from The happy place

moon shines 85% full with a bright shine through the misty dark blue sky.

The snow has been rainy, and underneath the five centimetres from today, the most treacherous ice lies slippery.

I wrote, last year, half a year ago, I wrote about cognitive dissonance, I wrote that my brain was compelling my worms of wisdom back into their can, hidden somewhere in the brain’s cellar, or some other area, where stuff is put and seldomly used again. A dank and moldy place riddled with spiders and fungi, perhaps.

What I realise today, is that I was facing a type of denial in real time. Even though it was me doing it, still it felt like an external force for my lack of control; maybe an old survival strategy which now only causes more pain, as the realisations come off and on like an old fluorescent light, type of which can be found in a hospital ward.

To be able to name it, to identify this force, to name it, helps my brain combat these reoccurring anxieties and self doubts, like a broken record.

It’s like this book by Patrick Rothfuss, name of the wind, that finding names of things will do something which I think is related to their magic system or somesuch. I haven’t read that book in ages. But names are important:

To be able to say, it’s just denial again, ot helps dispel this invisible power.

I nevere asked for this, but I acknowledge that this mechanism once helped preserve me,

But now it only hurts.

And today I spoke to father, I spoke to my cousin, having spent yesterday by the fire with my neighbours.

It’s true I have so much, so many people in my life, it’s a beautiful thing I think, more precious than any amount of gold.

It didn’t turn out the way I thought it would, but look at me now

In Scent of a Woman (1992), Frank Slade tells Donna:

“No mistakes in the tango, Donna. Not like life. It’s simple. That’s what makes the tango so great. If you make a mistake, get all tangled up, just tango on.”

It’s a great quote from a great movie (I love that one), and it applies very much I think to this text or my life,

The point is to keep dancing

 
Read more... Discuss...

from Theo Chevêche

Les grandes voyageuses

C'est par un mardi brumeux que je vis les grandes voyageuses. Je marchais dans la ville que novembre avait rendu grise, avec de lourds nuages tombés à terre et le bitume luisant des restes d'une pluie nocturne. Lassement, je m'en allais commettre mon devoir et suivre une journée de formation à un insipide concept managérial.

Je ne regardais rien autour de moi, ne songeant qu'aux prochaines heures qui m'attendaient, quand un bruit me fit relever la tête. Le sommet des immeubles disparaissait dans le ciel. Je cherchai, tendant l'oreille. Le bruit se répéta. C'était un bruit de trompette, caractéristique, inégalable.

Soudain, elles apparurent. Elles étaient quatre, battant lentement leurs ailes immenses, tendant leur long cou, continuant de pousser leur joyeux cri de trompette. Elles volaient en rond au-dessus de la ville, mes grandes voyageuses, les grues. Et je m'arrêtai, les yeux levés, ne voulant perdre un instant de leur ronde.

Mes grandes voyageuses n'avaient que faire du bitume et des insipides concepts managériaux — elles avaient traversé les prairies et les mers, du Grand Nord jusqu'à cette ville. Peut-être avaient-elles vu, il y a quelques jours à peine, les Pays-Bas ou le Lac du Der, et peut-être verraient-elles bientôt des estuaires, peut-être survoleraient-elles des montagnes, ignorant les frontières et tout ce qui nous retient sur notre bout de terre.

Elles firent quelques tours et puis se dirigèrent vers le sud-ouest. Je les suivis du regard jusqu'à ce qu'elles disparaissent de ma vue, mais je continuai de les entendre quelques temps encore. Et je rejoignis mon devoir, le cœur léger, la tête dans les nuages, avec les grues.

#aveclesoiseaux #instantssimples #automne

 
Lire la suite...

from rodrigue-alcazar

It starts as we approach. The bay from the sky, with the wall, the chimneys, the river splitting it in two, the eye. The green planes parked at the gates. The airport corridors I passed through so many times. People's accents. And then the ride into town on the bus. I look through the window like a child, getting excited by places I recognise. Along the river, into the city centre. Everywhere are memories. Streets, buildings, shops, pubs. So many pubs. The infinite ceiling of clouds rolling through countless variations of grey. Forgotten sounds that resonate naturally: the bell from the tram, the clattering of buses zipping by, the beeping from the traffic lights. And the seagulls, calling out as they strut down the quays — a song I had missed.

I analyse everything around me: is this new? Has this changed? How can this still exist? And I flinch when, turning a corner, I find an old institution of mine missing.

It's fitting that my first stop is where everything pretty much started: my English school. I then wander through the old playground. There is a feeling of joy and excitement. These are streets I used to navigate with closed eyes. Back then I knew their shape, their traps and shortcuts, their colours, their smells. I knew how to glide through their flow. Each had its role in the mechanics of my meanderings. Some had history. Most led to a pub.

It's all coming back. Yet I feel oddly awkward. As if I had forgotten my old ways, how to behave like a local, how to inhabit the place naturally. I am an onlooker wandering through a set, unsure if I'm doing it right.

Across several days I roam the different scenes of my past. Incessantly I look around. Through the city I see my old self. I relearn familiar names; get reacquainted with favourite places. They bring back forgotten feelings — the soothing solemnity of a park. I am constantly reminded of adventures and friends. Of lost love. And of the mundane as I retrace past habits, follow paths I had grown tired of treading. I move through two cities at the same time, the past projecting itself over the present.

There is no longing for times gone by. I am simply happy to be back in this familiar place. A place I used to call home. I am starting to feel less of a stranger, comfortable again. Yet it isn't home anymore... And it doesn't have to be. I am glad I came by. Glad for the fond gift I am offered. It feels like meeting a dear friend I have not seen in a while. Happy to see each other and catch up.

Speaking of which, time for a pint.

 
Read more...

from 💚

Our Father Who art in Heaven Hallowed be Thy name Thy Kingdom come Thy will be done on Earth as it is in Heaven Give us this day our daily Bread And forgive us our trespasses As we forgive those who trespass against us And lead us not into temptation But deliver us from evil

Amen

Jesus is Lord! Come Lord Jesus!

Come Lord Jesus! Christ is Lord!

 
Read more...

from 💚

Hibernia

Bless this day Thoughts of tin and thanking Water Repose of glory and to the Lord Peace to all people,- and liberally Accusing rain- of washing my dishes Set to unfree- in this glory to her,- my thundering tomorrow- and justice of heart To the prairie mews,- all at once A place for every day of the week A welcome home,- to feldspar by name The Royal Thanksgiver- to English by then Upon this Winter blanket,- signs of upheaval To the dayfore and log As a distant cousin In early Country,- obsessing with morning And every wish as a proper prayer That all may get well- by apostasy alone- when prayer is sparse- and dying to come home There is wisdom to thank And God’s upper annoy The thirsty arm, and a tongueful Praying for mercy upon Bocabec And distant to rhyme Wherefore upon death Knowing fold and coal and oil- were the reason.

 
Read more...

from Place Names Canada

“Heart of the Valley.” This 46-page planning study with brilliant red cover was published for the town of Middleton, N.S., in 1969. A copy of the volume was later donated to the University of Toronto’s Roberts Library.

Category: #NovaScotia

 
Read more...

from blog//x2600.cc

Rainfall

Pavillion, CC Park. Returned from fetching hot water for coffee. Coffee made, consuming. Starbucks Espresso Roast procured from WM in a sunrise walk to/from the megamart

Fruit and many other items bought, as well

Poncho dries on the table. I sip and enjoy the patter of rain drops and faint orange glow of sun through the dim, gray clouds

IRC lurking

Home

 
Read more...

from Rippple's Blog

Stay entertained thanks to our Weekly Tracker giving you next week's Anticipated Movies & Shows, Most Watched & Returning Favorites, and Shows Changes & Popular Trailers.

Anticipated Movies

Anticipated Shows

Returing Favorites

Most Watched Movies this Week

Most Watched Shows this Week


Hi, I’m Kevin 👋. Product Manager at Trakt and creator of Rippple. If you’d like to support what I'm building, you can download Rippple for Trakt, explore the open source project, or go Trakt VIP.


 
Read more...

from An Open Letter

I feel like I constantly struggle to follow through with creating things, and I have a graveyard of little projects or ideas that fall short, not too far past the start line. I think it’s kind of daunting when I think about how much effort will actually go into something like this and often by the time I have free time to actually work on them, it’s pretty late and I’m low on motivation.

 
Read more...

from The Final Blog at the End of the World

Is this unoriginal? Not these words, not their being published, but the very act of it, to bring it life, components who hold on desperate and delighted. Contemporary binary switches. Writing. Reading. Leaving comprehension shellshocked and paranoid. Pick up a pen and embarrass yourself. What pitiful horror daunts such that we have no chance with understanding. What life is inherently original? The ever-complex pointing at that which is truly seminal, though now more dictatorial than studious. Whatever you previously held as credence must be overwritten countlessly until it skips and you lack the fundamental cognizance to understand whether the needle or record is at fault. Sterling luck to know only one of them is replaceable.

We pay good money to ask a machine to perform a task we can’t be bothered with.

We pay good money to direct a secretary to perform a task we can’t be bothered with.

We pay good money to have a worker retrieve something from the top shelf.

We pay in the veil of granted autonomy to direct a scribe to feign our literacy, a task we can’t be bothered with.

But you’ve just restated the obvious cycle of needs and solutions! What process in our time as a conscious species hasn’t evolved? You mean to say you weep at the slowly fading dream of the individual?

Something in the air is corroding our ability to reason, our fortune of small accomplishment, our vision, our processing of sound, language. Our contentment. The worries we batten, the fear we worship, and the tongue to it we swear allegiance.

Genuflect.

 
Read more...

from The Morning Patrol with Mastelek💪

Marooned on a Sunday in Douglasdale

It was Sunday & I was still lying in bed. We were not going out to the Loop today. The road between the house in Douglasdale & the Cradle was closed for a cycle race. I don’t do it as I’m usually given a late start & the heat gives me a headache.

eddy was grumpy.

“Moenie worry nie ou boet,” I said. “More is nog ’n dag.”

“Ja, nee,” he replied.

In any case, I had bruised the tendon on the top of my foot & could hardly walk on Monday. It started burning about eight hours after the previous Sunday’s ride. I went on a trip to Slaapstad for a conference & hobbled around, determined to man up. I soldiered on.

Monday was sleepless. Resting my foot elevated on two cushions.

Anyhow.

It is probably good to have an extra week’s rest for that tendon.

“Nothing to get angry about,” said eddy.

“Yes,” I said. “Not worth it. The body will sort itself out. Lots of broccoli.”

“Not potatoes?” asked eddy.

“Potatoes are for comfort. Broccoli is for healing.”

“Humanoids are weird,” eddy said out loud, as if I would not hear. Damn bicycle.

eddy, you know what makes me angry.

“What?”

As a kid, when someone ridiculed me about my coloboma & microphthalmia. Usually saying I was skeel. Afrikaans for squint.

When I heard it I saw red & would punch them. If they were bigger or older than me I’d tell my boet & he would punch them for me. Except he isn’t around anymore.

To this day when it happens I see red. Same reaction.

There are other things that irritate me, eddy. Like when the Boks lose. Vandag is ek sommer die moer in as the Boks lost to Ireland.

And working in technology, nothing is more irritating than someone demanding you help them for no reward just because you know how to do something & they have not bothered to even attempt it.

“What have you tried?” I ask.

“I don’t care,” is the response. “Just tell me how to do it.”

I explain that at one time I also did not know how to do it & figured it out. Maybe they should as well, & only ask once that has failed.

“You are an asshole,” is the usual retort.

Yeah. Now I’m really not going to bother. Tsek.

Anyhow, eddy. I think I’m a rare man.

I once wrote about it. Not the whole thing again, it’s already there if anyone wants it: The Rare Man.

Four in a hundred thousand. Coloboma & microphthalmia. Words most people cannot pronounce, let alone understand. The thing that shaped my face, my vision, the way the world looks at me & the way I look back. The work of holding a gaze when depth is not granted the usual way. The quiet decision to lead with the difference instead of hiding from it.

eddy listened the way he always does, tilted on his stand next to the painting of the Dutch girl, no rush to fill the silence.

Then he gave his verdict.

“You humanoids spend a lot of time measuring yourselves against others. Rare, common, better, worse. Bicycles don’t care how many of you there are. The road doesn’t care. The tendon on top of your foot doesn’t care either. It just does what it does.

You got angry when people called you skeel. Fair enough. Kids are cruel & grown men sometimes stay children. But you still got on the bike. You still went to Slaapstad & walked around on a sore foot. You still put the broccoli on the plate.

That is the only measurement that matters.

The poem is fine. It is true. But do not make the rarity the whole story. Make the living the whole story. The rest is just noise.

And next time someone calls you skeel or demands free technical miracles without trying first, remember the broccoli. Healing takes longer than comfort. You already know which one you choose.”

He was smug in his own wisdom. He just didn’t address the matter around the Boks. I assume Rassie needs some broccoli.

Outside, the road to the Cradle stayed closed for the race. Inside, the house was quiet except for the small sounds of a Sunday that refused to be wasted on anger.

Tomorrow is another day. More is nog ’n dag.

And the body, given half a chance and enough broccoli, usually sorts itself out.

Ronald Bartels | LinkedIn | Instagram

 
Read more...

from Kevin Turby

Rien d’autre n’arrive à suivre si ce temps n’est pas accordé.

Je me rends bien compte que mes priorités aujourd’hui sont mal placées. À l’origine, l’écriture devait être quotidienne. C’était mon pacte, mon engagement vis-à-vis de moi même. Hier, ce pacte, je l’ai encore rompu.

Le problème ? Si je reste terre à terre : il n’y en a pas. Rater une journée d’écriture ne changera probablement pas ma vie, ni la face du monde. Cela n’aura pas un impact sur ma santé, ni sur une quelconque gratification, encore que…

Sauf que ce pacte, il est l’essence de ce que je suis. Je veux écrire. Je veux être cette personne qui respecte sa parole et qui se respecte soi-même. Et ce n’est qu’en écrivant que cette personne existe. Autrement, elle n’est qu’une idée.

Alors, oui, rater une journée d’écriture n’est pas “grave“. Mais écrire chaque jour fait honneur à celui que je veux être profondément. Et pour être honnête, je ne suis pas sûr que quelque chose peut compter davantage que cela. Faire honneur à sa propre personne.

 
Lire la suite... Discuss...

from Blog of Sand

The Blue Monkey Story II- Chapter 12

Pierce left the three strands where they lay. He had spent nearly a minute deciding that this was the proper thing to do, although there was very little dignity in having to make such a decision while kneeling on a concrete floor with an injured ankle and a flashlight whose batteries had begun to occupy an increasing share of his thoughts. He had no evidence envelopes, no forceps, no camera, and no controlled means of recovering the hairs without transferring material from his own clothing or the floor. A piece of folded notebook paper might have held them, provided he could transfer them at all, but the paper had been carried in his jacket through rooms containing dust, moisture, rust, and the debris of his own fall. He could still have collected the strands as a private citizen trying to preserve something important. The difficulty was that he was not a private citizen in the relevant sense. He was a detective who had entered a farmhouse unlawfully, descended through a concealed series of passages without anyone's permission, and arrived at a place whose existence he could not presently demonstrate to another human being. There was no chain of custody to preserve. A laboratory could perhaps compare whatever he brought back with the specimens collected beside John Smith's motorcycle, but a result would be difficult to interpret even if the material survived the journey. He wanted it to be the same animal. He wanted, more particularly, an identifiable relation between the strands on the floor and the scratches that accompanied them. Neither desire entitled him to convert his first impression into a conclusion. He drew a rough plan of the threshold in his notebook, marked the position of the three hairs relative to two of the deeper grooves, and wrote that the material was blue and hairlike, apparently consistent in color with the specimens described by Dr. Mercer. That wording displeased him for its excessive caution, which made him trust it a little more.

He rose slowly, waiting for the soreness in his knees to settle, and looked again at the gray door. It was an ordinary industrial door so far as he could tell, perhaps a little heavier than those on the storage closets, with a steel frame and a handle that returned to its horizontal position when he touched it. He had an unreasonable urge to ask permission before proceeding. The sensation was not the same as guilt over breaking into the Dobbins residence. It was more like the hesitation a person might feel before opening the door of a meeting room in which serious business was already under way. He listened with his ear several inches from the metal, careful not to put his face directly against a surface that might be contaminated by something he had not observed. He heard nothing, not even the low hum of the fluorescent fixtures in the corridor behind him. There was a narrow space beneath the door through which no light appeared. He pressed the handle down. The latch withdrew without difficulty, and the door opened inward onto a room illuminated by a dim red light.

The smell reached him before the objects on the floor resolved themselves into forms he recognized. It was not the overwhelming stench he associated with a fresh decomposing body in a confined room. He had encountered that smell often enough to know the peculiar way it seemed to enter the mouth as well as the nose, and to remember how stubbornly it could remain in a person's clothing long after a scene had been cleared. What came from this room was weaker and drier, with an old metallic quality under an odor of spoiled meat. There was also something faintly sweet and stale in the air, and another smell that might have belonged to the cleaning products he had found elsewhere in the building. Pierce stopped in the doorway and held the flashlight motionless. The room was large, perhaps twenty-five feet in width and longer in the other direction, although the red illumination made it difficult to distinguish the back wall. The ceiling was low enough to make the space feel constructed for work rather than display. Along its length hung four fluorescent fixtures fitted with red tubes or red covers; two were dark, one flickered at its far end, and the nearest glowed steadily with a color more characteristic of a photographic darkroom than a utility room. Its light reached the floor in irregular patches and made all dark stains look similar. The floor itself was plain concrete. It was littered with pale fragments, scraps of material that might once have been cloth, and long irregular marks whose direction he could not determine from the doorway. A metal cabinet stood against the right wall, its doors partly open. Against the left was a bench made from thick boards on a steel frame. The center of the room was almost empty of furniture. It was not empty of remains.

He recognized the first bone because its shape presented an unmistakable combination of length, curvature, and a rounded joint surface. It lay a little beyond the nearest light, partly crossed by what appeared to be a strip of dried tissue. He was familiar enough with skeletal remains to recognize a long bone, and he thought it was probably a femur, although he would not have sworn to that identification without being able to examine both ends in decent light. Nearby lay several ribs in a loose, overlapping arrangement. The rib fragments were not attached to an intact thorax. There was a section of pelvis near the bench, or something very like it, and an object with a smooth white arc that he initially took for a piece of broken pipe before his light found the sockets and broken rim of a human skull. A few teeth remained in the upper jaw. The skull lay with its face directed toward the wall, as if someone had set it there to look at the concrete. Pierce had been about to step fully into the room when he saw it. He stayed where he was, shifted the flashlight to the floor directly ahead, and examined the space available for a path that would not carry him through the central debris.

He had not expected this. Since entering the basement he had been able to describe his surroundings in the vocabulary of disuse, abandonment, storage, and eccentric construction. The pillow room had been peculiar but not threatening in any obvious human sense. The laundry, wine cellar, and flooded chamber had implied money, labor, and an old institutional purpose that could have been entirely innocent. The scratches and blue hair at the last door had brought back the Smith investigation without resolving it. This room offered a much more immediate possibility: human beings had been injured, killed, dismembered, or disposed of here. It did not matter for the moment whether he could identify the precise crime. He was looking at material that required the attention of a medical examiner, crime-scene technicians, and probably a much larger investigative team than Wescott County could supply. He thought of the calls he would make if someone had discovered a room like this in a barn or an abandoned mill. He would secure the scene, get everyone who was not essential out of it, request assistance, establish the limits of the property to be searched, notify Rowan, and have the prosecutor consider the proper legal authority before any further exploratory work. That procedure was so familiar that for several seconds he experienced it almost as a practical plan. Then he remembered the distance of the corridors behind him, the broken wooden floor, the impossible climb above the pile of pillows, and the concealed machine that hid the only staircase he knew leading to the wine cellar. No telephone was visible. He had not heard a human voice since entering the farmhouse. The realization that he had found an apparent homicide scene without any feasible way to report it gave him a harsher feeling of isolation than the discovery of the bones themselves.

He did not immediately enter. He studied the floor from the threshold, turning his flashlight off for several seconds to see what the red fixtures revealed without the distortion of a second light source. The arrangement did not become clearer. The red tubes reduced his ability to judge the color of dried substances and robbed him of some familiar visual distinctions between blood, rust, ordinary dirt, and stains from machinery. He switched the flashlight on again and directed it across the nearest section of floor at a shallow angle. A broad smear extended from the center of the room toward the left wall, where it broke into a number of narrow, overlapping streaks. Beyond it lay another dark area containing a low ridge of particulate debris. Some of the staining had a cracked, flaking surface, and some appeared to have entered the pores of the concrete. His first thought was blood that had dried in several different ways depending on how much had been deposited and whether anyone had moved through it. He wrote 'apparent dried blood' rather than 'blood,' then corrected himself to 'extensive dark reddish-brown staining, possible blood.' He found the need for that distinction irritating. A man could see a room full of bones and an expanse of dark fluid residue without pretending that the most likely explanation was spilled paint. But he had also spent enough years seeing certainty grow out of photographs and impressions to know how damaging it could be when a laboratory later supplied an unexpected answer. His obligation was to state what he had observed and what he had inferred from it, and to keep the two separated as long as possible.

He drew the room's general shape and located the door, bench, cabinet, light fixtures, and largest concentrations of apparent remains. He made no attempt to assign coordinates; his sketch lacked a measured baseline and was useful only as a personal record. He estimated that the door occupied the middle third of the near wall and that the largest cluster of bones lay slightly to the left of the room's center. The skull was farther away, roughly in line with the cabinet. On the right, beyond a patch of relatively clear floor, he could see short strips of fabric and what might be a shoe, its sole facing upward. A darker mass lay against the far wall. He could not determine from the doorway whether it was clothing, tissue, or a discarded piece of industrial padding. He looked for a safe route to the right, where the floor appeared comparatively clear. Even there he noticed small pale fragments that might be bone chips. He marked them mentally, then stepped over the threshold with exaggerated care, placing his shoes only where he could see bare concrete. He knew he was contaminating the scene. He was also standing in the only obvious entrance to a place where there might still be a living person in need of help. He said, 'Sheriff's office. Is anybody here?' His voice sounded unexpectedly ordinary. No one answered. He repeated the call more loudly and listened until the light fixture's faint electric buzz became audible again.

The first thing he examined closely was the skull. He approached from the clear side, crouched, and held the light low enough to illuminate its profile without placing his hand beneath it. He could see the frontal bone, the orbit facing upward at an angle, and the exposed edges of the upper teeth. A dark adherent substance covered part of the rear surface. There were irregular defects at one edge that might have resulted from trauma, scavenging, deterioration, or damage after death. A section near the jaw was missing, but the lower jaw itself was not nearby. He could not say whether the skull belonged to a male or female or what age the person had been. He knew the popular idea that a detective could read sex, age, and cause of death from a skull within seconds, and had always found it a useful demonstration of how thoroughly television had misrepresented his profession. A forensic anthropologist could make carefully qualified judgments from complete skeletal elements. He was a detective, tired, alone, and examining damaged material under red lights. He could confirm what appeared to be a human skull and little more. He recorded its location relative to the bench and cabinet, the direction it faced, and the conspicuous absence of the lower jaw. He resisted the desire to move it. There were features of its underside that he wanted to inspect, but changing its position would make an already compromised scene harder for someone else to interpret. He photographed it in his imagination, which he knew would not preserve the detail he needed, and wrote two more lines in the notebook.

The ribs lay near another collection of bones, several with substantial pieces of dried tissue still attached. He had expected a particular stage of decomposition to produce a particular odor, but his experience had taught him that temperature, moisture, air movement, and insect access could make the same passage of time look and smell quite different. He had seen remains in a heated apartment after a few days and remains outdoors after several weeks; they might as well have belonged to different categories of event. This room seemed comparatively dry. There were no obvious flies, and the smell, though nauseating, was not strong enough to drive him toward the door. The soft tissue he could see was leathery and dark, with irregular torn edges and no ordinary pattern of cutting. Some of the pale surfaces were smooth and some had rough exposed interiors where the bone appeared to have broken. He believed the remains had been there for some time. Weeks was possible, and perhaps likely from his limited impression, but he could not defend a more precise estimate. Nor could he establish that the bones had been damaged at the time the person died rather than later. He was confronted with evidence that suggested extraordinary violence while denying him the usual means of determining what sort of violence it had been.

He spent several minutes looking for the features that would distinguish one set of remains from several. An intact pelvis, a skull, and a femur could all belong to the same person. Even an unusually large quantity of bone fragments might result from one body if the bones had been broken and redistributed. He began by identifying what he thought were paired elements, left and right where he could, and making rough estimates of size. The difficulty was that he could not confidently distinguish a human long bone from certain animal bones when its ends were missing, and the red illumination made differences in weathering and surface condition harder to see. He found what appeared to be two substantial femoral shafts in the central cluster and another length of similar diameter near the far wall, but he would not assume that the third was a different person's femur. A fourth shaft lay partly beneath a mat of dried tissue, and he could see only one end. He counted several vertebrae without any visible anatomical connection between them. A forearm bone lay crossed over a thicker limb bone in a way that suggested movement or deposition rather than a body left intact. The amount of material was plainly more than he had expected from the first skull. It might represent one person severely fragmented, two people, or several. He wrote 'minimum one, possible multiple individuals,' and underlined the last three words once. Then he crossed out the underline. Emphasis would not improve the evidence.

For a moment he thought of Raymond Toliver, whose name had finally been returned to a family after Lenny compared orthopedic hardware from the Bellwether River body with old medical records. Lenny had been careful not to confuse identification with cause of death, and Pierce remembered his colleague's quiet satisfaction at being able to telephone a daughter who had spent years not knowing what had become of her father. There was nothing satisfying here. Even if he could return to the surface with a complete description of the scene, the remains might require months of examination before anyone knew whom they represented. If he could not return, he had found them only to become another person whom others would search for. He imagined Lenny being told that a second missing-person investigation was now necessary, and found the thought offensive in a way that embarrassed him. His embarrassment did not arise principally from the inconvenience to the department. It arose from having made himself the subject of a process he had so often regarded as the work of other people's poor decisions. A missing man was not an abstraction to the officers who had to follow his last known movements, and the persons who loved him could not be instructed to care less because he had brought the disappearance upon himself.

At the far side he examined the object resembling a shoe. It was a boot, or the remainder of one, with a thick black sole and a torn upper. There was no visible manufacturer's mark on the exposed side, and a layer of dark material had adhered to the heel. He did not pick it up to inspect for a size. Beside it lay a portion of coarse dark cloth that might once have been part of a trouser leg. The material had no visible seam of the sort that would readily identify its shape. A length of thin white cord was tangled in it. He could not determine whether the cord had been attached to the garment or merely thrown down nearby. He moved the beam over the cabinet, which held several shallow trays, two rusted clamps, a torn cloth sack, and an empty glass jar. The jar was free of its lid and lying on its side. The trays were covered in a mixture of dust and small dark spots. There were no names, tags, examination records, specimen numbers, or markings to suggest that the room had been used as a hospital, laboratory, or official mortuary. The objects were too generic to establish a purpose. Even the fact that human remains lay on the floor did not prove they had died there. A place of disposal could look much like a place where violent dismemberment had occurred, especially after extensive disturbance. He looked at the walls for impacts, splashes, damaged plaster, or a pattern of stains that might help distinguish those possibilities. At two places dark spots reached nearly shoulder height. Elsewhere there were long arcs that looked as though something had been rubbed against the concrete. Without photographs, testing, and a knowledge of the room's previous uses, he could only catalogue them. He felt himself growing more painstaking as the obvious explanation became more terrible, as if the precision of his notes could keep the implications at a manageable distance.

Along the lower edge of the far wall he found the second concentration of blue hair. Here the material was not restricted to three loose strands. Fine blue fibers lay caught in a crack where the concrete floor met the wall, several embedded in an old dark deposit and others resting in loose dust beyond it. They were irregular in length. He could see that some curved naturally and others had broken ends, but he could not tell whether the differences reflected the animal's coat or the effects of being torn loose. A few strands adhered to the dried tissue on a fragment of bone. That association caused him to stop writing. It was the first arrangement of objects since entering the room that felt to him like a direct continuation of the question which had brought him to the farmhouse. At John Smith's crash scene an unknown animal's blue hair had been collected near a smashed motorcycle and a considerable amount of blood. In this room similar hair lay beside and apparently among human remains. In neither place had he seen the animal from which the material came. The simplest working possibility was that an animal, or something carrying its hair, had been in contact with both scenes. That hypothesis said nothing certain about what it had done. An animal could pass through after a death, and a person could carry hair on clothes, equipment, or shoes. He tried to imagine a particular ordinary animal with a naturally blue coat and could name none. Dr. Mercer had been unable to match the crash specimens to common reference material, although that did not establish that the species was unknown or exotic. There were dyes, contaminants, and lighting effects to consider. The hair in his flashlight beam was blue without any help from the red lamps. He turned the beam off. It became an almost black tangle against the red-lit wall. He turned it on again and forced himself to describe it without using the word 'impossible.'

He was no longer searching for an exit as his immediate priority. He had become temporarily absorbed in the scene, and the absorption alarmed him when he noticed it. A person could die of exposure, dehydration, an untreated injury, or a second fall while carefully examining a question that could not be answered without equipment. He checked his watch. He had spent an astonishing amount of time in the room. There was no guarantee his watch was accurate as to elapsed time since his first fall, but he could still measure the interval since the last entry. He touched the side of his head where the earlier injury had left a tender raised area and wondered again whether the examination was being conducted by a concussed man whose judgment was no longer reliable. He knew some signs of concussion, but his ability to recite them was not a test of his own condition. He could remember his name and address, follow a sequence of thought, write legibly when his hands were steady, and recall what he had observed. None of that meant that he was well enough to continue alone. His thirst had become constant, and the pain in his shoulder and ankle rose sharply whenever he moved without thinking. He had been considering the room as an investigator for so long that he had neglected the room as a place from which he might not be able to escape.

He made a last circuit, as far as the clear portions of the floor permitted, and found no second doorway. There were several shallow recesses along the walls, but each ended in solid concrete. The bench was fixed in place and badly splintered along one edge. The metal cabinet stood on legs that left an open space beneath it, and in that space he found more dust and a single round washer, not an opening. Above the bench a length of electrical conduit ran into a junction box and up to the ceiling. He found no ventilation grille large enough for a person, no telephone, and no indication of a stairwell. The entry door remained his only visible way out. He had begun to move back toward it, rehearsing the route through the storage corridor and over the flooded chamber, when the door shut with a sharp metallic report.

The noise startled him so completely that he turned with his flashlight raised as though he expected to see a person standing behind him. The door was closed. He had left it at an angle of perhaps forty degrees, and he could no longer see the pale strip of corridor beyond it. The red fixtures flickered once, continuing to light the room in the same inadequate manner as before. Pierce waited for another sound. None came. A door on an imperfect hinge could swing shut after standing open for quite a while. A change in air pressure might do the same, particularly where ventilation machinery had been installed. There was no need to assume a person had entered the corridor and closed it deliberately. He approached along the route he had used before, avoided a pale fragment near the center of the floor, and pushed the handle down. It moved a short distance and stopped. He tried again with firmer pressure, then pulled. The door did not open. A latch might have caught in a strike plate, or the handle mechanism might have failed. He examined the frame with the flashlight. The door sat squarely within it. There was no visible chain or bar on his side. He pressed his shoulder against the metal, immediately regretted the pressure on his bruises, and tried a careful pull from the handle while lifting slightly on the edge. Nothing moved. The room remained silent except for the faint electrical noise above him.

He looked toward the bench, thinking of the broken planks and the length of metal he had noticed beside it. He could find a tool, perhaps pry the edge of the door just enough to free its latch, and return to the corridor. It would be another damage he had no right to commit, but that consideration had long since become secondary to the necessity of getting out alive. He walked toward the bench, selecting a reasonably clear path between two concentrations of debris. He had reached the middle of the room when something gave a deep, dull crack beneath the floor.

It was not the sharp snap of the wooden boards in the previous passage. It was a heavy sound, as if a large concealed support had shifted abruptly against another. He felt a vibration through the soles of his shoes and turned back toward the door. A second report followed, closer and longer, accompanied by a grating sound. The floor beneath the far half of the room began to move. For an instant he thought a slab was breaking free and falling into a cavity, and he instinctively bent his knees to keep his balance. Then the movement became continuous. The floor was changing its angle, tilting down toward the far wall. The bones nearest the bench began to slide. The cabinet leaned, struck the wall with a hollow clang, and toppled sideways. Pierce took a step toward the door, but the section of concrete beneath him had already begun to slope. He felt the soles of his shoes lose their purchase as loose dust and dried residue traveled past his ankles. A piece of pale bone slid by his left foot and disappeared into a widening black gap where the floor met the wall. He reached for the bench, caught its edge with his injured hand, and managed for a second to hold his position. The bench shifted with the floor, its steel legs shrieking against the concrete. He let go before it could pull him down beneath it. The angle increased so rapidly that he had no chance to move toward the door. The room's contents went with him. He fell onto his right side, struck the concrete with his hip and elbow, and began to slide. The motion was not initially fast. For a brief interval he could see individual objects passing him: a rib that bounced once and spun ahead, a dark scrap of cloth flattened by the movement of air, the empty glass jar rolling with a small bright sound that seemed absurdly delicate under the grinding of the floor. He dug the heels of his shoes against the concrete and succeeded only in rotating until he was traveling almost feetfirst. The slope continued to increase. By the time it reached anything like the angle he later estimated at sixty degrees, he was no longer able to control his speed. The floor seemed to end at the far wall, but the opening there had widened into the mouth of a descending chute. The concrete beneath him was smoother than the room's original floor. He felt the seam as a short collision against his lower back and then passed through the opening into darkness. The red light vanished behind him. He could hear debris following, striking the sides of the chute in an irregular succession of impacts, and he covered his head with his arms as best he could. Something hard hit the back of his boot. The flashlight struck stone, bounced against his wrist, and almost escaped; he caught it against his jacket with the forearm of his better hand. Then the chute bent to the left, the surface under him changed from smooth concrete to a rougher material, and he was thrown hard against the outer wall of the curve.

He had once attended a demonstration in which a rescue instructor showed how quickly a person could accelerate on a steep roof after losing a foothold. The instructor had used a weighted mannequin, a sloping wooden platform, and a series of measurements that Pierce no longer remembered. He recalled the unmistakable change in the room when the mannequin stopped being an object the instructor could position and became a projectile. It had seemed at first a simple slide, then crossed a point at which no human response could plausibly have interrupted it. The same transition occurred to him in the chute. He knew that trying to stand would only produce a more violent fall. He attempted to keep his legs in front, bend his knees, and protect his face, but every contact with the wall shifted his position. The passage was not straight. At least twice it changed direction, once sending him briefly onto his back and another time turning him sideways so that his shoulder scraped for several yards along a hard surface. He could not estimate his speed. The rush of air at his ears and the increasing frequency with which small pieces of debris struck around him suggested that it was considerable. He was frightened less by the speed itself than by the possibility of arriving at the bottom without any reduction in it. A stone wall, an upright post, or a short drop onto a floor could finish the work the room above had begun.

