark line curved away from the right corner and vanished under the neighboring table. He bent low and found a small wheel beneath the false machine, almost hidden by a skirt of metal. There was a matching wheel at the other side. The cabinet's apparent feet were attached to a frame that kept the wheels concealed from anyone looking at it from standing height. Pierce placed both hands against the side, tested the weight, and felt it shift more readily than an industrial washer should have. He took care not to let it roll against his injured leg. The movement was smooth for a few inches, then hesitated as one wheel crossed a grout line. With a second push the shell moved away from the wall far enough to expose a dark rectangular opening in the floor. The opening had apparently been beneath the machine all along.
He brought the flashlight around and looked into it. Narrow stairs descended between close plastered walls, turning beyond the first several treads. The uppermost step was made of stone or concrete and had a rounded edge worn by use. The next seemed to be the same material. A dull amber light came from around the bend. The opening was only a little larger than the cabinet that had covered it, and the stairs were steep enough that a person descending would need to turn sideways at the top. Pierce crouched beside the cavity and examined the transition between tile and the stairwell. There was no rough broken edge; the floor had been finished around the opening. The machine had not fallen there and happened to conceal a hole. It had been placed to conceal a constructed entrance. That much he was willing to record without qualification. Why anyone had done it was another matter. There could be a service passage below that the owners wished to keep closed to ordinary employees. There could be an old stairwell that had become unsafe, although hiding it beneath an easily moved cabinet seemed an irresponsible method of protection. It could have been a deliberate means of restricting access to another part of the building. The premises were not his, and his knowledge of their history was almost nonexistent. He was in no position to decide between those explanations. Nevertheless he felt a distinctly personal satisfaction as he wrote the find in his notebook. He had discovered an opening because a machine's plumbing did not match its appearance. For the first time in many hours, patient attention to a small physical detail had produced an unequivocal result.
The satisfaction lasted until he considered the direction of the stairs. They went down. Everything since the farmhouse had taken him away from the surface: the long tunnel, the ruined wooden floor, the improbable descent to the pillow room. A staircase downward could hardly be described as progress toward an exit. He looked back along the laundry room, toward the concealed opening whose broken plaster he could no longer see from this end. The lamps receded into a succession of small pale circles, and the empty machines stood along the walls without a single indication that anyone might arrive to use them. It was conceivable that the stairway beneath the false cabinet descended to a passage that eventually rose again. It was conceivable that the elevator shaft could be reached from a lower floor and that some functioning equipment remained there. Such possibilities did not constitute a plan. He understood that he had arrived at a choice between waiting in a place where no one appeared to be working and entering an unknown stairwell that at least continued the building's circulation. He would not have recommended the latter course to a lost person under ordinary circumstances. He would have told the person to stay near the last known route, conserve strength, and make noise when someone might hear. But his last known route led to a room without a conventional door and a hole far above his reach. Remaining there offered no prospect of discovery that he could defend as probable. He adjusted his jacket around his bruised shoulder, made another note about the location of the concealed stairwell, and began carefully lowering himself into the opening.
The staircase was narrow enough that his shoulders nearly touched the walls. Its treads were made of a hard gray material, perhaps cast concrete, worn smooth at their centers but dry and mostly free of debris. The dull amber illumination came from small fixtures set into shallow recesses near the ceiling. Each was covered by a pane of thick yellowish glass held with screws. One fixture flickered as he passed beneath it, then returned to its former steady glow. He tested the first three stairs before putting his full weight on them. They held without movement. His left ankle protested each downward step, and he altered his posture to keep most of his weight on the other leg. The stairs turned twice before opening into a corridor whose walls were lined with wooden racks. A cool, earthy smell reached him, mixed with the faint acidic odor of old wine and wet stone. He stepped off the final tread and found himself in a wine cellar.
The designation was his own, drawn from the racks and the unmistakable presence of bottles. He could not establish that the place had ever been used primarily to store wine, but the fittings made that conclusion reasonable. The first corridor was constructed of rough stone set in pale mortar, with a ceiling that curved inward at the top and disappeared into a succession of shallow arches. Narrow wooden racks occupied the lower half of the walls. Each had been divided into square compartments sized for bottles placed horizontally, and each compartment carried a lip at its front to prevent its contents from rolling out. Many were empty. In those that held bottles, the glass was dusty, sometimes so heavily that the color beneath could be judged only where the neck projected. The air was cool enough to make him pull his torn jacket closer around himself. A series of amber fixtures hung from the ceiling, spaced farther apart than he would have liked, and between them the stone took on an almost brown appearance. The corridor did not run straight. It curved gently to the left within a few yards of the stairs, then divided around a thick pier whose surface was darkened by years of moisture. At the division he could see more racks in both directions. Neither route revealed an end.
Pierce had little personal knowledge of wine. He knew what ordinary people knew from restaurants, grocery stores, and occasions on which someone had put a bottle on a table expecting him to admire it. He was capable of distinguishing red wine from white by looking into a clear bottle, and he had learned that a year printed on a label did not necessarily indicate the year in which the wine had been purchased. Beyond that, he considered himself fortunate if he could choose something that did not make dinner worse. Lenny had once tried to develop an interest in wine after reading an article claiming that its appreciation was largely a matter of learning vocabulary. For two months he had brought unusual bottles to small gatherings at his home and announced that he detected blackberries, leather, tobacco, or damp stone, depending on what the article said was appropriate. Melissa had finally asked him whether a person who found the smell of wet gravel in a drink ought to regard it as a recommendation. Lenny had laughed, though Pierce suspected he had been disappointed. The experiment ended when their youngest child knocked over a glass of the most expensive bottle while reaching for a bread roll. Pierce remembered the evening because it was one of the few times he had stayed late at Lenny's house without feeling guilty about work. The memory brought with it the image of Melissa wiping wine from the tablecloth and Lenny insisting that the carpet had needed cleaning anyway. Such scenes belonged to a world with usable doors and people who could be called when something went wrong. He was standing in a cellar so far beneath any place he recognized that the memory had acquired the detached character of an account someone had given him in an interview.
He examined the first full rack, choosing it because a group of bottles near the center appeared relatively undisturbed. Most had dark glass and long necks, with corks that sat nearly flush. Some had paper labels, or the ragged remains of labels, but mildew and abrasion had made their writing difficult to read. One seemed to bear a European place name that he could not decipher. Another retained the figures of a date, perhaps nineteen sixty-eight, although the middle digit might equally have been a five. On a lower shelf lay several squat bottles with narrow throats and flat bottoms; he could not tell whether they had contained wine, vinegar, or another liquid. A bottle near the end of the row was empty, its cork gone, and a little sediment had collected at its lowest point. Pierce held the flashlight behind it. The dust on the glass was thick, but its underside had a comparatively clean arc where it had rested against the rack. He resisted an urge to move every bottle into the light. Such a task would consume hours, and the information gained would not be proportional to the risk of breaking the glass. If the bottles had been used recently, the dust might tell him; if they had been sitting there for thirty years, the dust might tell him that too. It could not tell him what a room several levels beneath a rural farmhouse was intended to conceal.
He chose the left-hand passage and made a small arrow in his notebook. The wine cellar was not built on the regular plan of the laundry. Its walls followed irregular lines, and shallow recesses opened from them at intervals, each furnished with more racks or shelves. One recess contained a wooden table supported by trestles, so narrow that two people would have difficulty working beside one another. Its surface showed old circular stains and a shallow knife mark at one end. On a lower shelf he found a cracked ceramic funnel and a wooden object that might have been a corking device, missing a handle. None of these objects was extraordinary. Wine needed to be stored, poured, bottled, and sometimes moved between containers. But the details suggested a workshop rather than merely a place where a wealthy household kept bottles to serve at dinner. The air smelled faintly of old oak and sour fruit. He wondered whether the building had once been part of a distillery or some other agricultural operation now entirely forgotten. Wine was made in rural New York. An isolated farmhouse might have preserved fragments of a family industry that had failed long before Samuel Dobbins bought the property. The explanation would have been more satisfying if he had encountered a press, a vat, a drain with staining from grape skins, or any means by which harvested fruit could be brought to the cellar. He had not.
The passage ended abruptly at a wall of stone different in color from the walls beside it. The racks had been carried nearly to the end, leaving a narrow space in which a person could stand and turn around. An amber light hung near the termination, and beneath it the stones were mottled with white deposits. Pierce approached the wall, tapped it, and found that it sounded solid. The mortar was coarser than that in the arch behind him, perhaps because it had been applied at another time. If an opening had once existed there, its shape had been thoroughly obscured. He studied the possibility, then decided that the evidence did not justify damaging the masonry. The wall could simply mark the end of the cellar. He returned to the fork, checked the arrow in his notebook, and took the right-hand route.