The end was abrupt but not the sort of collision he had feared. The incline shallowed through a final curve, and he passed from the enclosed chute into a much larger space. He struck a level stone surface on his right hip, slid another several yards, and came to rest against the base of something broad and vertical. The last impact forced the air out of his lungs. He lay on his side with his mouth open, unable for several seconds to draw a full breath, while small objects continued to arrive behind him and scatter over the stone. Something brittle struck the ground near his face and broke with a dry report. A second fragment landed farther away. He closed his eyes and held his head down, resisting the urge to scramble upright. The passage behind him produced two more little cascades of debris, then quieted. Whatever had sent him down it had stopped moving, or at least stopped sending material through the opening. He waited until he could breathe without pain severe enough to make him gasp, then opened his eyes.

His flashlight was still in his hand. Its beam lay across an enormous pale surface interrupted by regular dark lines. For a moment he could not make sense of the pattern. He rolled carefully onto his back and directed the light downward. He was lying on white or near-white stone flags, each roughly rectangular, their edges worn and uneven. The joints between them were comparatively narrow, filled with dark material that might once have been mortar. Some stones were split across their surfaces. Others had shallow hollows at their centers, the sort of wear that developed when many people walked the same route for a very long time. The upright object against which he had stopped was the base of a pillar, immense by the standards of any structure he had personally visited. The lower section was square, its corners chipped and its face divided by shallow horizontal marks. Above his head it gave way to a round shaft that rose into darkness. He followed it with the flashlight until the beam ceased to show anything. Behind him was the opening from which he had emerged: a broad, steep, stone-lined incline entering the hall through a low recess. Pieces of bone and other debris lay scattered across its apron. The skull he had noticed in the room above was not visible among them. He did not look for it immediately.

He lay still long enough to make an inventory of himself. His breathing had returned, though there was a sharp pain under his ribs when he inhaled too deeply. He could move both feet. His already injured ankle had worsened, and his right elbow was abraded through the sleeve. His shoulder felt as though someone had driven it against a doorframe; he remembered the turn in the chute and suspected that was where most of the damage had occurred. He touched the back of his head and found no fresh wetness, although that observation was hardly a complete examination. The fingers he had hurt in the wooden-floor fall remained swollen and painful. He did not know whether he had broken anything. He carefully bent each knee, lifted each leg a little, and moved his arms through the limited range his pain allowed. Nothing seemed immediately useless, which was the most reassuring conclusion he could reach. He had been injured before, both in arrests and in the ordinary accidents of a man who repaired things without much talent for doing so. In his thirties he had fallen from a short ladder while helping Raymond Fletcher paint a porch, and had insisted that the resulting rib pain was merely a bruise until a doctor showed him the fracture on an X-ray. The injury had healed without much trouble, but the memory made him reluctant to identify his present pains as minor. He could walk, perhaps. He could not assume that because he could walk, walking would be wise.

He sat up with his back against the pillar and listened. The first sound he detected was water, or something like water, moving at a great distance. It might also have been air passing through a cavern or a ventilation duct. It had no clear direction. Beneath it was a faint, intermittent crackling sound. He lifted the flashlight and moved its beam around the hall. There were pillars in every direction he could see, not close together but spaced at considerable intervals across the pale floor. Some stood as wide as a small room. Their shafts rose out of the range of his light, and the darkness above them had no visible ceiling. A few were chipped along their lower edges. In one place, at a distance he could not judge confidently, a fallen fragment lay across the flags, and he thought it might have come from the upper portion of a pillar. He could not see an enclosing wall. The illuminated area around him was made to feel small by the repetition of the pillars beyond it; the next row emerged only partly from the dark, and beyond that they became pale vertical suggestions that might have continued indefinitely.

At first he thought the faint crackling came from an electrical short. Then he saw a yellow light between two pillars to his left. He turned toward it and found another farther away, then a third beyond that, each at a slightly different angle from the last. Their brightness was unsteady, and the light they threw onto the stone floor moved in soft patches. He rose partway, bracing his good hand against the base of the pillar, and saw that the lights were flames set in wall-mounted or free-standing holders. Torches, if that word could be used for a flame burning at the top of a rigid metal fixture rather than a stick carried in the hand. The nearest stood perhaps sixty feet away. Farther along, another illuminated patch appeared to the right, and then the next turned left again. The sequence formed a crooked passage through the hall, a series of abrupt changes in direction that bore no apparent relation to the orientation of the pillars. He could not tell whether there were other lights outside the visible succession. The hall was too large and its darkness too complete for him to rule that out. Still, this was plainly a route someone had taken care to illuminate.

He looked back toward the incline before moving. Its surface rose at an angle that made him feel ill merely to remember descending it. It was at least forty feet long within his visible range, and the point at which it disappeared into the wall or ceiling was farther away than the flashlight could reveal. The stone was smooth, with shallow parallel grooves running in the direction of travel. They might have been an intended drainage or traction pattern, although they had done him no good. He approached the bottom carefully, tested the surface with one shoe, and discovered that he could climb the first few feet by leaning forward and using the grooves for purchase. Beyond that the slope steepened. His ankle began to shake under the strain and his injured hand failed to hold against the stone. He retreated before falling. He tried a second time farther to the left, where a narrow seam ran along the side of the ramp. There he managed to get a little higher by wedging his shoe against the edge, but the seam narrowed, his right shoulder protested, and there was no handhold above. The chute's mouth lay out of sight. Even if he climbed several yards, he would eventually have to traverse the steeper portion without ropes or equipment. A fresh fall could disable him altogether. He returned to the flagstones breathing hard and waited for his pulse to settle.

He could imagine a rescue team descending the passage with ropes, harnesses, lights, and an understanding of the structure above. He could imagine a helicopter standing outside the farmhouse, though it would be useless below ground, and uniformed deputies carrying equipment down Farmer's Road. The images came so readily that he caught himself treating them as a possible continuation of his present circumstances. There was no team. He did not know how to contact one, and he could not even specify the route that would bring it to him. If he died here, a search conducted from the farmhouse might never reach this hall. The thought was too large to examine usefully, so he reduced it to a question he could answer: did he have enough strength to walk toward the first light? He did. He made a note of the ramp, its direction relative to the nearest pillar and the visible line of torches, and recorded the condition of his injuries. He left the bones scattered at its base as he had left those in the red room. Their presence was important, but he could not preserve them or reconstruct the scene while trying to find a way out. He turned to the light and began walking.

The first torch was not mounted on a pillar. It stood on a metal bracket fixed into a short block of stone beside the path. The flame burned from a narrow cup at the end of an upright tube, producing a wavering cone of yellow light that reached perhaps fifteen feet across the floor. He smelled burning gas with the faint sooty odor of a poorly adjusted flame. He studied the bracket. The metal had darkened, and rust had collected around the fasteners. A slender pipe ran down the back of the stone block and disappeared between two flags. That pipe might have supplied gas from a larger distribution system; he could not determine its source. There was no visible tank or electrical ignition. He crouched near the base and placed the back of his hand close enough to the metal to feel a little warmth, without touching it. The torch had been burning for at least as long as he had stood in the hall, and there was no sign that it would go out soon. A fixture of this type could burn for days, months, even longer if supplied with gas and maintained. The questions were why anyone had installed such a system in an underground space and who had kept it supplied. He made a sketch of the burner and its connection. The flame was real. It behaved like a flame. That did not make the reasons for its presence any easier to imagine.

He tried to establish the size of the hall by counting the pillars and estimating their spacing. The nearest pair stood more than thirty paces apart, but his stride was shortened by his ankle, and he could no longer use it as a dependable measuring instrument. He could estimate the distance between them from familiar objects: a two-lane roadway could have fit in the space several times over, perhaps with shoulders to spare. Each pillar's base seemed nearly the width of a small garage. The flags beneath them were large enough that the joints made a loose grid of lines across the floor, though the grid did not correspond neatly to the torches' path. He recorded the first three lights as points A, B, and C, with rough bearings relative to the opening behind him. It soon became apparent that without a compass the diagram could only express a local relationship among objects. He had no absolute direction. The stairs, wine cellar, and flooded chamber had involved so many turns that any north he had kept in his head had been lost long before the collapse. His watch could tell him the hour, but the sun was not visible and the ordinary relation between time and direction could not help him. He had once read an account of a surveyor who became disoriented after working in an unfamiliar quarry and had walked almost a complete circle while convinced he was traveling in a straight line. The story had seemed improbable when he read it. He was less inclined to dismiss it now.

At the second torch he found that the line of light turned sharply right, away from what appeared to be the most direct route between the nearest pillars. He considered continuing straight. There was no barrier, no raised curb, and no paint on the floor marking a permitted route. The torchlight merely suggested a path. A straight course might carry him toward an outer wall, a service door, or a less elaborate exit. It might equally carry him into the hall's unlit interior until he could no longer locate the torches behind him. He studied the next visible light, which was already small through the darkness, and asked himself whether following the route amounted to accepting someone else's directions. He had followed directions to this point, though most had consisted of openings rather than deliberate signs: a false washing machine, a door, a passage, a bridge. The jagged sequence of torches was the first feature he had encountered that seemed designed to tell a traveler where to go rather than merely to allow movement. He did not know who the designer was or whether a person who installed the lights intended to lead someone to safety. He followed them anyway, because the alternative was darkness without any superior plan.

The flames gave him little beyond orientation. Between them the floor returned to the gray-white color of his flashlight beam, and the pillars stood as massive shapes without detail. In the pools of light he began to see differences in the stone. Some flags bore narrow scratches resembling the tracks of heavy objects. Others had small circular depressions as though metal feet had stood on them for a long period. One had a patch of polished surface in its middle and rough edges that suggested repeated wear in a confined lane. He could not say whether any of those marks were ancient. Stone could be old and installed recently, and a hard floor could be damaged quickly by machinery. The arches and classical proportions he half expected to see overhead remained hidden. The hall felt ancient because the objects he could see were simple, heavy, and weathered, but antiquity was a judgment made from appearances, not evidence. A modern architect could construct an imitation of a temple or catacomb if given enough money and a reason. He had visited an amusement park with Emily several summers earlier, one that incorporated a faux medieval castle with an underground dining hall, and had watched a maintenance worker replace a loose plastic stone while visitors photographed the crenellations above him. The deception had been harmless and deliberate. He wondered what sort of enterprise would build the present hall to achieve an impression of age, and why it would place the installation beneath a farm rather than use it openly as a place people could visit.

He stopped to look at the first of the shadows he could not account for. It appeared several pillars to his left, a black movement crossing a darker background at the edge of his vision. When he turned the flashlight toward it, the surfaces remained still. A narrow vertical patch between two columns, which he had taken for a human outline, resolved into the edge of another pillar farther away. He could not establish that anything had moved. He had spent too long in uneven light, and his eyes were tired. A flickering flame could make stationary shapes appear to shift, especially outside the center of vision, where the eye was more sensitive to movement than fine detail. He explained this to himself as he would have explained it to a nervous witness. The explanation was sound, and for several minutes he felt better. Then he became aware of another apparent movement behind him, a little farther from the path, and turned so quickly that his ankle nearly gave way. This time he saw only a cloud of soot passing through the upper portion of a torch's light. He watched it rise, break apart, and disappear above the range of his flashlight. It was not difficult to understand why a man might become frightened in the hall. It was more difficult to guarantee that the fear would not interfere with his observations.

As he went farther, he called out again. His first 'Hello?' traveled away between the pillars and came back in several distinct echoes. One was quick and relatively weak. A second followed after a noticeable interval, and a third arrived so faintly that he could not tell whether it was another reflection of the same sound or a separate noise deeper in the building. He waited, then shouted, 'Sheriff's office. If anyone can hear me, answer.' The echoes scattered the phrase until its syllables overlapped. The last fragments returned long after his own voice had stopped. He had no experience estimating the dimensions of a space from echoes without instruments, but he knew a few relevant principles: reflection depended on the surfaces' hardness, size, and orientation, and a long reverberation could occur in an irregular volume without any one wall being exceptionally distant. Still, some surfaces must be very far away, or the sound was reaching them by complex paths. He could imagine the room extending for hundreds of yards. Miles was possible in the abstract, although he did not trust the impression enough to put it in his notes. He had spent most of his career in Wescott County, where a building's largest room was usually a gymnasium, warehouse, church sanctuary, or school auditorium. There were quarries, caves, and tunnels in the wider region, but nothing he knew of with a worked stone floor and repeated pillars arranged on such a scale. He was no longer certain that he was beneath Wescott County in any useful geographical sense. He was certain only that he had reached the hall by falling through the floor of a room which he had reached by entering Samuel Dobbins's farmhouse.

He took a rest beside the fifth torch and made himself sit rather than merely stand bent forward. His heart was beating faster than it should have for the distance he had walked, and his leg muscles trembled when he lowered himself to the floor. He was thirsty enough to feel the inside of his mouth stick when he swallowed. He thought about the communal showers and the clear water he had refused to drink. His caution had been reasonable at the time. He had been able to imagine obtaining safer water elsewhere. The idea now seemed optimistic, but it did not follow that he had been wrong to decline it. A man could make a sound decision with the information available and later regret the outcome. He had told witnesses and defendants much the same thing when they tried to explain decisions that had led to disaster, although in their cases he had often suspected that the explanation was an afterthought. His entry into the farmhouse could not be redeemed so easily. He had recognized the risk and ignored it. He had injured himself and found evidence of possible violent deaths as a consequence, but discovery did not make the original trespass lawful or prudent. He pictured Rowan reading the report he would someday have to write, if he lived. She would be more interested than he could imagine in the remains and the underground installation. She would also be entirely entitled to remove him from the department. He had once believed that being willing to accept the consequences of a wrong action made the action a little less wrong. He was no longer sure what acceptance was worth to the people who had not been consulted.

The next turn in the lighted route led past a pillar whose base bore a broad dark stain at about waist height. Pierce examined it in the yellow flame and then under his flashlight. It might have been mineral discoloration. There was no evident spatter pattern and no nearby objects with which to connect it. He was now in a place where every stain invited comparison with the room he had left, and he knew the temptation would exhaust him if he indulged it. He looked for features that would suggest a human passage: scuffs on the paving, discarded food wrappers, cigarette ends, clothing fibers, shoe prints in dust. The flags held very little loose dust except at their joints. He found no recognizable footwear impressions and no rubbish. In a recess near one column he noticed a small dark object and went out of his way to inspect it, only to discover a broken piece of the torch support's metal bracket. He had no reason to believe it was important. Nevertheless he wrote it down. The habit of recording inconclusive details had sustained his work through cases whose solutions eventually depended upon something very small. The present case had become so large that the same habit threatened to bury him beneath information.

Once he thought he heard footsteps other than his own. He had stopped beside a torch to adjust the binding of cloth around his injured hand, using a strip torn from an already damaged portion of his shirt. While he worked he heard a soft series of impacts from somewhere to his right, not quite synchronized with the faint crackle of the flame. He held still. The sound stopped. He took two experimental steps on the flags and heard the echoes travel among the pillars. He waited again, then moved back a pace. The echo changed. It was possible that he had heard his own previous footfalls returning after an unusual delay, although the interval seemed too long to him. It was equally possible that a small object had fallen from a height he could not see or that water was dripping onto stone somewhere nearby. He looked toward the unlit area and saw a darkness crossed by several narrow vertical gray bands. Nothing emerged. He called out once more and received no answer that could be distinguished from his voice. He decided he would not conduct an exhaustive search of every apparent movement. He could not. He was injured, hungry, and lost; the dark occupied almost the whole hall. If someone was there and wished to avoid him, the columns provided more than enough concealment. If no one was there, searching for the person would be an exercise in fear rather than investigation. He returned to the lighted route.

The path turned left, then right, then left again. The sequence had no geometrical elegance. Several times it brought him nearer a torch he had previously passed before carrying him away in another direction. He considered whether the flames might be arranged to avoid unstable portions of the floor. That would explain their seemingly wasteful course. He tested the stone at the edges of the lighted area, tapping with the hard heel of his shoe, and found it as solid as the path itself. There could be defects farther away. There could be shafts, cracks, or flooded pits hidden between the pillars. The lighted route might have been established by experience rather than by architectural convenience. Or it might mark a ceremonial or recreational course whose bends had no structural purpose. He could not choose among those possibilities, and he was becoming weary of multiplying them. He noticed that in the notes he had begun to substitute a question mark for entire phrases of uncertainty. 'Fourth turn—why?' 'Torch line—gas?' 'Hall size?' The shorthand would be nearly useless to someone who had not shared the experience. He made himself write a fuller description of the next two turns, then closed the notebook and put it away. He would need his hands free if he fell again.

He had been walking for a period he estimated at well over an hour, including his rests, when he saw a door. At first it looked like a darker rectangle set into the base of a distant pillar, and he passed several steps without attending to it. Then one of the torches illuminated its upper edge, and he recognized a doorframe with a lintel. The pillar was larger than most, so large that its base might have enclosed the ground floor of a modest house. The lighted route led directly toward it. His first reaction was relief so sudden that he almost hurried, followed immediately by suspicion of that relief. A door was not necessarily an exit. He had already learned that a door could lead to a vertical shaft, a flooded chamber, a sealed room containing bones, or another passage farther below. But this one was an interruption in a long landscape of repeated stone. It was a specific place where a human being could have entered or left the hall, and that fact mattered. He forced himself to approach at his injured pace, watching the floor for defects and the dark space between nearby pillars for anyone who might be waiting.

The door was made of thick boards strapped with dark metal. Its surface was worn, but the edges fitted the stone opening closely. A simple metal latch projected at hand height. Above it the pillar carried shallow marks that might once have been letters, though he could not read them under the combined illumination of the torch and flashlight. The doorway was roughly the height of a normal interior door, and the frame's ordinary proportions seemed strangely intimate after the scale of the hall. He examined the hinge pins, the latch, and the threshold. Dust had collected at the base but not evenly; a narrow patch near the hinge was comparatively clean. That suggested recent movement, though recent could mean many things in a place whose condition he could not date. He listened. From within came a faint draft carrying a dry mineral smell and a suggestion of warm metal. There was no conversation. He placed his hand on the latch and raised it. The door opened toward him, slowly, its hinges protesting with a long thin squeal. Beyond it, a spiral staircase descended around a thick central column, and the first few treads were lit by another gas-fed flame. The staircase was narrow, but not particularly primitive. Its steps were cut from pale stone and fitted into the inner and outer walls with joints of surprising regularity. Each tread was slightly wider at the outer end, allowing a person to descend with one hand against the curve of the wall and the other near the central column. There was no rail. The opening through which Pierce had entered formed the top of an enclosed spiral, and beyond the first turn the great hall was no longer visible. He wedged the door open for a moment with a small stone he found near the threshold, wanting to be sure that it would not close automatically behind him. It remained in place when he removed the wedge. He replaced the stone where he had found it and looked down. The nearest torch projected from a recessed fitting in the outer wall. Its metal tube emerged from a small circular opening, bent upward, and ended in a cup from which a yellow-blue flame rose steadily. Behind it ran a narrower line that disappeared into the masonry. The next fitting, visible another half-turn below, had the same arrangement. The flames were not set into loose wooden handles or fed by combustible rags; they were fixed gas burners made to look rather like torches. This was one of those distinctions he had lately begun to value. An impression of antiquity was not an accurate description of a device. Someone had fitted an old-fashioned staircase with a working fuel distribution system, or had constructed both together to give a particular effect. The pipework was so neatly concealed that he could not decide which was more likely.

He stayed at the top while he tested the air. He had smelled gas in the hall, not as a strong leak but as the faint odor that sometimes accompanied an imperfect burner. The natural gas supplied to houses around Briar Glen was odorized, and he had responded to several calls in which people believed a gas leak was responsible for a headache or an unusual smell. Here the air was warm near the flames and otherwise cool. There was no suffocating heaviness, and the flames showed no obvious difficulty burning. That did not guarantee adequate oxygen or safe ventilation, but it suggested at least some circulation. He found a small dark opening above the second torch, about the size of a hand. It might have been a ventilation channel. He could not look far into it. He could hear a faint rush of air when he brought his ear near, and he took that as a modest reassurance rather than proof of safety. He had been navigating underground rooms for so long that he could no longer afford to let every uncertain feature become a reason to remain where he stood. He placed his less injured foot on the first tread, tested its firmness, and started down.

His progress was slow enough to make the staircase an examination of his own condition. Descending required weight on the ankle whenever he shifted his other foot, and after the first dozen steps he was obliged to turn his body slightly so that he could use the outer wall as a support. The rough stone caught the fabric of his jacket. He kept the flashlight pointed down, although the burners made it unnecessary for simple visibility. He counted the steps for the first two complete turns and found thirty-four, then lost count after a painful misstep forced him to stop. He began again at the next full rotation and counted thirty-five. The small discrepancy could have resulted from the starting point, or from a slight change in the steps' arrangement. He was annoyed to be measuring the staircase without knowing what measurement would tell him. A story of thirty-five steps per circuit meant little without the radius and rise, but he could at least estimate that he was descending many feet with each revolution. He had already traveled much deeper after the second floor collapse than he had intended to go in the farmhouse. The staircase would take him deeper still. When he rested against the wall, the flames above and below formed a descending chain whose repetition made it difficult to locate the top. He tried not to think of what it would cost him to climb them again.

He recalled a school field trip he had attended as a boy, when a guide took a class through the old courthouse in Briar Glen and showed them a narrow stair intended for judges and clerks. The guide described it as a private passage, although half the students found its location obvious and spent the rest of the tour trying to catch the judge using it. Pierce had been more interested in the building's records room. He remembered long shelves of bound volumes, some so heavy that two children were invited to lift one together. He had asked the guide whether a person who destroyed a book could make an old law stop existing. The guide, amused, had told him that a law did not live in its paper, which was both true and insufficient. Pierce had thought about the answer for days. Now he had filled much of a notebook with facts that could be lost in a single accident. The bones in the red room existed whether he recorded them or not. The court would need a way to establish that existence and its significance, but the room did not depend on a court to be real. He found the distinction oddly useful. He had begun to worry so much about the ability to prove what he had seen that he sometimes forgot he was seeing it.

After a number of revolutions he ceased estimating his depth and concentrated on the steps. He was aware of an intermittent draft rising past him. It brought a damp, stale smell from below, unlike the dry mineral air of the hall. A few of the treads bore black deposits near their outer edges, as if old torch soot had settled there, and two were chipped badly enough that he had to place his foot toward the center. His shoes made a hollow note in some places and a sharper one in others. He could imagine the stairwell as part of a subterranean service network for a large institution, perhaps a mining complex or a government facility whose plans had never been made public. It was a hypothesis that had grown more attractive precisely because it could accommodate almost anything. A hidden facility could have laundries, mess halls, wine storage, utility tunnels, and a monumental chamber if its builders were wealthy or eccentric enough. It could even have rooms in which people had died. Yet an explanation capable of accommodating every fact without predicting anything was not a very useful explanation. He could not say what an ordinary underground facility would contain that this one did not, or why the possible existence of secret owners told him where he should turn next. He wished for a single readable sign, a dated inspection tag, a crate bearing an address, anything to anchor the complex to an actual history.

The staircase ended with no warning beyond a gradual widening of the last few treads. Pierce came around the final turn and found a short landing with a flat stone floor and a door made of dark metal. The air was cooler, and water could now be heard distinctly on the other side, though not as a rushing flow. He stopped before the door because the floor was littered with objects that his exhausted eyes initially refused to organize. There were pale fragments near the wall, some rounded and some long, and a dark mass beneath the lowest torch. He held the light closer and felt the familiar tightening in his stomach. It was another collection of bones, with scraps of dried tissue attached to several pieces and dark staining on the stone. The remains were less extensive than those above. A portion of an arm lay near the wall, or what he thought was an arm, and an irregular cluster of ribs rested partly within a recessed drain. There was something that might have been a vertebra embedded in a strip of stiff cloth. Near the base of the torch lay a narrow piece of shoe leather. Once again he could see blue strands caught among the debris. A few adhered to the torn material, and a thicker tuft lay against the rough corner of the metal door's frame.

He felt neither the same astonishment nor the same professional urgency that the first room had produced. This change disturbed him more than the remains. He had already seen evidence of violent death; these bones appeared to extend that possibility into a second location, but his body reacted chiefly with weariness. He knew that an experienced officer sometimes failed to display emotion at a scene because he was concentrating on the work. He had never considered an absence of outward response evidence of indifference. In this case there was no work he could use to justify his calm. He could not request assistance or preserve the location. He had an injured ankle, a watch, a flashlight, and a notebook that was becoming harder to hold. He wanted to get through the next door. That desire was understandable; he was nevertheless ashamed that he had to make himself look down at what had been a person or persons rather than simply walking past. He crouched on the relatively clean side of the landing and studied the distribution of the bones. He could not determine whether they had been placed there, fallen from above, or carried by something that subsequently moved away. The staircase seemed too narrow for a large body to have tumbled down without leaving additional marks on the treads, but he had not examined every tread closely enough to rule that out. The remains might have been brought through the door. One long fragment bore a dark transverse line that could have resulted from contact with a hard edge. He recorded the details he could defend and avoided imposing a single narrative on them.

The blue hair presented a stronger continuity with the room above than any geometry he had been able to establish. He could no longer dismiss the first three strands by the storage door as an isolated accidental transfer. Similar material appeared at several locations through which he had moved, including two associated with human remains. This did not prove that John Smith had passed through the lower hall, but it made a connection between the basement and the crash evidence increasingly difficult to treat as coincidence. He remembered Evelyn Markham's account of an animal-like sound around the time of the motorcycle accident. A cry heard in the countryside on a night of confusion could be misidentified; the witness had been candid about that. He remembered Samuel Dobbins's reluctance to discuss the cellar and the cooperative purchase of reinforcing materials on the crash morning. A large animal could damage a farmhouse entrance, and a frightened occupant could conceal an event because of embarrassment, liability, or a desire to avoid a government inspection. In the red room, however, the damage to human remains suggested more than an animal merely passing through. It could be postmortem scavenging. He considered that possibility carefully, because it provided a connection between the hair and bones without requiring the animal to have attacked anyone. The difficulty was that he had no direct evidence of feeding, no known species, and no means of determining whether the bones had been broken before or after death. It was a hypothesis, not an explanation. His mind kept trying to make it do more work than it could.

He examined the metal door. Its handle was cold and slightly rough. There were several shallow scratches at the lower edge of the frame, much like the marks he had seen at the storage-room threshold, but these were interrupted by what looked like old corrosion. The narrow gap beneath it admitted a cool draft. He called out once, more quietly than before, and waited. Water made an intermittent lapping noise from beyond. Nothing answered. He opened the door inward and found that the landing gave onto the edge of an underground waterway.

The passage beyond was a tunnel with a low arched roof and walls of roughly worked stone. It was wider than the staircase and long enough that its far end lay beyond the flashlight's useful reach. Water occupied most of the floor, leaving a narrow stone ledge along one side and a smaller broken shelf along the other. The water was dark brown-green under the torchlight, opaque except for a few inches at its edge, where a pale submerged surface could be seen. It did not smell strongly of sewage, but it was brackish in the ordinary descriptive sense: stagnant, mineral, slightly foul, with a saltlike sharpness that came and went as the air shifted. He could see no obvious flow. Tiny ripples reached the stone edge at irregular intervals and faded. Torches were mounted along the walls, their flames appearing at intervals into the distance. Their reflections made broken gold tracks on the water. The tunnel's ceiling showed old mineral deposits, and in places dark streaks descended from joints in the stone. He expected to hear machinery or a pump. He heard only the water's soft movement and the faint crackle of the flames.

An old wooden rowboat was tied to an iron ring near the landing. He did not immediately trust the appearance of it. It was a narrow craft of a type he associated with ponds and small lakes, with pointed ends, three crosswise seats, and a shallow interior made of planks whose paint had worn away in long patches. A pair of oars lay across the central seat. The bow was secured by a thick rope, its fibers dark with damp, and the stern rested close to the wall. The boat moved a little against the stone as he stood watching it, not carried by a discernible current but rocked by minor disturbances in the water. The ring to which it was tied had been fixed into the masonry with two heavy anchors. Pierce examined the rope from the ledge. It was not new, though the most worn portions appeared to have been cut away and its free end secured with an ordinary knot. Someone had maintained it, at least at some point after the original rope was installed. The wooden seats showed narrow pale marks where an object had rubbed against them. He could not tell when the last person had used it. The place looked abandoned, and the boat appeared usable. The two impressions were not mutually exclusive.

He did not like water in a confined tunnel. He had always been a competent swimmer, though not a particularly enthusiastic one, and he had been around enough water recoveries to know how quickly a seemingly shallow, calm surface could hide an obstruction or a depth that no one expected. The Bellwether River case had involved a decomposed body caught against debris in an area where local fishermen often waded without difficulty. Water was seldom uniform. The present channel had no visible shore beyond the narrow ledges, no boat traffic, no markers indicating depth, and no discernible exit within the reach of his light. He could return up the spiral staircase, but the great hall offered no known path to the surface. He could attempt to follow the ledge on foot, although it narrowed after about thirty feet and appeared to end beneath the next torch. The opposite side offered even less room. The boat was not a solution, merely the only available means of continuing. He spent several minutes studying the hull for cracks, missing planks, or signs that it was taking on water. A little moisture pooled in the bottom. When he dipped two fingers into it and smelled them, the odor was the same as that of the tunnel water. The moisture might have entered through a seam, splashed aboard, or condensed from the air. He found no standing depth sufficient to alarm him. He pressed down carefully on each seat, examined the oarlocks, and checked whether both oars were intact. One blade was chipped and one handle wrapped with a narrow strip of cloth. The cloth was worn, not obviously recent. He had found no alternative.

Pierce took off his jacket and shook loose the accumulated grit, not because it needed cleaning but because he wanted the pockets to be accessible. He checked his notebook and pencil, the flashlight, his watch, and the small items he had been carrying since the farmhouse. He had no signal device, no rope of useful length, and no means of making a flotation aid. He put the jacket back on and tied nothing to the boat; he knew that being attached to a sinking craft could be worse than falling free. He loosened the bowline, held the rope while he stepped down onto the nearest seat, and nearly lost his balance when his bad ankle met the moving floor of the hull. He sat quickly. The boat rocked toward the wall, struck it with a hollow knock, and steadied. He placed his weight toward the center and brought the oars into the locks. His father had taught him to row at a summer camp when he was a child, though Pierce remembered the instruction mainly because his father had insisted on correcting the position of his wrists while a storm gathered across the lake. His father had been a careful man whose carefulness sometimes became a means of expressing impatience. 'If you row properly, you'll get there before the rain,' he had said, and then spent so long explaining the proper stroke that they were caught by the first drops before reaching shore. Pierce had not thought of that day for years. The memory returned while he adjusted the oars, and he found himself almost smiling, though there was nothing amusing about the tunnel. He pushed away from the landing with the nearer blade and allowed the boat to drift far enough from the wall to begin rowing.

The channel was still. After three strokes he stopped and watched the way the boat moved. It traveled forward for several seconds, slowed, and eventually appeared to rest almost motionless under the nearest torch. There was no steady pull carrying it downstream or upstream. Small ripples traveled away from the hull and struck the stone walls, returning as weaker reflections that rocked the boat gently. He dipped the right oar, made a short correcting stroke, and turned the bow toward the succession of lights. He did not know whether the tunnel led to a larger body of water, a lock, a reservoir, or a blocked chamber. He knew only that the boat moved when he rowed and stopped when he did not. The effort would be his to supply. He settled into a slow rhythm that spared his shoulder as much as possible, drawing each blade through the water with a measured pull and bringing it forward low enough to avoid the wall. His injured hand did not close easily around the handle. He adjusted his grip, found a position he could tolerate, and began moving away from the landing.

The first writing appeared on the left wall perhaps a hundred yards from the staircase. He noticed it because the color differed so strongly from the stone. A broad band of white spray paint formed the words THE SUN SHALL BE TURNED INTO DARKNESS, and below it, in smaller letters, JOEL 2:31. The letters had been applied with a stencil or a very steady hand. The surface beneath them was rough and damp in places, and the paint had run along several shallow grooves. Pierce knew the phrase from the Bible, though he could not have supplied the chapter and verse without seeing them. He turned the boat slightly toward the left to examine it, then stopped rowing so that the movement would not carry him past too quickly. Beneath the white message was a second inscription in red, almost obliterated by water stains: THE DAY COMES WITHOUT ASKING. It had no citation. A small black arrow pointed forward, though it was impossible to say whether it had been painted at the same time as the words. He wrote down the first inscription exactly and the second as accurately as the faded letters permitted. There was no reason to treat a biblical quotation as a warning addressed to him personally. A person might have painted it here as a religious statement, a piece of graffiti, or part of an elaborate private decoration. The tunnel was strange enough that a conventional meaning for an inscription could not be assumed, but it was not so strange that he could stop distinguishing text from intention.

A little farther on, another passage appeared in yellow paint: AND THE STARS SHALL FALL FROM HEAVEN. Beneath it someone had written MATTHEW 24:29 and drawn a small cross whose lower arm had been extended into a crooked line. The letters were uneven and crowded near the end, as if the painter had misjudged the length of the wall available. Next to the cross, in green, stood an entirely different message: DO NOT BELIEVE THE FIRST MAN WHO TELLS YOU THE TIME. This was followed by a series of short vertical marks that could have been a tally. The green paint looked brighter than the yellow in the torchlight, but the difference could reflect composition rather than age. Pierce had investigated vandalism at rural churches and schools and had observed that paint exposed to weather often faded at different rates even when applied on the same night. Here the tunnel's humidity and lack of sunlight might preserve colors unpredictably. He could not tell whether a series of people had used the walls over decades or one person had arranged the inscriptions to create that impression. The difference mattered if he was trying to understand whether others had traveled the route, but neither hypothesis gave him a basis for deciding which message, if any, deserved attention. The next several inscriptions were spaced too far apart to form a continuous text. At one torch a line of blue lettering, so bright it almost hurt his eyes, declared WHEN THE SUN IS FOLDED UP, with 81:1 written beneath it. On the opposite wall another hand had added WHEN THE STARS FALL AND LOSE THEIR LIGHT. The second line was followed by the words THE QURAN in block letters. Pierce had only a general familiarity with Islamic scripture. He thought the lines might be references to the last judgment, but he did not know whether the English wording was faithful to a particular translation or whether a painter had combined several passages. Beneath the second inscription somebody had written a name that had been crossed through so completely that only the lower ends of a few letters survived. Near the waterline, where the torchlight failed to reach much of the stone, he found a small crescent drawn in green. It could have had religious significance or none at all. He tried to picture the person painting such a design from a boat like his, holding a spray can toward a rough vertical wall that rose above the water. It would be awkward, especially if there were any motion in the channel. A ladder could have been lowered from above, or the water level might once have been much lower. He looked for horizontal marks indicating an earlier level and found a broad discolored band a foot or two above the present surface. The band was interrupted by mineral deposits and might not represent a consistent waterline. Still, it gave him another possible account of the inscriptions' different heights. They need not all have been painted from boats. Some could have been placed here before the channel filled.

He continued past a section where the left wall became smoother and the ceiling lowered enough that he felt obliged to keep his head down, although no part of the arch came close to him. The torch fixtures here were newer-looking than those by the landing. Their pipes had been painted black, and the edges of the mounting plates retained traces of silver-colored metal. One had an additional little tube feeding air to the burner. The installation strengthened his belief that there was active maintenance somewhere within the complex, but did not tell him how recently it had occurred. A pipe could retain its paint for a long time in a protected passage. He imagined a technician making the trip in a small utility boat, checking each flame, clearing soot from the holders, and returning to some unseen service room. It was mundane work, a job that might have seemed as ordinary to its employee as repairing the furnace at the sheriff's office. Yet he could not imagine the work order. He could not imagine the foreman's office, the supply account, the person who approved the cost of gas, or the address to which the bills were sent. The physical apparatus suggested an organization, while the absence of identifying material made that organization impossible to locate in any familiar social world. He realized that for hours he had been looking for a single institution responsible for everything, as though the rooms were parts of one deliberately designed building. They might instead be remnants of several projects connected over time, an accumulation of tunnels and basements as irregular as the histories of the properties above them. But that explanation would ordinarily produce transitions, construction seams, evidence of successive owners, some relationship to the surface. The more passageways he encountered, the less surface there seemed to be.

A long stretch of wall had been painted with a sequence of quotations attributed to sources Pierce recognized only imperfectly. ALL COMPOUNDED THINGS ARE IMPERMANENT appeared beneath the name DHAMMAPADA, its letters white with a narrow black border. Farther on, an orange inscription announced I AM TIME, THE DESTROYER OF WORLDS and identified the BHAGAVAD GITA 11:32. Beneath that somebody had painted a crude round clock with its hands pointing in different directions, one extending well beyond the circle. The clock was crossed by the words NOTHING HAS FINISHED. On the opposite wall, in small careful lettering that looked as though it had been sprayed through a stencil, was MANY WHO SLEEP IN THE DUST OF THE EARTH SHALL AWAKE, followed by DANIEL 12:2. Pierce recognized the last reference as a biblical book, although he could not have said how its interpretation differed among Jewish and Christian traditions. The variety interested him. He had seen apocalyptic verses used at roadside preaching gatherings and in the correspondence of prisoners who thought their trials were signs of a larger catastrophe. He had also seen ancient religious text used simply because its language sounded powerful. These passages did not necessarily indicate a religious community, much less a single theology. The quotations seemed to concern destruction, awakening, and the end of ordinary time, but those themes were broad enough to appeal to many people. A determined writer could find support for almost any private conviction in fragments taken from sacred books. Pierce made a short note identifying the sources as claimed on the walls. He could not verify them where he sat. He had an uncomfortable suspicion that whoever painted the quotations might have expected a traveler to accept the citations as proof.

The water altered the sound of the place. Each oar entered with a soft slap, then made a short dragging noise as Pierce pulled it through. The blades left small eddies, and their disturbances traveled to the walls and returned, giving the boat a slight irregular movement between strokes. He could hear his breathing under the tunnel's high arched ceiling. If he stopped, the sudden absence of the repeated oar sounds made the quiet seem more complete than it really was. There were faint dripping noises and a distant mechanical vibration, sometimes lost beneath the crackle of a torch, sometimes apparently ahead of him. He tried to use those sounds to determine whether the tunnel led toward an occupied area. They provided no dependable direction. A sound transmitted through stone and water could emerge far from its origin. He had learned that during the search for a missing child near an old quarry, when cries reported by volunteers had proved to be voices from a roadway on the other side of a ridge. The child had been found safely in a neighbor's shed, a result Pierce remembered with uncommon gratitude. The volunteers had not been foolish to follow the sounds, but their confidence about direction had been misplaced. He tried to apply the lesson here. The apparent vibration might indicate pumps or generators. It might equally be a pipe carrying sound from machinery much farther away. He could not tell whether it meant he was approaching people, leaving them, or simply crossing under a part of the facility where equipment operated.

At another torch he reached a section of wall covered in painted eyes. Most were simple shapes: two curved lines meeting at pointed ends, with a dark circle in the middle. Some were very large and others smaller than his hand. Their colors varied, and several had been drawn over earlier inscriptions. One eye had been painted with a meticulous iris made from concentric rings of different blues. Directly beneath it stood YOU ARE BEING WATCHED. The phrase was repeated ten or twelve yards farther on in yellow and again in red, though the last repetition lacked the word YOU. Other statements filled the spaces between: THE WALLS HAVE NO BLIND SIDE; TURN AROUND IF YOU WANT TO SEE THE WATCHER; THE WATCHER IS NOT BEHIND YOU; LOOK STRAIGHT AHEAD. One line had been partly erased by a broad stroke of black paint, leaving only the words IS WATCHING. Pierce stopped rowing to study the eye nearest the torch. He searched the stone around it for a circular opening, a concealed lens, or a wire that might indicate a camera. The painting itself followed the wall's irregularities and appeared to cover solid masonry. He found no instrument. The lack of one did not mean there were no observation points elsewhere. The tunnel might contain small apertures hidden in the upper arch or a distant wall. He had not looked for them systematically, and could not do so from the boat. But the painted assertion did not become more credible merely because he was unable to disprove it. He had seen threatening messages written by people who wanted to frighten strangers without possessing any ability to carry out the threat. He had also seen perfectly genuine threats written in a casual hand on common paper. The words alone were insufficient. He turned the boat away from the wall and resumed rowing, conscious that he had looked over his shoulder twice while examining the inscription.

The strain in his shoulder had become substantial. It was no longer the sharp pain of a sudden movement but a deep ache that spread from his upper arm toward his neck after every series of strokes. His injured hand had begun to lose its grip when he pulled too hard. He stopped beside a narrow projection of stone that formed a small shelf above the water and let the boat rest against it. There was no ring or cleat, but he could hold the nearer oar against the wall and keep the bow from wandering. He considered taking off his shoes and soaking his foot in the water, then rejected the idea almost immediately. The ankle needed rest and probably support, not prolonged immersion in an unknown channel. He was cold despite the humidity, and he had begun to shiver when he stopped working. Hunger had ceased to feel like an ordinary desire for a meal and become a diffuse weakness that made every decision slower. He remembered eating breakfast in his apartment before leaving for the farmhouse: toast, an egg, a cup of coffee, and perhaps something else he could no longer recall. He tried to determine how many hours had passed since then. His watch gave him a time, but he had lost enough consciousness or continuity during the falls that the reading no longer translated into a reliable account of his experience. It was possible that he had been underground for less than a day. It was also possible that a considerable interval had escaped his memory. He examined the watch face, as though it might reveal something about its own accuracy. The second hand continued to move, indifferent to his uncertainty.

There had been a period in Pierce's life, after the end of his relationship with Christine, when he occasionally forgot to eat for much of a working day. It had not been a deliberate form of self-punishment, and he would have been irritated by anyone who described it that way. He was simply living alone, spending long hours at the office, and coming home without the ordinary pattern of shared meals that had once made time visible. He sometimes opened a refrigerator containing nothing but mustard, half a carton of milk, and a container of food that had become unidentifiable. Raymond Fletcher had taken to leaving a bag of apples outside his apartment door with a handwritten note explaining that the tree had produced more than one man could use. Pierce knew Fletcher did not have an apple tree. The old man had probably purchased the apples at the market and wished to avoid making the gift look charitable. Pierce had thanked him and never challenged the story. The memory of those apples arrived now with such physical clarity that he could almost feel the crisp skin breaking beneath his teeth. It was a stupid thing to long for in a tunnel that might contain a way out, yet it frightened him that he could think of a piece of fruit more readily than the next turn in the passage. His mind was becoming occupied by needs he could not satisfy. That did not mean he was losing reason. It meant he was a human being who had spent too long trying to live without the necessities of ordinary human life.

He forced himself to examine the boat before departing the shelf. A little more water had collected in the bottom, but not enough to suggest rapid leakage. The oar wrapped with cloth had worn a shallow groove against its lock, and one of the small retaining pieces was loose. He tested it with his fingers and discovered that it would probably remain in place under gentle strokes but might jump free if he pulled too hard. He adjusted his method, keeping the blade lower in the water and avoiding abrupt changes of direction. The correction made his progress slower. He had been trained to think that haste in an investigation produced more work later, but this was not an investigation in which there was anyone waiting to receive the results. His impatience came from physical discomfort, from the absence of a map, and from a feeling he had not yet admitted fully to himself: he was beginning to fear that the underground passages might have no conventional end. Not that they were literally infinite. He did not know anything that justified such a proposition. But a building could have so many connections and dead ends that, for a person with no plan and no information, its practical effect was indistinguishable from endlessness. He could travel until he was unable to continue without ever passing within reach of an exit. The thought made the apparently continuous tunnel ahead almost welcome. At least water forced him to choose one line of movement rather than dozens of branching rooms.

The inscriptions resumed as soon as he passed the next light. On the right wall somebody had written THE SEVENTH DOOR HAS NEVER BEEN OPENED, though Pierce could not tell from what point the doors were supposed to be counted. Beneath it a smaller message declared THIS IS THE FOURTH, with a narrow arrow pointing backward. The same wall carried the words EVERY CORRIDOR ENDS SOMEWHERE in dark green, followed several feet later by EXCEPT THIS ONE in white. He recognized the technique. In adolescent vandalism, contradictory messages were often added by a second person answering the first, sometimes within minutes. The writers might never have intended to create a coherent statement. The difference was that this tunnel did not look like an accessible place where bored children could gather after school. The scale of the paintings, their persistence over a considerable distance, and the expense of reaching the walls suggested a sustained effort. He wondered whether a community of workers once traveled this channel daily, adding jokes and warnings over the years, or whether travelers who came through under circumstances like his had used paint to leave some record of themselves. The second possibility was less likely if the visitors were lost and injured. He had no spray can, and he could not imagine that acquiring one would become a priority. He thought about the lack of names on the signs, in the storage rooms, and on the machinery. No one seemed willing to identify a person or an institution, yet the walls were full of voices. He could not decide whether the anonymity was deliberate or merely a consequence of looking in the wrong places.

One long panel of writing was particularly elaborate. At its upper edge, in gold paint, appeared a sentence Pierce had never heard and could not assign to any scripture: WHEN THE NINTH BELL RINGS, THE DUST SHALL REMEMBER ITS OWNERS. Beneath that, in black, somebody had added NO BELL HAS EVER RUNG HERE. A different hand had written YOU WERE NOT BROUGHT. YOU CAME. Below it a series of small arrows pointed at one another in a rough circle. The paint of the arrows had been applied over parts of the earlier text. Farther down, barely above the water, there was a phrase he could not make out until he brought the boat close enough that the oar scraped the wall. It read COUNT THE PEOPLE WHO ARE NOT IN THE BOAT. He looked away before he had finished writing it. He was alone. He could see the empty forward seat and the wet bottom boards beneath it. The instruction might have been a joke aimed at travelers in boats, or a reference to some previous event, or nothing more than a deliberately disquieting arrangement of words. He knew all of those possibilities. He nevertheless found himself counting the seats, then glancing backward along the tunnel to make sure no one had boarded while he was examining the wall. The boat rocked under the shift of his weight. He waited for it to settle and felt annoyed at himself, more for the wasted movement than for the fear.

There were stretches with no writing at all. In one he passed between walls that narrowed sufficiently to make the channel little wider than the boat's outstretched oars. He brought the blades in and used one as a pole against the masonry, easing the hull forward by short pushes. It took several minutes to negotiate the constriction. The water was almost black beneath him, and the torchlight reached it only as an irregular shimmer. A thin line of pale mineral deposit ran along the wall at about the level of his shoulder. He examined it and found a layer of different-colored stone below, as if the tunnel had been repaired or lined in successive stages. The joint looked old. He wondered whether the narrow section had once been a lock or a place where a gate controlled the passage of water. There were no visible hinges or slots that would accommodate a gate, and he could find no machinery. The passage widened again, and he resumed rowing. The act of solving a modest physical problem gave him a disproportionate sense of competence. He had prevented the oars from striking the walls. He had kept the boat centered. These were tasks whose success he could verify. The messages were not.

At the next group of torches the graffiti grew dense enough that the wall behind it almost disappeared. Paint covered paint, large letters crossed smaller ones, and some words had been deliberately obscured by whole rectangles of color. A passage resembling a Christian hymn began in formal lettering and ended in a row of uneven strokes that could have been an attempt to cancel it. Beside it stood THE EARTH WILL GIVE BACK WHAT IT HAS KEPT, attributed to no source, and then THE DOORS OF MERCY ARE NOT THE DOORS OF RETURN. The latter sounded to Pierce like something a preacher might say, though he had no reason to believe it was religious rather than invented. Lower down somebody had written YOU HAVE BEEN SEEN AT EVERY TURN, followed by NO ONE CAN SEE THROUGH STONE, followed by STONE IS NOT THE PROBLEM. In one place a warning had been painted in a fresh-looking red: IF THE LIGHTS GO OUT, KEEP YOUR HANDS INSIDE THE BOAT. Another hand had answered in black: THEY DO NOT GO OUT FOR YOU. The phrase was ambiguous enough that he read it twice. It could mean the lights remained lit regardless of a visitor's wishes. It could mean something else that the painter had not bothered to explain. A network of old inscriptions did not need to make sense to the traveler who happened upon it. He knew that, but the mounting density of the messages made it harder not to look for a single voice operating beneath them all.

Pierce had always thought himself relatively resistant to suggestion. He did not believe in the evidentiary value of a medium's impressions or a suspect's insistence that the air in a room felt evil. In one investigation, after a burglary had been attributed to a family curse, he had spent a dull afternoon showing the property owner how a loose basement window could be opened from outside. The woman had been embarrassed, and he had regretted his impatient tone more than his insistence on evidence. She had wanted a narrative that explained several unhappy events together, and he had offered her a broken latch. His conclusion had been correct, but it had not answered everything that mattered to her. Here, confronted by anonymous messages in a tunnel he could not locate on a map, he had to resist forming a narrative that would explain all the rooms and all the violence at once. The idea of a person or group watching the passage was plausible. Cameras were common in institutional corridors; concealed observation points were not beyond ordinary engineering. But the paintings were not cameras, and the darkness between flames did not become a watching eye because someone had drawn an eye nearby. A proper investigation would require examination of fixtures, wiring, possible sightlines, and the people who maintained the premises. He could not conduct that investigation while rowing a leaking boat with an injured hand. The only honest conclusion was that the walls contained statements claiming surveillance, and he had neither confirmed nor refuted them.

He passed a panel on which the individual letters had lost their conventional shapes. The upper words were legible: IN THE BEGINNING. Below them the line continued through a succession of almost recognizable terms, some crossed out, until the marks became an arrangement of spirals and vertical slashes. A phrase in blue read THE END IS NOT BELOW YOU, but the last word had been repainted so many times that it seemed to have several endings. Beneath it, in orange, stood THEY ARE COUNTING THE HOURS, and still lower a string of digits had been painted with no separators. Pierce copied the first part of the sequence, realized it was far longer than he could conveniently transcribe, and stopped. He found himself trying to decide whether its length had any mathematical meaning. A serial number? A date with too many figures? A coded message? An example of a person filling space until the paint ran out? He had no basis for choosing, and the thought that he might waste an hour trying to find one made him tired before he had even begun. He closed the notebook. He had written pages of inscriptions. In a normal case such a record would be supplemented by photographs and by other investigators examining the text independently. Here his transcription was a private burden. He could still remember the first words on the wall, but the intervening passages had begun to mix together in his mind. He did not want to discover later that he had attributed a statement to the wrong source or invented a continuity between texts separated by hundreds of yards. He resolved to record only what was unusual enough to matter for navigation or immediate safety.

The tunnel continued. Pierce rowed through patches of light and darkness, past more inscriptions he left unread, and past others that entered his awareness against his will. WATCH THE WATER appeared above an old stain. THE WATCHER HAS HANDS was written in black beneath a blue outline of an arm. YOU ARE NEARLY THERE appeared twice within the same short stretch, followed by YOU HAVE ALWAYS BEEN NEARLY THERE in smaller letters. He could not tell whether he had been moving for half an hour or several hours since his last proper rest. Each torch offered a short unit of progress, each patch of dark water a repetition of the preceding one. His injured shoulder began to respond to the rhythm without conscious supervision, pulling, resting, pulling, as he let his attention settle on the change in the tunnel wall and the sound of the water against the hull. Occasionally he stopped and listened. He heard no other boat. He saw no wake moving toward him. The lighted passage remained empty in both directions. He was grateful for the absence of company and increasingly afraid of it. If there were people here, they might be responsible for the deaths he had seen. If there were none, then he had traveled an extraordinary distance through a maintained underground system without passing another living person, a fact he found no easier to understand.

A draft touched his face. He had grown so accustomed to the close, damp air of the tunnel that the difference was immediately noticeable. It was a little warmer and seemed to carry a faint odor different from stone or water. He stopped rowing, lifted his head, and listened. The tunnel ahead made a gentle turn. Beyond it, the light looked different: steadier and somewhat brighter than the isolated torches. He was tempted to interpret the draft as evidence of an opening or ventilation shaft, but the air might have come from another chamber without any access to the surface. He thought of the narrow mechanical passages in the old county jail, which could carry smells from the kitchen to rooms far away. On one occasion a plumbing leak had filled the evidence storeroom with the odor of boiled cabbage because a ventilation damper had been left in the wrong position. The captain at the time had ordered an inspection of the stored evidence, convinced at first that the smell originated with a seized package. It had taken three days to establish that the air was arriving from a kitchen two floors below. Smell could travel. He could not use it as a map.

The wall turned, and a landing appeared ahead. It was a narrow raised platform of pale stone extending from the right side into the channel. A set of shallow steps emerged from the water and rose to a dry surface perhaps two feet above it. An iron ring had been fixed into the edge, and a short length of rope hung from it. Beyond the landing stood a door made of finely fitted oak. At first Pierce was uncertain about the wood, because torchlight could change the appearance of almost any finished surface, but as he approached he saw the deep, characteristic grain running through broad panels and the darker medullary flecks where the light caught them. The door had not been assembled from rough boards like the one in the pillar. It was carefully made, with a substantial frame, raised panels, and heavy hinges that appeared to have been polished or at least kept free of rust. There was no metal kick plate, no institutional number, and no sign identifying what lay beyond. On either side of the frame stood a torch in a dark metal holder. Their flames were blue.

He brought the boat alongside the landing and held it there while he studied the flames. The gas-fed torches in the tunnel had burned yellow with blue at their bases. These produced a much cleaner, narrower blue light that made the oak look unusually dark and left cold-colored reflections on the water. Their color could result from a different mixture of fuel and air, or from chemical additives, or from the way a hotter flame burned in a carefully adjusted nozzle. He did not know enough about burners to make a more definite judgment. The fixtures themselves were elegant, almost ornamental, unlike the practical brackets in the long hall. They rose from square metal bases fixed to the stone and curved upward in a simple shape that might have belonged in the entrance of an expensive hotel. The blue light illuminated a clean area of paving around the door. There was less dust there than he had seen on the staircase landing, and the oak's lower panels bore faint scratches at the height where shoes or carried objects might strike them. He looked for footprints, found none that he could distinguish, and decided that the scene did not justify a prolonged examination from the boat. The door had a handle. The platform appeared sound. Those were facts of immediate practical importance.

He secured the bow rope to the iron ring, using a knot he could release if he needed the boat again. He considered taking one of the oars with him, but it was awkward to carry and had been useful as a means of movement rather than a weapon. There was no indication that a person with an oar would be better equipped to face whatever lay beyond the door. He left both inside, crossed from the seat to the stone steps with exaggerated care, and waited for the pain in his ankle to settle before standing fully. His legs were stiff from the rowing. He had to put one hand against the doorframe to keep his balance. The oak felt dry, solid, and surprisingly smooth beneath his fingers. He looked back along the passage, where the nearest yellow torches seemed smaller and farther away than he expected. From the platform he could see only the beginning of the channel's last curve. There was no sign of movement in the water. The boat remained where he had tied it, rocking slightly against the step. He thought of the route he had followed since the farmhouse: the first furnace, the tools and storage rooms, the old well, the cages, the tractor, the industrial pipes, the utility tunnel, the mess hall, the communal showers, the collapsed floor, the pillows, the laundry, the concealed stair, the wine cellar, the pool beneath the grating, the storage closets, the blue hair, the bones, the falling floor, the colossal hall, the pillar, the staircase, the further remains, and this long silent waterway. There were places in that sequence he could no longer locate in relation to one another. There were places to which he could never return by the route he had traveled. He did not know whether anyone above had discovered his absence. He did not know whether John Smith was alive, whether the human remains belonged to one person or several, or whether the creature whose hair appeared at so many locations was dangerous, harmless, or even in the vicinity. He knew that a door stood before him and that, for now, he was capable of opening it.

He took a moment to consider the possibility that he was walking directly toward the people who had built and maintained the facility. He no longer had any authority to command their cooperation merely by introducing himself. His identification and his years in law enforcement might impress them or make them hostile; if they had been concealing violent deaths, they might regard his presence as a threat. He was alone, injured, and unfamiliar with the ground. It would be foolish to rush through without listening. He leaned closer to the oak and heard a low, indistinct sound from the other side. It might have been ventilation, the movement of people, or machinery operating at a distance. He could not distinguish words. The handle was cool beneath his palm. He was about to turn it when he thought of Emily sitting at the kitchen table in Christine's house, trying to decide whether her father had disappointed her again or whether something had happened to him. She would not yet know which explanation was correct. He had no means of telling her. For the first time since leaving the room of bones, he felt an almost physical urge to turn around and attempt the journey back, not because he believed it possible but because there was something indecent about continuing to move away from the people who expected him to return. Then he remembered the chute and the impossible climb, the flooded room and the broken boards. Turning around would not bring him home. It would only return him to obstacles he already knew he could not overcome. He drew a careful breath, put his weight on his sound foot, and pressed down the handle.

The latch withdrew with a firm, well-oiled movement. Pierce opened the oak door and stepped through. Before his eyes adjusted to the light beyond, before he had time to examine the floor or the walls or determine whether anyone was there, he smelled food. Not the faint memory of cooking carried through a ventilation duct, but the immediate, rich warmth of something being prepared nearby: browned meat, onions softening in fat, fresh bread, and a sweetness he could not identify. After the damp stone and stale water, after the dry odor of the remains and the metallic air of the halls, it was so delicious that his empty stomach contracted painfully and he stood for a moment without moving.

 
Read more...

from Blog of Sand

FICTIONAL WHAT IF: Part IX- What if Galadriel Was The Antagonist in The War of the Rings? Volume 7

BOOK SEVEN: THE LONG SUMMER From the Making of Yavannia to the Coming of the Grey Ship

Compiled in Avallónë upon Tol Eressëa, from the testimony of those who came West

A Note on This Book

This is the last book of this history, and it is unlike the others. The first six books describe a hundred and fifty years of war. This one describes four and a half thousand years in which, by the reckoning of every annal kept in Middle-earth, almost nothing happened. No kingdom rose or fell. No war was fought. No great deed was done that anyone remembered. The people of Middle-earth call this age the Long Summer, and they call it so with love. The historian has tried to call it so with honesty, which is harder.

The sources for this book are of two kinds, and the reader will notice the difference. For the first part, which covers the long years of the Summer, the historian has relied above all on a body of writings that came West at the very end, in a wooden box, carried by someone no one in the Blessed Realm expected. These writings were made beneath the green hill of Lothlórien, over many centuries, by Pallando the Blue Wizard, wearing the face of Celebrimbor, from what the Queen told him in the forge when she came to visit the one she believed was her Ring-maker. They are the only account we have of the inner life of the Queen in the Summer. They are written in the hand of a prisoner who loved her, a little, against his will, and the reader should remember it.

For the second part, which covers the last year of the Summer and the coming of the grey ship, the historian has relied on the testimony of the one who carried the box. He was a hobbit of the Shire, as the small folk of the vales of Anduin came to be called in the Summer, and he wrote down his own account in Avallónë, in the year after he came West, at the historian's request. The historian has followed it closely, and has kept something of its voice, because it seemed wrong to tell the end of this history in any voice but the voice of someone who lived in the Summer and saw it crack.

PART ONE: THE SUMMER

Chapter I: The Forgetting

The war was forgotten within three generations. The historian does not mean that the people of Middle-earth chose to forget it, or that the Queen forbade them to remember. She did neither. She simply told them what had happened, and they believed her, and in time there was no one left who had seen it except the few who stood at the foot of her throne, and they did not speak.

The heralds of the Queen told the story in every town and city of the Dominion, in the years after the making of Yavannia, and the historian has the words they used, which came West in Pallando's box. The story went like this. In the days before the Summer, the Dark Lord had risen in the East and made war on all the peoples of Middle-earth, and the Elves and Men of the West had been too weak or too proud to stand against him. Then the Lady of the golden wood, who had hunted him through the waste places of the world for a thousand years, went into his own land and took his power from him and broke him, and saved the world. Some rebels, foolish and proud, had refused to accept her peace, and had gone into the Black Land and sworn themselves to the Dark Lord's shadow, and made a last war. She had defeated them on the slopes of the mountain of fire, and bound the shadow in chains, and made the Black Land a forest, and the Summer began. Everything in the story was true. The heralds left out the thorn-groves, and the orcs, and the postern of Eregion, and the reasons the rebels had refused her peace. They did not need to lie. They only needed to leave things out.

The people of Middle-earth did not ask about the things the heralds left out, because they had no reason to. They were fed. They were healed. They did not die. Their grandparents, who had lived through the War of the Weeds, had told them that the rebels had burned the groves along the Lune and brought hunger back into the world, and that was true, and it was enough. By the third century of the Summer, the War of the Weeds was a story told to children, and the rebels in it were villains, and the Queen in it was the heroine. By the tenth century, it was a story told only by the heralds on the great feast-days. By the twentieth, it was not told at all, because no one asked to hear it. The people of Middle-earth knew that there had once been a Dark Lord, and that the Queen had defeated him, and that there had once been rebels, and that she had defeated them too. They did not know their names.

The orcs were forgotten more completely than anything else. By the end of the first thousand years of the Summer, the last thorn-grove in Middle-earth had stood empty for three centuries, because there were no more orcs to feed it, and the Entwives had taken them down. The soil they had made remained, black and rich, and the fields that grew in it remained, and the bread of the Summer was baked from their grain. No one remembered what had made the soil. The historian has the testimony of the hobbit who carried Pallando's box, and he says that in the Shire, in the last years of the Summer, the word orc was used to frighten children, and that most hobbits believed orcs were a kind of goblin from an old story, and that none of them had ever thought about whether orcs had been real. He says that when he read in Pallando's writings what the soil of the Shire was made of, he was sick in the garden behind Bag End, and that afterward he could not eat bread for a month. He says that he does not think the hobbits of the Shire are wicked. The historian does not think so either. He thinks that it is very easy to forget something when everyone around you has forgotten it too.

The ones who remembered were the ones at the foot of the throne. Isildur son of Elendil stood at the Queen's right hand in his white robe with his staff of white wood, the Herald, the Voice of the Queen, and carried her word to every court of Middle-earth for four and a half thousand years, and did not age, and did not speak of his father. Eärien stood behind him and did not speak to him. The Daughters of Varda stood around the throne, seven of them, and grew stiller and brighter every century, until by the end of the Summer they were more like statues of light than women, and moved only when the Queen spoke to them, and the people who came to Yavannia to see the Queen could not look at them at all. And on the lowest step of the throne there knelt a small grey bent figure with red eyes, in chains made of nothing but her will, and it did not move, and it did not speak, and its red eyes never left the Ring on her hand. The people who came to Yavannia called it the Last Servant. They believed it was a kind of statue. Some of them left offerings at its feet, the way people leave offerings at old shrines, without knowing why.

Chapter II: The Shrinking of the Cradles

In the first centuries of the Summer, the loremasters of the Queen's court noticed something they could not explain, and reported it to her, and she told them that it was nothing. Fewer children were being born.

The historian has the figures, from the census of the Dominion, which Pallando copied into his writings from the reports the Queen brought down to the forge. In the first century of the Summer, the peoples of Middle-earth bore children as they always had. In the second century, they bore perhaps four children for every five they had borne in the first. In the fifth century, they bore one for every two. By the tenth century of the Summer, a child born in a town of Eriador was an event, celebrated for a week, and by the twentieth century, there were towns in Eriador where no child had been born in a lifetime, though a lifetime, in the Summer, was very long.

The loremasters of the Queen's court had an explanation, and the Queen accepted it. They said that the peoples of Middle-earth had borne many children in the old days because so many of their children died, and so many of them died young, and that now that no one died, there was no need for many children, and the peoples of Middle-earth knew it, in their bodies, without knowing that they knew it. They said that it was a mercy. They said that if the peoples of Middle-earth had gone on bearing children at the old rate while no one died, the world would have been full within a few centuries, and there would not have been bread enough even in the Summer to feed them all. They said that the Queen's preservation had brought the world into balance.

The historian sets down this explanation because it may be true. He sets down beside it another, which Olórin gave to the loremasters of Avallónë when the census figures came West in Pallando's box. Olórin said that the Queen's power was the power of preservation, the power to hold things as they were, and that it had held the world as it was so completely that nothing new could come into it. He said that a child is the newest thing there is. He said that the world under the Queen was like a garden in which the gardener had pruned every plant so perfectly that none of them would ever set seed. He said that this was what Treebeard had meant when he said that in the Queen's garden, nothing grew that the gardener had not planted. He said that the gardener had not planted children. She had not forbidden them. She simply had not planted them, and nothing in her garden grew unless she did.

The historians of the West have recorded what the Summer was like, in the long middle of it, from the testimony of those who lived through it. It was peaceful. It was very beautiful. Nothing changed. The town of Bree, which had grown into a city in the first years of the Dominion, was the same city in the four thousandth year of the Summer as it had been in the two hundredth, the same streets and the same houses and, for the most part, the same people. The tongues of Men did not drift, as tongues had always drifted in the old days, because no new generation came to change them. A Man of Bree in the last century of the Summer spoke exactly as his grandfather's grandfather had spoken, and his grandfather's grandfather was very often still alive to hear him. No new songs were made, or very few, because the old songs were still sung by the people who had made them. No new kingdoms were founded, because there was nowhere left to found them and no one who wished to. No new tools were invented, because the old tools worked, and there was no hunger or war or plague to drive anyone to invent better ones. The historian has heard Men of the Summer describe it as a long golden afternoon in which no one ever had to go home. He has heard others describe it, more quietly, as a long golden afternoon in which no one could.

The small folk of the vales of Anduin, who had stopped wandering in the first years of the Dominion, crossed the Misty Mountains in the second century of the Summer and settled in the green lands west of the Baranduin, which the Queen gave them as a gift because they had been the first of her peoples to love her. They called it the Shire. They built holes in the green hills with round doors, and planted gardens, and ate the bread of the Summer, and grew plump and contented, and they were the happiest of all the peoples of Middle-earth in the Long Summer. They had always been happiest when they were left alone, and in the Summer they were left alone more completely than any people had ever been. They kept no annals. They did not need to. Nothing happened in the Shire that anyone needed to remember. The hobbit who carried Pallando's box has told the historian that in the last years of the Summer there were hobbits in the Shire who had lived in the same hole for three thousand years, and tended the same garden, and argued with the same neighbors about the same hedge, and that they were perfectly happy, and that he loved them, and that he had never once in his life heard any of them say anything that surprised him.

On Númenor, the Witch-Queen Míriel reigned with the star on her hand for the whole of the Summer, and the island was the richest and most peaceful of all the Queen's realms, and the most silent. The Faithful who had not fled with Elendil had long since forgotten what the Faithful were. The ships of Númenor still sailed, carrying the bread of the Summer to the coasts of Middle-earth, but they did not sail West, toward the Blessed Realm, because no one on Númenor any longer wanted to, because no one on Númenor any longer feared death. In the Dwarf-kingdoms that had knelt to the Queen, the stone kings sat on their thrones in their deep halls, granite to the crown, and ruled their people in voices like grinding rock, and the Dwarves worked the mines and forged the metals as they always had, but they did not delve any deeper. There was nothing deeper they needed. The historian has been told that in the last centuries of the Summer, the deepest mines of Khazad-dûm, below the halls where the Balrog had lain, had been sealed again, and that the Dwarves did not remember why.

Chapter III: The Edges of the Garden

There were places in Middle-earth that the Summer did not reach, and the historian must describe them, because they are where the end of the Summer began.

The first was the Old Forest. The master of the house by the river had told Olórin and Celebrimbor that he would never leave his forest, and he did not. But the forest was not as large at the end of the Summer as it had been at the beginning. The Queen had ordered it left alone after her supper there, and her servants left it alone, but her orchards did not. They grew up to the eaves of the Old Forest and pressed against them, century after century, as the sea presses against a cliff, and the cliff gave way a little at a time. Pallando wrote in the two thousandth year of the Summer that the Old Forest had shrunk to half its size. The hobbit who carried his box told the historian that at the end of the Summer it was perhaps a day's walk across, and that the hobbits of the Shire, whose eastern borders ran beside it, were afraid of it, and told stories about trees that moved and a river that sang, and that most of them had never been inside it. The master of the house still lived there, at the heart of what was left, with the River-daughter. And by the river, the descendants of the orc-children he had taken in during the War of the Weeds still lived too. There were perhaps two hundred of them by the end of the Summer. They fished, and sang the songs he had taught them, and they did not look much like the orcs of the old stories any longer. The historian will say more of them in their place.

The second was Fangorn. The Ents had won the War of the Trees, and the Queen had never sent her hosts into their forest, but the Ents had been dying of grief since the Entwives left them, and the Summer did not heal grief. By the end of the first thousand years of the Summer, most of the Ents had grown treeish, standing silent in the deep forest with their roots in the earth, and did not move again. By the end of the third thousand, there were only three Ents left who still walked. By the end of the Summer there was one. Treebeard walked alone in the forest of Fangorn, the eldest of all living things that walked beneath the sun, and spoke to the trees, and to the treeish Ents who had been his friends, and to no one else. The Entwives, in the Queen's garden, did not come to him. Pallando wrote that the Queen asked Fimbrethil once, in the second thousand years of the Summer, whether she ever thought of going back. Fimbrethil said that she thought of nothing else. The Queen asked her why she did not go. Fimbrethil said that she was afraid that if she went into the wild forest, she would want to stay, and that she did not know any longer whether she was allowed to want anything the Queen had not planted.

The third was the Far North, the cold lands of the Forodwaith, where the Lossoth lived on the ice. Nothing the Queen made would grow there, and she sent them nothing, and they did not know her name. They lived as they had always lived, on the ice, hunting seals and fishing through the holes, and they aged, and died, and bore children, and their children bore children, as they always had. The historian has learned, from Pallando's writings, that the Queen's loremasters reported this to her in the third thousand years of the Summer, as a curiosity: that the Lossoth were the only people in Middle-earth among whom children were still born at the old rate. Pallando wrote that the Queen was silent for a long time when she heard it. Then she asked how many of the Lossoth children died in their first winter. The loremasters told her: one in three. She said that she had made her choice, and that she would make it again. Pallando wrote that she did not sleep that night, and that she came down to the forge at dawn and sat by the anvil without speaking until the sun was high.