That passage widened into a small chamber where racks covered three walls and another opening stood opposite the entrance. The bottles here were different in appearance. Some were green and others nearly black; several had broad shoulders and short necks. In a few compartments someone had placed the bottles with their bottoms facing outward, as though their labels had been of little importance. Pierce examined the floor and saw the remains of a flattened cardboard carton beneath one shelf. Its surfaces had softened to the point that no wording remained. Above it, a piece of thin wire had been twisted around a wooden upright, perhaps once supporting a tag. The tag was gone. He tried to imagine an inventory system for the cellar. A person who stored wine in these quantities would ordinarily want to know which bottles were which, how long they had been kept, and where particular varieties could be found. Even a person with no interest in the subtleties of wine would eventually grow tired of hunting through hundreds of identical dark bottles. Yet the few visible labels were too damaged to support such a system now. There might once have been written records stored elsewhere. A cellar could lose its order after many years of neglect without having been created for a mysterious purpose.
Beyond the small chamber, the passages divided again. One turned sharply right and sloped downward by a barely perceptible amount. The other followed the curve of the outer wall and passed through an arch with an unusually low crown. Pierce followed the outer route. After two turns he came upon a shallow recess in which a single broken chair had been left, its seat detached and one leg lying beside it. He inspected the joints, mostly from habit, and found that the chair was of ordinary cheap construction. Its failure did not interest him as evidence, but he was grateful for the opportunity to sit somewhere other than a damp floor. He set it upright with the broken leg against the wall and lowered himself briefly onto the sound side, keeping most of his weight on his feet. His ribs ached from the movement. The room's cool temperature had made the bruises less noticeable while he walked, but now that he stopped he could feel the cumulative effect of the fall in his shoulder, thigh, ankle, and lower back. He had no water. His mouth was dry and tasted faintly of plaster dust. The wine bottles presented the obvious possibility of liquid, but he had no intention of drinking from an unknown old bottle on the assumption that its contents were safe. A corked container could contain something other than wine. Even if it contained wine, alcohol was the last thing he wanted while injured and uncertain of his route. He remained seated until the strain of supporting himself on the chair became more trouble than relief, then stood again.
He was beginning to lose his sense of direction. The cellar's curves made it difficult to preserve a compass orientation, and he had no compass to begin with. His sketch showed forks, chambers, and dead ends, but the distances between them had been estimated by steps that shortened when his ankle hurt. In two places the walls looked sufficiently similar that he could not be certain he had not returned to an earlier passage. He began adding small marks to the notebook drawing for distinctive features: the broken chair, the pale wall, a shelf with an unusual diagonal brace, a patch of dark mold near the floor. When he came to the same diagonal brace again, he discovered that he had formed a loop. This was not evidence of impossible architecture. Cellars could be built with circulation routes around load-bearing piers, and a maze was often no more than a building whose organization made sense only to its original occupants. He had visited barns in which machinery had been added over so many decades that a person had to go out one door and in another to reach a room only a few feet away. He had once accompanied a building inspector through a converted hotel whose service corridors ended at walls behind which former kitchens had been concealed. The inspector had considered the arrangement annoying but not surprising. Buildings accumulated intentions from people who were no longer alive to explain them. Pierce was walking among such intentions now, though their number seemed unreasonably large.
The sloping passage took him to a second dead end. Here the stone wall had been interrupted by brickwork, and the bricks differed markedly in color and size. Some were deep red, with chipped corners and irregular surfaces. Others were pale, almost yellow, and bore shallow grooves along their sides. The mixture suggested reused material. The wall was approximately eight feet high where it joined the vault, but its upper courses had not been completed. A ragged gap remained near the right side at the level of his shoulders, wide enough to admit the flashlight and perhaps his forearm. The bricks below the gap were set in old-looking mortar; above it the last course was loose enough that he did not want to lean against it. For no reason he could adequately defend, Pierce found himself thinking of a person sealed behind a wall. It was a familiar image from books, films, and the sort of gruesome rumor that attached itself to old buildings. At the sheriff's office, a recurring story held that the first county jail had contained a hidden chamber where prisoners died after being forgotten during an evacuation. Pierce had once checked the claim while preparing material for a local history presentation. The alleged chamber had been a coal chute, and the prisoners had never existed. The story had survived the correction because it was more interesting than the architectural truth. He recognized that the bricked wall before him was inviting the same mistake. An unfinished partition was not a tomb. Even so, he raised the flashlight to the gap with a reluctance that irritated him.
The space beyond contained debris. Broken bricks lay in a shallow heap against the far side, along with fragments of mortar, a length of rotted wood, and a portion of rusty metal mesh whose original use he could not determine. He shone the light toward the back, sweeping carefully from floor to ceiling. The cavity seemed to extend several feet, no more. There was a patch of damp earth beneath the rubble and a dark stain that could have been the result of water running down the wall. He saw no human remains, no clothing, no bones, and nothing that suggested a concealed passage. He held the beam there for a little longer, partly to verify that he had not mistaken shadows for solid objects, then lowered it. A bricked-up recess with construction debris behind it was precisely what the physical evidence suggested. He felt an almost disproportionate embarrassment at the expectation he had briefly entertained. Had he been with Laura, he would not have mentioned it. If she had asked what he thought might be behind the bricks, he would have said rubble, because that was what he could now see. It occurred to him that the basement's scale was encouraging him to abandon an otherwise useful discipline: he was beginning to look at ordinary objects with a hunger for extraordinary explanations. He had done the same thing in the Smith investigation, though at the time the inaccessible Dobbins cellar had been the object upon which he placed the unreasonable expectation. Now he had entered it and found not one hidden room but a procession of them. The appetite had not diminished. It had simply acquired more material on which to feed.
Pierce left the bricked recess and returned along the sloping passage to the last known fork. His injured ankle had become stiff, and he began placing each foot more carefully to prevent an awkward twist on the uneven stone. He made one more wrong turn, recognized the broken chair through an arch, and corrected his course. Eventually he reached a passage whose walls were not lined with bottles. The stone had been faced with pale plaster, much of it peeling near the floor, and the amber lights were set behind metal guards rather than glass covers. The route ran straight for perhaps fifty feet, then bent left and ended at a door. This door was made of a thick, dark material, probably painted steel, with a broad handle and a frame set deep into the stone. Its surface was dented near the bottom, and on the side nearest the hinges a thin line of rust followed the edge. There was no sign identifying the room beyond. He tried the handle. It was free. Before opening it, he listened with his ear near the metal. A sound came through, so faint and constant that he could not say whether it was produced by air, electrical machinery, or moving water. He took the flashlight in his sore hand, kept his other hand against the door, and opened it slowly.
Beyond was an enormous chamber containing a pool of dark water. The change in scale was so abrupt that he remained in the doorway, uncertain for several seconds where to direct his attention. The cellar behind him had confined his sight to a few yards at a time, with each curve replacing the last and making it impossible to think of the structure as a whole. Here he could see across a space whose far wall was only partly illuminated, the ceiling disappearing into shadow above a grid of suspended fluorescent fixtures. The lamps had once been arranged in regular lines, but many were dark. A few were missing their tubes entirely. Others flickered intermittently, producing brief changes in brightness across the water. The walls appeared to be reinforced concrete, with broad vertical ribs rising from the edge of a deep basin and supporting crossbeams high above. A metal platform of open grating extended from the doorway toward the opposite side of the room. It was supported at intervals by heavy vertical members that descended into the water. Narrow guardrails ran along both sides, though several posts were bent and one section lacked its middle horizontal rail. At the far end a door stood in a concrete wall, directly opposite the one through which he had entered. Nothing else offered an obvious route onward.
The pool occupied nearly the entire visible floor of the chamber. Its water was so dark that the light from the surviving fixtures penetrated only a short distance before disappearing into a dull, uncertain color. At the edges a narrow band of pale mineral deposit marked a former water level perhaps several inches above the present one. Rust stains ran down the support columns and spread in irregular brown fans where they reached the water. A thin, almost oily film occupied some of the calmer corners, although when he leaned forward he could not tell whether he was seeing oil or the reflection of discolored concrete above. The smell was unpleasant but not overwhelming: stagnant water, damp metal, and a faint sharpness that reminded him of salt left behind after road crews treated a street in winter. The pool might have been fresh water containing minerals, brackish water from an unknown source, or water contaminated by chemicals from the building. He had no equipment with which to test it. A slow drip came from somewhere in the chamber and fell at intervals into the basin. Each impact made a tiny sound that seemed louder than it ought to have in such a large space. Beneath that sound was a low, continuous vibration. He listened to it long enough to decide that a pump might be running, although he could not locate one.