And the fourth was the far East, beyond the Red Mountains, beyond the edge of the world the Queen's maps showed, at the place the Elves called Cuiviénen, the Water of Awakening, where the Elves had first woken beneath the stars at the beginning of days. Thranduil had taken the Silvan Elves and the Avari and as many orcs as would come with them out of the Black Land by the eastern way on the night before the end of the war, and he had taken them there. Arondir had gone with him. The Queen knew where they had gone. Míriel, with her far-seeing eyes, could see the light of them, very faint, at the edge of the world. But the Queen did not go after them. Pallando wrote that she said once that Cuiviénen was too far, and that the Avari were too few, and that a garden needs a few weeds at the edges. He wrote that she said it in the same words she had used of the alliance, long before the War of the Weeds. He wrote that he did not think she noticed.

What happened at Cuiviénen in the Long Summer, the historian knows only from a few lines in Pallando's writings and from what Olórin has been able to learn, and it is the strangest thing in this book. The Avari had come west to the war, Morwë had told the High King, for the orcs, who had been Elves of the Avari once, taken in the dark before the first sunrise. When the war was lost, they took the orcs who survived it back with them to the place where the orcs' ancestors had been taken from, the shores of the Water of Awakening. And there, in the long years of the Summer, beneath the same stars the Elves had first seen, the Avari set about trying to undo what Morgoth had done. The historian does not know how. Olórin says that he does not either. He says only that the Avari remembered what the orcs had been, which no one else in Middle-earth remembered, and that memory is a kind of power, and that the Avari had four and a half thousand years to use it. Pallando wrote, in the four thousandth year of the Summer, that Míriel had told the Queen that the light at the edge of the world was growing brighter, and that some of the lights in it, which had been the dim red lights of orcs, were not red any longer. The Queen asked her what color they were. Míriel said she did not know. She said that she had never seen that color before.

Chapter IV: The Unpassed

People still died in the Long Summer. Not many. The bread of the Summer held back age and sickness, and there were no wars, and no famines, and no plagues. But there were accidents. A fall from a roof. A drowning in a river. A horse that threw its rider. Perhaps one in ten thousand of the peoples of Middle-earth died in this way in any century of the Summer, and their families mourned them, and buried them, and were very much astonished, because death had become so rare.

They did not leave.

The historian has hesitated over this chapter more than over any other in this book, because the evidence for it is strange, and the loremasters of Avallónë disagree about what it means. He will set down the evidence and let the reader judge. In the first century of the Summer, the people of Middle-earth began to report that they had seen the dead. Not in dreams. In daylight. A widow of Bree saw her husband, who had fallen from a hayrick, standing at the end of her garden, grey and faint, looking at her. A Dwarf of the kneeling houses saw his brother, who had been crushed in a fall of rock, standing in the deep mines, grey and faint, looking at the walls. A hobbit of the Shire saw her son, who had drowned in the Brandywine, sitting on the bank of the river where he had drowned, grey and faint, looking at the water. They did not speak. They did not move. They did not seem to know that they had been seen. They faded after a while, and were not seen again for a long time, and then were seen again, in the same places, unchanged.

The people of Middle-earth called them the Unpassed. They were not afraid of them, for the most part. The Unpassed did no harm. They were grey and quiet and sad, and they stood where they had died, or where they had loved, and looked at things. In the long years of the Summer, as the accidents went on, one in ten thousand, century after century, there came to be a great many of them. By the end of the Summer, the hobbit who carried Pallando's box told the historian, there was hardly a field in the Shire or a street in Bree without one. The hobbits had grown used to them. They set out little plates of bread for them on feast-days, though the Unpassed never ate. Children played around them.

Olórin had feared this. He had said to the loremasters of Avallónë, long before Pallando's box came West, that the spirits of Men were meant to pass out of the circles of the world when they died, to a place even the Valar did not know, and that the Queen's preservation held Men back from that door. He had said that he did not know what happened to a spirit that was held back from its door for too long. Now he knew. The spirits of the Men who died in the Long Summer could not pass. The world was held too tightly. The Queen had made a garden of it in which nothing changed and nothing left, and the spirits of the dead were caught in it, like leaves in a pool where the stream has stopped. They could not go on to wherever Men went. They could only stand in the places they had loved and look at things, grey and faint and patient, and wait.

The Elves who died in the Summer, and there were a few, went to the Halls of Mandos in the West, as the spirits of the Elves always had. The historian has learned from the loremasters who keep the records of the Halls that they came there in the Summer as they always had, and that they told the Lord of the Halls what they had seen in Middle-earth before they died. And they told him about the Unpassed. Mandos, the historian has been told, said nothing when he heard it. But it is recorded in the Halls that the Doomsman of the Valar, who speaks seldom and never in haste, went from his Halls in the four thousandth year of the Summer to the Ring of Doom, where the Valar sit in council, and asked for the Valar to be summoned. That belongs to its place.

Pallando wrote that the Queen knew about the Unpassed. She had known since the first century of the Summer. She went to see one once, in the first years: a girl of the Southlanders, who had fallen from a cliff in the mountains of Yavannia and stood afterward at the top of the cliff, grey and faint, looking at the sky. Pallando wrote that the Queen stood before her for a long time and that the girl did not see her. He wrote that the Queen tried to speak to her, and that the girl did not hear. He wrote that the Queen tried to make her pass, with the power of the One, and that she could not, because the power of the One was the power that held her. He wrote that the Queen came down to the forge that night and asked him whether he could make a ring that would let the dead go. He wrote that he told her, in Celebrimbor's voice, that he could not, and that if he could, it would let everything go, because everything in her garden was held by the same power. He wrote that she said nothing for a long time, and then she said that the dead were very few, and the living were very many, and that she had made her choice. He wrote that she said this more and more often as the centuries went by, and that he began to understand that she was not saying it to him.

Chapter V: The Throne in Yavannia

What the Queen did in the Long Summer, the historian knows only from Pallando's writings, and the writings are partial, because Pallando saw her only when she came down to the forge beneath the green hill of Lothlórien, and she came less often as the centuries went by.

She ruled. That is the simplest thing to say, and the truest. She sat on her throne in the hall of white stone and living wood on the hill in Yavannia where the Dark Tower had been, and the lords of the Dominion came to her from every corner of Middle-earth and knelt, and she heard them, and gave them her word, and Isildur carried it to every court in the world. She settled every quarrel. She healed every hurt. She watched over every field and every forest and every river, through the far-seeing eyes of Míriel and the other Daughters of Varda, and wherever anything began to wither, she made it grow again. Pallando wrote that in the whole of the Summer, she never once failed to answer a petition, and never once made a judgment that he thought unjust, and never once rested. He wrote that he did not think she could.

She did not change. This is the thing Pallando wrote about more than any other, and the historian has come to believe it was the thing that troubled him most. The Daughters of Varda grew stiller and brighter every century, until they were more like statues of light than women. The stone kings of the Dwarves turned to granite. Isildur, standing at her right hand, grew so grave and silent that the people of Middle-earth half believed he was not a Man at all but a kind of statue, like the Last Servant. But the Queen did not grow stiller, or brighter, or stranger. She remained what she had been on the night she sat alone on her throne and put the Ring back on: tall, and fair, with hair the gold of the Trees and eyes entirely silver, and a smile that was the most beautiful thing Pallando had ever seen, with nothing behind it. He wrote in the first thousand years of the Summer that she was exactly as she had been on the day the hall on the hill was finished. He wrote the same in the two thousandth year, and the three thousandth, and the four thousandth. He wrote that she was the only thing in Middle-earth that the Summer did not touch, because she was the Summer.

She came down to the forge beneath the green hill, in the first centuries, every few years, and sat with the one she believed was her Ring-maker, and talked. Pallando wrote down everything she said. She told him about the war, about the postern of Eregion and the bridge over the Sirannon and the Balrog and the Chambers of Fire, all the things the historian has set down in the books before this one, and Pallando wrote them down in Celebrimbor's careful hand and hid the writings in a box beneath the anvil. She told him about the night she sat alone on her throne with the Ring in her palm. She told him about the Unpassed, and the cradles, and the Lossoth. She asked him, over and over, through the centuries, whether she had been right. He answered her, in Celebrimbor's voice, as he thought Celebrimbor would have answered. He told her that he did not know. Pallando wrote that this was the only answer she ever seemed to want from him, and that he thought it was because no one else in Middle-earth would give it to her. Everyone else told her she was right.

She came less often as the centuries passed. By the third thousand years of the Summer, she came perhaps once a century. By the fourth, she had stopped coming at all. Pallando wrote that the last time she came, in the three thousand eight hundredth year of the Summer, she sat by the anvil for a long time without speaking, and then asked him whether he remembered the night in Eregion when he had put Nenya on her finger. He said, in Celebrimbor's voice, that he did. She asked him what she had looked like. He did not know, because he had not been there. He told her that she had looked young, and sad, and very brave, which was what he believed Celebrimbor would have said. She smiled at him, he wrote, and for the first time in four thousand years there was something behind the smile, for a moment. Then it was gone. She rose and went up the stair, and did not come back.

He wrote that every night of the Summer, wherever she was, she went out under the open sky and looked up at the star of Eärendil. It was the Silmaril, the last of the three jewels of Fëanor that the war of the First Age had been fought over, borne across the sky in the ship of Eärendil the Mariner, Elrond's father, and it was the one light in the world that she could not reach, or grow, or preserve, or hold. He wrote that she looked at it every night for four and a half thousand years. He wrote that he did not know whether she looked at it as a promise or a threat. He did not think she knew either.

He wrote about the Last Servant once. Only once, in the whole of the writings. He wrote that in the two thousand six hundredth year of the Summer, the Queen told him that something had happened in the hall on the hill that had never happened before. The Last Servant had spoken. It had not spoken to her. It had spoken to Isildur, who was standing at the foot of the throne, a few paces from it, as he always stood. It had said three words, very softly, in the common tongue of the West, and then fallen silent again, and it had not spoken since. The Queen told Pallando what the words were. Pallando wrote them down. They were: You were closer. The Queen asked Pallando what he thought the Last Servant meant. Pallando wrote that he told her, in Celebrimbor's voice, that he did not know. He wrote that he knew exactly what it meant. It meant that in the Chambers of Fire, at the end of the war, Isildur's hand had been an arm's length from the One, closer than anyone in the history of the world had ever come to taking it from her, and that the Last Servant remembered, and wanted Isildur to remember too. Pallando wrote that he did not know whether Isildur remembered. He wrote that Isildur had not moved when the Last Servant spoke, or changed his face, or looked down. He wrote that the Queen had watched Isildur very closely for a century afterward, and seen nothing.

Chapter VI: The Ring-Maker's Box

Pallando sat in the forge beneath the green hill for four and a half thousand years, wearing Celebrimbor's face, making rings for the Queen when she asked for them, which was seldom, and writing down everything she told him, which was a great deal. He was alone. The Silvan healers who brought him food did not know what he was. The Queen did not know. He did not speak to anyone except her, and in the last seven centuries of the Summer he did not speak to her, because she did not come. The historian has read his writings, and in the later centuries there are long passages that are about nothing at all: the color of the light on the stair, the sound of the wind in the golden trees overhead, the taste of the honey the healers brought him. The historian has come to believe that he wrote them because there was no one else to tell.

Alatar found him in the three thousand two hundredth year of the Summer. The historian has Pallando's account of it, and it is brief. Alatar had been the Queen's servant since the twentieth year of the Dominion, when he knelt to her on the green hill. He had been her counselor, and her wizard, and had walked at her side in Yavannia for three thousand years. And he had walked beside Pallando in the East for seven hundred years before that, and he had known him as well as one Maia can know another. He came down the stair into the forge one night, alone, and stood before the anvil, and looked at the Ring-maker for a long time. Then he said Pallando's name.

Pallando wrote that he did not answer. He wrote that he went on working at the anvil, in Celebrimbor's face, with Celebrimbor's hands, and did not look up. Alatar stood there for most of the night. Then he said that he had wondered for three thousand years why the Ring-maker had grown so quiet. He said that he had wondered why the Ring-maker never spoke of Eregion, or of Fëanor, or of the Silmarils, which the real Celebrimbor would never have been able to stop speaking of. He said that he had wondered, and that he had not wanted to know. Pallando wrote that he still did not look up. Alatar asked him whether the real Ring-maker had gone West. Pallando did not answer. Alatar asked him whether the Valar knew what had happened in Middle-earth. Pallando did not answer. Alatar said that he had knelt to the Queen because she had done what they had both been sent to do, and that he had believed for three thousand years that he was right. He said that he had begun, in the last few centuries, to see the Unpassed in the fields of Eriador, and to count the cradles, and to wonder. He said that he did not know any longer whether he had been right. And then he said that he would not tell the Queen.

Pallando wrote that he looked up then. He wrote that Alatar was weeping, which he had never seen in four thousand years. He wrote that Alatar said: If you are writing it down, write that I did not tell her. Write that I did one thing. Then he went up the stair, and did not come down again. Pallando wrote it down. The historian has set it down here, as Alatar asked. He does not know what became of Alatar in the last centuries of the Summer, and Pallando's writings do not say.

The box was a problem. Pallando had been writing for three thousand years by then, and the writings filled a chest beneath the anvil, and they were the only true account in the world of what had happened in the Second Age, and they were useless where they were. He needed to get them West. He could not leave the forge, because if he left it, the Queen would know the Ring-maker was gone. He could not give them to the Silvan healers, because they were the Queen's. He could not give them to anyone in the Dominion who would carry them to the Queen. He needed someone she would never think to watch, who could carry a box out of the golden wood and keep it hidden for as long as it took, and who would know, when the time came, what to do with it.

He found a hobbit.

The hobbits of the Shire, in the long years of the Summer, sent gardeners to the golden wood. It was a custom that had begun in the first centuries, when the Queen gave them the Shire, and the hobbits, who had nothing else to give her in return, sent her their best gardeners every hundred years to tend the gardens of Lothlórien for a season. The Gardeners' Tribute, the hobbits called it, and it was a great honor, and every young hobbit of the Shire who had green fingers dreamed of being chosen. In the four thousand one hundredth year of the Summer, one of the gardeners chosen was a young hobbit of a good family, the Bagginses of Bag End under the Hill, named Bilbo. He was, by the standards of the Shire, a very odd young hobbit. He was curious. He asked questions. He liked maps. And in the golden wood, in the season he spent there, he found his way, as no gardener had ever found his way before, down a stair beneath the green hill that no one was supposed to know about, into a forge where an Elf with a ruined face sat at an anvil, working.

Pallando wrote down that meeting too, and it is one of the few passages in the later writings that is happy. He wrote that the young hobbit stood at the bottom of the stair with his mouth open, and that he asked who Pallando was, and that Pallando told him he was a smith, and that the hobbit asked what he was making, and that Pallando, who had not been asked a question by anyone but the Queen in four thousand years, told him. He wrote that the hobbit came back every day for the rest of the season. He wrote that the hobbit asked him about everything: about rings, and about Elves, and about the Queen, and about the old stories of the Dark Lord and the rebels, which the hobbit had heard as a child and did not quite believe. He wrote that he did not tell the hobbit the truth, at first. He wrote that on the last day of the season, the hobbit asked him whether he was happy, and that he told the hobbit that he had been sitting in this forge for four thousand years, alone, waiting, and that the hobbit was the first person in all that time who had asked.

Then he gave Bilbo the box. He did not tell him what was in it. He told him that it was a gift, and that it was very precious, and that he must take it home to the Shire and hide it and never show it to anyone. He told him that one day, perhaps not for a long time, something would change in the Shire, something that had never changed before, and that when it did, he must open the box and read what was in it, and then he would know what to do. Bilbo asked him what kind of change. Pallando told him that he did not know. He told him that he would recognize it.

Bilbo took the box home. He hid it in the deepest room of Bag End, behind a panel in the wall that his father had built and forgotten about, and he did not open it, because he had promised. He did not tell anyone, though he was the kind of hobbit who found it very hard not to tell people things. And he waited. He waited for four hundred and eighty years. He grew from a young hobbit into a middle-aged one, as hobbits did in the Summer, slowly, and then stopped, as everyone stopped in the Summer, and he lived in Bag End and kept his garden and argued with his neighbors and told the young hobbits stories about his season in the golden wood, and about the Elf with the ruined face in the forge beneath the hill, which none of them believed. Nothing changed in the Shire. Nothing ever changed in the Shire. And then, in the four thousand five hundred and eighty-second year of the Summer, two things changed at once.

Chapter VII: The Blessed Realm

Before the historian tells of the last year of the Summer, he must go West, across the Sea, and tell what had been happening in the Blessed Realm while the Summer went on in Middle-earth. It is the part of this history the historian knows best, because he was there for it.

The grey ship came to Tol Eressëa in the spring of the eighteen hundred and sixty-ninth year of the Second Age, the second year of the Summer. It came into the harbor of Avallónë on the evening tide, small and plain, with a Maia standing in the bow with a red ring on a chain around his neck, and an Elf with a ruined face beside him, and behind them a young Man of the mountains and a dozen orcs. The historian was on the quay. He remembers that no one on the quay knew what to do about the orcs. He remembers that the Elves of Avallónë drew back from them, and drew their swords, and that the Maia in the bow said, in a voice that carried across the whole harbor, that these were his companions, and that anyone who drew a sword against them would answer to him. He remembers that the orcs came down the gangway very slowly, blinking in the light of the Blessed Realm, which hurt their eyes, and that one of them, a young one carrying a battered Númenórean shield with a white tree painted on it, looked up at the white towers of Avallónë and said something in the orcish tongue that the historian did not understand. He learned later what it was. It was: So this is where they came from.

Olórin and Celebrimbor went before the Valar in the Ring of Doom, at the Máhanaxar in Valinor, in the summer of that year, and spoke for many days. The historian has used their testimony throughout this history, and he will not repeat it here. He will say only that when they had finished, the Valar were silent for a long time, and then Manwë, the Elder King, spoke. He said that the Valar had heard. He said that the Valar would consider what they had heard. And he said that the Valar would not go to war in Middle-earth. Not yet. Perhaps not ever.

The historian has heard the reasons for that decision given many times in the long years since, in Avallónë and in Valinor, and he will give them as fairly as he can. The Valar had gone to war in Middle-earth once, against Morgoth, at the end of the First Age, and they had won, and Beleriand had sunk beneath the sea, and a whole country with all its peoples and its forests and its rivers had been lost forever. They did not wish to do it again. The Queen was not Morgoth. She was not even Sauron. She had made the peoples of Middle-earth happy, and fed them, and healed them, and the peoples of Middle-earth loved her and did not wish to be saved from her. If the Valar went to war against her, they would be going to war against the peoples of Middle-earth too, who would fight for her, and die for her, and the Valar would have to destroy them to destroy her. And the Valar had made a mistake once, long ago, in the beginning, of deciding what was best for the Children of Ilúvatar and then making it so. They had summoned the Elves into the West, to keep them safe, and in doing so they had sundered the Elves forever. The Queen was making that mistake now. The Valar would not answer her mistake by making it again.

Celebrimbor said, when he heard this, that he understood it. Olórin said that he understood it too. He said that he thought the Valar were right. He said that he thought they would be wrong to wait too long. Ulmo, the Lord of Waters, who had never in all the ages of the world ceased to care for Middle-earth, and who spoke to it still in every river and sea, said that he agreed with Olórin. He said that he could feel the waters of Middle-earth growing still, as the Summer went on, and that it troubled him. Manwë said that the Valar would wait and see.

They waited for four and a half thousand years.

The historian lived through those years in Avallónë, and he spent them, as the reader knows, compiling this history. He gathered the testimony of every Elf who came West from Middle-earth in the Summer, and there were not many, because the Elves who remained in the Dominion did not wish to leave it. He gathered the testimony of Olórin and Celebrimbor, over and over, until he knew it as well as they did. And he gathered the testimony of the orcs. The orcs who came West in the grey ship were given a hall in Avallónë, on the hill above the harbor, because no one knew where else to put them, and they lived there through the whole of the Summer. They did not die. The light of the Blessed Realm hurt their eyes, and they never grew used to it, but they did not die. And they changed, a little, over the long years, as everything in the Blessed Realm changes a little toward what it was meant to be. The historian has watched them change. He does not know what they are changing into. He does not think they do either.

Ushgra, the orc mother who had escaped from a thorn-grove near the ruins of Eregion with one of her three young, had come West, she said, because she wanted to see the land the Elves had come from, and ask them why. She asked. She asked the historian, in the first year she was in Avallónë, why the Elves had let the Queen feed the orcs to her thorns. The historian did not know what to tell her. She asked the loremasters of Avallónë. They did not know either. She asked Olórin, who said that he was sorry. She asked Celebrimbor, who wept. And at last, in the hundredth year of the Summer, she walked from Avallónë to Valinor, alone, which no orc had ever done, and stood before the gates of Valmar, the city of the Valar, and asked to speak to the Elder King. The historian does not know what Manwë told her. She would never say. She came back to Avallónë, and lived in the hall on the hill with the others, and did not ask anyone why again. But she kept her children's names. She had them painted on the wall of the hall, in the orcish script, beside the shield of Hallas: two names, for the two children she had lost in the thorn-grove near the ruins of Eregion. The third child, the one she had saved, had died in the War of the Weeds. She had his name painted there too.

In the four thousandth year of the Summer, Mandos, the Doomsman of the Valar, went from his Halls to the Ring of Doom and asked for the Valar to be summoned. The historian has been told what he said. He said that the spirits of the Elves who died in Middle-earth were telling him of the Unpassed. He said that the spirits of Men were being held in the circles of the world against the will of Ilúvatar, and that this was a thing that had never happened before, not even in the darkest days of Morgoth, and that he did not know what it would lead to. He said that the Valar had decided not to choose for the Children of Ilúvatar. He said that the Queen had chosen for them, and that her choice was now reaching beyond the circles of the world, into the one place the Valar had never been permitted to go. He said that he did not think the Valar could wait any longer.

Manwë asked how much longer the Valar could wait. Mandos said that he did not know. He said that he would know when it was time.

The historian has learned since then that Mandos returned to his Halls, and waited, and that in the four thousand five hundred and eighty-second year of the Summer, he went to Manwë again, and said that it was time. And that on the same day, in the Shire, a hobbit of Bag End died of old age.

PART TWO: THE CRACK

Chapter VIII: The Last Birthday

What follows is told from the account of Frodo Baggins of Bag End, which he wrote down in Avallónë in the year after he came West. The historian has kept as much of his voice as he could.

Frodo Baggins was the youngest hobbit in the Shire. He was the first child born in the Shire in a hundred and twelve years, and his birth had been celebrated for a month, and every hobbit in the Shire had come to see him in his cradle, because none of them had seen a baby in so long. His parents had both died, very strangely, when he was a child, drowned together in a boating accident on the Brandywine, and they were among the Unpassed now, and stood together on the bank of the river where they had drowned, grey and faint, looking at the water. Frodo used to go and sit beside them, when he was young. They never saw him. When he was twelve, his cousin Bilbo, who lived at Bag End and was very old and very odd and had no children of his own, took him in, and raised him, and told him stories about the golden wood, and the Elf with the ruined face in the forge beneath the hill, and Frodo was the only hobbit in the Shire who believed them.

Frodo wrote that he was fifty years old in the four thousand five hundred and eighty-second year of the Summer, and that in the spring of that year, he found a grey hair.

He found it in the mirror in the bathroom at Bag End, on a spring morning, above his left ear. He wrote that he did not know what it was at first. He wrote that he had seen grey hair in the old pictures in Bilbo's study, pictures of hobbits from before the Summer, who had grown old and grey and died, the way people did in the old stories. But he had never seen a grey hair on a living hobbit, because no living hobbit in the Shire had grown old in four and a half thousand years. Hobbits in the Summer grew up, and then stopped, and stayed as they were forever. He wrote that he pulled the grey hair out and looked at it in the light for a long time. He wrote that he found another the next week. And another. By midsummer there was a streak of grey above his left ear that he could not hide, and there were lines at the corners of his eyes that had not been there in the spring, and his knees ached when he climbed the Hill.

He wrote that he was the only one. He went all over the Shire that summer, looking, and he did not find a single other hobbit who was growing old. Not even the hobbits who had been born before him, which was all of them. He wrote that the hobbits of the Shire looked at his grey hair and did not know what it was, and some of them laughed, and some of them were frightened, and a few of the very oldest, who remembered the old days before the Summer, or remembered their grandparents remembering them, went very quiet and would not look at him. He wrote that he told Bilbo, and that Bilbo looked at the grey streak above his ear for a long time, and then went into the deepest room of Bag End and did not come out for the rest of the day.

Bilbo's birthday was in the autumn. He was very old. Frodo wrote that no one in the Shire knew exactly how old, because no one had kept count, but that Bilbo had been chosen for the Gardeners' Tribute in the four thousand one hundredth year of the Summer, when he was a young hobbit, and that he had been well past his youth for more than four centuries since. Every year, on his birthday, he gave a party. Every year, the whole of Hobbiton came, and ate and drank and danced in the field below Bag End, and Bilbo made a speech that no one listened to, and told the story of his season in the golden wood, which everyone had heard. Frodo wrote that the party that year was like every other party. He wrote that he had been to four hundred and eighty of them, and that he could have told you, before it began, exactly who would drink too much, and who would dance with whom, and what Bilbo would say in his speech. He wrote that this was what the Summer was like. He wrote that he had loved it, and that he had not known until that year how tired of it he was.

Bilbo made his speech. He told the story of the golden wood. He told about the stair beneath the green hill, and the Elf with the ruined face, and the box. Frodo wrote that Bilbo had never told about the box before. He wrote that Bilbo looked at him while he told it, all the way across the field, over the heads of the hobbits who were not listening, and that Bilbo said that the Elf had told him that one day something would change in the Shire, something that had never changed before, and that he would recognize it. Bilbo said that he had waited four hundred and eighty years. Bilbo said that he thought it had come. Then he sat down in his chair at the head of the table, under the great tree in the party field, and smiled, and closed his eyes, and the hobbits of Hobbiton went on eating and drinking and dancing, and did not notice for an hour that he was not breathing.

Bilbo Baggins was the first hobbit in the Shire to die of old age in four thousand five hundred and eighty years.

Frodo wrote that he sat beside Bilbo's chair under the great tree in the party field for the rest of the night, after the hobbits had gone home, frightened, and that he held Bilbo's hand, which grew cold. He wrote that he waited. He wrote that he did not know what he was waiting for, until near dawn, when he understood that he was waiting for Bilbo to become one of the Unpassed: to stand up out of his chair, grey and faint, and stand under the great tree in the party field, looking at things, forever, as Frodo's parents stood on the bank of the Brandywine. He wrote that dawn came, and Bilbo did not stand up. He wrote that the chair was empty except for Bilbo's body, and that there was nothing grey and faint anywhere in the field, and that he understood, as the sun came up over the Hill, that Bilbo had gone. Not to stand in the field. Not to wait. He had gone wherever Men and hobbits had gone in the days before the Summer, beyond the circles of the world, through the door that had been held shut for four and a half thousand years. Something had let him through.

Frodo wrote that he wept for a long time. He wrote that he did not know whether he was weeping because Bilbo was dead, or because Bilbo was free.

Chapter IX: The Herald in the Shire

The news of Bilbo's death went out of the Shire within a day, and reached Yavannia within a week, because nothing like it had happened in Middle-earth in four and a half thousand years, and because Míriel, the first of the Daughters of Varda, with her far-seeing eyes, had seen a light go out in the Shire that should not have gone out, and had told her mistress.

The Queen sent her Herald. Frodo wrote that he did not know, at the time, that the Herald was anyone in particular. He knew him only as the hobbits of the Shire knew him, and as the people of Middle-earth had known him for four and a half thousand years: the Herald, the Voice of the Queen, the grave and silent Man in white with the staff of white wood, who came to the courts of the world on the great feast-days and spoke the Queen's word, and went away again. The Herald had come to the Shire perhaps a dozen times in the whole of the Summer. Every hobbit knew his face from the pictures. Frodo wrote that when the Herald came up the lane to Bag End, on a grey morning in the autumn, nine days after Bilbo died, alone, on foot, with his staff in his hand and his white robe muddy at the hem, every hobbit in Hobbiton came out of their holes to stare.

The Herald came to the door of Bag End and knocked. Frodo opened it. He wrote that the Herald was very tall, as Men of Númenor were tall, and that his face was the face of a Man of perhaps forty years, grave and still, and that his eyes were the oldest eyes Frodo had ever seen. He wrote that the Herald looked down at him, and at the grey streak above his left ear, for a long time, without speaking. Then the Herald said that the Queen had sent him to learn how the hobbit Bilbo Baggins had died, and what had become of his spirit, and whether there was anything in the Shire that the Queen should know.

Frodo let him in. He wrote that he did not know what else to do. He gave the Herald tea, in the parlor of Bag End, and told him how Bilbo had died, at his party, in his chair, smiling, and how he had not become one of the Unpassed, and how Frodo had sat beside him all night and watched him go. He did not tell the Herald about the box. He wrote that he had not opened the box yet. He had found it, in the deepest room of Bag End, behind the panel in the wall, the morning after Bilbo died, where Bilbo had left it with a note on top in his spidery hand, which said only: For Frodo. It has changed. He had not opened it. He had been too frightened. He wrote that it was sitting at that moment on the table in Bilbo's study, at the end of the hall, behind a closed door, and that he was certain the Herald would know it was there, and that he could not stop himself from glancing at the door.

The Herald listened to everything. Then he asked to see Frodo's hands. Frodo held them out. The Herald took them in his own, which were very cold, and turned them over, and looked at the lines on the backs of them, which had not been there in the spring. He asked Frodo how old he was. Frodo told him: fifty. The Herald asked him when he had first noticed. Frodo told him: in the spring, a grey hair. The Herald was silent for a long time, holding Frodo's hands. Then he said a thing that Frodo did not understand at the time, and that he has since written down exactly, at the historian's request. The Herald said: My father would have been glad.

Frodo asked him who his father was. The Herald did not answer. He let go of Frodo's hands and stood up and went to the window of the parlor and looked out at the garden of Bag End, where the leaves were falling from the trees, which they had not done in the Shire in four and a half thousand years. Frodo had not noticed until that moment. The leaves were falling. The Herald watched them fall for a long time. Then he turned and looked down the hall, at the closed door of Bilbo's study, where the box was. Frodo wrote that his heart stopped. He wrote that the Herald looked at the door for perhaps a minute, and that his face did not change at all. Then the Herald looked back at Frodo, and said that the Queen would want to know that the hobbit Bilbo Baggins had died of old age and that his spirit had not remained, and that the hobbit Frodo Baggins was growing old, and that the leaves were falling in the Shire. He said that he would tell her. He said that it would take him some time to reach Yavannia, because he was traveling on foot, as he always did, and because he had not been well. He said that he thought it might take him a month. Perhaps two. He said that a hobbit who wished to visit the Old Forest, or walk to the Sea, might find the roads quiet in that time.

Then he picked up his staff and went to the door. Frodo wrote that he followed him, because he did not know what else to do, and that at the door the Herald stopped and looked down at him one more time. He wrote that the Herald said: I was an arm's length from it once. And I knelt. Do not kneel. Then he went down the lane, alone, on foot, with his staff in his hand, and the hobbits of Hobbiton watched him go, and Frodo stood in the door of Bag End until the white robe was out of sight.

The historian has asked Frodo, many times, whether he believes the Herald meant to let him go. Frodo says that he believes the Herald did not know himself, until he saw the leaves falling, and that the leaves decided him. The historian has asked Olórin, who knew Isildur son of Elendil, what he believes. Olórin says that he believes that somewhere beneath four and a half thousand years of silence, Isildur had been standing on the slope of the mountain of fire, looking west, listening for something, for the whole of the Summer. And that in the parlor of Bag End, watching the leaves fall, he heard it.

Chapter X: What Bilbo Left

Frodo opened the box that night.

He wrote that it took him three days and three nights to read everything in it, and that he did not sleep, and that he ate only when his friend Samwise Gamgee, the gardener of Bag End, came in and put food in front of him and stood over him until he ate it. He wrote that when he had finished, he went out into the garden behind Bag End and was sick in the cabbages, because he had read about the thorn-groves and understood what the soil of the Shire was made of, and that Sam held his head while he was sick and did not ask him anything. He wrote that afterward he sat in the garden for a long time, in the falling leaves, and told Sam everything. He told him about the Queen, and the Dark Lord, and the postern of Eregion, and Elrond on the bridge, and the orcs, and the thorn-groves, and the War of the Weeds, and the pact, and the Chambers of Fire, and the night the Queen sat alone on her throne with the Ring in her palm and put it back on. He told him about the Herald, and who the Herald was. He told him about the Unpassed, and why they could not pass, and why Bilbo had. He wrote that Sam listened to all of it without saying a word, and that when he had finished, Sam was quiet for a long time, and then said that he had always thought there was something wrong with the soil in the Shire, because nothing he planted ever surprised him.

At the bottom of the box, beneath the writings, there was a letter. It was addressed to whoever opened the box. It was written in Celebrimbor's careful hand, but it was signed with a name Frodo had never heard of, Pallando, and beneath the name, in a different, rougher hand, as though written very quickly: Celebrimbor's face, but not Celebrimbor. The historian has the letter. It is short. It said that the writings in the box were the only true account in the world of what had happened in the Second Age, and that they must be carried West, over the Sea, to the Blessed Realm, to the Valar, who had been waiting for a sign. It said that the one who opened the box would know that the sign had come, because something would have changed in the Shire that had never changed before. It said that the Valar would not act on the word of the Elves, or the word of Olórin, or even the word of the Ring-maker, because all of them were partisans in the war. It said that the Valar would act, if they acted at all, on the word of someone who had lived in the Summer, and loved it, and seen it crack. It said that the one who opened the box should go to the Old Forest, to the house by the river, and that the master of the house would show the way to the Sea. And it said, at the very end, in the rougher hand: I am sorry. I have been sorry for four thousand years. Tell them I was sorry, and tell them I did one thing.

Frodo wrote that he did not want to go. He wrote that he was fifty years old and growing older, and that his knees ached, and that he had never been farther from Bag End than Bree, and that he had loved the Summer, even if he had been tired of it, and that the hobbits of the Shire loved it, and that if the Valar came, the Summer would end, and the hobbits of the Shire would grow old and die, as they had in the old days, and their children would die of fevers, as the children of the Lossoth died, one in three. He wrote that he sat in the garden behind Bag End with the letter in his hand and thought about the farmer of Bree, in Pallando's writings, whose daughter had lived because of the bread, and the Harfoot woman who had wept because the Elves never came, and the mother of Númenor who had held her son while he died of a fever. He wrote that he thought about his parents, standing on the bank of the Brandywine, grey and faint, looking at the water, for forty years, unable to go. He wrote that he thought about Bilbo, smiling in his chair under the great tree, and how in the morning there had been nothing grey and faint anywhere in the field.

He wrote that he did not decide. He wrote that he sat in the garden until the stars came out, and that the star of Eärendil came up over the Hill, very bright, and that he looked at it, and remembered that in Pallando's writings the Queen looked at it every night, and did not know whether it was a promise or a threat. He wrote that he looked at it for a long time, and that he found that he knew. He wrote that it was a promise. He wrote that he could not have said, then or now, what it promised. Only that it was not the Summer.