The platform did not look like a bridge constructed for pedestrians crossing a natural body of water. It looked like an industrial service walkway, built so that workers could inspect tanks, valves, or machinery without descending into a basin. Its grating was made of intersecting metal bars with square openings large enough that he could see the water below. Bolts fastened the grating to transverse supports, and the supports were joined to the vertical members by triangular plates. In places the metal retained traces of green paint. Elsewhere it had become brown with corrosion, the surfaces flaking in thin scales near the joints. He inspected the first few feet from the doorway and found that the exposed metal was not equally deteriorated. Some bolts were bright at their edges and looked more recently replaced. One support carried a new-looking band of gray material beneath an older painted surface. Such details suggested maintenance, perhaps within the past decade, although Pierce could not know how quickly metal would weather in this environment. He could not establish that the structure was safe simply because some of its components had been repaired. He knew that a rusted railing could detach under the weight of a person who leaned against it, and that a section of grating could fail even when the support beneath it remained sound. After his fall through the wooden corridor, his willingness to trust an unfamiliar floor had been substantially reduced.
But before he tried to cross, he needed to consider the larger difficulty. The cellar had begun beneath a farmhouse. That statement was not a supposition; he had entered through the Dobbins kitchen and walked down the cellar stairs. He had then passed through a series of rooms and an old industrial installation, followed a long tunnel, examined a mess hall and communal showers, and fallen into a lower structure from which there had been no ordinary route upward. The building had grown more extensive with every stage, and the paths through it had become sufficiently irregular that he could not calculate his present position. He had not kept a reliable record of changes in elevation. He had estimated distances by steps, and the fall had made any calculation of depth speculative. Nevertheless the accumulated geometry strained belief. The Dobbins property was a farm, not a factory complex. The nearby roads and fields had been canvassed by deputies searching for John Smith, and there had been no evidence of an institution large enough to require such installations. A vast service tunnel, an industrial laundry, a maze of wine racks, and a chamber built around what looked like a reservoir did not become more plausible merely because they were connected by doors. He could not fit all of them into the landscape he remembered.
He took out the notebook and spread its pages against the doorframe. The earlier diagrams were embarrassingly crude. A rectangle for the farmhouse cellar joined another rectangle for the storage rooms. A line represented the pipe chamber. The utility tunnel extended across most of one page, terminating in a square for the mess hall. He had drawn smaller shapes for the showers and the wooden passage. The fall had no useful dimension at all: only a downward arrow and the words 'unknown depth,' followed by a rough outline of the pillow room. The laundry was represented by a long narrow rectangle, the wine cellar by a network of uncertain curves and short lines. He tried to place the chamber on the same scale and found that he had no reason to prefer one estimate over another. He could not prove that the underground construction occupied more land than existed above it. He had lost too much information for that. He could, however, say that the structure was substantially larger and more complicated than anything the known use of the farm would require. He understood the limitation of his conclusion, and the understanding did nothing to relieve his unease.
There were several possible explanations, and he made himself consider them in order of decreasing familiarity. The first was that the buildings had belonged to a former enterprise whose existence he had never discovered. A railroad facility, pumping station, military depot, emergency shelter, or private institution might have occupied land later divided among farms. Some of those enterprises built extensive underground works. There were Cold War shelters in the state, some official and some privately funded, and a few were larger than their aboveground entrances suggested. A service tunnel could connect one to another. The mess hall, communal showers, and laundry would fit an institutional purpose. The pipes and reservoir could support its operations. The wine cellar remained an odd addition, but old buildings often acquired new uses. He could imagine a wealthy owner appropriating part of a former facility to store wine after the larger installation was abandoned. What he could not imagine was the whole enterprise leaving no usable record in the ordinary survey materials he had seen, no surface entrances he had noticed while investigating the farm, and no explanation available from the Dobbins family. Samuel's secrecy might account for some of that absence. It could not by itself account for the size of the works.
The second possibility was that he had misunderstood where he was. The service tunnel might have carried him well beyond the Dobbins land, perhaps under neighboring properties toward an old industrial site whose surface buildings had been demolished. He had walked for a long time, and during much of that walk he had been unable to see anything outside the tunnel by which to orient himself. If the passage had curved, he might have covered a considerable horizontal distance without appreciating it. The fall could have shifted him another substantial distance along an inclined shaft. There was no need to presume that all the rooms stood beneath the farmhouse or even beneath one farm. That explanation was sensible as far as it went. Its weakness was the amount of infrastructure it required and the peculiar sequence in which the rooms were connected. Why should the route from an old farm cellar to a remote institution pass through a room of empty animal cages, a tractor without wheels, a hidden laundry entrance, and a wine cellar? He could explain each feature independently. He struggled to imagine a plausible history that explained all of them together.
The third possibility was more difficult to face because it involved the reliability of his own perceptions. He had fallen. He might have struck his head hard enough to suffer a concussion. He could not rule out a period of unconsciousness, or confusion after awakening, or the persistence of a dreamlike state. He had been exposed to stale air, dust, and the fumes of old cleaning materials. He had spent considerable time near a furnace and in poorly ventilated underground passages. Carbon monoxide, a solvent, or some other contaminant might have affected his judgment. He had eaten little since leaving the surface and had no water. He was injured, frightened, and exhausted. A person in those conditions might experience a disturbing alteration in perception without recognizing it. He had taken statements from people who described things they believed they had seen with absolute sincerity, only for independent evidence to show that the descriptions were wrong. He had no privilege exempting him from the same failure.
He looked at the grating beneath his feet, then deliberately moved back to the stone floor of the doorway. He put one hand against the concrete wall and pressed until the rough surface hurt his palm. He examined the lines in his skin where the cement caught them. He checked his watch and counted the movements of the second hand through half a minute. He looked from the watch to the ceiling fixtures and back again, noting whether the light changed while his attention was elsewhere. He closed one eye, then the other, comparing the apparent position of a railing post against the far door. Everything behaved in an ordinary fashion. He could feel the bruise on his ribs whenever he bent. The smell of the water persisted when he looked away from it. None of these observations proved that he was not hallucinating. A persuasive hallucination would, by definition, persuade the person experiencing it. Nor would pain prove reality to anyone who had experienced pain in a dream. But he could find no clear defect in his perceptions: no inability to read the same number twice, no sudden change in the shape of the room, no disappearance of an object when he turned his head, no failure of the world to respond consistently to his actions. If he were drugged or concussed, the appropriate response would still be to avoid unnecessary risks and seek an exit. He could not improve his situation by declaring the water unreal and stepping into it.
He thought briefly about John Smith. The missing man had been injured at the farmhouse, according to the available testimony, and had later crashed his motorcycle into a maple tree with sufficient violence to pin him and cause substantial bleeding. A person who suffered such injuries might have become confused. He might have remembered events incorrectly, or misjudged the danger he faced, or sought help in a place he had no reason to approach. Pierce had never accepted speculation about John's state of mind as a substitute for evidence. He would not begin doing so merely because his own state of mind had become a problem. The hair collected near the crash remained a material fact. The repaired farmhouse entrance remained a material fact. The missing wallet remained unexplained. The family had described John's fear and injury before the collision, and their statements did not cease to matter because Pierce could not interpret what he was seeing underground. He would have liked to speak to Laura. She might have interrupted his reasoning at the point where it became too accommodating of a preferred conclusion. She would also have pointed out that a man with an injured leg and no idea where he was had no business stepping onto a corroded metal bridge without assistance. Pierce could hear the observation so clearly that he found himself answering it under his breath: 'Yes. I know.'
He returned the notebook to his jacket and examined the platform more closely. A narrow strip of solid metal ran along the center of the grating, perhaps intended for the wheels of a handcart. The strip was about the width of his shoe and showed a series of scuffs running lengthwise. The grating on either side was firmly attached at its near end. He placed one foot on the first section, kept most of his weight on the stone threshold, and pressed. The metal gave a little but returned to its position without a crack or sudden movement. He shifted more of his weight onto it and waited. A faint tremor passed through the structure, sufficiently slight that he could have mistaken it for movement in his injured leg. He took the first full step, keeping his hand near the rail without gripping it. The platform held. He placed the other foot beside it and repeated the test on the next section. The open grid was unpleasant to look through. Water occupied the space below without enough reflection to tell him how deep it was, and the square openings produced a repetitive pattern that interfered with his ability to judge distance. He looked ahead rather than down whenever he was not testing a foothold. There would be plenty of time to examine the surface if he reached the other side.