Sam said that he would come with him as far as the Sea. Frodo told him that he did not have to. Sam said that he knew that, and that he was coming anyway, and that someone had to carry the food.

Chapter XI: The House by the River

They left Bag End on the first day of the winter month, which the hobbits of the Shire had not called winter in four and a half thousand years, because there had been no winter. There was one now. Frodo wrote that frost lay on the fields of the Shire when they set out, for the first time in the memory of anyone living, and that the hobbits came out of their holes to stare at it, and touch it, and some of them were frightened, and some of them laughed, and some of the children, the very few children in the Shire, ran across the white fields shrieking with delight. He wrote that the leaves had all fallen from the trees by then. He wrote that the Unpassed stood in the fields among the frost, grey and faint, as they always had, and that as he and Sam walked past them on the road east, he thought that some of them were looking, for the first time, not at the things they had loved, but at the sky.

The Herald had spoken truly. The roads were quiet. No servant of the Queen stopped them, or questioned them, on the road from Hobbiton to the eastern borders of the Shire. They came to the edge of the Old Forest on the third day. It was very small. Frodo wrote that it was perhaps a day's walk across, a dark island of old wild trees in the middle of the Queen's golden orchards, and that the hobbits of Buckland, who lived beside it, had built a hedge along its edge in the old days to keep it from creeping into their gardens, and that the hedge was overgrown now, and the forest was creeping. He wrote that he had been afraid of the Old Forest all his life, because every hobbit was, and that when they went in under the eaves of the trees, it was dark, and cold, and the trees seemed to lean toward them, and the paths seemed to shift, and he was very frightened. He wrote that Sam was frightened too, and that they held hands, which they had not done since they were small. And he wrote that after an hour of walking in the dark, they heard singing.

The master of the house by the river came to meet them on the path, singing, as he had come to meet the Queen, and Olórin, and Celebrimbor, long ago. Frodo wrote that he was exactly as the writings said: a small man, not much taller than a hobbit, with a brown beard and a blue jacket and yellow boots and a battered hat with a feather in it, and that he was singing nonsense, and that he did not stop singing when he saw them. He wrote that the master of the house looked at the grey streak above Frodo's left ear and laughed, very kindly, and said that it suited him, and that he had been waiting for a hobbit with a box for four hundred and eighty years and was glad that one had finally come, and asked whether they would like some supper.

They stayed for three days in the house by the river, with the master of the house and the River-daughter, who set out bread and honey and cream and berries on the table, as she had set them out for the Queen. Frodo wrote that the bread was not the bread of the Summer. It was made from grain that grew wild in the Old Forest, in the clearings by the river, and it tasted of nothing he had ever tasted before, and he could not stop eating it. He wrote that the master of the house told him that it was ordinary bread, the kind of bread that everyone had eaten before the Summer, made from grain that grew on its own, in its own time, in ordinary soil. He wrote that it was the best thing he had ever eaten.

And on the second day, by the river, Frodo met the people who lived there.

The historian has been waiting through the whole of this history to set down what Frodo wrote about them, and he will set it down exactly. Frodo wrote that there were perhaps two hundred of them, living in houses of wood and stone along the banks of the river in the heart of the Old Forest, where the master of the house had let them live since the War of the Weeds. He wrote that they were tall, taller than hobbits and nearly as tall as Men, and lean, and dark-skinned, and that their eyes were large and dark and very bright, and that they could not bear the full light of the sun but loved the dappled light of the forest, and that they fished, and grew grain in the clearings, and sang. He wrote that their songs were in a tongue he did not know, harsh and strange, but that the tunes were the tunes the master of the house sang, nonsense tunes, and that the children of the river people sang them while they played. He wrote that there were children. Many children. He wrote that more children were born by the river in the Old Forest in a single year than had been born in the whole of the Shire in a century, and that some of them died, as children had died in the old days, and that the river people buried them in a grove beside the river and sang over them, and that their spirits did not linger as the Unpassed lingered, but went wherever the spirits of the river people went.

He wrote that he asked the master of the house who they were. The master of the house told him that they were the grandchildren's grandchildren's grandchildren of the orc-children he had taken in during the War of the Weeds, who had fled the thorn-groves of the southern Shire-land and come into the Old Forest because there was nowhere else to go. He told Frodo that he had fed them, and let them play by his river, and sung to them, and not decided what they would become. He told Frodo that they had become this. He said that he did not know what to call them, because they were not orcs any longer, and they were not Elves, and they were not Men. He said that they called themselves, in their own tongue, a word that meant the people of the river. He said that he thought that was a good enough name.

Frodo wrote that he sat by the river with the children of the river people for most of the second day, and that one of them, a girl of perhaps ten, with large dark bright eyes, asked him why he had grey in his hair. He told her that he was growing old. She asked him what that meant. He told her that it meant that one day he would die, as Bilbo had died, and go wherever hobbits went. She thought about it, and then she said that her grandmother had grown old, and died, last winter, and that they had buried her in the grove and sung over her, and that it had been very sad, and that it had been right. Frodo asked her how she knew it had been right. The girl said that she did not know how she knew. She said that she just did. She said that everyone by the river knew it, and that she had always thought everyone in the world knew it, until she heard that in the Queen's lands, people did not die. She asked Frodo whether that was true. He said that it was. She asked him whether the people in the Queen's lands were happy. He said that they were. She thought about it for a long time, and then she said that she was sorry for them.

On the third day, the master of the house walked with Frodo and Sam to the western eaves of the Old Forest, and showed them a path that went west, through the Queen's orchards, toward the Sea. He told them that no one in the Dominion could see it, and that it would take them to the Havens. Frodo asked him whether he was afraid of what would happen when the Valar came. The master of the house laughed, and said that he had seen the Valar come before, and go, and come again, and that he had been in his forest before any of them and would be in it after. He said that he would miss the Summer a little, because the honey had been very good, and that he would not miss it very much, because nothing in it had ever surprised him. He said that the river people would like the winter. Then he said a thing that Frodo has written down exactly, and that the historian sets down here as the last words of the master of the Old Forest in this history. He said: The Lady came to supper once. She was very sad. Tell her, if you see her, that she can come again. Tell her the honey will be different.

Chapter XII: The Grey Havens

The path took them west for nine days, through the Queen's orchards, across the Tower Hills, down into the green lands of Lindon that had been a garden for four and a half thousand years. Frodo wrote that the frost lay on the orchards as they passed, and that the fruit had fallen from the trees, and that the Men of the Dominion who tended the orchards stood among the fallen fruit and stared at it and did not know what to do. He wrote that the Unpassed stood in the orchards among them, and that more and more of them, as Frodo and Sam went west, were looking at the sky. He wrote that on the seventh day, passing an orchard near the Tower Hills, he saw an Unpassed woman standing among the fallen fruit, grey and faint, and that as he watched, she grew fainter, and fainter, and then was gone. He wrote that the Man who tended the orchard, who had been standing beside her, cried out, and fell on his knees in the frost, and that Frodo did not know whether he was crying out in grief or in joy. He wrote that he did not think the Man knew either.

They came to the Grey Havens on the ninth day, in the evening. The Havens were a garden. They had been a garden since the fall of Lindon, four and a half thousand years before, and the great hall of Gil-galad was overgrown with flowering vines, and there were fruit-trees growing on the quays where the ships of Círdan had sailed, and the flowers had died in the frost and the fruit had fallen and lay rotting on the stones. Frodo wrote that it was the most beautiful place he had ever seen, and the saddest. He wrote that he and Sam walked down the last quay, where the Gulf of Lune opened to the Sea, in the dusk, and that there was nothing at the end of it. No ship. He wrote that he stood at the end of the quay with the box in his arms and looked at the empty Sea and did not know what to do. Pallando's letter had said that the master of the house would show the way to the Sea, and he had. It had not said what to do when you reached it.

They waited. They sat on the end of the quay with the box between them and waited through the night, and the star of Eärendil came up over the Sea, very bright, brighter than Frodo had ever seen it, and they watched it climb. And near dawn, Sam said that there was something on the water.

It was a grey ship. It was small and plain, and it came out of the West on the dawn wind with its sails full, toward the Havens, across the Sea that had been empty of ships from the West for four and a half thousand years, and there was someone standing in the bow. Frodo wrote that as the ship came into the Gulf of Lune, the sun came up behind them over the hills of Lindon, and lit the sails, and the figure in the bow, and he saw that it was an old man in grey, with a tall pointed hat and a staff, and that there was a red ring on his hand. Not on a chain. On his hand. The ship came alongside the end of the quay as gently as a leaf on a pond, and the old man in grey stepped off it onto the stones, and looked down at the two hobbits with the box between them, and at the grey streak above Frodo's left ear. Frodo wrote that he had the kindest face Frodo had ever seen, and the saddest, and that he was smiling.

He said that his name was Olórin, and that in Middle-earth he had been called Gandalf, and that he had told the Queen of Middle-earth, long ago, in the Chambers of Fire, that he would go West and tell the Valar what had happened, and that she had told him that if he ever came back, she would kill him. He said that he had come back. He said that he had been sent to fetch a box. He said that he had not known who would be carrying it, and that he was very glad it was a hobbit, because hobbits were the only people in Middle-earth he had ever been able to trust completely, and that he had been taken in by hobbits once, long ago, when he fell out of the sky, and had never repaid them. He said that the Valar had been waiting for four and a half thousand years for someone who had lived in the Summer, and loved it, and seen it crack, to come and tell them that it was time. He asked Frodo whether he would come.

Frodo wrote that he said yes. He wrote that he did not decide. He wrote that he had already decided, in the garden behind Bag End, looking at the star, and had not known it.

Sam would not come. Frodo wrote that he begged him, at the end of the quay, in the dawn, and that Sam stood with his hands in his pockets and shook his head. Sam said that someone had to go back to the Shire. He said that the leaves were falling in the Shire, and the frost was on the fields, and the hobbits did not know what was happening to them, and they would be frightened, and someone had to go back and tell them. He said that someone had to plant the gardens in the spring, if there was a spring, and see what came up. He said that he had been planting the gardens of Bag End for three hundred years and nothing he planted had ever surprised him, and that he wanted to see what would come up now. He said that Frodo had to go and tell the Valar, and that he had to go home and tell the hobbits, and that it was the same job, really, only in different directions. Frodo wrote that he could not argue with that. He wrote that he did not try very hard.

The old man in grey put his hand on Sam's shoulder, at the end of the quay, and told him that he was the wisest hobbit he had ever met. Sam said that he did not know about that. Then Sam embraced Frodo, which he had not done since they were small, and turned and walked back up the quay through the rotting fruit, toward the hills of Lindon and the long road home, and did not look back. Frodo wrote that he stood at the end of the quay and watched him go until he was out of sight. He wrote that he thinks of him every day.

They sailed on the morning tide: the old man in grey, with Narya on his hand, and the hobbit with the box. Frodo wrote that as they passed out of the Gulf of Lune, the old man in grey stood in the bow and looked back east, over the hills of Lindon, toward something very far away, and that his face was very sad. Frodo asked him what he was looking at. The old man in grey said that he was looking at the Queen. Frodo asked him whether he could see her. The old man in grey said that he could feel her, through the ring on his hand, far away in the East, in Yavannia, and that she was standing under the open sky in her hall on the hill, as she did every dawn and every dusk, looking up at the star of Eärendil. He said that she could see the grey ship. He said that the star was very bright that morning, and that she was looking at it, and that she knew. Frodo asked him what she was feeling. The old man in grey was silent for a long time. Then he said that he could not tell. He said that for the first time in four and a half thousand years, he did not think she could tell either.

Chapter XIII: How This History Came to Be Written

The grey ship came to Tol Eressëa on the evening tide, in the four thousand five hundred and eighty-second year of the Summer, and the historian was on the quay.

He had been waiting for a long time. He had been compiling this history for four and a half thousand years, from the testimony of Olórin and Celebrimbor and the Elves who came West, and the orcs who lived in the hall on the hill above the harbor, and he had known for all that time that it was missing its heart. He had known what the Queen had done. He had not known what she had felt, or what she had told no one, or what she had become. He had known that somewhere in the Summer, in the forge beneath the green hill of Lothlórien, there was a Maia wearing Celebrimbor's face, who might be writing it down. He had not known whether the writing would ever come West. And then a grey ship came into the harbor of Avallónë on the evening tide, with Olórin standing in the bow, and beside him, holding a wooden box in his arms, a hobbit with grey in his hair.

The writings in the box are the heart of this history. The historian has used them throughout these seven books, wherever the reader has seen the words Pallando wrote, or the Queen told Celebrimbor, many centuries later. The account of the Queen alone on her throne, with the Ring in her palm, that closes the sixth book of this history, came from them. So did the account of her orders to the Balrog, and the death of Glorfindel. So did most of what the reader knows of her inner life, from the night she kept Nenya on in Lothlórien to the night she told the one she believed was her Ring-maker that she was unfading. Without them, this history would have been a history of what she did. With them, it is a history of who she was. The historian does not know which would have been kinder to her. He has tried to be fair.

Frodo Baggins went before the Valar in the Ring of Doom, at the Máhanaxar in Valinor, in the spring of the following year, and spoke for nine days. The historian was there. Frodo told them about the Shire, and the Summer, and the hobbits who had lived in the same hole for three thousand years and argued about the same hedge. He told them about the bread, and the Unpassed, and the cradles, and his parents on the bank of the Brandywine. He told them about Bilbo smiling in his chair under the great tree, and the grey hair above his own left ear, and the leaves falling, and the frost. He told them about the Herald in the parlor of Bag End, watching the leaves fall, and what he said at the door. He told them about the people of the river in the Old Forest, and the girl who said she was sorry for the people in the Queen's lands. He told them about Sam, walking home through the rotting fruit. And at the end, when the Valar asked him what he wished them to do, he told them that he did not know. He told them that he had loved the Summer, and that the hobbits of the Shire loved it, and that if the Valar ended it, the hobbits would grow old and die, and their children would die of fevers, and they would be frightened and sad and would not understand. He told them that he did not want that for them. He told them that he did not want them to stand in the fields forever either, grey and faint, looking at things. He told them that he had come because Pallando's letter had said that the Valar would act, if they acted at all, on the word of someone who had lived in the Summer and loved it and seen it crack. He told them that he had seen it crack. He told them that he did not know whether it should be mended or broken. He told them that he thought they should decide, and that he thought it was very hard, and that he was sorry.

Manwë thanked him. The historian has the Elder King's words, which were few. He said that the Valar had waited four and a half thousand years for someone to come before them who did not know the answer, because everyone who had come before them in all that time had been certain, the Queen most of all, and the Valar had learned in the beginning of the world what came of being certain. He said that the Valar did not know the answer either. He said that they would have to decide anyway. And he said that they would decide together, in council, as they had not decided anything since the end of the First Age, and that Mandos had told them it was time.

Ushgra was at the Máhanaxar. She had walked from Avallónë to Valinor again, for the second time in the history of the world, when she heard that a hobbit had come West with a box. She stood at the back of the Ring of Doom through the whole of Frodo's testimony, with her children's names painted on a cloth that she held in her hands. When Frodo had finished, and Manwë had spoken, she walked down through the Ring of Doom to where the Valar sat, which no orc had ever done, and stood before the Elder King. And she asked him the question she had asked him in the hundredth year of the Summer, when she stood before the gates of Valmar. The historian has the question now, because Ushgra gave him leave to set it down. She asked the Elder King why the Valar had let the Queen feed her children to the thorns.

Manwë looked at her for a long time. The historian was close enough to see his face. Then the Elder King of Arda, the Lord of the Breath of the World, rose from his throne, and came down from it, and stood before the orc mother on the floor of the Ring of Doom. And he said: Because we were afraid of making the mistake she made. And so we made the other one. We let her choose for everyone, because we would not choose for anyone. I told you once that we were waiting to see. We waited too long. I am sorry. I should have said it the first time.

Ushgra said that it would have been better if he had. Then she went back up through the Ring of Doom, with her children's names in her hands, and the historian saw that she was weeping, and that she was not hiding it.

The Valar went into council that day. They are in council still, as the historian writes these words. He does not know what they will decide. No one does. He knows that Ulmo has said that the waters of Middle-earth are moving again, and that he can feel the rivers running toward the Sea for the first time in four and a half thousand years, and that he does not intend to let them stop. He knows that Mandos has said that the spirits of the Unpassed are beginning to go, one by one, through the door that has been held shut for so long, and that he can feel them going, and that he does not know how long the Queen's power can hold the rest. He knows that Olórin has asked to be sent back to Middle-earth, with Narya on his hand, whatever the Valar decide, because he promised the hobbits of the Shire long ago that he would repay them, and has not. And he knows that somewhere in the Valar's council, someone has asked the question the Valar have refused to ask for four and a half thousand years, which is whether there is any way to end the Summer without breaking the world, and that no one has yet answered it.

He knows other things too, which he will set down here at the end, because they belong to the history that has not yet been written.

He knows that in Middle-earth, the leaves are falling. He knows that in the Shire, a gardener named Samwise Gamgee is planting a garden in the frost, and does not know what will come up. He knows that by the river in the Old Forest, the people of the river are singing over the graves of their dead, and that their dead are going where they should go. He knows that at Cuiviénen, at the edge of the world, there are lights that are not the red lights of orcs any longer, and that Thranduil and Arondir and Morwë of the Avari are watching the West. He knows that in the forge beneath the green hill of Lothlórien, an old man in blue is sitting at an anvil, wearing a face that is not his own, and that he has heard that the leaves are falling, and that he is smiling. He knows that in the forest of Fangorn, an old Ent is walking alone among the trees, and that he has felt the frost, and stopped, and lifted his head, and that somewhere in the Queen's garden, an Entwife has felt it too.

He knows that in Yavannia, on the hill where the Dark Tower stood, in the hall of white stone and living wood, a grave and silent Man in white has come back from the Shire, on foot, after two months on the road, and has stood before the Queen's throne and told her that the hobbit Bilbo Baggins died of old age and did not remain, and that the leaves are falling in the Shire, and that a hobbit with grey in his hair has sailed West in a grey ship. He knows that the Herald did not tell her about the box. He knows that on the lowest step of the throne, a small grey bent figure with red eyes, which has not moved in four and a half thousand years, has turned its head, very slowly, and is looking West.

And he knows that every night, at dusk, the Queen of Middle-earth goes out under the open sky in her hall on the hill, with the One Ring and Nenya on her hand and Vilya on a chain around her neck, and the Daughters of Varda shining around her, and looks up at the star of Eärendil. He knows that it has grown very bright. He knows that she has not looked away from it since the grey ship sailed. And he knows, because Olórin has told him, and because Olórin can still feel her, faintly, through Narya on his hand, across all the leagues of the Sea, that for the first time since the night she sat alone on her throne and put the Ring back on, the Queen Unfading is afraid.

The historian does not know what she is afraid of. Perhaps the Valar. Perhaps the end of the Summer. Perhaps the thought, which has not come to her in four and a half thousand years, that she might have been wrong.

Or perhaps, and this is what the historian believes, and has believed since the first page of this history, she is afraid of the thing that frightened her on the plain before the sea, when the water came over Anfauglith and she had to let go of Celeborn's hand. She is afraid of what happens to the things you let go of. She has spent four and a half thousand years holding on to everything, so that nothing would ever be lost again. And now the leaves are falling. And she cannot hold them.

In the West, a door is opening.

Here ends The Queen Unfading, the history of the Second Age of Middle-earth as it was, compiled in Avallónë upon Tol Eressëa from the testimony of those who came West: of Olórin and Celebrimbor, of the Elves of Lindon and the Faithful of Númenor, of the young Man of the mountains who did not kneel, of the orcs who came West in the grey ship, and of Pallando, who wore another's face for four and a half thousand years and did one thing. And of Frodo Baggins of Bag End, who lived in the Summer, and loved it, and saw it crack, and did not know the answer, and came anyway.

What the Valar decide belongs to another history.

 
Read more...

from Blog of Sand

FICTIONAL WHAT IF: Part IX- What if Galadriel Was The Antagonist in The War of the Rings? Volume 6

BOOK SIX: THE LAST ALLIANCE From the Voice in the Tower to the Making of Yavannia

Compiled in Avallónë upon Tol Eressëa, from the testimony of those who came West

A Note on This Book

This is the last book of the history of the war. It covers some twenty-five years, from the coming of the alliance into the Black Land in the eighteen hundred and fifty-fifth year of the Second Age to the making of Yavannia, and it is the hardest of all the books of this history to write, because the historian knows its ending and has known it from the first page. The reader knows it too. The reader has known since the first book that the Queen would win.

What the reader does not yet know, and what this book must tell, is how she won, and what the free peoples of Middle-earth did in their last years to try to stop her. They did terrible things. They made a pact with the Dark Lord. They marched beside the creature who had murdered Finrod and corrupted the Nine and burned Eregion, and they called him an ally, and they lied to him as he lied to them. The historian does not excuse them for it. He asks the reader only to remember where they were standing when they did it: in the ash of the last free land in the world, starving, with nowhere left to go, against an enemy who was right about almost everything.

The sources for this book are fewer than for any other part of this history, because so few of those who saw its events survived. The historian has relied above all on the testimony of Olórin, who was present at nearly every moment of importance, and of Celebrimbor, who was not, but who heard the rest from the Queen herself. He has relied too on the testimony of the orcs, the last free orcs of Middle-earth, a handful of whom came West in the grey ship with Olórin and the Ring-maker. They are the only witnesses to some of what follows. The loremasters of Avallónë, who once would not have accepted the word of an orc on anything, have learned in the course of this history to accept it on a great deal.

Chapter I: The Voice in the Tower

The Dark Lord had no body. The historian must begin with this, because everything that followed depended on it, and because the free peoples who came into Mordor in the eighteen hundred and fifty-fifth year did not at first understand what they were dealing with.

When the Queen took the One from him on the field of the Gwathló, Sauron's fair form had failed, and the shadow that rose from the empty armor had fled east over the Misty Mountains to the Black Land, howling. It had been in the Dark Tower ever since, for a hundred and fifty-five years. It could not take a shape. It could not walk, or fight, or forge. It was a darkness, the orcs said, that filled the highest chambers of Barad-dûr, a darkness that was colder than the coldest night and thicker than smoke, and in the heart of it there burned a single red light, like an eye. It could speak. Its voice came out of the darkness and out of the stones of the Tower, and out of the minds of anyone who came near it, so that those who heard it were never sure afterward whether they had heard it with their ears. And it could think. It had done nothing else for a hundred and fifty-five years.

Adar's orcs had come to it, band by band, as they fled the thorn-groves of the West. The orc testimony is clear that they did not come willingly. They came because there was nowhere else to go, and because the shadow in the Tower was the only power in Middle-earth that did not want them dead. Adar hated it. He had killed it once, in the years after the War of Wrath, and he had knelt to it with his hand on his sword, and he had fled from it when the Queen purged his people in its name. But he was the father of forty thousand orcs living in the ash, and the shadow in the Tower knew their names. It had known them since the beginning. It had made them. And when the Queen's power could not reach into the Black Land, and the orcs who lived there began, for the first time in a century, to raise their young without fear, it was the shadow in the Tower that told them where to find water beneath the ash, and which caves were warm, and how to grow the grey lichen that was the only thing that would grow in Mordor. The orcs did not love it. But they lived.

When the alliance came through the Black Gate, Adar went up into the Tower and told the shadow they had come. The orc testimony records what the shadow said. It said that it had been waiting for them. It said that it had known for a hundred and fifty years that they would come, because there was nowhere else in the world for them to go, and that it had kept the Gate open for them. It said that it would speak to their lords. Adar asked it what it meant to say to them. The shadow said that it meant to offer them the only thing they had left, which was a chance.

The lords of the alliance were brought to the Tower on the third day after they came into Mordor. There were seven of them: Gil-galad, the High King of the Noldor; Glorfindel of Gondolin; Elendil of the Faithful, with his sons Isildur and Anárion; Durin the Younger, with Disa at his side; and Thranduil of the Silvan Elves. Olórin came with them, unbidden. Adar led them up the stair of Barad-dûr, past the empty chambers where the Dark Lord's captains had once held council, to the highest hall of the Tower, where the darkness was so thick that the torches they carried would not burn. They stood in it, blind, and the red light came out of the dark toward them, and the voice spoke.

Olórin's testimony on what the voice said is the fullest the historian has, and the historian has followed it closely. The voice said that it knew why they had come. It said that the woman who had once hunted it through the waste places of the world now ruled the world, and that she had driven them into the only land she could not reach, and that she would come for them here in the end, because she could not bear that anything in Middle-earth should be beyond her. It said that they could not defeat her. They had tried for eighty years and failed, and they would go on failing, because they did not understand what she was and what she carried. It said that it understood. It said that it had made the thing she carried, and that it knew every secret of it, and every weakness, and that without that knowledge the free peoples of Middle-earth would die in the ash. And it said that it would give them that knowledge, and the strength of the forty thousand orcs of Mordor, and the strength of every Man of the East and South who still remembered their old master, if they would stand beside it against her.

Gil-galad asked it what it wanted in return. The voice laughed. Olórin said that it was the worst sound he had ever heard. The voice said that it wanted what was its own. It said that the Ring on the Queen's hand had been made in the fire of the mountain outside the window, from the stuff of its own spirit, and that it wanted it back. It said that it would not lie to them about this, because they would not believe it if it did. It said that the free peoples had a choice between two masters. One of them was a beautiful woman who would rule them forever and never let them die, and feed them on the bones of the orcs, and make the whole world into a garden in which nothing grew that she had not planted. The other was a shadow in a tower that had never pretended to be anything else. It said that it had been their enemy for an age, and that they knew exactly what it was. It said that this was more than they could say of her.

Chapter II: The Council in the Ash

The lords of the alliance held their council in a cave on the slopes of the Ephel Dúath, three days' march from the Tower, because Gil-galad would not hold it within sight of the red window. It lasted nine days. The historian has the testimony of Olórin, who spoke at it, and of Thranduil, who came West long afterward, and of one of the orcs of Adar's people, who served the lords of the alliance as a guide and stood at the mouth of the cave through the whole of it. He has set down what each of them said as faithfully as he can. It is the last time in this history that the free peoples of Middle-earth stood together and argued about what was right, and the historian thinks that they deserve to be heard.

Olórin spoke first, and he spoke against the pact. He said that the Dark Lord had never kept a promise in the whole history of the world, and that he would not keep this one. He said that if the alliance helped him take the One back from the Queen, he would use it to make himself master of Middle-earth again, and that he would be a worse master than she was, because she at least believed she was doing good, and he had never believed anything except that he should rule. He said that the alliance had fought for eighty years for the right of the free peoples to choose their own fate, and that if it chose Sauron now, it would have chosen the one fate worse than the one it was fighting. He said that he would rather die in the ash with his honor than live with his hand in Sauron's.

Durin the Younger answered him. He said that honor was a fine thing to die with, and that he had watched four thousand of his people die with it in the ruins of Eregion and the passes of the Grey Mountains, and that he was tired of it. He said that the White Lady had opened the postern of Eregion and killed Elrond, and turned his father to stone, and that if the Dark Lord himself offered him an axe to put through her, he would take it, and settle with the Dark Lord afterward. He said that he did not trust Sauron. He said that he did not need to. He needed only to be standing close enough to the White Lady when the moment came.

Thranduil spoke for the Silvan Elves. He said that his father had died at the western eaves of the Greenwood defending the oak beneath which he had been crowned, against thorn-trees planted by a Noldorin queen, and that the Silvan Elves had never loved the Noldor and did not love them now. He said that the Silvan Elves had never served the Dark Lord either, and would not begin. He said that he would go back east into the wild lands beyond the Anduin, and wait there with his people for the end of the world, and take no part in either master's war. Gil-galad asked him where he would go when the Queen's orchards reached the wild lands beyond the Anduin. Thranduil did not answer.

Adar spoke for the orcs. He was not asked to. He stood up in the mouth of the cave, where his orc guide was standing, and the lords of the alliance turned and looked at him, and he said that he would tell them what the orcs wanted, since no one had ever asked. He said that the orcs wanted to live. He said that the White Lady had decided that they should not, and had fed them to her thorns, and that the alliance had fought her for eighty years and freed a few hundred of them from the groves and never once asked what had happened to the rest. He said that the only power in Middle-earth that had ever let the orcs live was the shadow in the Tower, and that it had let them live because it had a use for them, and that he knew this, and that he had hated it for an age. He said that he would follow it now because it was the only thing standing between his children and the thorns. He said that if the free peoples of the West wanted the orcs of Mordor to fight beside them, they would have to swear that when the war was over, the orcs would be let alone. He said that he did not much care who held the Ring afterward, so long as whoever held it swore to that.

Gil-galad spoke last but one. The annals of Lindon, which came West in Círdan's ships long before this council, cannot record what he said, and Olórin's testimony is the historian's only source. Gil-galad said that Olórin was right, and that Durin was right, and that Adar was right, and that he did not know how all three of them could be right at once. He said that he had sat behind the line of the Lune for eighty years while the Queen built her dominion, waiting for someone else to begin the war, and that he had been wrong to wait. He said that he would not make that mistake again. He said that he would vote for the pact, because the alternative was to die in the ash and leave the world to her forever, and that he did not believe the world deserved that, whatever it had chosen. And he said that he would vote for it on one condition. He said that when the One was taken from the Queen, it must not be given back to the Dark Lord. It must be carried up the mountain to the fire in which it was made, and thrown in, and destroyed. He said that the Dark Lord must never know this was the alliance's purpose until it was done.

Olórin said that if the One was destroyed, the Dark Lord would be destroyed with it, because he had poured so much of himself into it that he could not survive its unmaking. He said that the Dark Lord knew this, and would never let it happen if he could stop it. Gil-galad said that he knew. He said that this was why the Dark Lord must not know.

The historian pauses here to note what the High King of the Noldor had just proposed. He had proposed that the alliance make a pact with the Dark Lord, and swear to it, and fight beside him, and accept his help, and then betray him at the end. He had proposed that the free peoples of Middle-earth, in their last war for the right of every people to choose its own fate, deceive their only ally into helping them destroy him. The loremasters of Avallónë have argued about this proposal more fiercely than about any other in this history, because it was made by an Elf, and a king, and a good one. Some of them say that it was justified, because it was made against the Dark Lord, who had lied to everyone in Middle-earth for an age and deserved to be lied to. Some of them say that it was the moment the alliance became what it was fighting, because the Queen, too, had lied to her ally, and betrayed him, and taken the Ring from his hand on the field of the Gwathló. Olórin, asked about it, said that he had voted against the pact, and that he had then helped to keep the High King's secret for fifteen years, and that he did not know which of those two things he was more ashamed of.

Elendil spoke last. He said that he had lost his daughter to the Queen, and his wife long ago, and a son to a fever before any of this began, and that he did not have much left to lose. He said that he had refused to kneel to the Queen on the field of the Gwathló because he had read the books of the Faithful about the coming of Morgoth, and he had seen in her the same light. He said that he had been fighting her ever since because he believed that the gift of Ilúvatar was worth more than the bread of the Dominion, and that he still believed it, though he had stopped being able to explain why. He said that he would vote for the pact. He said that if Ilúvatar had meant for the free peoples of Middle-earth to stand alone against her, Ilúvatar should not have let them be driven into Mordor. He said that he was going to do the only thing left that might save his daughter, and that if it damned him, he would take that up with Ilúvatar himself, beyond the circles of the world, where he expected to be very soon.

The vote was taken on the ninth day. Gil-galad, Elendil, Durin and Adar voted for the pact. Olórin voted against it. Thranduil abstained, and said that he would stay with the alliance until the Avari came, because he had promised Morwë that he would, and that after that he would make no promises at all. Glorfindel did not vote. He said that he had come back from the dead for one thing, and that the pact would bring him closer to it, and that the rest was for the living to decide.

Isildur did not vote either. He had not been asked to, because he was his father's son and not a lord of the alliance in his own right. But the orc guide at the mouth of the cave remembered him, and the historian has the orc's testimony. He said that Isildur sat at the back of the cave through the whole nine days and did not speak, and that on the last night, after the vote, he went out of the cave alone and stood on the slope of the mountain looking west, toward the golden wood that he could not see. The orc said that Isildur stood there until dawn. He said that he had never seen a Man look so much like he was listening for something.

Chapter III: What the Maker Knew

The pact was sworn in the highest hall of Barad-dûr, in the darkness, before the red light. The historian has the words of the oath from Olórin's testimony, and he will not reproduce them, because they were sworn in the Black Speech of Mordor at the Dark Lord's insistence and Olórin will not repeat them. He has said only that the lords of the alliance swore to stand beside the shadow in the Tower against the Queen of the West until the One was taken from her hand, and that the shadow swore to give them all its knowledge and all its strength until the same moment, and that Adar made the shadow swear, separately and at length, that the orcs of Mordor would be let alone when the war was over. It swore. The historian does not know whether it meant to keep that oath. He does not think anyone does.

Then it told them what it knew.

It told them first about the Daughters of Varda. The alliance had lost every battle of the War of the Weeds because its soldiers could not fight the Queen's Nine. They knelt and wept before the light of the Rings of Varda and let the Daughters pass. The shadow told them why. It said that the Rings of Varda had been made with its own knowledge, by the only smith in Middle-earth who had learned ring-craft from it, and that they were bound to the One whether the smith had meant them to be or not. And it said that their light was not the light of Varda at all. It was the light of the One, passing through the Rings of Varda as the light of a fire passes through a lantern, and the thing that made the soldiers of the alliance kneel was not beauty but domination: the will of the One, reaching out through the Daughters' eyes and bending the wills of everyone who looked at them. It said that there was only one kind of creature in Middle-earth whose will the One could not bend in that way, because its will had already been bent, long ago, into a shape that could not be bent further. It said that the orcs did not see the Daughters of Varda as beautiful. They saw them as the White Pain. The light of the Rings of Varda hurt them, as all bright light hurt them, and it did not enthrall them, because they had been made in the dark by Morgoth to hate the light of the Elves, and the One could not make them love it.

The historian records that the lords of the alliance were silent for a long time after the shadow told them this. Olórin said afterward that he had understood, in that silence, the cruelest joke in the history of Middle-earth. The Queen had spent a hundred and fifty years feeding the orcs to her thorns, because she believed they were the last poison of Morgoth in the world. And the orcs were the only creatures in the world who could stand against her angels. The thing that Morgoth had done to them, the hatred of the light that he had bred into them, was the only thing in Middle-earth that the light of the One could not reach.

It told them second about the Balrog. It said that the Queen believed the Balrog of Khazad-dûm had knelt to her, and that it had not. It had knelt to the One, and to the echo in the One of the will of Morgoth, which the shadow had learned from its master and poured into the Ring. The Balrog would obey whoever held the One, the shadow said, but it would obey grudgingly, as it had never obeyed anyone but Morgoth, and it hated the Queen as it hated everything that was not its old master. And the shadow said that there was one being in the alliance whom the Balrog would always turn to fight, whatever it had been commanded, because it remembered him. It remembered Cirith Thoronath. It remembered its kinsman falling from the cliff in his arms. The shadow said that if the lord of Gondolin stood in the Balrog's path, the Balrog would forget everything else to reach him. Glorfindel, who was standing in the darkness with the other lords, said that he had counted on it.