His progress was slow. He tested each new panel with a portion of his weight before stepping onto it. Where the metal was visibly corroded around a bolt, he favored the central strip or the nearer part of a support. He stopped at a bent railing post and looked for damage to the platform beneath it. A strong impact might have bent the post without affecting the supports, but the damage could also indicate an accident involving a heavy object. The grating there showed a few shallow gouges, and an edge had been bent upward enough to catch a shoe. He stepped over it, mindful of his ankle. From the middle of the chamber he could see farther down the basin and realized that its dimensions were greater than those apparent from the entrance. The water extended into shadow beyond the last functioning ceiling light. A row of concrete piers stood along one wall, each separated by a broad dark recess. He could not tell whether the recesses were outlets, former machinery bays, or simply spaces between supports. There were no ladders descending into the water and no visible pump controls. If the chamber had been intended as a reservoir, the engineering was more elaborate than he could explain, but he had no expertise that entitled him to dismiss it.
At approximately the halfway point, something disturbed the water. He had been looking ahead at the far doorway when the movement occurred at the edge of his vision, below and to his right. It was brief, perhaps a second or two, and consisted of a widening dark patch accompanied by two low ripples that traveled outward before dissolving into the uneven reflections from the lights. He stopped. One hand rose instinctively toward the railing, then remained suspended when he remembered its condition. He looked directly at the place. The water was dark and almost still. A drop fell from the ceiling somewhere beyond his line of sight and produced a faint ring. Another followed after several seconds, farther away. The marks he had seen seemed too broad to have been caused by a single drop, but he had not observed them carefully enough to say so. A submerged object might have moved. A bubble could have reached the surface. A pump might have displaced water through an opening below the visible level, and the result might have arrived at the surface as a small swell. There could be fish. He could not rule out an animal, though he had no evidence that one was present. The existence of murky water did not establish the existence of something dangerous in it.
He remained on the platform for longer than was comfortable, listening. There was a gentle intermittent tapping somewhere along the steel supports, perhaps produced by water moving against them. The low mechanical vibration continued. He tried to decide whether the dark patch had traveled with a direction of its own or had merely grown outward as the ripple spread. He could not recover enough of the moment to answer. For a few seconds he entertained the idea of dropping something into the water and observing the response. He had no object worth sacrificing, and creating a disturbance would make it harder to interpret any movement that followed. He considered shining the flashlight below the surface, but the beam illuminated only a small brownish cone before its light was scattered into the murk. The attempt might have told him the water was three feet deep or thirty; at that angle he could not distinguish bottom from suspended sediment. He turned the light off and allowed his eyes to adjust again. Nothing moved that he could identify. He did not enjoy the thought of standing motionless over an unknown depth of water, supported by rusted metal, while he waited for a phenomenon that might never recur. He resumed crossing.
Near the opposite wall, the grating became more solid and the railing straighter. The last two panels looked better maintained than those in the middle, their edges showing relatively little corrosion. He stepped from them onto a concrete landing and stood with both feet planted while he examined the far door. Its paint had been worn near the handle by contact with hands or carried objects. A short strip of dark rubber ran along the bottom, possibly a draft seal. He checked the wall beside it for a switch, sign, or maintenance placard and found nothing. When he looked back across the chamber, the platform seemed narrower than it had while he was on it, an ordinary effect of perspective that nevertheless made him wonder whether he had been foolish to cross. The water below was still. He could no longer distinguish the point at which he had noticed the disturbance. The ripples had left no trace. He put his ear near the door and listened. There was no sound of voices or machinery on the other side, only a faint electric hum. He took hold of the handle and opened it.
The corridor beyond was long and remarkably plain. It had a concrete floor poured in broad sections, with narrow straight joints dividing the surface into rectangles. The walls were painted a pale gray that looked almost white beneath the surviving fluorescent fixtures. The ceiling was lower than that of the flooded chamber and composed of flat panels interrupted by exposed conduit and occasional square ventilation grilles. Light came from rows of fixtures mounted overhead, some with intact translucent covers and others with bare tubes. One tube buzzed and flickered every few seconds, but enough remained illuminated for Pierce to see the far end of the passage. There stood another door, dull and rectangular, apparently made of metal. Between him and it were closets. Narrow doors lined both walls at regular intervals, so many that the repeating sequence of frames and handles became difficult to count by sight. Each door had the same simple round knob, and each was painted a color only slightly darker than the wall. There were no numbers, names, symbols, instructions, or notices anywhere. Pierce stood at the entrance and looked down the corridor for a long time, trying to determine whether this was an ordinary storage wing of the sort that might serve a hospital or industrial facility. It resembled one in its regularity, although the lack of any identifying signs was difficult to explain. Institutions usually numbered their rooms because the people who worked in them needed to find things. He knew that firsthand from the county office, where even a closet containing nothing but paper towels and spare toner had acquired a number that appeared on the maintenance schedule. The arrangement before him suggested systematic construction without a corresponding system for ordinary use.
He walked to the first door on the right, tested its handle, and opened it. The room behind was approximately six feet deep and four feet wide, with bare concrete underfoot and a single shelf supported by steel brackets. Nothing occupied the shelf or the floor. A thin film of dust covered the surface, except near the hinge where flakes of paint had fallen from the door. Pierce shut it and opened the opposite closet. There he found an assortment of hand tools resting on two shelves: a claw hammer with a wooden handle, several screwdrivers of different lengths, adjustable wrenches, a small hacksaw, a measuring tape with a cracked housing, and a pair of pliers whose grips had deteriorated. A metal toolbox sat on the floor with its lid open. It contained a collection of loose nuts and screws, most of them dark with age, but no organized trays. The tools were ordinary, though the absence of maker's names surprised him when he examined them closely. The hammerhead bore no visible stamp; the handle had no lettering. The measuring tape had a scale but no brand printed on its body. He was aware that inexpensive tools were not always conspicuously marked, and that markings could wear away. He could not treat their anonymity as evidence of anything on its own. Yet the feature repeated across the collection. He checked the underside of the toolbox lid for a name scratched by an owner and found none. There was no address, no work order, no tag indicating who was responsible for replacing lost equipment. He wrote 'tools, mixed condition; no inventory or owner marking visible' and closed the door.
The next room contained nothing. The one opposite it held three folded canvas sheets, a coil of thick rope, and a pair of rubber boots standing on a piece of corrugated cardboard. The boots were tall, black, and the sort that might be used in farm work or in a flooded service chamber. Their soles were worn unevenly, suggesting real use. The rope had become stiff where dirt had accumulated between the fibers. One canvas sheet was frayed at its edge. Pierce tried lifting a corner and found that the fabric resisted unfolding because it had been pressed into the same position for so long. He put it back without opening the rest. There was nothing unusual about canvas, rope, or boots, and he was not certain why he had expected anything more. Perhaps because so much of what he had encountered in the past several hours had refused to provide a useful explanation, he had begun to regard each new door as an opportunity for the building to announce its purpose. A tool closet might reveal what kind of facility had been maintained. A cupboard of clothing might contain the insignia of a former employee. A discarded personal letter might identify a person who had worked here. He was now looking for the simplest items that might answer a question. He would have been delighted to discover a utility bill.
He established a method and followed it. Starting on the right side, he inspected each closet in order, then crossed to the opposite door at the same point along the corridor. He assigned consecutive numbers to the pairs on his drawing and made brief notes about their contents. An empty closet required only an indication that he had opened it and looked at its walls, floor, and shelving. A filled closet received a more detailed description. He did not move objects unless their position prevented him from seeing something important, and he tried not to touch anything with his injured hand. The system was slow but familiar. When he had joined the sheriff's office, a lieutenant named Philip Banford had insisted that young detectives learn to make inventories before they learned to speculate about motives. Banford believed that an investigation became unreliable at the moment an officer decided that an item was too ordinary to record. Pierce had once accompanied him to an abandoned hunting camp used intermittently by a group of teenagers. Banford had recorded the make and condition of several mismatched mugs, a package of batteries, and a damaged cushion long after the younger officers had decided the scene contained nothing useful. Weeks later the batteries helped establish that someone had visited the camp after its supposed abandonment. The revelation had been modest. No murderer was caught and no great mystery solved. It had merely corrected the date in a report. Banford considered this an excellent result, and Pierce had come to agree with him. An observation was not wasted because it disappointed the observer.