It told them third about the Ring itself. It said that the One was strongest where it had been made, in the fire of the mountain, and that its bearer was strongest there too. It said that if the Queen came into Mordor, she would come into the place where the One's power was greatest, and that she would draw on that power as she had never drawn on it before, and that this would be her strength and her weakness. Her strength, because she would be able to do things in the shadow of the mountain that she could do nowhere else. Her weakness, because the more she drew on the One, the more the One would draw on her, and the less of her would be left. It said that there would come a moment, if she drew on it deeply enough, when the One would be closer to its bearer's will than her own mind was. It said that the alliance must be standing close enough to her in that moment to take it.

And it told them, last of all, a thing it did not mean to tell them, which Olórin heard in what it did not say. When the shadow spoke of the Rings of Varda, it said that they had been made by the only smith in Middle-earth who had learned ring-craft from it. Olórin asked it who that smith was. The shadow did not answer. Olórin asked it again, and it said that it did not know. Olórin told the loremasters that he had known in that moment that it was lying, and that he had known why. There had been only one smith in Middle-earth who learned ring-craft from Annatar in Eregion, and the Elves of the West had seen his body carried on a pole before the armies of Mordor for a hundred and fifty years. And if the Rings of Varda had been made by him, then the body on the pole had not been his. Celebrimbor was alive. He was alive and in the Queen's service, somewhere in her dominion, making rings for her. And the shadow in the Tower had known it for a long time, and had not told anyone, because it meant to have the Ring-maker for itself when the war was over. Olórin said nothing of this to the shadow. He said nothing of it to the lords of the alliance either, except to one.

Chapter IV: The Strangest Host

The host that marched out of the Black Gate in the spring of the eighteen hundred and sixty-sixth year was the strangest army ever gathered in Middle-earth, and the historian must describe it, because nothing like it had ever been seen before and nothing like it will ever be seen again.

There were the Elves of Lindon, perhaps three thousand of them by then, under Gil-galad, with Glorfindel at their head, who had come out of the West to fight a Balrog and had been waiting eighty-six years for his chance. There were the Faithful of Elendil, perhaps four thousand, Men of Númenor who had fled their island and fought for eighty years without ever winning a battle. There were the Men of the White Mountains, perhaps two thousand, who had sworn on the black stone of Erech to follow Isildur son of Elendil until the end. There were the Dwarves of Durin the Younger and Disa, perhaps fifteen hundred, the last free Dwarves of the West. There were the Silvan Elves of Thranduil, perhaps two thousand. There were the Easterlings of the tribes of the far East who had refused the Queen's peace on the counsel of the Blue Wizards, and who now came west across Rhûn to stand with their old master against her, perhaps eight thousand, with the eastern Dwarf-houses of the Red Mountains, who had never knelt, marching among them. There were the Haradrim of the tribes of the deep South who had never accepted Amaret the priestess, perhaps five thousand, with a few dozen mûmakil. And there were the orcs of Mordor, forty thousand of them, under Adar, the last free orcs in the world, who had lived in the ash for a century and who were marching out of it now to fight the White Pain.

None of them trusted any of the others. The historian has the testimony of soldiers from almost every part of that host, and they agree on nothing else, but they agree on that. The Elves of Lindon would not camp within a mile of the orcs. The Faithful would not eat with the Easterlings, who had marched for Sauron against Eriador. The Dwarves would not speak to the Elves of Lindon, whose High King had sat behind the Lune while the White Lady turned their old king to stone. The Silvan Elves would not speak to anyone. And everyone, without exception, was afraid of the shadow in the Tower, which marched with them in a fashion: a darkness that went before the host along the road like the shadow of a cloud, though there was no cloud, and in which, at night, a red light burned.

And yet, the historian must record, in the weeks that the host spent marching north toward the Black Gate and the wide plain beyond it, something happened among them that none of them had expected. They began to fight beside one another. They did not begin to like one another. But the orcs began to teach the Elves of Lindon how to fight blind, with their eyes covered against the light of the Daughters of Varda, as the orcs had learned to fight in the dark tunnels of the Misty Mountains. The Faithful began to teach the orcs how to hold a line, as Men of Númenor held a line, shields locked, against cavalry. The Dwarves began, grudgingly, to forge for the orcs weapons that would not break, because the orcs' weapons were made of bad iron scavenged from the ruins of Mordor and broke at the first blow. The Easterlings and the Haradrim, who had marched beside the orcs in Sauron's armies a hundred and seventy years before and had despised them then, began to share their food with them, because the orcs had been starving in the ash for a century and the Easterlings had brought cattle.

The historian has the testimony of an orc named Grishak, the same young orc who had been freed from a thorn-grove by the alliance in the War of the Weeds and who had followed it into Mordor. He said that a Man of the Faithful named Hallas, who had lost his wife and children in the burning of Rómenna, taught him to hold a shield on the march north to the Black Gate. He said that Hallas did not like him and did not pretend to. He said that every night on the march, Hallas taught him for an hour, and then went back to the camp of the Faithful and would not speak to him until the next night. He said that on the last night before the battle, Hallas asked him his name. He said that it was the first time in his life that a Man had ever asked him his name. He said that Hallas died the next day, in the line beside him, and that he carried Hallas's shield for the rest of the war, and carried it West, and that it hangs now in the hall in Avallónë where the orcs who came West in the grey ship were given a place to live. The historian has seen it. It is a Númenórean shield of the old pattern, battered almost flat, with the white tree of the Faithful painted on it. Beneath it, someone has painted, in the rough letters of the orcish script, the name Hallas.

Isildur marched at the head of the Men of the White Mountains. They had sworn to him at Erech, and they followed him with a loyalty the other contingents of the host found almost frightening. They did not speak to anyone else. They did not camp with anyone else. When Isildur rode out along the line of the march, they watched him go and watched him come back, and when he slept they set a guard around his tent that no one, not even his father, was allowed to pass without his leave. The historian has the testimony of Olórin, who watched Isildur closely in those weeks, as he had watched him since the council in the ash. Olórin said that Isildur did not sleep much. He said that Isildur sat up late in his tent, every night, with a lamp burning, and that once, passing the tent late, Olórin heard him speaking to someone who was not there. Olórin said that he spoke softly, and that the name he spoke was Estrid.

Chapter V: The Plan of Olórin

There was one lord of the alliance to whom Olórin told what he had heard in the shadow's silence, and it was not one of the lords who had sat in the council in the ash. It was Pallando, the Blue Wizard, who had gone among the Avari at the edge of the world, and who came back west in the eighteen hundred and sixtieth year, ahead of the Avari host, to tell the alliance that the Avari were coming at last.

Pallando was of the same order as Olórin, a Maia sent from the West to stand against the darkness, and he had spent seven hundred years in the East doing so, and he had failed, as Olórin had failed, and as all the servants of the Valar in Middle-earth had failed in that age. He had watched his companion Alatar kneel to the Queen on the green hill of Lothlórien and become her servant. He had not forgiven him. He came to Olórin's tent on the night he arrived in Mordor and asked him what he could do. Olórin told him that the Ring-maker was alive.

The historian has Olórin's account of what followed, and Pallando's, as Pallando set it down in the writings that came West at the very end, since Pallando himself did not come West. Olórin said that if Celebrimbor was alive, he was alive in the Queen's dominion, and that he was making rings for her, and that he must be somewhere close to her, because she would never let the only smith in Middle-earth who could make rings of power out of her sight. He said that there was only one place where she would keep him. He said that she would keep him in the golden wood, beneath the green hill, where she held her court, because it was the one place in Middle-earth where she was always near. And he said that if Celebrimbor could be got out of the golden wood, and carried over the Sea to the Blessed Realm, he would be the one witness in the history of the world whom the Valar could not ignore. He had made the Three, and the Seven, and the Nine, and the Rings of Varda. He had learned ring-craft from Annatar. He knew what the One was, and what it did, and what it was doing to her, better than anyone except the shadow in the Tower. If he stood before the Valar and told them what had happened in Middle-earth, the Valar would have to decide what to do about it. Olórin said that the Elves who had fled West from Lindon had told the Valar what they knew, and that the Valar had done nothing, because the Elves of Lindon had not known enough. He said that Celebrimbor knew everything.

Pallando asked him how they could possibly get the Ring-maker out of the golden wood without the Queen knowing. Olórin said that they could not. He said that the Queen would know the moment Celebrimbor left, unless someone took his place.

The historian records that Pallando was silent for a long time, and that then he laughed, the first time anyone in the alliance had heard him laugh in seven hundred years. He said that the servants of the Valar were not bound to the shapes they wore, as the Elves and Men were, and that a Maia who had walked in Middle-earth for seven hundred years in the form of an old man in blue could, with some effort, walk in it in the form of an Elf of the house of Fëanor instead. He said that he had been looking for something useful to do for seven hundred years. He said that he would go to the golden wood.

Olórin asked him whether he understood what it would mean. He said that if Pallando took the Ring-maker's place, he would have to stay in it, perhaps forever. He would have to live beneath the green hill in Celebrimbor's face, and make rings for the Queen in Celebrimbor's forge, and answer to her, and never once let her see what he was. He would be alone, in the heart of her power, for as long as her dominion lasted. And Alatar was at her court. If anyone in Middle-earth could see through a Maia's disguise, it was another Maia. Pallando said that he understood. He said that he had been alone in the East for seven hundred years and had grown used to it. He said that he thought it would be rather interesting to see whether Alatar ever noticed.

He went west in the eighteen hundred and sixty-fifth year, the year before the battle, alone. The historian does not know how he crossed the Queen's dominion, from the Black Gate to the golden wood, without being seen. Olórin says that he went as a beggar, and a crow, and a wind, and other things that Olórin would not name. He came to the eaves of Lothlórien in the autumn, and he did not go in, because the Queen was there. He waited. He was waiting for her to leave. Olórin had told him that she would leave, when the alliance marched out of the Black Gate, because she would want to see it destroyed with her own eyes. Olórin was right. But that belongs to its place.

Chapter VI: The Coming of the Avari

The Avari came in the eighteen hundred and sixty-second year, fifty-eight years after Morwë had promised Thranduil at the eastern eaves of the Greenwood that they would come. The historian has the testimony of the Avari themselves, a few of whom came West in the grey ship, and of Thranduil, who was waiting for them.

They came out of the far East, from beyond the Red Mountains, from lands no Elf of the West had ever seen, and they came across the plains of Rhûn, which were the Queen's. Khavra of the horse-lords, with the star on her hand, rode out against them with every Easterling tribe that had knelt to the Queen, and the Avari fought their way through the Queen's East for three years to reach the Black Land. The Avari did not ride. They walked, and they walked through the plains of Rhûn at night, as Elves who had never seen the light of the Trees could walk, unseen, and they fought only when they were found. Khavra hunted them across the whole breadth of the East. She never caught them all. Of the perhaps twelve thousand Avari who set out from the East, some six thousand reached the Black Gate. They came through it on a winter night in the eighteen hundred and sixty-fifth year, silent and dark-eyed and hungry, and Morwë walked at their head.

He went to Thranduil first, as he had promised. Then he went to Gil-galad. The historian has Olórin's account of that meeting, and it is brief. Morwë stood before the High King of the Noldor, the last king of the people who had followed the summons of the Valar into the West and come back to Middle-earth with the Silmarils and a curse, and he did not bow. He said that the Avari had refused the Valar at Cuiviénen because they would not be ruled by anyone, even for their own good. He said that they had watched the Noldor come back from the West with their oaths and their wars, and drown a country, and they had not been sorry. He said that the Avari had come now because a Noldorin queen was trying to give all of Middle-earth the gift the Valar had offered the Elves at Cuiviénen, light and safety and a garden in exchange for obedience, and that the Avari had refused that gift once and would refuse it again, and would make sure no one else was forced to take it. He said that the Avari had not come for the Noldor. He said that the Avari had not come for the Dark Lord, whose shadow they could feel from the far side of the plain. He said that they had come for the orcs.

Gil-galad asked him what he meant. Morwë said that the orcs had been Elves once. He said that they had been Elves of the Avari, taken in the dark at the beginning of days by Morgoth's servants, before the summons of the Valar ever came to Cuiviénen, and twisted into what they were. He said that the Avari remembered. They had always remembered. They had never forgiven Morgoth, and they had never forgiven the Valar, who had known what Morgoth was doing to the Elves in the dark and had come too late. And they had never forgiven the Noldor, who had come back from the West and hunted the orcs for an age as vermin, and never once asked where they had come from. He said that the Queen of the West was feeding to her thorns the descendants of the Avari's own kin, who had been taken from Cuiviénen before the first sunrise, and that the Avari would not allow it while one of them still lived.

The historian records that Adar was present at this meeting, and that when Morwë finished speaking, Adar came forward and stood before him. They looked at each other for a long time. Then Morwë spoke a word in an Elvish so old that no one else in the tent could understand it. Olórin understood it. He told the loremasters that it was a name, a name of the Avari from the days before the first sunrise, and that he believed it was Adar's own name, the name he had borne before Morgoth took him, which he had not heard spoken in the whole long age since. Adar did not answer. Olórin said that he wept. He said that it was the only time he ever saw Adar weep, and that Adar did not hide it.

Chapter VII: The Queen in the Golden Wood

The Queen learned of the pact within a month of its swearing. Míriel saw it. The first of the Daughters of Varda, who could see the light inside every living thing across leagues of land and sea, had been watching the alliance since it came into Mordor, and she saw the lords of the alliance go up into the Tower and come down again with the darkness walking before them, and she knew what had happened. She came to Lothlórien herself to tell her mistress.

The testimony of Celebrimbor, who was in the forge beneath the green hill when Míriel came, records the Queen's reaction. He said that she laughed. He said that it was not a cruel laugh, or a triumphant one. It was the laugh of someone who has been told the end of a joke she has been waiting to hear for a long time. She said that the free peoples of the West had called her a tyrant and a servant of the Ring for a hundred and fifty years, and that they had made a pact with Sauron. She said that the High King of the Noldor had put his hand in the Dark Lord's hand. She said that Elendil, who had refused to kneel to her because he saw the light of Morgoth in her, was marching beside the shadow of Morgoth's own lieutenant. She said that she could not have asked for a better proof of everything she had ever said about them. She said that they were not fighting for freedom, or for the gift of Ilúvatar, or for the orcs. They were fighting because they could not bear that she had been right.

She had heralds proclaim the pact in every town and city of the Dominion. The historian has the words of the proclamation, which came West in the grey ship among the papers Celebrimbor carried. It said that the rebels of the West had sworn themselves to the Dark Lord, and had gone into the Black Land to raise his armies, and that the shadow of the Enemy was rising again in the East as it had risen in the days of the war against Eriador, and that the Queen would go out against it as she had gone out against it on the field of the Gwathló, and destroy it, and the rebels with it, so that the peoples of Middle-earth might live in peace forever. Every word of it was true. The Queen's subjects, who had eaten her bread and lived in her peace for a hundred and fifty years, heard it, and were afraid, and came to her by the tens of thousands. The host she gathered in the eighteen hundred and sixty-fifth year was the greatest ever gathered in Middle-earth. The historians of the West estimate it at more than two hundred thousand.

She did not want to lead it. Celebrimbor said that she told him so, in the forge beneath the green hill, on the night before she left. She said that she had not wanted the war, and had not started it, and had spent eighty years trying not to destroy the alliance, letting it go after the battle of the ruins, leaving the gap in the Gulf of Lune so that the Elves of Lindon could go West, calling the Balrog back from the Redhorn. She said that she had wanted them to understand. And now they had gone to Sauron, and there was nothing left to understand, and she would have to finish it. Celebrimbor asked her whether she was sure that it was she who wanted to finish it. She looked at him, he said, for a long moment, and the light of her rings was very bright, and he could not hold her gaze. She said that she was always sure. Then she said that she would be back before the spring, and that she would bring him the Dark Lord's tower for a forge, if he wanted it, since he had always wanted to see what the fire of Orodruin could do. He said that he did not want it. She smiled at him, he said, the way she had smiled at him in the gardens of Eregion when she was young, and kissed his forehead, and went up the stair.

He did not see her again for a thousand years.

There was one thing more the Queen did before she left the golden wood, and the historian must record it, because it was the most terrible thing she did in the whole of the war, and because no one knew of it until long afterward. She went down beneath Khazad-dûm, where the Balrog lay in the deep places waiting for her, and she gave it its orders. She spoke of this many centuries later, in the years of the Long Summer, to the one she believed was Celebrimbor, in the forge beneath the green hill, and what she said came West at the very end, by a road this history has not yet told. She said that the alliance had a champion, the lord of the golden flower, who had come back from the dead to fight the Balrog, and who had held it on the Redhorn. She said that as long as he lived, the alliance's soldiers would believe that they could win. She said that the Balrog was the one weapon in her service that she had never trusted, because she had never been sure that it was kneeling to her. She said that she had sent the Balrog to the battle that was coming, with orders to find Glorfindel and fight him, and that she had sent it knowing that the two of them would destroy each other. She said that it was the cleanest stroke of the whole war. She said that she had removed in a single afternoon the alliance's greatest hope and her own greatest danger, and that the alliance would think it was a victory. The historian notes here what the reader may already have guessed: that when the One called the Balrog back from the Redhorn, fifty years before, and kept the lord of Gondolin alive, it had been keeping him for this. The Ring had never trusted the Balrog either. It had wanted a sword that could rid it of the one servant in its keeping that remembered an older master, and it had found one.

The one who wore Celebrimbor's face asked her whether she had grieved for Glorfindel. She said that she had known him in Valinor, in the days of the Trees, when they were both young, and that he had been kind to her. She said that she had not grieved for him. She said that she had not grieved for anyone since Elrond, and that she had begun to wonder whether she still could.

Chapter VIII: The Battle of Dagorlad

The armies met on the plain of Dagorlad, before the Black Gate, on the ninth day of the fourth month of the eighteen hundred and sixty-sixth year. It was the largest battle in the history of Middle-earth since the War of Wrath, and the free peoples won it.

The historian will describe it more fully than he has described any other battle in this history, because it was the only one the alliance ever won, and because the soldiers who fought in it deserve to be remembered.

The Queen's host came up from the south and west across the plain in the dawn, two hundred thousand strong. At its center, under the Queen's banner, which was a white star on a field of gold, marched the knights of Númenor, with Míriel the Witch-Queen at their head, shining. To the left of them marched the horse-lords of Rhûn under Khavra, and the Haradrim under Amaret, and the Dunlendings under Cadha. To the right marched the Northmen under Hildrun, and the Men of the White Mountains who had stayed loyal to the Queen under Meneth, the king's daughter, and the Southlanders under Bronwyn and her son Theo. Before them all walked the Daughters of Varda: Míriel and Eärien, Estrid and Bronwyn, Khavra and Amaret, Hildrun and Meneth and Cadha, nine lights moving across the plain like stars fallen to the earth. Behind them came the Entwives, and behind the Entwives came the stone kings' Dwarves, and behind them, on a white horse, came the Queen.

The alliance stood before the Black Gate, perhaps seventy thousand strong. At its center stood the orcs of Mordor under Adar, forty thousand of them, in a single great mass, with their eyes uncovered. On their left stood the Elves of Lindon and the Faithful of Elendil and the Men of the White Mountains under Isildur. On their right stood the Easterlings and the Haradrim of the far East and South, and the Dwarves of Durin and of the Red Mountains, and the Silvan Elves of Thranduil. Behind them all, in reserve, stood the Avari, six thousand of them, silent, under Morwë. And over the whole host, though the day was bright, there lay a shadow, cold and dark as the shadow of a cloud, and in the heart of it a red light burned.

The Daughters of Varda came forward first, as they always had. They walked across the plain toward the line of the alliance with the light of their rings going before them, as they had walked through the line of the alliance at the battle of the ruins and in every battle of the War of the Weeds, and the Queen's host came behind them. And the Elves and Men of the alliance, on the left and right of the line, did what the orcs had taught them to do. They covered their eyes. They bound strips of black cloth across their faces, and they could not see the Daughters coming. And at the center of the line, the orcs of Mordor, who had been made in the dark to hate the light of the Elves, looked at the Daughters of Varda with their eyes wide open, and saw them as they were, and were not enthralled. They saw the White Pain. And they charged it.

The historians of the West have the testimony of the Queen's soldiers who survived that charge, and it is the only testimony in this history that describes the Daughters of Varda afraid. The soldiers said that the Daughters had walked across a hundred battlefields and never once seen an enemy who did not kneel to them. They said that when the orcs came out of the line of the alliance at a run, forty thousand of them, howling, with their eyes wide open and their weapons raised, the Daughters stopped. They did not understand what was happening. The light of their rings, which had brought armies to their knees, was falling on the orcs and doing nothing, except to make them angrier. The orcs reached them before the Queen's host behind them understood what was happening either. The Daughters of Varda were immortal and very strong, and they fought, and they killed hundreds of the orcs of Mordor in the first minutes of the charge. But there were forty thousand of them, and they did not stop, and they did not kneel.

Khavra of the horse-lords fell first. She had wheeled away from the orcs' charge toward the right of the alliance's line, where the Easterlings of the far East stood under the shadow of their old master, and she rode at them with the light of her ring blazing, as she had ridden across the plains of Rhûn for a hundred and fifty years, settling the quarrels of the tribes in the Queen's name. The Easterlings of the far East were her own people. Some of them were of her own tribe. They had refused the Queen's peace when Khavra brought it to them, and they had been hunted across the East for it, and they had come west across the whole breadth of Rhûn to stand in this line. They did not cover their eyes. They looked at her as she came, and the light of her ring fell on them, and some of them began to kneel. And then an old Easterling chieftain, whose name the testimony of the Easterlings gives as Ulfang, stepped out of the kneeling line with a spear in his hand and called her by her name. Not the name the Queen had given her, the testimony says, but the name her mother had given her, the name she had borne as a girl among the horse-lords before the star was put on her hand. Khavra stopped. Ulfang put the spear through her. The Easterlings of the far East say that as she fell, the light of her ring went out, and that her face, for a moment, was the face of an old woman.

Hildrun of the Northmen fell to Durin the Younger. The Dwarves of the testimony say that she came down on the right of the line with the Northmen behind her, and that Durin, who had covered his eyes with a strip of black cloth like the rest of the alliance, could not see her, but could hear her. He waited until she was close enough. Then he put his axe through the light, blind, where he judged her heart to be. He judged rightly. The Dwarves say that when he pulled the cloth from his eyes afterward and saw what he had killed, a woman of the Northmen with the face of a girl, he sat down on the field beside her and did not move for an hour, while the battle went on around him. Disa found him there. She said that he told her that he had wanted, for thirty years, to put his axe through one of the Queen's angels, and that he had done it, and that it had felt like nothing at all, and that he did not know what he had wanted it to feel like.

The other seven Daughters fell back. The orcs of Mordor drove them back across the plain into the ranks of the Queen's host, and the Queen's host, which had never fought a battle without the Daughters walking before it, broke. The knights of Númenor held, for a time, under Míriel. Then the Elves of Lindon and the Faithful of Elendil came in on their left with their eyes covered, fighting blind, guided by the orcs who ran among them calling out where the enemy was, and the knights of Númenor broke too. By midday the Queen's host was falling back across the plain of Dagorlad toward the south and west, and the alliance was following it.

The Balrog came at midday.

It came out of the south, from the direction of the Anduin, where it had come down through the mountains from the deep places beneath Khazad-dûm. It came across the plain in a storm of fire and shadow, through the Queen's own broken host, and the Queen's soldiers fled before it as the alliance's soldiers did. And it went straight, the testimony of every witness agrees, for the lord of Gondolin. It did not look at anyone else. Glorfindel was fighting on the left of the alliance's line among the Elves of Lindon, and the Balrog came through the Queen's host and through the alliance's line, killing everything in its path, and it reached him. He was waiting for it. He had pulled the black cloth from his eyes. He stood in the burned grass of Dagorlad with his sword in his hand and the light of the Blessed Realm about him, and the Balrog stopped before him, as it had stopped on the Redhorn. Olórin, who was near, said that Glorfindel spoke to it, as he had on the Redhorn, in the tongue of the Maiar and the dead. Olórin said that this time he understood what Glorfindel said. He said it was only: I told you that next time I would.

They fought for the rest of the afternoon. The historian will not describe it, because no one could. Olórin said only that it was like the fight on the Redhorn, but that this time the Balrog did not stop when the sun went down, because no one called it back. It had been sent to fight until it was finished. The two of them fought across the plain of Dagorlad in the gathering dusk, and the battle stopped around them, and the soldiers of both hosts stood and watched. And at the very end, with the sun gone down and the plain lit only by the fire of the Balrog and the light of the Blessed Realm, Glorfindel drove his sword into the Balrog's heart, and the Balrog wrapped its whip of flame around him and drew him into its fire. Olórin said that they fell together, as Glorfindel and the Balrog of Gondolin had fallen together from the cliff of Cirith Thoronath in the First Age. He said that when the fire went out, there was nothing left of either of them but a great black scar in the earth of Dagorlad, which is there still, and in the center of it, a sword.

The free peoples won the battle of Dagorlad. The Queen's host fell back across the plain in the night, and the alliance did not pursue it, because the alliance had lost twenty thousand dead, and its champion, and could not. The Queen's host had lost forty thousand, and two of the Daughters of Varda, and the Balrog of Khazad-dûm. The alliance's soldiers lit fires on the plain that night and sang. The orcs sang, and the Elves of Lindon sang, and the Faithful sang, and the Easterlings and the Haradrim and the Dwarves sang, each in their own tongue, and for one night the strangest host in the history of Middle-earth was one host. Grishak the orc, who carried the shield of Hallas, said that he heard an Elf of Lindon singing a song about Glorfindel that night, a lament, and that he did not understand the words but understood the tune, and that he sat down beside the Elf and listened, and that the Elf let him.

The historian records that the shadow in the Tower did not sing. Olórin, who was watching it, said that the red light in the heart of the darkness above the host burned brighter that night than it ever had. He said that he did not think the shadow was rejoicing in the victory. He thought it was rejoicing in the death of the Balrog, which had been the one servant of Morgoth in Middle-earth that had never served Sauron. And he thought it was rejoicing in what it had felt on the plain that day, from across the whole breadth of the field: the One on the Queen's hand, drawing on its full power for the first time since the binding at Khazad-dûm, when the Daughters fell. It had felt her reach for the Ring, Olórin said, and it had felt the Ring answer her. And it had felt, very faintly, the Ring answer it too.

Chapter IX: The Garden in the Ash

The Queen came into Mordor in the summer of the eighteen hundred and sixty-seventh year, herself, at the head of what remained of her host. She came, the historians of the West believe, for three reasons. She came because the alliance had defeated her at Dagorlad, and she could not let that stand. She came because the shadow in the Tower was rising again, and she had sworn on the field of the Gwathló that it would never trouble the world again. And she came because the One wanted to go home. Olórin has said that he felt it pulling, through Narya, all through that summer: pulling toward the mountain of fire where it had been made, as a river pulls toward the sea. He said that he did not think the Queen knew. He said that she believed she had chosen to come.

The alliance had expected her to come through the Black Gate, where it had defeated her at Dagorlad, and had fortified the Gate. She did not come through it. She came over the mountains of shadow, the Ephel Dúath, from the west, by the pass the orcs called Cirith Ungol, where a great spider had once lived in the First Age and where no army could pass. Her army passed. The historians of the West have the testimony of the orcs who watched from the rocks above the pass, and they say that the Queen walked at the head of her army through the dark pass with the light of her rings going before her, and that the dark of the pass fled from her, and that behind her, as she walked, flowers grew in the rock.

That was the first sign. The alliance's lords had believed, as the Queen herself had believed for a hundred and fifty years, that her power could not reach into Mordor, because there was nothing living there for it to take hold of. They were wrong. The shadow in the Tower had told them that the One was strongest where it had been made, and that the Queen would be able to do in the shadow of the mountain things she could do nowhere else. It had not told them what. Now they saw it. She came down out of the pass of Cirith Ungol onto the plain of Gorgoroth, and she began to plant.

She did not plant as the Entwives planted. The Entwives had come with her, and they could not plant in the ash, any more than they ever could. She planted with the One. She walked across the plain of Gorgoroth toward the mountain of fire, slowly, with her army behind her, and wherever she walked, the ash turned to soil, and the soil turned green. Grass grew in the ash. Then flowers. Then saplings, which grew into trees in a single night, golden trees like the trees of Lothlórien. The poisoned rivers ran clear. The fumes of the mountain thinned and blew away. The orcs who watched from the rocks said that it was like watching the dawn come up across the plain, except that it came up a little at a time, a few hundred paces each day, in a great green tide that spread out from wherever she walked, and that the dawn did not stop at sunset.

Olórin said that it was the most beautiful thing he had ever seen, and the most frightening. He said that the Queen was drawing on the One as she had never drawn on it before, because it was the only way to do what she was doing, and that he could feel the One on the other side of Narya, burning, as it had never burned before. He said that he could feel it drawing on her too. He said that each day she walked across the plain of Gorgoroth, there was a little less of Galadriel in her and a little more of the Ring. He said that the shadow in the Tower had told them that there would come a moment when the One was closer to its bearer's will than her own mind was, and that the alliance must be close enough to her in that moment to take it. He said that he believed the moment was coming. He said that he did not know whether there would be anything left of her when it came.

The alliance could not stand against the garden. It tried, in the first weeks of the summer. The orcs of Mordor went out against the Queen's host across the plain, and the Daughters of Varda went out against them, and the orcs drove the Daughters back as they had at Dagorlad. But wherever the orcs fought, the garden grew around them, and the orcs, who had lived in the ash for a century, did not know how to fight in a garden. The grass caught their feet. The trees grew up between them and broke their lines. The light, the green and golden light of the Queen's garden, hurt their eyes, and there was no dark left to hide in. They fell back. The alliance fell back with them. By midsummer the garden had spread across the whole western half of the plain of Gorgoroth, and the alliance had been driven back to the slopes of the mountain of fire and the foot of the Dark Tower, the last ash in Mordor. Everything else in the Black Land was green.

The alliance's lords held a council at the foot of the mountain on the night before the end. The historian has Olórin's account of it. Gil-galad said that there was nowhere left to fall back to. Elendil said that his daughter was in the Queen's host, on the far side of the garden, and that he could see her light from where he stood. Durin said that he had brought an axe for the White Lady and that he meant to use it. Adar said that if the alliance was going to die on the slopes of the mountain, the orcs would die with it, because there was nowhere left in Middle-earth where the orcs could live except here, and it was nearly gone. Thranduil said that the Avari had told him there was a way out of Mordor to the east, through the mountains of ash, which the orcs used, and that he would take his people out by it if the end came, and the Avari with them, and as many orcs as would come, and go east, to Cuiviénen, where the Elves had first awoken, beyond the edge of the world, where the Queen would never find them. He said that he would not stay to die in the shadow of the Dark Lord. Gil-galad said that he did not blame him.

And then the voice in the Tower spoke, to all of them, out of the darkness that lay over the slopes of the mountain. Olórin said that it had not spoken to the lords of the alliance since the swearing of the pact, except through Adar. Now it spoke to all of them at once. It said that the Queen would come to the mountain the next day. It said that she would come because the One was pulling her to it, and because the last ash in Mordor lay on the mountain's slopes, and she could not bear that any of it should remain. It said that she would come up the mountain to the fire in which the One was made, the Sammath Naur, the Chambers of Fire, because she would want to stand in the place where the One was born and plant a garden there, so that no one would ever be able to unmake it. It said that she would be drawing on the One more deeply than she had ever drawn on it, there in the place of its making, and that in that moment, the One would be closer to its own will than to hers. It said that the alliance must be waiting for her in the Chambers of Fire. It said that it would be waiting too.

Gil-galad asked it what it meant to do. The voice said that it meant to take back what was its own. Gil-galad asked it what would happen then. The voice was silent for a moment. Then it said that the alliance would be free of the Queen, as it had sworn, and that the orcs would be let alone, as it had sworn. And that what happened after that would be between it and the Ring.

Olórin said that he looked at Gil-galad then, and that Gil-galad looked back at him, and that neither of them said anything. The High King of the Noldor had sworn in the cave on the slopes of the Ephel Dúath that the One would never be given back to the Dark Lord, but carried into the fire and destroyed. He had kept that oath secret for fifteen years. Now the shadow in the Tower was telling the alliance that it would be waiting in the Chambers of Fire, where the One could be destroyed, and that it meant to take the Ring there. Olórin said that he understood, in that look, that the shadow knew. It had known all along. The alliance had meant to betray it in the Chambers of Fire, and it had always meant to betray the alliance there first.

Chapter X: The Chambers of Fire

The Queen came up the mountain of fire in the morning of the seventh day of the eighth month of the eighteen hundred and sixty-seventh year, and the historian must now set down the end of the war. He has the testimony of Olórin, who was in the Chambers of Fire, and of the few orcs who survived, and of the Queen herself, as she gave it to Celebrimbor many centuries later. Where they disagree, he has said so. He has not softened anything.

She came alone. She left her host at the foot of the mountain, in the garden, and walked up the road that the orcs had cut into the mountain's side long ago, toward the door of the Chambers of Fire, which opened on the mountain's eastern face, looking toward the Dark Tower. As she walked, the ash on the slopes of the mountain turned green behind her, and flowers grew in the cracks of the road. The alliance's soldiers, waiting on the slopes, watched her come, and did not try to stop her. The orcs say that some of them could not have stopped her if they had tried, because she was no longer something that could be stopped. They say that she shone so brightly that day that it was like watching the sun walk up the mountain. They say that the light of her did not hurt them, as the light of the Daughters of Varda hurt them. It simply made them want to lie down in the grass that was growing around them, and sleep, and never wake up.

The lords of the alliance were waiting in the Chambers of Fire. Gil-galad was there, and Elendil and his sons, and Durin and Disa, and Adar, and Olórin. Thranduil was not there. He had taken the Silvan Elves and the Avari and as many orcs as would go with them out of Mordor by the eastern way, in the night, on the alliance's orders, so that whatever happened on the mountain, some of the free peoples of Middle-earth would survive it. Arondir had gone with him. The historian records this because Arondir asked to stay, and Elendil told him to go, and said that someone had to remember what the alliance had been, and that it might as well be an Elf, since Elves remember longest. Arondir went. He did not see Bronwyn again.

And the shadow in the Tower was there. It had come across the plain from Barad-dûr in the night, a darkness moving across the last ash in Mordor, and it filled the Chambers of Fire as it had filled the highest hall of the Tower. The red light burned at its heart, above the great crack in the floor of the Chambers through which the fire of the mountain could be seen, far below, burning. The lords of the alliance stood in the darkness, around the edge of the crack, with torches that would not burn, and waited.

She came in through the door, and the darkness fled from her. Olórin said that it did not retreat. It simply ceased to be, wherever her light touched it, and the Chambers of Fire, which had been dark since the One was forged, were full of light for the first time since the world was young. And in that light the lords of the alliance saw her as she was. Olórin said that she was still Galadriel. She was tall, and fair, and her hair was the gold of the Trees, and she wore white. But her eyes were silver now, entirely silver, without any grey in them at all, and her face was still as marble, and the light that came from her was not the light of Nenya any longer. It was the light of the One. She looked at them, and she smiled, and Olórin said that it was the most beautiful smile he had ever seen, and that there was nothing behind it.