The fifth closet held clothing. Several metal hangers were suspended from a plain rod near the ceiling, and on them hung gray and brown work jackets, trousers, and shirts made of coarse fabric. Their shapes suggested adult clothing, mostly in medium and large sizes. Some articles had been folded over hangers rather than properly hung. One jacket had a missing button. Another had a dark stain along the lower sleeve. Pierce examined the collars and inside seams without removing the garments. He found no sewn names, no employer patches, no laundry markings, and no fabric labels indicating sizes or manufacturers. A person might have cut the labels out for comfort, but here the seams showed no obvious remnants of them. There were no wallets in the visible pockets. A loose piece of paper lay in the back corner, and he crouched to examine it with increasing interest. It was a fragment of stiff packing material without writing on either side. He replaced it and made a note. The sixth closet, opposite, was empty except for a single shelf bracket whose shelf had been removed. The seventh contained two folding chairs, an unopened bundle of paper napkins, a stack of enamel cups, and a small metal tray. The cups were plain cream-colored objects with chips along their rims. He could see the dull edge of exposed metal beneath the enamel where the chips had formed. There was no institutional crest, no initials, and no indication that they belonged to any particular dining room. He thought of the mess hall he had entered earlier and wondered whether the cups had once been used there. It was a reasonable connection, although nothing about a cream-colored cup could establish it.
The corridor seemed longer as he worked. Every few pairs of closets he stopped to check his drawing against the doors behind him, counting the handles to confirm that he had not skipped an opening. The doors were so similar that he could easily have lost track. Some closets had shelves; others were bare. A few contained floor drains, capped pipes, or empty wall brackets suggesting that equipment had once been installed. One held a stack of wooden crates without markings. The crates had no lids, and their interiors were empty except for sawdust caught at the corners. Another contained a set of long-handled cleaning implements: two brooms, a floor brush, a mop with a stiffened head, and a dented bucket. The handles were unpainted and had been worn smooth where hands would grip them. An adjoining closet was completely empty. In the next pair he found a collection of folded blankets, most of them gray, and an old electric fan with a cage around the blades. The fan's cord was coiled neatly and tied with string. He examined the plug, found that its insulation had become brittle near the base, and decided not to test it even if he found a working outlet. There was little value in discovering whether a neglected fan could turn its blades. He wanted evidence of an occupant, a caretaker, a purpose, anything that would explain why the room existed. The fan supplied none of those things.
He had reached the center of the corridor when he became aware of his thirst. It had been present for some time, but the combination of pain, concentration, and repeated bending had made it more urgent. His mouth was dry and his lips felt cracked. There were no drinking fountains, sinks, or taps visible in the corridor. He considered returning to the communal showers, where he had observed water running clear after an initial discharge of brown sediment, but the route would require crossing the pool again, finding his way through the wine cellar, and ascending a staircase concealed beneath a false machine. The water from the showers had not been tested and might have stood in pipes for years. Clear water could contain bacteria or contaminants without announcing them by color or smell. He might have to risk it if no alternative appeared, but he did not want to make that decision while he could still walk and think. He checked the time and was surprised by how much of the afternoon had passed since the last entry. The watch still ticked. It had preserved a chronology of his movement even while his geographical understanding dissolved. Somewhere above, perhaps, Samuel Dobbins was returning to a damaged front entrance and discovering that someone had entered his home. Pierce wondered whether the old farmer would recognize immediately where the intruder had gone. Samuel might be afraid. He might be angry. He might call the sheriff's office. He might refuse to report the damage and attempt to deal with it himself. Pierce knew nothing that would let him choose among those possibilities, and the same uncertainty extended to his colleagues. Laura could already be receiving a telephone call about a trespass at the Dobbins farm. Rowan might already have learned that Pierce had gone somewhere he was forbidden to go. The realization produced less shame than it should have, not because he believed his conduct justified, but because the practical problem of surviving had begun to occupy the place where his concern for professional consequences had been.
At the next closet he found a narrow metal cabinet within the larger storage space. Its drawers were labeled only with tiny impressed numerals on the handles: one, two, three, four. There were no words identifying what ought to be kept in them. He pulled the upper drawer open and found a scattering of thin metal washers. The second held nails of several sizes. The third contained a few small springs and an object that looked like a broken hinge pin. The fourth was empty. These were ordinary repair supplies, and the numerals at least suggested that someone had once distinguished the drawers, although they were not informative labels. The cabinet's back was secured to the wall by two screws, and one was missing. Dust marked the place where it had rested before the missing screw came out. Pierce found himself examining the cabinet for a date of manufacture and then felt foolish, because no date was present and he had already wasted more time on it than it deserved. He opened the opposite closet and found nothing at all. A small square of discoloration on the wall suggested that a cabinet or shelf had once hung there. Its removal had left no trace of its purpose.
He worked on. There were boxes of ordinary white dishes wrapped in plain brown paper; a closet containing only an iron bedframe dismantled into four pieces; another with coils of electrical cable, a wooden ladder, and two tins filled with assorted fasteners. In one closet a row of shelves held clean folded towels, each pale gray and apparently identical. He inspected a hem. The fabric was stiff with age but bore no laundry mark or identifying tag. Another closet contained children's clothing in a small assortment of sizes: sweaters, trousers, and socks, all folded and placed in low cardboard boxes. He stared at this discovery longer than at the work clothes. The existence of small clothes in an abandoned facility did not require an extraordinary explanation. Families sometimes lived at institutions. Shelters stored clothing for people of different ages. Donations accumulated in rooms that no one remembered to empty. Nevertheless the sight of a small pair of knitted socks made him think immediately of Emily, not as she was now but as a child who had once refused to wear matching socks because she believed that a different color on each foot made running more interesting. Christine had let her go to kindergarten that way and had told Pierce that children should be allowed harmless eccentricities while they still had the opportunity to enjoy them. He had disagreed at the time, mostly because he thought the matter of matching clothing too trivial to argue over, and had later realized that this was precisely Christine's point. He looked at the socks in the box and wondered whether he would see Emily again. The thought was no longer a rhetorical expression of guilt. He could picture the consequences of a search if he failed to return: his car found along Farmer's Road, his apartment entered by officers, Christine asked to provide a recent description, Emily learning that her father had gone missing while investigating a case from which he had been removed. He wanted with sudden force to send a message, even a useless one, explaining that he had made a serious mistake and was trying to find his way out. No method of sending it was available. He replaced the lid and closed the closet.
By the time he reached the last third of the passage, he had begun to make a distinction between the objects and the rooms containing them. The objects were inconsistent in age and condition. Some had the dull patina of long use. Some looked nearly new. In one cupboard a cracked wooden chair rested beside a metal lamp whose paint was barely scratched. In another, clean linen had been stacked above a cardboard box softened by damp. The rooms, however, were all constructed to essentially the same dimensions and finished with the same materials. The doors opened inward in the same manner. The shelves, where present, were supported by similar brackets, and the wall paint varied only slightly with exposure to moisture. Whatever the purpose of the storage wing, it had been designed as one system, then supplied with materials that might have come from several unrelated places. That was not especially unusual for an institution. A maintenance staff accumulated things no one wanted to discard. Supplies migrated from closed departments and defunct buildings. Pierce had once found three generations of filing cabinets in a county storeroom, the oldest locked and missing its key, with no one able to say what records it held. The oldest cabinet had eventually been opened by facilities staff and proved to contain expired parking permits and a broken adding machine. Not every old container guarded a secret. The thought helped him continue with a little more patience.
At the final pair of closets he counted his entries. There were twenty-eight doors on each side of the corridor, fifty-six in all. He had examined each one. Twenty-eight were empty by any practical description, though a strict inventory would include the shelves, brackets, residue, or small scraps left in several of them. Of the occupied closets, most contained tools, clothing, furniture, cleaning materials, or general household and maintenance supplies. None contained a document with a name, an address, a date that could be reliably assigned to the facility, or an identifying institutional mark. He had found no record books, no medicine cabinets with prescriptions, no payroll materials, no employee belongings with initials written on them, and no signs indicating a department or a room number. A few common manufactured objects had numerical scales or measurement marks, but such marks told him only what the objects were made to do. The items seemed to have been gathered without the information by which people ordinarily kept track of their property. He found the result peculiar, though not as peculiar as the simple fact that so much space had been built to store so little. Half the closets were empty. The other half could have been consolidated into a much smaller number. A building could outlive the need for its storage rooms, and an institution might empty them when it shut down. But where would the supplies have gone? Why had some been left and others taken? What person had decided that the children’s socks should remain while the cupboard next to them stood completely bare? He had no answer that rose above speculation.
He closed his notebook and slipped it into his jacket. His handwriting had become smaller and less regular, a change he attributed partly to fatigue and partly to the discomfort in his fingers. He had been standing and walking for much longer than his injuries recommended. The last few yards of the corridor lay ahead, leading to the single metal door at its end. He had inspected fifty-six closets, crossed a corroded walkway above dark water, and passed through an elaborate wine cellar without gaining any dependable indication of his position. He had added many observations to the record and almost no understanding. For a moment he felt the sort of exhausted impatience that sometimes seized him near the end of a difficult interview, when a witness had provided hours of accurate incidental information but still could not answer the question that mattered. He recognized the feeling and allowed himself to stop. It would be a mistake to approach the next door merely because he was tired of the present room. That had been the habit he most needed to resist: the conviction that the next thing, rather than the thing already before him, must contain the solution.
He stood quietly and examined the end of the passage from several yards away. The overhead fixture nearest the door was dark, so the last section of concrete received light from behind him. The door was painted gray, with a horizontal metal plate near its bottom and a handle worn to a brighter color at the points where it would be touched. The frame was set directly into concrete. There was no window. The wall beside it was plain except for a narrow patch where the paint had blistered and begun to peel. He studied the hinges and the threshold, searching for indications of recent movement. The hinges showed a little exposed metal at their edges; that could result from a door being used or from the paint flaking as temperatures changed. The lower plate was scratched. Heavy objects might have been pushed or carried against it. None of these things established anything he could not have said about a service door in a hundred ordinary buildings.
Then, while looking at the threshold, he noticed a set of marks on the floor. He moved closer, crouched carefully to spare his injured knee, and directed the flashlight obliquely across the concrete. Several scratches extended toward the door from the middle of the corridor. They were not straight enough to suggest wheels traveling in a regular track. Some curved slightly and others overlapped at different angles. Their widths varied. One began as a shallow gray scuff, deepened for several inches, then ended abruptly. Another consisted of two almost parallel grooves with an irregular break between them. Pierce could not tell whether they had been made by furniture, machinery, a dragged container, or something else with hard edges. He knew that the visual impression of scratches was easily mistaken for evidence of a particular action. He had investigated a burglary in which marks across a kitchen floor were confidently described as the tracks of a heavy safe being dragged out of the house. They had been made by a refrigerator moved during a repair three weeks earlier. Without a known object to compare, marks were marks. He altered the angle of the light, following each groove to its end, and found a small quantity of dust caught in the deepest sections.
He was about to rise when he saw something lodged along the edge of one scratch. At first he thought it was a fragment of paint or the end of a thread from his torn jacket. He held the flashlight closer and lowered his head. There were two fine strands, separated by less than an inch, lying partly within the groove and partly against the rough concrete. A third had caught at the edge of a neighboring mark. They were short and irregular, bending where the surface rose beneath them. They did not look like pieces of wire. He could not determine their composition without magnification, and he had no clean container or laboratory instrument with which to examine them. But their color was unmistakable. He had seen descriptions and photographs of similarly colored strands in Dr. Elaine Mercer's reports on the motorcycle crash, where the laboratory had established that the material was genuine animal hair without identifying the species. He did not know whether these belonged to the same animal, whether they had been carried here by someone or something else, or when they had become trapped in the scratches. He knew only what was in front of him, in a corridor far beneath the farmhouse. He had followed the floor marks to an unmarked door. At the end of the deepest groove lay three fine strands of hair, blue against the gray concrete.
from
Notes I Won’t Reread
Oh look who it is. its me. im back. havent written since the 18th. i know, you missed me, i didnt miss you, but besides that, theres something satisfying about habout having one particular thing to do every day, even if its just sitting down and bothering people with my thoughts. when you stop being consistent. even for few days, it gets on your nerves. the 19th was interesting. i had my usual reason to ignore the birthday nonsense, and then another reason to dislike the day altogether. thre was someone missing from the day who wouldve made more sense being there than i did. but i guess thats not how these things work. anyway, i wasnt interested in celebrating anything to begin with. ive never been fond of the 19th, but i think its managed to earn a special place on my list of dates id happily erase. great. its finally found a way to become even worse.
And Oh, how funny. its the 21st. todays date is looking familiar. i wonder why. id joke about it but i lost my sense of humour today. just figure it out maybe.
Sincerely, No wiser than before, but hotter
from Le carnet français
Fin 2026, vapoter reste légal en France, mais dans un cadre strict : les puffs jetables sont interdites, les e-liquides nicotinés sont plafonnés, la publicité est proscrite et la vente aux mineurs sanctionnée. La fiscalité, elle, n'a pas changé, malgré deux automnes de débats budgétaires.
Voici, point par point, ce que dit le droit aujourd'hui.
Les cigarettes électroniques jetables ne peuvent plus être vendues ni offertes en France depuis le 26 février 2025. L'interdiction vient de la loi n° 2025-175 du 24 février 2025, adoptée à l'unanimité par le Parlement.
Le critère retenu n'est pas la batterie, mais le réservoir. Sont visés les dispositifs préremplis de liquide qui ne peuvent pas être remplis à nouveau, que leur batterie soit rechargeable ou non. Un appareil dont on recharge seulement la batterie reste donc concerné.
Deux précisions utiles :
La France est le deuxième pays européen à avoir pris cette mesure, après la Belgique.
Les règles applicables aux e-liquides viennent de la directive européenne 2014/40/UE, transposée dans le code de la santé publique. Elles n'ont pas bougé depuis 2016.
L'étiquette doit mentionner la présence de nicotine, les coordonnées du fournisseur et un avertissement sanitaire. La fiche de la DGCCRF détaille ces mentions.
Ces obligations pèsent sur tous les professionnels, du laboratoire à la boutique en ligne. Un fabricant français comme eliquide-pas-cher.fr y est soumis au même titre qu'un importateur.
La vente de produits du vapotage à un mineur est interdite, avec ou sans nicotine. Le vendeur peut exiger une preuve de majorité.
La vente en ligne reste légale. Le projet de budget pour 2026 prévoyait de l'interdire aux particuliers, mais la mesure a été retirée du texte final. Les sites doivent rappeler l'interdiction de vente aux mineurs, notamment au moment du paiement.
Vapoter est interdit dans trois types de lieux :
Ailleurs, c'est le responsable des lieux qui décide. Un restaurant, un commerce ou une entreprise peut étendre l'interdiction par son règlement intérieur. La fiche officielle sur l'interdiction de vapoter précise les sanctions.
Toute publicité ou propagande en faveur des produits du vapotage est interdite, qu'elle soit directe ou indirecte. C'est l'article L. 3513-4 du code de la santé publique.
La règle couvre l'affichage, la presse grand public, les réseaux sociaux et le parrainage. En boutique, aucun message ni visuel promotionnel ne doit être visible depuis l'extérieur. Un produit de vapotage ne peut pas non plus être présenté comme un médicament.
Les e-liquides ne supportent aucune taxe spécifique en France : ils sont soumis à la TVA au taux normal, sans droit d'accise.
Le sujet revient pourtant chaque automne :
Une taxation harmonisée est aussi en discussion au niveau européen. Rien n'est donc acquis au-delà de 2026 : pour l'instant, le cadre fiscal est inchangé.
La vente de produits du vapotage est interdite aux mineurs. Si vous ne fumez pas, ne vapotez pas.
from
Hunter Dansin
“Behold they are one people, and they all have the same language. And this is what they began to do.”
— Genesis 11:6, NASB

It is difficult to appreciate language as a technology because we use it so naturally. By the time we have developed the capacity to think about language in the abstract we have already forgotten to think about it at all. Perhaps that is why Large Language Models like Claude and ChatGPT are so seductive. We read and hear them speaking in a human way, and ascribe human qualities to them without thinking. Animals like dolphins and even bees can communicate with each other, but communication is not language. Language is uniquely human. We do it spontaneously and imaginatively. It is the foundation upon which all the greatest collaborative achievements of our race have been built (hence the tower of Babel), and yet languages are dying. Globalization and political forces have already reduced the number of languages, but I would argue that, especially as an English speaker, our own relationship to our mother tongue is coming under attack. Readers are reading less and easier books. Writing jobs are being poached by LLMs. And even if we don’t use AI, most of us live in such a perpetually hurried and worried state that we rarely use language for anything more than animal communication. Is it any wonder then, that the technology that has even its creators prophesying about doomsday, is built around human language?[^1]
I don’t care to go on dooming about AI. I think we are all pretty anxious about it. Rather, I would like to look into sources from the past to think about how we can respond. It gets a little dark and confusing, because that’s where C.S. Lewis goes in The Abolition of Man, but there is light at the end of tunnel. The light of The Way, or 道 “Dao,” a concept and word which Lewis borrows from the ancient Chinese text, 道德经 “The Dao de Jing.”[^2]
What I discovered in writing this essay is that reaching the frontiers of both space and computer technology is forcing all of us to make a decision about what it means to be human. We can no longer live in denial about the direction this road is taking us. One way leads to a rejection of our past and our humanity, the other leads to life. Far from curing cancer, AI simply reveals the cancer that has been growing in our civilization since at least the 1950s, but I suspect it has been a human problem from the beginning (as we will see with Shakespeare’s King Lear). But we do not have to despair (forever).