She said that she had come to end the war. She said that she had come to plant a garden in the Chambers of Fire, so that the place where the One was made would be green forever, and the fire of the mountain would never burn again. She said that she was sorry it had come to this. She said that she had loved some of them. She looked at Elendil when she said it, and at Olórin, and at Gil-galad. She said that they could still kneel, and live, and eat the bread of the Dominion, and never die. She said that it was the last time she would offer.

No one knelt. And then the shadow moved.

It went toward her. Olórin said that it went toward her the way a river goes toward the sea, the way the One had been pulling toward the mountain all through that summer, and that the red light at its heart was burning so brightly that he could not look at it. The lords of the alliance moved too. Durin went toward her with his axe raised. Gil-galad went toward her with his sword. Isildur, who had been standing at the edge of the crack beside his father, went toward her with his hand outstretched toward the One on her finger, as Olórin had told him to in the night, because the alliance had decided that whatever happened, someone must be ready to take the Ring and throw it into the crack.

And the Ring called.

Every witness agrees on this, and none of them can describe it. Olórin said only that the One on her hand spoke, there in the Chambers of Fire where it had been made, not to her and not to any of them but to the shadow, in a voice that he heard through Narya on its chain around his neck, and that what it said was a single word in the Black Speech of Mordor, and that the word was the shadow's name. Not the name Sauron, which the Elves had given him. Not Annatar, or Gorthaur, or Halbrand. The name he had borne in the beginning, before he was any of those things, when he was a servant of Aulë the Smith in the days before the world was made. Olórin said that he had not heard it spoken since the Music of the Ainur. He said that the shadow had not heard it either. And he said that when the Ring spoke it, the shadow broke.

It turned. In the Chambers of Fire, at the edge of the crack, with the Queen's hand a few paces away and the One shining on it, the shadow of the Dark Lord turned away from her, and fell on the alliance. It fell on Gil-galad first. The High King of the Noldor was nearest to the Queen with his sword raised, and the shadow came down on him, cold and dark as the bottom of the world, and Olórin said that he heard Gil-galad cry out once, and that when the shadow lifted from him he was dead, and his body was black and burned as though he had been thrown into the fire of the mountain, and there was no wound on him. Vilya, which he had carried locked in a casket in his robes since the fall of Lindon, fell out of his robes onto the floor of the Chambers and rolled to the Queen's feet. She did not look at it. Míriel, who came into the Chambers behind her, picked it up.

The shadow fell on Durin next. Disa threw herself in front of him, the Dwarves who survived say, and the shadow took her first, and Durin roared and swung his axe through the darkness where the red light burned, and the axe went through it as through smoke, and the shadow took him too. They died together at the edge of the crack. The last free Dwarves of the West died with them, on the slopes of the mountain, when the shadow went out of the Chambers of Fire and down the mountain into the alliance's host, and fell on them in the darkness it carried with it. The Dwarves of the testimony say that the last of Durin's folk fought in that darkness until there were none of them left, and that they could not see what they were fighting, and that they did not stop.

The orcs were next. The historian has the testimony of the orcs who survived, and he has read it many times, and he does not know how to set it down. The shadow went down the mountain into the forty thousand orcs of Mordor whom it had sworn, in the highest hall of Barad-dûr, to let alone, and it did not let them alone. It took them, the orcs say. Not all of them, and not by killing them. It took their minds. It had made them, long ago, in the dark, as Morgoth's lieutenant, and it knew their names, as Adar had said, and it called them by their names, and they turned. Half the orcs of Mordor turned on the alliance in the space of an hour, with the shadow's voice in their minds, and the other half fought them, and the slopes of the mountain of fire ran with orc blood while the Queen's garden grew up around them.

Adar fought the shadow. The orc testimony is unanimous about this, and the historian has no reason to doubt it. He went out of the Chambers of Fire after it, down the mountain, into the darkness, calling his children by their names, the names he had always known, trying to call them back. Some of them came back. Most did not. He found the heart of the darkness at last, on the slope below the Chambers of Fire, where the red light was burning above a heap of the dead, and he went into it with his sword raised, as he had gone into it once before, in the years after the War of Wrath, when he had killed it. He did not kill it this time. It had no body to kill. The orcs who saw him go in did not see him come out. When the darkness lifted from that slope, hours later, Adar was lying at the edge of the heap of the dead with his sword in his hand, alive, and the Queen was standing over him.

Chapter XI: The Death of Elendil

While the shadow went down the mountain, the Queen remained in the Chambers of Fire, and the historian must now record what happened there, because it was the end of the house of Elendil.

Elendil was standing at the edge of the crack when the shadow fell on Gil-galad. He had his sword in his hand. He did not go toward the Queen, as Gil-galad and Durin had gone toward her. He went toward the door of the Chambers, because his daughter had come in through it behind the Queen, with Míriel and the other Daughters of Varda, and she was standing in the doorway, shining. He went toward her. Olórin said that he went toward her the way he had gone toward her across the great square of Ost-in-Edhil at the battle of the ruins, with his sword in his hand and the light falling on him, and that he did not cover his eyes. He wanted to see her.

She raised her sword. Olórin said that she raised it as she had raised it in the great square at the battle of the ruins, and that Elendil stopped a few paces from her, as he had then, and looked at her, and that they stood like that for a long moment while the shadow raged on the slopes of the mountain outside. Then Elendil lowered his sword. He let it fall to the floor of the Chambers. He held out his empty hands to her. And Olórin said that he spoke to her, and that what he said was: I am looking at you. I am looking at you the way I looked at them. I always was. I am sorry you could not see it.

And Eärien killed him.

The historians of the West have argued about this more than about any other single death in this history. Some of them say that Eärien did not mean to kill her father. They say that the light of the One was in her, through her ring, and that the One saw a lord of the alliance with his sword on the floor and his hands outstretched toward the Queen's servant, and struck him through her, as it had struck Pharazôn through the Queen's eyes. Some of them say that she meant it. They say that she had been waiting her whole life for her father to say those words to her, and that he said them a hundred years too late, and that she could not bear it. Olórin, who was there, says that he does not know. He says that he saw her face as she did it, and that it was as still as marble, and that the tears on it were shining. And he says that after Elendil fell, she knelt down beside him on the floor of the Chambers of Fire, and took his head in her lap, and sat there with him until the end of the day, and did not speak, and did not let anyone come near.

Anárion died on the slopes of the mountain, in the darkness, fighting the orcs whom the shadow had turned. The historian has no account of his death except that his body was found afterward among the dead of the Faithful, with the shield of the White Tree still on his arm.

Isildur was in the Chambers of Fire, standing a few paces from the Queen, with his hand still outstretched toward the One on her finger, when his father died. He had been going toward her, as Olórin had told him to, to take the Ring and throw it into the crack, and he had stopped when the shadow turned, and he had not moved since. He watched his father die. He watched his sister kneel beside the body. And then, Olórin said, he turned and looked at the Queen, and she looked at him.

She said his name. She said it gently, Olórin said, the way she had said it on the raft in the Sundering Sea, long ago, when Elendil's ship had pulled her out of the water and Isildur had been a boy on the deck, staring at the Elf-woman who had come out of the sea. She said that his father had refused to kneel to her for a hundred and sixty-seven years, and that it had come to this. She said that she had never wanted it to come to this. She said that his sister was weeping, and that his father was dead, and that his brother was dying on the slopes of the mountain, and that the woman he had loved in the wild was standing behind her, in the doorway of the Chambers of Fire, shining, and had been waiting for him for a hundred and sixty years. She said that he did not have to lose anyone else. She said that he only had to kneel.

Olórin was standing at the edge of the crack. He told the loremasters of Avallónë that he called to Isildur then, as loudly as he could, and that Isildur did not hear him. He said that he tried to go to him, and that he could not move. The light of the One was on him, and he was of the order of the Maiar, and still he could not move through it. He said that he watched Isildur look at the Queen, and then past her, at the doorway, where Estrid was standing with the light of her ring about her, young as she had been on the day he met her in the wild, a hundred and sixty years before. He said that he watched Isildur look at his sister kneeling beside their father's body. He said that he watched Isildur look at his own hand, which was still outstretched toward the One.

And then Isildur knelt.

He knelt on the floor of the Chambers of Fire, at the Queen's feet, a few paces from the crack in the floor where the fire of the mountain burned far below, where the One could have been thrown and destroyed. Olórin said that it was the closest anyone in that age ever came. He said that Isildur's hand, when he knelt, was perhaps an arm's length from the Ring. He said that Isildur looked at it for a long moment, kneeling, and that the Queen let him look. And then Isildur bowed his head and laid his hand on the floor, palm down, at her feet, and did not reach.

The Men of the White Mountains were on the slopes of the mountain, outside the Chambers of Fire, fighting the orcs whom the shadow had turned. They had sworn on the black stone of Erech to follow Isildur son of Elendil until the end, and to fight beside him against the Queen. And Isildur had sworn on the same stone that he would never kneel to her while they followed him. The historian has the testimony of one of them, a young man of the mountains who came West in the grey ship, because Olórin found him wounded on the slopes and carried him to the Old Forest. He said that the Men of the mountains felt it when Isildur knelt. He said that they all felt it at once, like a door closing. He said that they stopped fighting, and turned, and looked up at the door of the Chambers of Fire, and that Isildur came out of it a little while later, behind the Queen, with his head bowed. And he said that the Men of the mountains had sworn to follow him. So they followed him. They followed him down the mountain into the Queen's garden, and knelt to the Queen there, because Isildur had knelt, and they had sworn to do as he did. The young man of the mountains said that he did not kneel, because he was wounded and could not stand, and that he lay on the slope and watched his people go down into the garden, and that he did not know whether they had kept their oath or broken it. The loremasters of Avallónë have not decided either. They have decided only that in another age, if Isildur had broken his oath and the Men of the mountains had broken theirs, they might have been cursed. In this one, Isildur broke his oath and the Men of the mountains kept theirs, and they were the Queen's forever.

Chapter XII: The Shadow at Her Feet

When the darkness lifted from the slopes of the mountain of fire, toward evening, the war was over.

The alliance was destroyed. Gil-galad was dead, and Elendil, and Anárion, and Durin and Disa, and Glorfindel before them. The Faithful were dead, or kneeling. The Dwarves of Durin were dead, to the last of them. The Elves of Lindon were dead, or fled. The Easterlings and the Haradrim of the far East and South had broken and fled when the shadow turned, back across the plain, and the Queen's riders were hunting them. The orcs of Mordor were dead, or the shadow's, or fled east into the mountains of ash after Thranduil and the Avari. The Queen stood at the door of the Chambers of Fire, looking out over the plain of Gorgoroth, and the plain was green from the mountains of shadow to the mountains of ash, and the only darkness left in the Black Land was the darkness that lay on the slope below her, over the heap of the dead, where Adar lay.

She went down to it. The darkness drew back from her as she came, and the red light at its heart dimmed. The orcs who survived, hidden among the rocks of the slope, watched her come, and they say that the shadow did not flee from her as it had fled from her on the field of the Gwathló. It went to her. It came across the slope to her feet like a dog coming to its master, and lay there, at her feet, dark and cold and quiet, with the red light burning very low. She looked down at it. And the orcs say that she spoke to it, and that she called it by the name the Ring had called it in the Chambers of Fire, and that the shadow shuddered at her feet like something being struck.

She did not destroy it. The historians of the West have recorded what she did instead, from the testimony of the orcs and from the Queen's own account. She bound it. She took the One from her hand, for the first time since the field of the Gwathló, and held it over the shadow at her feet, and spoke to the shadow through the Ring, and the shadow went into the shape she gave it. It was not the fair form of Annatar or the form of Halbrand, or any form the Dark Lord had ever worn. It was the form of a Man, small and grey and bent, with red eyes, and chains on its wrists and ankles that were made of nothing but her will. She put the Ring back on her hand. The shadow knelt before her in its new shape, in its chains, and bowed its head. She told it that it would kneel at the foot of her throne for as long as she ruled, and that it would never leave, and never speak unless she spoke to it, and never be free. It said nothing. Its red eyes, the orcs say, never left the Ring on her hand.

Then she turned to Adar.

He was lying at the edge of the heap of the dead, with his sword still in his hand, alive. He had gone into the darkness to fight the shadow and come out of it broken, and he could not rise. She knelt beside him. The orcs who watched from the rocks say that it was the first time they had ever seen her kneel. She looked at him for a long time. She had held a blade to his throat on the field below Ostirith, long ago, and sworn to him that she would exterminate every one of his children in every hole in which they hid. She had purged his people in the shadow of the mountain, in the Dark Lord's name. She had fed his children to her thorns for a hundred and fifty years. And now his children were dead on the slopes of the mountain around them, or bound to the shadow at her feet, or fled east into the mountains of ash, and he was dying.

She asked him his name.

The orcs say that she asked it gently. They say that she asked it the way someone asks the name of a stranger they have met on a road. She said that Morwë of the Avari had called him by a name once, in the tent of the High King, and that she wanted to know it. She said that she wanted to know what he had been called before Morgoth took him. She said that she had never known the name of a single one of his children, and that she thought she should know his.

Adar looked up at her. The orcs say that he smiled. And he said: You will have to learn it.

He died. The orcs say that he died with his eyes open, looking at her, as Pharazôn had died, but that there were no tears on his face, and that he did not look as though he had seen anything beautiful. They say that he looked as though he had won something. The Queen knelt beside him for a while longer. Then she rose and went back up the mountain to the Chambers of Fire. The orcs who were hiding in the rocks waited until she was gone, and then they came down and took Adar's body, and carried it east, into the mountains of ash, after Thranduil and the Avari. The historian does not know where they buried him. He does not think the orcs would tell him if he asked.

Chapter XIII: The Grey Ship

Olórin did not die in the Chambers of Fire. He should have. He was standing at the edge of the crack when the shadow turned, and the shadow passed over him on its way to Gil-galad, and he said that he felt it pass, and that it did not touch him. He did not know why. He has since come to believe that it was Narya, which he wore on its chain beneath his robes, and which the shadow could feel, and which it did not want to touch, because it was one of the Three, made without its hand. Or perhaps it was the Queen, who did not want him dead. He does not know. He knows only that when Isildur knelt, and Elendil lay dead in his daughter's lap, and the Queen turned at last toward him, he was the last of the lords of the alliance still standing in the Chambers of Fire.

She looked at him for a long time. Then she told him to go. She said that he had been sent from the West to oppose the Dark Lord, and that the Dark Lord was broken and chained and would kneel at the foot of her throne forever, and that his work in Middle-earth was done. She said that he should go back West, to the Valar who had sent him, and tell them what had happened in Middle-earth. She said that she wanted them to know. She said that they had sat in the Blessed Realm while her brother died in a cell and her husband drowned in the sea, and that they had come too late to save anyone, as they always did. She said that she wanted them to know that she had not come too late. She said that she wanted them to know that the world was saved, and that she had saved it, and that it did not need them any longer. And she said that if he ever came back, she would kill him.

He went. He went down the mountain in the dusk, through the garden, past the Queen's host, which let him pass because she had told it to, and out of the Black Land by the pass of Cirith Ungol, where flowers grew now in the rock. He found the young man of the White Mountains wounded on the slopes and carried him, and a few orcs who had hidden in the rocks found him and followed him, because they had nowhere else to go. He went west. He told the loremasters of Avallónë that he did not remember much of the journey. He said that he walked for most of a year, across the Queen's dominion, through the orchards and past the thorn-groves, hiding, and that he wore Narya on its chain beneath his robes the whole way and did not dare to put it on. He said that he did not know where he was going until he got there.

He went to the Old Forest. He came under its eaves in the summer of the eighteen hundred and sixty-eighth year, with the young man of the mountains on his back and a dozen orcs behind him, and the trees let him in. He walked to the house by the river. And the master of the house came out to meet him, singing, and told him that he was very late, and that the other one had been waiting for him for a month, and had eaten a great deal of honey.

The other one was Celebrimbor.

The historian must now go back a year, to the golden wood, and to the night after the Queen left Lothlórien to march against the alliance. Pallando the Blue Wizard had been waiting at the eaves of the wood since the autumn before. When the Queen and her host were three days gone, he went in. The historian has Celebrimbor's account of what followed. He said that he was sitting in the forge beneath the green hill, in the night, at his anvil, not working, when an old man in blue came down the stair, and that before he could cry out, the old man had put a hand over his mouth and told him, very quietly, that Olórin had sent him, and that they had very little time. Celebrimbor said that he did not believe it at first. He said that Pallando told him three things that only Olórin could have known, and then told him the plan, and that when he understood the plan, he wept, because he understood that someone was offering to spend the rest of his existence in a cell beneath the green hill so that Celebrimbor could go free.

He asked Pallando why. Pallando said that the Ring-maker was the only witness who could make the Valar act. Celebrimbor said that he did not want the Valar to act. He said that he had seen what happened when the Valar acted: whole countries sank beneath the sea. He said that he did not know whether the Queen was wrong. He said that he had made rings for her for a hundred and fifty years and watched her feed the world and heal it and keep it from dying, and that he did not know whether anything the Valar could do would be better. Pallando said that he did not know either. He said that this was why the Valar should hear it from someone who did not know, rather than from someone who was sure. He said that the Queen was sure. He said that the alliance had been sure, in its way. He said that the Valar had heard from enough people who were sure.

Celebrimbor went. He went up the stair in the night, past the Silvan guards, who saw an old man in blue going out and thought nothing of it, because the Queen's council had been full of old men in blue since Alatar came. And Pallando sat down at the anvil in the forge beneath the green hill, and took Celebrimbor's face, and Celebrimbor's hands, and Celebrimbor's voice, and when the Silvan healers came down the stair in the morning with the Ring-maker's breakfast, they found the Ring-maker at his anvil, working, and did not notice anything at all.

Celebrimbor walked west, through the Queen's dominion, as Olórin would walk a year later. He went to the Old Forest because Olórin had told Pallando to tell him to, and because Olórin had said that it was the only place in Eriador where the Queen could not see. The master of the house took him in, and fed him, and let him sit by the river with the orc-children who had grown up there, and did not ask him anything. He waited a year. And then Olórin came under the eaves of the forest, with the young man of the mountains on his back and a dozen orcs behind him, and they wept, the two of them, the Maia and the Elf, in the garden of lilies before the house by the river, and the master of the house brought them supper.

They stayed a month. Olórin told the loremasters that it was the first time since the burning of Rómenna that he had slept through a night. Then the master of the house walked with them to the western eaves of the forest, and showed them a path that went west, through the Queen's orchards, that no one in the Dominion could see, and told them that it would take them to the Sea. They asked him whether he would come. He laughed, and said that he had never left his forest and never would, and that someone had to feed the orc-children. They asked him whether he was afraid of the Queen. He said that she had come to supper once, and that she had been very sad, and that he was not afraid of sad people. He said that he was rather sorry for her. Then he went back into his forest, singing, and they did not see him again.

The path took them to the Grey Havens. The Havens were a garden now. The Entwives had planted them in the years after the fall of Lindon, and the great hall of Gil-galad was overgrown with flowering vines, and there were fruit-trees growing on the quays where the ships of Círdan had sailed. There were no ships. But at the end of the last quay, where the Gulf of Lune opened to the Sea, there was a grey ship riding at anchor in the dusk, small and plain, with no one aboard. Olórin said that he knew it at once. It was the last ship of Círdan the Shipwright, which Círdan had once told him he would keep at the Havens until the end of days, for the last of the Elves who wished to go West. Círdan had sailed with the fall of Lindon. He had left his last ship behind. And the Queen's servants had planted the Havens around it for eighty years without ever once seeing it, as the Queen's servants had never once seen the path through the orchards, because it was not meant for them.

They sailed in the autumn of the eighteen hundred and sixty-eighth year: Olórin, with Narya on its chain; Celebrimbor, the Ring-maker; the young man of the White Mountains, who had not knelt; and the dozen orcs who had followed Olórin out of Mordor, among whom were Grishak, who carried the shield of Hallas, and an orc mother named Ushgra, who had escaped from a thorn-grove near the ruins of Eregion a hundred and thirty years before with one of her three young, and who had spent the war in Adar's host, and who had come out of the Black Land with Olórin because she said that she wanted to see the West, where the Elves had come from, and ask them why. The grey ship went out of the Gulf of Lune on the evening tide, and the wind came out of the East behind it, and the Sea was very calm. Olórin said that as they passed out of the Gulf, he looked back, and saw the Queen's orchards on the hills of Lindon, golden in the last light, and that they were the most beautiful thing he had ever seen, and that he wept, and did not know why.

The Queen did not know that Celebrimbor had gone. She would not know for a thousand years. In the forge beneath the green hill, the Ring-maker went on working, with Pallando's patience and Celebrimbor's face. And somewhere in the Queen's court, Alatar, who had been a Blue Wizard once, and who had walked beside Pallando in the East for seven hundred years, began, very slowly, to wonder why the Ring-maker had grown so quiet.

Chapter XIV: Yavannia

The Queen did not go back to Lothlórien. She stayed in Mordor, and made it her seat.

The historians of the West have recorded the making of Yavannia from the testimony of the Elves of the golden wood who came to it in the years afterward, and from the Queen's own account to Celebrimbor, who was by then Pallando, and who reported it to no one until the Long Summer was nearly over. It took her ten years. She began on the morning after the war ended, on the slopes of the mountain of fire, and she did not stop until the whole of the Black Land, from the mountains of shadow to the mountains of ash, and from the Black Gate to the sea of Núrnen, was a forest.

It was not a garden like the gardens of the Entwives, in rows, pruned and ordered. It was a forest like the forests of the Elder Days, before the Sun, when the Elves first woke beneath the stars at Cuiviénen. The trees were golden, like the trees of Lothlórien, and taller, and older, though they had been planted only a year before. The rivers ran clear and cold out of the mountains. There were flowers in the grass that no Elf of Middle-earth had ever seen, flowers that the loremasters of Avallónë say had not bloomed in Middle-earth since the Trees were destroyed. There were birds. There were deer. The orcs who survived in the mountains of ash at the edge of it, and watched it grow, said that it was like watching the world being made again from the beginning, and that they did not know whether to be glad or afraid, and that they were both.

The Dark Tower vanished. She did not tear it down. She made the forest grow over it, and the trees grew up through its windows and its stairs and its great halls, and their roots broke its foundations, and in ten years there was nothing left of Barad-dûr but a hill of golden trees, with a few black stones showing through the grass. On the summit of that hill, where the highest hall of the Tower had been, where the shadow had burned with its red eye for a hundred and fifty-five years, she had a hall built of white stone and living wood, open to the sky, with a throne in it, and that was her seat.

And the mountain of fire went out. This is the last thing the historian must record about the making of Yavannia, and it is the most important. The Queen went up the mountain to the Chambers of Fire, where the One had been made, and where it could have been unmade, and she planted a garden there. She did it with the One, drawing on it in the place of its making as she had drawn on it in the last days of the war, and the fire in the crack in the floor of the Chambers, which had burned since the world was young, sank down into the roots of the mountain and went cold. Grass grew in the Chambers of Fire. Flowers grew in the crack. The mountain, which had smoked and burned since the day Adar's orcs flooded its tunnels and woke it, stood silent over the forest, green to its summit. Orodruin, the Mountain of Fire, was a mountain of flowers.

The historians of the West have understood what that meant, though the Queen's subjects did not. The One Ring could be destroyed only in the fire in which it was made. That fire was gone. There was no longer any place in the world where the One could be unmade. The Queen had planted a garden over the only door out of her dominion, and she had done it with the One itself, and the loremasters of Avallónë have argued ever since about whose idea it was. Olórin has said that he does not think it was hers.

She named the forest Yavannia, after Yavanna, the Giver of Fruits, the Queen of the Earth, the Vala who had made the Two Trees and loved all growing things. The historians of the West have noted that this was the second time the Queen had taken the name of a Vala for her own work, after the Rings of Varda, and that she did it, in both cases, as a message. The Valar had made the Trees, and lost them, and gone into the West and left Middle-earth in the dark. She had made the light again, in the place where the darkness had been deepest. She had named it after the Vala who had loved the Trees most, so that the Valar would know, when they heard of it, that she had done what they had failed to do.

On the day the hall on the hill was finished, the Queen came into it, in white, with the One and Nenya on her hand and Vilya on a chain around her neck, and sat down on the throne. The Daughters of Varda stood around her, seven of them now, shining. Isildur son of Elendil stood at her right hand, in a white robe, with a staff of white wood, and she named him her Herald, the Voice of the Queen, and gave him the office of carrying her word to every court of Middle-earth, as the Mouth of Sauron had once carried the Dark Lord's. He would hold that office for a very long time. The bread of the Dominion and the light of Yavannia would keep him alive through the whole of the Long Summer, and he would never once speak of his father, and the people of Middle-earth, who had forgotten the war within a few generations, would know him only as the Herald, the grave and silent Man in white who spoke for the Queen. Eärien stood behind him. She did not speak to him. The historians of the West have recorded that in all the long years of the Long Summer, the brother and sister stood within a few paces of each other at the foot of the Queen's throne, and never once spoke.

And at the foot of the throne, on the lowest step, there knelt a small grey bent figure with red eyes and chains on its wrists and ankles that were made of nothing but her will. It did not speak. It did not move. Its red eyes never left the Ring on her hand. The Queen's subjects, who came to Yavannia from every corner of Middle-earth in the years that followed, saw it there and did not know what it was. The heralds told them that it was the last servant of the Dark Lord, kept as a reminder of the darkness from which the Queen had saved the world. They believed it. It was true, as far as it went.

Chapter XV: The Queen Alone

The historian comes now to the last thing he has to tell in the history of the war, and it is the only thing in this book that happened with no one there to see it. The Queen told it to Celebrimbor, or to the one she believed was Celebrimbor, many centuries later, in the forge beneath the green hill, in the years of the Long Summer. Pallando, wearing the Ring-maker's face, wrote it down. The writing came West, at the very end, by a road this history has not yet told. The historian sets it down here as Pallando wrote it.

It was the night after the hall on the hill was finished. The Queen had sat on her throne all day, receiving the lords of the Dominion, who had come from every corner of Middle-earth to kneel to her in her new seat. When they had gone, and the Daughters of Varda had gone, and Isildur had gone, she stayed. She sat alone on her throne in the hall open to the sky, with the golden trees of Yavannia around her and the stars above, and the grey figure kneeling on the lowest step below her with its red eyes on the Ring. She said that she had not been alone in a long time. She said that she had forgotten what it was like.

She said that she thought, that night, about the war. She thought about Elrond on the bridge over the Sirannon. She thought about Glorfindel, who had been kind to her in Valinor, and whom she had sent to die. She thought about Elendil lying in his daughter's lap. She thought about Adar, who had asked her to learn his name. She thought about Finrod, in the cell on Tol-in-Gaurhoth, looking at her across the corridor before the end, not afraid. She said that she tried to weep for them, as she had wept for Celebrimbor in the cells of Eregion, and that she could not. She said that she felt nothing at all. She said that she had felt nothing at all since the Chambers of Fire, and that she did not know when she had stopped.

And then she said that she thought about the One. She said that she looked at it on her hand, in the starlight, and that she thought, for the first time, really thought, about the moment in the Chambers of Fire when it had called the shadow by its name. She said that she had not called the shadow. She had not told the Ring to call it. The Ring had done it by itself. And she said that she had begun, sitting there alone, to remember other moments. The night on the field of the Gwathló when her arm would not move. The voice in the war councils of Barad-dûr that had not quite been her own. The thought that had come to her in Lothlórien when Sauron forged the One, a heartbeat before she thought it, which she had assumed was hers. The certainty. Always the certainty, from the first night she kept Nenya on, that only she could save the world, and that she must never let it go.

She said that she understood, sitting alone on her throne in Yavannia, that the thought had never been entirely hers. She said that she could not tell any longer where she ended and the Ring began, and that she had not been able to tell for a very long time, perhaps since the beginning, and that everything she had done, every life she had saved and every life she had taken, had been done by something that was partly her and partly the thing on her hand, and that she would never know which part was which.

She said that she took it off.

She said that she sat on her throne with the One Ring in her open palm, in the starlight, and looked at it, and that the grey figure on the lowest step below her raised its head, for the first time since she had bound it, and looked at the Ring too. She said that for a moment, with the Ring in her palm and not on her finger, she felt what she had felt in the Old Forest, when it was on the finger of the master of the house by the river. She said that it felt like being able to breathe. And she said that in that moment, she could feel everything she had not felt since the Chambers of Fire. She could feel Elrond. She could feel Glorfindel. She could feel Elendil, and Adar, and the orc-children in the thorns, all of them, at once, and that it was more than she could bear.

She said that she thought about the mountain. She said that she thought about the Chambers of Fire, where the fire had gone out, and about how she had put it out, and about how she did not know any longer whether she had wanted to. She said that she thought about the Valar, in the West, and what they would do when Olórin told them what she had done. She said that she thought about the world without her: the hunger coming back, and the fevers, and the wars, and the dragons, if there had been any dragons left, and the orcs, if there had been any orcs left, and the children dying. She said that she thought about the farmer of Bree and his daughter, and the Harfoot woman who had wept because the Elves never came, and the mother of Númenor who had held her son while he died of a fever. She said that she thought about Finrod, in the cell, and how she had sworn that she would never be powerless again.

And then she said that she put it back on.

She said that she did not do it because the Ring told her to. She said that she was sure of that. She said that for once, for that one moment, alone in the starlight with the Ring in her palm, she had been able to tell the difference between its voice and her own, and that the Ring had been silent. She said that she had put it back on because she had looked at everything she could feel without it, and everything the world would be without her, and decided that she did not care whose thought it had been. She said that the world was saved. She said that she had saved it. She said that it did not matter any longer how much of her had done it.

Pallando wrote that the Queen was silent for a long time after she told him this. Then she said that she had understood, in that moment, that she was no longer Galadriel. She said that Galadriel had died somewhere, she did not know where. Perhaps in the cell on Tol-in-Gaurhoth, or on the plain before the sea, or on the bank of the Glanduin with Halbrand's hand in hers, or in Lothlórien on the night she kept Nenya on. She said that what was left was the Queen. And she said that the Queen did not grieve, and did not doubt, and did not let go of anything, ever, because she had learned on the plain before the sea what happened to things you let go of.

Pallando wrote that he asked her, in the Ring-maker's voice, whether she was happy. And he wrote that she smiled at him, the most beautiful smile he had ever seen, and that there was nothing behind it, and that she said: I am unfading.

So ended the war, in the eighteen hundred and seventy-seventh year of the Second Age, with the Queen alone on her throne in Yavannia, with the One Ring on her hand and the Dark Lord at her feet and the whole of Middle-earth green and fed and at peace around her, from the Blue Mountains to the Sea of Rhûn and from the Ice to the bay of Umbar. The free peoples were dead, or kneeling, or fled to the edge of the world. The fire in which the Ring was made had gone out. And in the West, beyond the Sea, a grey ship was coming to the shores of the Blessed Realm, carrying a Maia with a red ring on a chain around his neck, and the maker of the rings, and a young man of the mountains who had not knelt, and a dozen orcs who wanted to ask the Elves why.

Here ends the sixth book of The Queen Unfading, and the history of the war.

What came after, in the long years of the Summer, belongs to another book.

 
Read more...

from Blog of Sand

FICTIONAL WHAT IF: Part IX- What if Galadriel Was The Antagonist in The War of the Rings? Volume 5

BOOK FIVE: THE LONG DEFEAT From the Flight of the Faithful to the Retreat into the Black Land

Compiled in Avallónë upon Tol Eressëa, from the testimony of those who came West

A Note on This Book

The loremasters of Avallónë call the war described in this book the War of the Weeds. The name was the Queen's before it was theirs. She used it once, in council, to describe the enemies gathering at the edges of her garden, and her heralds spread it across Middle-earth as a mockery, and the alliance took it up as a badge, as the oppressed so often take up the names their masters give them. The historian uses it here because it is honest. It was a war fought by the few against the many, by the hungry against the fed, by those who would not kneel against those who had knelt gladly and had good reason to. It lasted eighty years. The alliance lost nearly every battle in it.

It is also, the historian must warn the reader, the war in which the alliance brought death back into the world. Before the Faithful fled Númenor and the High King of the Noldor marched out of Lindon, there had been no war in the Queen's dominion for eighty years. There had been no famine for fifty, and no plague for thirty. When the alliance rose, all three came back. The free peoples of Middle-earth fought for their freedom, and for the gift of Ilúvatar, and for the orcs in the thorns, and for a world that would be allowed to change. They paid for it in the lives of a great many people who had not asked to be freed. The historian does not know how to weigh that price. He will set it down as fully as he can, and let the reader try.

Chapter I: The Nine Ships

The war began on Númenor, and it began without the Queen's leave.

For twelve years after the stranger in the grey hat came to the house of Elendil at Rómenna, the Faithful gathered on Elendil's estates and in the western havens of the island, and the Queen let them gather. Míriel, the first of her Nine, with her far-seeing eyes, watched them and reported to her mistress, and her mistress did nothing. She had said that a garden needs a few weeds at the edges. Pharazôn, her Champion, did not agree. He had hated Elendil since the field of the Gwathló, where Elendil had stood unkneeling in the white light while Pharazôn knelt first, and he had hated the Faithful all his life, and he had been passed over for a Ring of Varda while Elendil's daughter received one. In the summer of the seventeen hundred and eightieth year, while the Queen was in the North overseeing the last of the dragon hunts, Pharazôn sailed from the havens of Eriador to Númenor with a company of the Queen's knights, and he went to Rómenna to finish it.

The annals of the Faithful record what he did there, and the historian will not soften it. He came into Rómenna at night with the knights and the lords of the King's Men behind him. He went to the houses of the Faithful one by one. He did not kill them, at first. He proclaimed, in the Queen's name, that the Faithful were traitors to the Dominion, and that their lands were forfeit, and that every Faithful man and woman on the island would be taken to Middle-earth and set to labor in the fields of the Entwives until they learned gratitude. Those who resisted were killed. There were many who resisted. The streets of Rómenna burned for two nights. On the third night, Elendil and his sons Isildur and Anárion, with Arondir the Silvan Elf and every Faithful family that could reach the harbor, went aboard the ships that had lain ready in the western haven for twelve years, and sailed. There were nine ships. They carried perhaps three thousand souls, and the books of the Faithful, and a seedling of the White Tree of Númenor, which Isildur had taken from the king's court at the risk of his life, because the Faithful held that as long as the White Tree lived, the line of the kings would not fail. Pharazôn's ships pursued them for a day and then lost them in a storm. The annals of the Faithful say that the storm came out of the West. They say that it was the first sign in an age that the Valar were still watching.

The Queen learned what Pharazôn had done when she came back from the North, and her anger, the annals of her own court record, was terrible. She summoned him to the green hill in Lothlórien before the whole of her council, and she asked him by whose authority he had burned Rómenna. He said that he had done it by hers. He said that the Faithful had been plotting war against her, and that she had refused to act, and that he had acted for her, as her Champion was bound to do. She told him that he had made a war where there had been none, and that every death in it would be on his head. He said, with great courtesy, that every death in it would be on the heads of the traitors who had started it, and that the Queen's subjects would see it so. He was right about that. The historian sets this exchange down because it marks the moment when the Queen first understood that the peace of her dominion did not depend only on her will. It depended on the wills of everyone she had raised up to keep it. And some of them, like Pharazôn, had wills of their own.