“The head rules the belly through the chest—the seat, as Alanus tells us, of Magnanimity—Sentiment—these are the indispensable liaison officers between cerebral man and visceral man. It may even be said that it is by the middle element that man is man: for by his intellect he is mere spirit and by his appetite mere animal. The operation of The Green Book and its kind is to produce what may be called Men Without Chests.”
(Lewis, 1955, p. 34)
I am not sure anyone can really summarize The Abolition of Man. It plays that great trick of good philosophy by revealing the mysterious abyss beneath the fundamental elements of existence. The element of Lewis’s concern is morality, or more precisely, the moral training that enables a person to follow through with moral behavior.
He begins by criticizing a textbook (“The Green Book”) that is intended “for boys and girls in the upper forms of schools.” He quotes a commentary that the authors of the textbook make about a passage from Coleridge, in which a character says that a waterfall “is sublime.” The authors of The Green Book state:
“When the man said That is sublime, he appeared to be making a remark about his own feelings. What he was saying was really I have feelings associated in my mind with the word ‘Sublime’ or shortly, I have sublime feelings. This confusion is continually present in language as we use it. We appear to be saying something very important about something: and actually we are only saying something about our own feelings.” (Lewis, 1955, p. 14)
This is a problem for C.S. Lewis because he fears that its underlying presupposition—that feelings and value judgments are merely emotional—will lead students to moral oblivion. If unchecked, it will even threaten the foundations of a just and stable civilization. It is what the poor authors of The Green Book have not written which worries him more than what they have. C.S. Lewis says:
“...the schoolboy will learn about literature precisely nothing. What he will learn, and perhaps indelibly, is the belief that all emotions aroused by local association are in themselves contrary to reason and contemptible.” (p.19)
We might be tempted to refute his assertions with a reducto ad absurdam: “So Clive… I can call you Clive right? You mean to tell me that a silly English textbook could undermine the foundations of a just and honorable society? You mean to tell me that the church could crumble, that morals could fracture, that people could forget how to read? And even when they do, have no education that enables them to tell what literature is good and what is not? You mean to tell me that relationships could suffer? That trust in governments could collapse? That the moral and ethical frameworks that sustained our spiritual institutions could… just… die like that? That’s ridiculous! That’s… uhh… well… That feels like what is happening right now.”
C.S. Lewis is using the textbook as an example of the general spirit of “debunking” that was beginning to pervade the education of his time. He defines the error and takes it to the extreme. He fears that students who learn exclusively from textbooks like The Green Book will learn “precisely nothing” about learning to love intrinsic Good, Beauty, and Truth. What they will learn instead is the art of debunking the feelings that ought to lead them to the Good. If the waterfall cannot actually be sublime, then nothing can be sublime.
There is certainly wisdom in questioning your feelings and not taking them for Truth, but if we never trust our feelings, if we never learn to feel love for things that are truly beautiful, and only view them as chemical reactions in the brain instead of natural responses to real Beauty or real Good, then we are in great danger. Moral fortitude requires emotional and spiritual training more than it requires a logical argument. At the eleventh hour, when no one is watching, all that stands between you and your harmful impulse is you. The person who has practiced virtue and made it a part of their inner life will have a much greater chance of resisting temptation than the person who has only thought of virtue as a nice idea (even if the second person’s theological or philosophical framework is more robust). There is a great difference between a scholar of war and a soldier. The scholar might have what he considers to be a more complete picture, unclouded by the fog of war, but the soldier will know what it is to have confronted his own limitations in the face of real evil and real danger. Students armed with only a general encouragement to “be kind” will have no real inspiration or training to stand in the face of evil when it threatens their lives and socioeconomic status. “Men Without Chests,” is the inevitable conclusion of this kind of education because the Chest (the “seat of Magnanimity”) cannot grow without real exercise and real examples. It is like teaching kids to swim without ever letting them get wet.
Students who only learn to “see through” things will become trapped in what C.S. Lewis calls “an infinite regress” (p.47) of values. We feel the result of this education when we jump from hobby to hobby, cause to cause, partner to partner, job to job, post to post, church to church, religion to religion. When we are taught to see everything as transparent it is only ourselves we can trust, and this is a terrible responsibility. Alan Noble defines the voice of this terrible responsibility in his book, You Are Not Your Own, like this:
“I am responsible for living a life of purpose, of defining my identity, of interpreting meaningful events, of choosing my values, and electing where I belong. If I belong to myself, then I am the only one who can set limits on who I am or what I can do. No one else has the right to define me, to choose my journey in life, or to assure me that I am okay. I belong to myself” (Noble, 2021, p. 4).
For Noble, this ideal of the self which our culture glorifies would seem ideal until we discover that our self is unreliable. Attempts to “self actualize” end in burnout or denial.[^3] It is only by relying on something larger than ourselves that we can find peace and stability. This is connected to Lewis’s infinite regress because it shows how lost the self can become when it does not have any reason for exercising a Chest. “The heart is deceitful above all things and beyond cure. Who can understand it?” (Jeremiah 17:9, NIV) says the prophet, because “the heart” (the self) can use any shape, any creed, and any lifestyle. If the self is the only solid thing, “I want” becomes “I need.” It can apply itself to the American Dream, to the Socialist Dream, to our Instagram Dreams, our recommended videos, our taste in books, our blogs, our sports, our leisure, our pen brands, our church, our music, our everything. Since there are now hardly any obstacles left in our education or culture to oppose self aggrandizement, we are free to justify any purchase and any behavior. It is far more insidious and pervasive than anyone wants to admit, and I think it explains why many American Christians seem to be more interested in projecting the appearance of a God fearing household than in practicing the love of Jesus.
“But wait Clive—I know you like it when I call you Clive—What’s the problem? You’re talking about Men Without Chests. All I’m doing—Oh, I am the Spirit of the Age, btw, nice to meet you! All I’m doing, really, is telling people that they ought to exercise their Chest to be whatever they want to be. Isn’t that what you want?”
C.S. Lewis’s answer is something we already hinted at, which is that without any kind of moral law that is really True and really Good, there is nothing to stop a person from falling into the abyss of infinite regress. We could try to regulate our impulses, but without an authoritative Rule, we will just be pitching our instincts against each other depending on our nature and our nurture. Without something like Practical Reason, or Logos, or Summum Bonum or Dao, we are lost not to the infinite regress of culture this time, but to the infinite regress of the impulses that rage within ourselves. Technology only amplifies and accelerates this recursive process. We might do well in affirming the Spirit of the Age for a while, but we eventually burn out in a cycle of denial, despair, and escapism. We must turn to something outside of ourselves. We must turn to the Dao.
“The Dao” is what C.S. Lewis, in typical fashion, uses as a shorthand for what thousands of years and philosophical traditions have illuminated as the true Truth that all our seeing through is supposed to finally see. He defines the Dao (which literally means “the Way” in Chinese) like this:
“It is the reality beyond all predicates, the abyss that was before the Creator Himself. It is Nature, it is the Way, the Road. It is the Way in which the universe goes on, the Way in which things everlastingly emerge, stilly and tranquilly, into space and time. It is also the Way in which every man should tread in imitation of that cosmic and supercosmic progression, conforming all activities to that great exemplar (Lewis, 1955, p. 28).”
Before we go on. I feel compelled to state that I do not believe there is a conspiracy in education, and especially not among teachers in schools. If you have spent any amount of time in a school you will quickly realize that frontline educators are some of the most underpaid and undermined defenders of the Dao. They often have the lowest salaries and the highest workloads, while irresponsible administrators (not all administrators), EdTech entrepreneurs, and misinformed legislators shove curriculum after curriculum and technology after technology down the pipeline, leaving teachers to pick up the pieces to try and give kids a decent education. If there is any conspiracy, it is the conspiracy of greed and pride at work in every human being, in tension with the good within us that desires fulfillment in the Dao. It is pride that said in the garden of Eden, “No! My way is better!” for no good reason. It is pride we see when our kids defy commands meant for their own good. It is pride that wants to turn from the Way to use and create sycophantic techno-magical devices.
The desire to turn away from the Dao is something that we will never be free from while we live in these bodies on this earth. For if the Dao is really the Dao then it is perfect, and when perfection meets imperfection the imperfect must invariably suffer. This is why “trained emotion,” or “a chest” as Lewis puts it is necessary (I believe he means something like a practice of faith that is not merely intellectual). The Chest is the muscle we use to command our body and evaluate our emotions and direct them back to the Way. We cannot simply optimize ourselves to less screen time and a better future. The Chest is what turns faith into works. The Chest is what we need to fight our passions and our doubts tooth and nail, and the road only gets steeper as life goes on. The Path does not care about your previous accomplishments or socioeconomic status. That is why priests and pastors and politicians and teachers and philosophers and cops and uncles and parents and grandmothers are capable of so much hypocrisy. It is why the struggle to follow the Dao is lifelong, and possibly longer.
Yet though this struggle between pride and the Dao has been the eternal struggle of humanity, we must acknowledge that every age has unique battlegrounds with unique features. Whether the data tells the full picture or not, I think we can say with confidence that there has been a significant decline in the authority of moral institutions like the church, as well as in biblical literacy. It is no longer a given that most people in the western world have more than a piecemeal understanding of Jesus or the story of the Bible, let alone the old testament or anything outside of Christianity except for Tik Toks that mention fragments of spiritual traditions. We have fallen into the exact trap that Lewis warned us against. We have been taught a method for seeing through traditions, like navigators told only which stars not to follow. It is not that we don’t want virtues, because I think we are very hungry for them. It is not even that we don’t try to teach them (again, visit a school and you will see virtues tacked on almost every wall), but we have not received and we do not give any real training for how to adhere to those virtues in a world that tries to crush them. The communities that we would traditionally turn to for help, such as churches, are infected with the same disease because churches are made up of people like us.[^4]
It is really already too late. The plane is already going down and we have to put the mask on ourselves. The men and women who hold the most influence in our world have already been through this education. We are already reaping the results of putting Men Without Chests in positions of power. It is not hard to imagine how the Zuckerbergs, Bezoses, Musks, Altmans and Amodeis were formed (put whatever billion dollar name you want up there, and yeah, it’s mostly men at this point). It is not hard to see how they could believe that whatever they decide is perfectly right, which usually coincides with whatever is right for their bottom line. In the absence of a Dao to regulate our moral sense, money is the closest thing to an external substitute in the modern world, because limitless cash enables the “I am my own” lifestyle. With a great amount of money, almost any impulse becomes fulfillable (even though experience ought to teach us that following impulses is almost always unfulfilling); and anything that serves money looks like the right choice. “The love of money is a root of many kinds of evil,” because we obey what we really love. Our culture worships people of astronomical net worth because they appear to have won the race for unfettered self expression and limitless personal freedom. It is therefore worth exploring, in the next chapter, what these Men Without Chests are really driving us towards.
Thank you so much for reading! Next week will be focused on the application of “Men Without Chests” to AI. If you want to read ahead I will, among other things, be comparing and contrasting Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei's essay Machines of Loving Grace with Emilia Javorsky's AI vs. Cancer. If you only read one I recommend the one by Javorsky, and if you want to know where the title for this series comes from, read the first scene of King Lear!
As I publish these chapters (there will be eight), you will be able to see all of them together (hopefully in order) if you click on this hashtag: #ourfastintent
You can also get an email when I publish a new one!
If you appreciate my work, and that I don't paywall anything, please consider buying me at least one of the many cups of coffee I consumed while writing this essay. I try to add some behind the scenes goodies for potential supporters: https://buymeacoffee.com/hdansin
These words were made from 100% organic human ingredients such as clickety clackety, caffein, joy, despair, existential dread, and more. Who needs LLMs?
#essay #non-fiction
[1] In case the hyperlinks expire in this paragraph: “ascribe human qualities” is supported by a Time article reporting about people falling in love with AI Chatbots on platforms like Character.AI and Replika. Users have reported troubling emotional attachments eerily similar to the main character in the movie Her (2013). “Language is uniquely human” is asserted by John H McWhorter in The Story of Human Language, he argues convincingly that while there are many instance of humans training apes or parrots to “talk,” there are no instance of apes or parrots talking in the wild. Thus human language to animals is like a game that we can teach them through painstaking and tedious training, not a real mode of self expression. “Languages are dying” cites an article that cites several books from the year 2000 to 2024, which document Language Death (by David Crystal) and Vanishing Voices (by Daniel Nettle and Suzanne Romaine), showing that we are losing language diversity at an accelerated and alarming rate. “Readers are reading less” cites an NPR podcast which cites a Gallup survey from 2022 which shows that Americans are reading fewer books per year, and data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics which shows that the time people spend reading has dropped steadily over the past two decades. “Writing jobs poached by LLMs” is a Substack article, which is admittedly an anecdote, about how the author uncovered an AI writer with published articles across several prominent religious magazines which explicitly reject AI generated content. Somehow this ‘author’ managed to fool them. There are other documented cases of AI writing creeping into significant publications and it is depressing. Also anecdotally, the SEO writing job I held for a short time no longer exists as of several years ago.
[2] It is at this point that a pastor would mention the “Nones.” They are one of the largest ‘religious’ groups in the US and they have grown over the years (https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2024/01/24/religious-nones-in-america-who-they-are-and-what-they-believe/). According to Pew Research, their growth has leveled off. Far more troubling to me than any statistical group is the declining authority of the church (or any religious institution), as well as the lack of biblical literacy. Since I’m not a pastor this issue is not as existential for me, but I think it proves my point about C.S. Lewis’s predictions. The church in his day had a much greater influence on life and culture. If you will allow a blunt metaphor, church now is “opt in,” where it used to be much harder to avoid. Further reading on Nones: https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/09/18/dont-believe-everything-you-read-about-death-religion/ https://www.graphsaboutreligion.com/p/the-first-wave-left-with-conviction
[3] Noble defines two poles of “affirmation” and “resignation” that most of us tend to go between throughout our lives when we try to live out our culture’s ideal of the self. His diagnosis of our culture is much more thorough and precise than mine, you should go read it! You should also read his Substack.
[4] What the church offers ideally is not an ideal community, but a connection to a tradition and to other people that recognize their own brokenness, and who strive to follow the Way of Jesus by depending on God’s grace. “We are called to be an incarnate community in a world of digital avatars, a household of healing amid a culture of division and anger, and a surrogate family where a generation of spiritual orphans can find the love of Christian mothers and fathers, sisters and brothers, which ultimately points to the love of God Himself. But at precisely the moment when our society badly needs the church to rediscover the value of being a family, it has scoffed at this simple vision to chase after the dehumanizing values of corporations instead.” Excerpt from What if Jesus was Serious About the Church, by Sky Jethani.
Lewis, C. S. (1955). The abolition of man ; or, reflections on education with special reference to the teaching of English in the upper forms of schools. Macmillan
Noble, A. (2021). You are not your own: Belonging to god in an inhuman world. IVP, An Imprint of InterVarsity Press.
Chow, A. (2023, February 23). Why people are confessing their love for AI chatbots. Time. https://time.com/6257790/ai-chatbots-love/
Malesic, J. (2026, September 24). How I uncovered a prolific AI author in religious magazines. Burnout Culture. Substack.Com. https://jonmalesic.substack.com/p/how-i-uncovered-a-prolific-ai-author
Mcwhorter, J., & Teaching Company. (2004). The story of human language. Teaching Co.
NPR, & Published February 20, 2025 at 5:50 PM EST. (2025, February 20). Americans are reading fewer books for less time. People want to know why. WHRO. WHRO Public Media. https://www.npr.org/2025/02/20/nx-s1-5298185/americans-are-reading-fewer-books-for-less-time-people-want-to-know-why
Roche, G. (2026). Languages are disappearing, and the problem is political. The Conversation. https://doi.org/10.64628/aa.9muc5qrnu
Burge, R. (2026, July 16). The first wave left with conviction. The second wave just drifted. Graphs about Religion. Substack.Com. https://www.graphsaboutreligion.com/p/the-first-wave-left-with-conviction
Smith, G. A., Tevington, P., Nortey, J., Rotolo, C., Kallo, A., & Alper, B. A. (2024, January 24). Religious ‘nones’ in America: Who they are and what they believe. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/religion/2024/01/24/religious-nones-in-america-who-they-are-and-what-they-believe/