She did not punish him. The historians of the West have argued about why. Some say she could not afford to, because he commanded the hosts of Númenor and Númenor was the greatest of her kingdoms. Some say she did not want to, because some part of her was glad that the thing had been done without her having to do it. The historian of this account inclines to a third view. She did not punish him because the One on her hand did not want her to. Pharazôn was ambitious, and resentful, and hungry for something he had not been given, and the One loved such men. It had been watching him since the night the ninth Ring of Varda was given out. It was not yet ready to let him go.

The nine ships of the Faithful reached Lindon in the autumn. Gil-galad received them at the Grey Havens. He had not spoken to a man of Númenor in eighty years, and the annals of Lindon record that when Elendil came ashore, the High King of the Noldor embraced him, which no one in Lindon had ever seen him do to a mortal. Elendil told him that the war had begun. Gil-galad said that he knew. He said that he had been waiting for someone to begin it for eighty years, and that he had hoped it would be someone else. Behind them, on the quay, Olórin stood with his staff and said nothing, and Círdan stood beside him, and on Círdan's hand, for the first time in eighty years, Narya was burning.

Chapter II: The First Groves

The first blow of the alliance against the Dominion was struck in the spring of the seventeen hundred and eighty-second year, on the eastern bank of the Lune, at the thorn-groves that stood along the road where Sauron's hosts had marched to Eregion. It was a small blow, and a successful one, and the historian has come to believe that it was the most important battle of the whole war. It was the battle in which the alliance learned what it was fighting for, and what it would cost.

The Elves of Lindon crossed the Lune at night, two thousand strong, with the Faithful of Elendil beside them and Olórin among them. They came to the first of the thorn-groves at dawn. It stood beside the road, the tallest of all the groves of Eriador, because it had been the first to be planted, and it was full. A column of orcs had been driven into it the day before. The Elves of Lindon could hear them inside the thorns. They set fire to the grove. Thorn-trees with bark like iron do not burn easily, and it took them most of a day, and the trees screamed as they burned in voices the Entwives would later say were their own. When the grove was ash, the Elves went into it, and found perhaps two hundred orcs still alive among the roots, half-swallowed, too weak to stand. Olórin ordered them freed. Some of the Elves of Lindon refused. They said that the creatures in the roots were orcs, the servants of Morgoth, who had burned Eregion and slain their kin, and that the White Lady was doing nothing to them that they did not deserve. Olórin said that the White Lady was doing nothing to them that she would not one day do to anyone she decided did not deserve to live, and that the alliance would have no reason to exist if it could not see that. The orcs were freed. Most of them died in the following days, because they were too weak to live. The few who survived went east, and the historian will meet them again.

The alliance burned eleven more groves along the Lune in that season, and the Queen's knights did not come to stop them, because the Queen had ordered her hosts not to engage until she could see what the alliance meant to do. What it meant to do became clear by midsummer. The fields of Eriador along the Lune had been planted in the soil the thorn-groves made. Without the groves, the soil began to fail. The second harvest of that year was thin. The third did not come. By the autumn of the seventeen hundred and eighty-second year, for the first time in fifty years, there was hunger in the villages of eastern Eriador, and the Men of those villages, who had eaten the bread of the Dominion all their lives and had never known what it was to go without, did not understand what was happening to them. The Queen's heralds told them. The heralds said that the Elves of Lindon had burned the groves that fed them, and freed the orcs who had burned their grandfathers' steadings, and brought hunger back into the world. Every word of it was true.

The historian has the testimony of a woman of one of those villages, who came West long afterward and told the loremasters of the winter of the seventeen hundred and eighty-second year. She said that her mother had been born in the Dominion and had never been hungry, and that she herself had never been hungry, and that her youngest child had been born that spring. She said that by midwinter there was nothing to feed him. She said that the Queen's riders came in the last week of the winter with bread from Lothlórien and saved the rest of the village, but that they came too late for her son. She said that she had heard the Elves of Lindon say that they were fighting for the gift of Ilúvatar, and that she did not know what a gift was if her son had to die of it. She said that she had never hated anyone in her life until that winter, and that she had hated the Elves of Lindon ever since, and that she still did, and that she had come West anyway because she wanted to tell them so.

The alliance was not ignorant of what it had done. The annals of Lindon and the books of the Faithful both record the council that was held at the Grey Havens at the end of that year, and the historian has read both accounts. Elendil said that they had brought hunger back into the world, and that they must find a way to fight that did not starve the people they meant to free. Gil-galad said that there was no such way: the Queen's bread grew on the Queen's groves, and as long as the groves stood, the orcs would die in them, and as long as the orcs died in them, the alliance could not stop burning them. Durin the Younger, who had come from the Grey Mountains with a thousand of his exiles, said that the Men of Eriador had eaten the bread knowing what it grew on, and that if they went hungry now it was the price of having eaten it. Olórin was silent for a long time. Then he said that Durin was right, and that Elendil was also right, and that this was what made the war hard. He said that it would be easy to fight a war against a Dark Lord who starved the people he ruled. It was not easy to fight a war against a Queen who fed them. He said that the alliance would have to decide, again and again, through the whole of the war, whether the thing it was fighting for was worth what it cost the people who had not asked to be saved. He said that he did not know the answer. He said that he thought the alliance would be better for not knowing it, and worse if it ever stopped asking.

The alliance went on burning the groves. It never stopped asking. It never found an answer.

Chapter III: The Parley at Amon Sûl

In the spring of the seventeen hundred and eighty-fourth year, as the alliance marched east toward the ruins of Eregion and the Queen's hosts gathered to meet it, the Queen asked for a parley. She asked for it in a letter to Elendil, which survives in the books of the Faithful. It said that she would meet with him, and with the High King, and with the grey wanderer who traveled with them, on the hill of Amon Sûl in the North of Eriador, under a truce, with no more than three companions each. It said that she did not want this war, and that she believed they did not want it either. It said that she owed Elendil her life, and that she would hear him before she fought him.

They went. The meeting at Amon Sûl is recorded in three accounts: the books of the Faithful, from Elendil's side; the annals of Lindon, from Gil-galad's; and the testimony of Olórin, who was there. The Queen came with Míriel, Eärien and Celebrimbor's apprentice, an Elf of Lothlórien whose name the accounts do not give. Elendil came with Isildur and Arondir. Gil-galad came with Glorfindel, of whom more will be said in the next chapter. Olórin came alone. They met on the summit of the hill, where there was then no tower, only the bare grass and the wind and the wide lands of Eriador spread out green and gold in every direction under the spring sun. The historian has reconstructed what was said as faithfully as three partisan accounts allow. It is the most important conversation of the war, because it is the only time the two sides of it stood face to face and said what they believed.

The Queen spoke first. She asked them what they wanted. Elendil said that they wanted her to surrender the One Ring to be destroyed, to release the peoples of Middle-earth from her dominion, to free the orcs from the thorn-groves and to let the world go on as it had been meant to go. The Queen asked him what he meant by meant. Elendil said that Ilúvatar had made the world, and given each of its peoples a fate, and that the fate of Men was to live, and grow old, and die, and pass beyond the circles of the world, and that she had no right to hold them back. The Queen said that Ilúvatar had also made the world in which his son died of a fever. She knew about the son. Elendil had lost a son in his youth, long before the war, and he had never spoken of it to anyone outside his family. She said that if Ilúvatar had meant for the boy to die, then she did not think much of what Ilúvatar meant, and she did not think Elendil did either, in his heart. She said that she had stopped the fevers. She asked him whether he would bring them back.

Elendil did not answer her. The books of the Faithful record that he could not, for a time.

Gil-galad answered instead. He said that she had not stopped the fevers out of love. She had stopped them to bind the peoples of Middle-earth to her, so that they would never dare to be free of her for fear of dying. He said that a gift that cannot be refused is not a gift but a chain. The Queen said that the High King of the Noldor had sat behind the line of the Lune for eighty years while the Men of Eriador died of fevers and famines and wars, and that he had never once offered them anything, gift or chain. She said that the Elves had been in Middle-earth since the beginning of days, and that in all that time they had healed no one but themselves, and that they had kept the Three hidden while the world faded because they were afraid of what the rings might cost them. She said that she had not been afraid. She asked him which of them had loved the world more.

Gil-galad did not answer her either. The annals of Lindon do not record his silence. Olórin's testimony does.

Then the Queen turned to Olórin, and asked him what he wanted, and he said that he wanted her to remember who she was. He said that she was Galadriel daughter of Finarfin, and that she had seen the light of the Trees, and that she had hunted the Enemy through the waste places of the world for a thousand years because she had loved her brother. He said that the woman who had done that would not have built the thorn-groves. The Queen said that the woman who had done that had watched her brother die in a cell while she stood chained across the corridor and could do nothing, and that she had sworn she would never be powerless again, and that the thorn-groves were what not being powerless looked like. She said that Olórin had come into Middle-earth as a wanderer, with no memory and no power, and that he had been taken in by the Harfoots, who were starving, and that he had done nothing for them. She said that she had fed them. She asked him who had been the better friend to the Harfoots.

Olórin said that she was right. The books of the Faithful record that Elendil turned to stare at him. Olórin said that she was right about the Harfoots, and about the fevers, and about the Elves who had hidden their rings, and about the High King behind the Lune. He said that she was right about almost everything, and that this was exactly why she was so dangerous. A tyrant who was wrong about everything would have no followers. A tyrant who was right about almost everything would have the whole world kneeling. He said that the thing she was wrong about was the only thing that mattered, and that it was very small. He said it was this: she believed that the world belonged to the people who could save it. And it did not. It belonged to the people who lived in it, even the ones who could not save themselves, even the ones who would choose wrongly, even the ones who would rather be hungry and free than fed and kept. He said that she had taken that choice from them, and that she had done it for their own good, and that this was the oldest temptation in the world. It was the temptation Morgoth had given in to. He said that he did not think she was Morgoth. He thought she was much more dangerous than Morgoth, because Morgoth had never been loved.

The Queen was silent for a long time. Then she said the thing that all three accounts record in nearly the same words, and that the loremasters of Avallónë have argued over ever since. She said: Ask the orcs whether they would rather be free, and see what they tell you. Ask the Men of Eriador whose children died of the hunger you brought them this winter whether they would rather be free. Ask the Harfoots, who never had a choice in their lives until I gave them bread enough to make one. You speak of the people who live in the world as though they were all wise enough to choose, and strong enough to bear the cost of choosing. They are not. Most of them are children. I have made a world in which children do not die. If you want to give them back their freedom, you will have to give them back their graves, and you had better be sure that they will thank you for it.

Olórin said that he was not sure. He said that no one could be sure. He said that this was the difference between them.

The parley ended without agreement. The Queen rose and went down the hill to her escort, and Eärien went with her, and as Eärien passed her father on the summit of Amon Sûl, she stopped, and looked at him. The books of the Faithful record that it was the first time she had looked at him since the field of the Gwathló. She was already shining, a little, with the light of the ring on her hand, and her face was very still. She said: You never looked at me the way you looked at the Elves. She looks at me that way. Then she went down the hill. Elendil did not move until she was out of sight.

Chapter IV: The Lord of the Golden Flower

Before the battle that followed the parley, the historian must say something of the Elf-lord who stood beside the High King on the summit of Amon Sûl, because he will be one of the most important figures in the rest of this history, and because his coming was the only answer the Valar ever gave to the war, before the end.

His name was Glorfindel, and he had died in the First Age. He had been a lord of Gondolin, the hidden city of the Noldor, and when Gondolin fell to the hosts of Morgoth he had held the pass of Cirith Thoronath against a Balrog so that the survivors of the city could escape into the mountains. He had slain the Balrog, and fallen with it from the cliff into the abyss, and died. His spirit had gone to the Halls of Mandos in the West, as the spirits of the slain Elves do. And in the West, in the long years since, he had been healed, and released, and clothed again in a body, and he had lived in the Blessed Realm in peace. Then, in the seventeen hundred and eightieth year of the Second Age, in the summer of the burning of Rómenna, a ship came out of the West to the Grey Havens, the first ship to come from the Blessed Realm to Middle-earth in an age, and Glorfindel stepped off it.

He brought no army. He brought no word of the Valar's will. The annals of Lindon record that Gil-galad asked him, before the whole court, whether the Valar had sent him to aid the free peoples against the Queen, and that he answered that the Valar had sent no one. He said that he had asked to come, and that Manwë had permitted it, and that Manwë had said only that the Valar did not command the Children of Ilúvatar and would not fight their wars for them, as they had fought the last one, because the last time the Valar had fought a war in Middle-earth, a whole country had sunk beneath the sea. Gil-galad asked him whether the Valar knew what was happening in Middle-earth. Glorfindel said that they knew. Gil-galad asked him why they did nothing. Glorfindel said that he had asked Manwë the same question, and that Manwë had said that the Valar had made that mistake before, of deciding what was best for the Children and then making it so, and that the Queen was making it now, and that the Valar would not answer her mistake by making it again.

The historian records this answer because it lies at the heart of the philosophical difficulty of this war. The free peoples were fighting for the right of the Children of Ilúvatar to choose their own fate, even wrongly. The Valar, who could have ended the war in a season, refused to end it, because they believed in that same right, and would not take the choice out of the Children's hands even to save them from the Queen. The alliance was fighting, in other words, for a principle so absolute that the Powers of the world would let the alliance be destroyed rather than violate it. Many in the alliance found this a comfort. Many found it monstrous. Durin the Younger said that the Valar could keep their principles, and that he would keep his axe. Elendil said that he understood the Valar, and that he wished he did not. Olórin, who was himself of the order of the Valar's servants, said nothing at all, and the loremasters of the West have noticed that he never spoke of the Valar's silence in the whole of his testimony.

Glorfindel himself, the annals record, had only one thing to say about it. He said that he had died once fighting a Balrog, and that he had heard there was a Balrog beneath Khazad-dûm, and that he had not come back from the dead to sit in the Havens. He would have his chance at it.

Chapter V: The Battle of the Ruins

The alliance met the Queen's hosts in the ruins of Eregion on the twentieth day of the fifth month of the seventeen hundred and eighty-fourth year. It was the greatest battle fought in Middle-earth since the Gwathló, and the alliance lost it in an afternoon.

The historian has the numbers from the annals of Lindon, and they are not in dispute. The alliance numbered perhaps twenty thousand: the Elves of Lindon under Gil-galad and Glorfindel, the Faithful of Elendil, the Dwarves of Durin the Younger and a few hundred Men of the North who had come to the alliance out of hatred for the thorn-groves. The Queen's hosts numbered more than a hundred thousand: the knights of Númenor under Pharazôn, the horse-lords of Rhûn under Khavra with the star on her hand, the Haradrim under Amaret, the Northmen under Hildrun, the Dunlendings under Cadha, the Dwarves of the kneeling houses under the captains of the stone kings, the Southlanders under Theo son of Bronwyn and, at the center of it all, the Daughters of Varda, shining. And behind them, along the eastern edge of the field where the walls of Ost-in-Edhil had once stood, the Entwives had planted a line of thorn-trees in a single night, and the thorn-trees were hungry.

The battle was fought in the ruins of the city where Elrond had died, and the historian will not describe it at length. It was not a battle so much as a slaughter, and the slaughter went both ways for a time. The Elves of Lindon fought with the fury of a people who had waited eighty years to fight, and the Dwarves of Durin fought with the fury of exiles, and for most of the morning the line of the alliance held. Glorfindel was everywhere. The Faithful remembered afterward that wherever the line was breaking, the lord of the golden flower came, and the line held again. But there were too many of the Queen's hosts, and they were fed and fresh and unafraid, and by midday the line was bending. And then the Daughters of Varda came forward.

The historian has heard the testimony of the alliance's survivors about the Daughters of Varda at the battle of the ruins, and it is the most frightening testimony in the whole of this history. They came forward on foot, all nine of them, walking slowly through the ranks of the Queen's hosts, and the light of their rings went before them. The alliance's soldiers who saw them said that they were beautiful beyond any beauty they had ever seen, and that looking at them was like looking at the sun, and that when they came near, the soldiers of the alliance found that they could not raise their weapons. Not because they were afraid. Because they did not want to. The Daughters of Varda walked through the line of the alliance as through a field of grain, and where they walked, the soldiers of the alliance knelt and wept and let them pass, and the Queen's hosts came behind them and killed the kneeling men where they knelt.

It was at the battle of the ruins that Elendil met his daughter. The books of the Faithful record it, and so does Olórin, who was near. Elendil was rallying the Faithful in the ruins of the great square of Ost-in-Edhil when the light came toward him across the square, and in the heart of the light was Eärien. She was shining. She was beautiful beyond anything he had ever seen. She came toward him across the square with a sword in her hand, and the Faithful around him knelt, one after another, and Elendil stood. He had refused to kneel on the field of the Gwathló, and he refused now. He stood with his sword in his hand and looked at his daughter, and she stopped, a few paces from him, and looked at him. Olórin said that they stood like that for a long time, while the battle raged around them, and that neither of them raised a sword. Then Eärien turned away. Olórin said that her face, as she turned, was as still as marble, and that there were tears on it, and that the tears were shining too.

By mid-afternoon the alliance was broken. Gil-galad ordered the retreat. Glorfindel held the western road out of the ruins with a few hundred Elves of Lindon while the alliance fled toward the Lune. Durin the Younger tried to take his Dwarves back toward the West-gate of Khazad-dûm, which stood within sight of the ruins, and found it closed against him by the captains of his father, who was by then stone to the waist. He turned north instead, toward the Misty Mountains, and took perhaps half of his exiles with him. The other half died in the ruins. The alliance lost more than half its strength that day. The Queen's hosts lost a tenth of theirs. The Queen did not pursue. She stood on the hill above the ruins, where she had stood eighty-seven years before to watch Eregion fall, and watched the alliance go, and her captains asked her why she did not finish it. She said that she did not want to kill them. She wanted them to understand.

Chapter VI: The Fall of Lindon

The alliance went back behind the Lune, and the Queen came after it, slowly, the way a tide comes in. She did not attack Lindon. She surrounded it.

The siege of Lindon lasted six years, from the seventeen hundred and eighty-fifth year to the seventeen hundred and ninetieth, and it was unlike any siege in the history of Middle-earth. The Queen's hosts did not assault the walls. The Entwives planted orchards along the eastern bank of the Lune, from the Blue Mountains to the Sea, and in the orchards the trees bore fruit all year round, and the scent of the fruit came across the river to the Elves and Men behind the walls, who were eating the last of their stores. The fleet of Númenor, under Pharazôn, closed the Gulf of Lune so that no ship could come or go except to the West. And every day, at dawn, the Queen's heralds stood on the eastern bank of the river and called across it, in the tongues of the Elves and of Men, that the gates of the Dominion were open to anyone who would cross, and that anyone who crossed would be fed and healed and welcomed, and that no one would be asked to kneel who did not wish to.

People crossed. The historian must record this, because the annals of Lindon do not. In the six years of the siege, nearly a third of the Men who had fled to Lindon with the alliance crossed the Lune to the Dominion. A fifth of the Faithful of Elendil crossed, families with children who could not bear to watch their children go hungry within sight of the orchards. Even some of the Elves of Lindon crossed, Green-elves and Sindar who had never loved the Noldor and who had lived in the forests of Eriador before the war, and who missed their forests. The Queen's heralds kept their word. Those who crossed were fed and healed and welcomed, and no one asked them to kneel. Many of them knelt anyway. The annals of Lindon call them traitors. The historian has spoken with some of them, in the West, and he does not think the word is fair. They were tired, and hungry, and frightened, and someone had offered them bread. He does not know that he would have done differently.

Lindon fell in the autumn of the seventeen hundred and ninetieth year, not to an assault but to hunger and despair. Gil-galad, seeing that the walls could not be held through another winter, ordered the evacuation of the Havens. Every Elf in Lindon who would go West was to go aboard the ships of Círdan and sail for the Blessed Realm, through the gap the fleet of Númenor had left open, because the Queen had ordered it left open, and the High King believed she had done it so that the Elves would leave Middle-earth to her. He was right. Thousands went. The annals of Lindon record that in the last month of the siege the ships of Círdan sailed from the Grey Havens every day, crowded to the rails, and that the Elves on the quays sang as they went, and that the singing could be heard across the river in the Queen's orchards, and that the Queen's hosts fell silent to listen. The Elves who sailed West in those weeks carried their annals with them, and their testimony. It is from them that the loremasters of Avallónë first learned what was happening in Middle-earth. The Valar heard it too. The historian will say more of that in its place.

Círdan sailed with the last ship. He was the eldest of the Elves in Middle-earth, and he had kept the Havens since the First Age, and he had never once wished to leave them, and the annals of Lindon say that he wept as he went aboard. Before he went, he did a thing that the historians of the West have counted among the most important acts of the war. He took Narya, the Ring of Fire, the red ring that had burned on his hand since the burning of Rómenna, and he gave it to Olórin. The annals of Lindon record his words, which Olórin has confirmed. He said that the ring was meant to kindle hearts in a cold world, and that the world was about to grow very cold for the free peoples, and that Olórin would have more need of it than anyone in the West. Olórin took it. He did not put it on. He wore it on a chain around his neck, beneath his grey robes, and he told the loremasters that for the rest of the war he could feel the One on the other side of it, close, and listening, and that he did not dare to wear it on his hand, because he was afraid of what the One would learn from him if he did.

Gil-galad did not sail. The annals of Lindon say that his counselors begged him to go, and that he refused them all. He said that he was the last High King of the Noldor in Middle-earth, and that if the Noldor were leaving Middle-earth to her, then someone of the Noldor had to stay and tell her she was wrong. He went east with what was left of the alliance, perhaps eight thousand Elves and Men, with Vilya locked in a casket in his baggage, across the Blue Mountains by the northern passes, while the Queen's hosts came into the empty Havens behind them. The Queen did not burn Lindon. She planted it. Within ten years the Grey Havens were a garden, and the great hall of Gil-galad was overgrown with flowering vines, and the Entwives walked on the quays where the ships of Círdan had sailed.

Chapter VII: The Supper in the Old Forest

In the seventeen hundred and ninety-second year, while the alliance was wandering in the wild lands north of Eriador and the Queen's dominion stretched unbroken from the Blue Mountains to the Misty Mountains, the Queen went to the Old Forest.

It was the one place in Eriador she had not touched. Three armies of Mordor had gone into it in the war against Sauron and not come out, and the Queen had ordered it left alone, and for ninety years it had been left alone, an island of wild forest in the middle of her orchards. Its trees were older than her orchards and did not bear fruit, and its paths shifted and its river ran where it pleased, and at its heart, it was said, there lived a master who could not be frightened or bargained with or killed. The Queen had never met him. Celebrimbor said that she had been thinking about him for a long time, and that she went to the Old Forest because she could not bear that there was something in Eriador that did not know her name.

She went alone. She left her escort at the eaves of the forest and walked in, in white, with the One and Nenya on her hand and the light of them going before her. The trees drew back from her path, the Silvan Elves of her escort said afterward, and then closed behind her. She was gone for three days. When she came out, she would not speak of what had happened for a long time. She told Celebrimbor, a year later, in the forge beneath the green hill, and he told the loremasters, and the historian sets it down here because it is the strangest episode in the whole history of the Queen, and because the loremasters of Avallónë have never decided what it means.

She said that she walked into the forest for most of a day, and that the forest tried to lose her and could not, and that in the evening she came to a house by a river, with a garden of lilies before it, and that a man came out of the house to meet her, singing. He was a small man, she said, with a brown beard and a blue jacket and yellow boots and a battered hat with a feather in it, and he was singing nonsense, and he did not stop singing when he saw her. She stood before him in the full light of her rings, the light that had brought the host of Númenor to its knees on the field of the Gwathló and made the soldiers of the alliance weep and let the Daughters of Varda pass. He looked at her, and laughed, and said that she was very bright and must be tired from carrying all that light about, and asked her whether she would like some supper.

She said that she was so astonished that she said yes. He took her into his house, where a woman with golden hair whom he called the River-daughter set out bread and honey and cream and berries on the table, and he talked to her all through supper about lilies. She said that she tried to tell him who she was. She said that she told him she was the mistress of the One Ring and the Queen of Middle-earth and the conqueror of the Dark Lord, and that he nodded and said that was very fine, and asked whether she had seen the water-lilies on the Withywindle, which were very fine this year. She said that she took the One off her hand and showed it to him. He held out his hand for it, and she gave it to him, she did not know why, and he put it on his finger, and nothing happened. He did not vanish. He did not change. He looked at it for a moment and laughed and gave it back to her, and said that it was a pretty thing, but heavy, and that he did not know why anyone would want to carry it about. She said that it was the only time since the field of the Gwathló that she had not been wearing the Ring, and that for the space of perhaps a minute, while it was on his finger and not on hers, she had felt something she could not describe. Celebrimbor asked her what it was. She said that it had felt like being able to breathe.

She stayed three days. She said that on the second day she saw orc-children playing by the river. There were five or six of them, the young of a clan that had fled the thorn-groves of the southern Shire-land the year before and had come into the Old Forest because there was nowhere else to go. The master of the house had taken them in. He fed them, and let them play by his river, and sang to them, and did not seem to think that there was anything strange about it. She said that she asked him whether he knew what they were. He said that they were children, and hungry, and that he fed whatever came to his door hungry, Elves or Men or badgers or orcs, and always had. She said that she told him that the creatures by the river were the seed of Morgoth, and that they would grow up to burn and kill. He said that perhaps they would and perhaps they would not, and that it was not his business to decide, and that it was not hers either, though she seemed to think it was. She asked him whose business it was. He laughed, and said that he did not know, and that he had never needed to know, and that this was why he was the master of his forest and she was the servant of her ring.

She told Celebrimbor that she had wanted to kill him for that. She said that she had stood in his garden on the third morning with her hand on her sword and the One burning on her finger, and that the Ring had wanted her to kill him more than it had ever wanted anything, and that she had not been able to do it. Not because her hand would not move, as it had not moved on the field of the Gwathló. Because she had understood, standing in his garden, that if she drew her sword, he would laugh at her, and that she could not bear it. She had left that morning. She had ordered the Old Forest left alone, forever, and she had never gone back.

The historians of the West have argued about what the master of the Old Forest meant, in the history of the Queen. Some say that he was the proof that her power had limits. Some say that he was the proof that there was a third way, neither ruling the world nor fighting for it, but simply living in it, and feeding whatever came to the door. Olórin, asked about him, said that the master of the Old Forest was the only being in Middle-earth who was entirely free, and that he was free because he wanted nothing, and that this was a freedom neither the Queen nor the alliance could ever have, because they both wanted the world to be a particular way. He said that he envied him. He said that he did not think he could live as he lived, and that he did not think anyone could, except him. And he said that the master of the Old Forest had been right about one thing, and the Queen and the alliance had both been wrong about it: it was not anyone's business to decide what the orc-children by the river would become. The Queen had decided they would become monsters, and had killed them. The alliance had decided they did not matter, and had let her. Only the master of the Old Forest had fed them and waited to see.

The orc-children grew up in the Old Forest, the loremasters have learned from later testimony. They did not burn or kill. They lived by the river, and fished, and sang the songs the master of the house had taught them, and when the Queen's orchards pressed against the eaves of the forest in the long years of the Dominion, they stayed inside it and were not found.

Chapter VIII: The War of the Trees

The Ents went to war in the seventeen hundred and ninety-fifth year. It had taken Treebeard six years to decide, and another six to rouse the others, and by the time the Ents came out of the forests west of the Misty Mountains, the alliance had already lost Lindon. They came out anyway. They came out because the Entwives had planted a thorn-grove at the southern eaves of the forest of Fangorn, where the Ents had lived since the world was young, and because the Ents had heard what was in it.

The War of the Trees, as the Ents themselves name it in the long songs they have since sung of it, was the strangest war in the history of Middle-earth, and the saddest, because it was a war between husbands and wives. The Ents and the Entwives had been estranged for an age, since the Entwives went east over the Anduin to tend their gardens and the Ents stayed in the wild forests of the west. But they had never stopped loving each other. Treebeard said to Olórin once that in all the long ages of the estrangement, there had not been a day when he did not think of Fimbrethil, his wife, who walked in the gardens beyond the river. And now Fimbrethil was in the golden wood, at the Queen's side, planting thorn-groves along the roads of Eriador, and Treebeard was marching to burn them.

The Ents did not burn them, in the end. They tore them up. The Ents are the shepherds of the trees, and they understand trees as no other creatures do, and they knew that the thorn-trees of the Entwives were not true trees but something the Entwives had made, with the Queen's power, out of the art they had always had. They went into the groves along the southern eaves of Fangorn and pulled up the thorn-trees by the roots, one by one, with their great hands, and the trees screamed, and the orcs in the roots were freed. Some of the orcs were alive. Most were not. The Ents carried the living ones out of the groves and set them down at the edge of the forest and went back for more, and the orcs, who had never in their lives been carried by anyone, did not understand what was happening to them. Many of them fled east. The historian will meet them again.

The Entwives came to defend their groves. They came out of Eriador and up the valley of the Isen, perhaps a hundred of them, with the Queen's knights behind them, and the Ents met them at the southern eaves of Fangorn in the autumn of the seventeen hundred and ninety-sixth year. The battle lasted three days. It was fought in the slow, terrible way of the Ents and the Entwives, with roots and branches and stones, and with songs that made the earth shake. The Queen's knights, the testimony of the survivors says, did not dare to enter it. They stood at the edge of the field and watched the shepherds of the trees and the gardeners of the earth tear each other apart, and they did not understand what they were seeing, and neither did anyone else.

On the third day, Treebeard found Fimbrethil. The songs of the Ents record it. He found her at the edge of a thorn-grove she had planted herself, singing to the thorns, and she was so changed that at first he did not know her. Her bark had grown hard and dark and thorned like the trees she planted, and her eyes, which had been green as new leaves, were the silver of the Queen's rings. But her voice was the same. Treebeard said that he would have known her voice at the end of the world. He stood before her and called her name, and she stopped singing and looked at him, and the songs of the Ents say that for a long moment she knew him. Then she told him to go away. She said that the Queen was making the world into a garden, as the Entwives had always wanted, and that the Ents had always been too slow and too wild to understand it, and that if he loved her, he would put down his anger and come and help. He said that he had seen what the garden grew on. She said that every garden grows on something. She turned back to her thorns. Treebeard went back to the forest. The songs of the Ents say that he did not speak again for a year, and that when he did, it was only to say that she had been right about one thing: every garden grows on something. He said that the question was whether you had asked it first.

The Ents won the War of the Trees, in the sense that the Entwives withdrew to Eriador and the forest of Fangorn was never touched by the Queen's thorn-groves. They lost it in every other sense. The Entwives never came back to them. In the long years of the Dominion that followed, the Ents grew fewer and slower and sadder, and more of them grew treeish, standing silent in the deep forest and never moving again. The Queen did not send her hosts into Fangorn. She did not need to. The Ents were dying of grief, and she was patient.

Chapter IX: The Greenwood and the Edge of the World

In the eighteen hundredth year, the Queen sent the Entwives to the eaves of Greenwood the Great.

The Silvan Elves of Oropher had refused the Queen's peace for eighty years. They had refused her bread and her protection and her envoys, and they had told her that their forest did not wish to be tended. She had let them be. But the War of the Trees had shown her that the wild forests of Middle-earth were the alliance's refuges, and the alliance was wandering in the wild lands north of Eriador, and there was talk among her captains that Gil-galad meant to bring what was left of his host east, over the Misty Mountains, into the Greenwood. She sent the Entwives to the eaves of the forest with the Queen's knights behind them, and an order to Oropher that his forest would be tended now, whether he wished it or not.

Oropher fought. The annals of the Silvan Elves are few, but those that came West are clear on this. He gathered every Silvan Elf of the Greenwood who could bear a bow, and he met the Entwives at the western eaves of the forest, and for four years he held them. The thorn-trees could not take root in the shade of the great oaks, and the Queen's knights could not follow the Silvan Elves along the paths of the forest, and the Entwives, for the first time, were afraid. Then the Queen sent the Daughters of Varda. Khavra and Hildrun came into the Greenwood with the light of their rings going before them, and the Silvan Elves who saw them could not raise their bows, and the Entwives planted their thorns in the light, where the shade could not reach them. Oropher fell at the western eaves of his forest in the eighteen hundred and fourth year, defending the oak beneath which he had been crowned. His son Thranduil led what was left of the Silvan Elves east, through the forest, away from the thorns, and came out on the far side of the Greenwood, on the edge of the wide lands east of the Anduin, with perhaps three thousand of his people and nowhere to go.

He met Pallando there. The Blue Wizard had come out of the far East to meet him, the annals of the Avari say, because he had seen the light of the Daughters of Varda in the Greenwood from a hundred leagues away. And with Pallando came an Elf whom Thranduil had never seen, an Elf of a kind that no Elf of the Greenwood had seen since the beginning of days. He was tall, and dark-haired, and his eyes had never seen the light of the Trees, and he spoke an Elvish so old that Thranduil could barely understand it. He said that his name was Morwë, and that he was the eldest of the Avari, the Unwilling, who had refused the summons of the Valar at Cuiviénen and had lived in the East ever since. He said that he had watched the quarrels of the Noldor from the edge of the world for an age, and had never once joined them. He said that he had come to join this one.

The historians of the West have recorded Morwë's reasons, because Pallando reported them to Olórin and Olórin reported them to the loremasters. Morwë said that the Avari had refused the Valar because they did not wish to be ruled by anyone, even the Powers of the world, even for their own good. He said that they had paid for that refusal with an age of darkness at the edge of the world, and that they had never regretted it. He said that the Queen of the West was offering the Avari what the Valar had offered them at Cuiviénen: light, and safety, and a garden, if only they would let her rule them. He said that the Avari had refused it once, and that they would refuse it again. He said that he did not much care for the Noldor, or for the Faithful of Númenor, or for the Dwarves of Durin, and that he did not think the alliance would win. He said that the Avari would fight beside it anyway, because it was the only thing in the West that was saying no.

Thranduil asked him how many of the Avari would come. Morwë said that it would take some time to persuade them, because the Avari did not hurry, and they did not trust anyone. He said that it might take forty years. Thranduil said that the alliance might not last forty years. Morwë said that the Avari had been waiting since the beginning of the world, and that they had found that most things lasted longer than anyone expected. He was right. It took them fifty years. They came at the very end, when they were needed most, and when the alliance had almost forgotten that they had promised to come.

The historian records here a dispute among the loremasters of Avallónë about the Avari, because it touches the philosophical heart of this book. Some of the loremasters hold that the Avari were the purest of the alliance's members, because they alone had never been ruled by anyone, and they alone were fighting for nothing but the right to say no. Others hold that the Avari were the most dangerous of the alliance's members, for the same reason. A people who would refuse the light of the Trees rather than be ruled would refuse anything, they say, and would follow no one, and would build nothing. They had spent an age at the edge of the world refusing, and in all that age they had made nothing that anyone remembered. The Queen, whatever else she was, had made a garden. The Avari had made only a refusal. Olórin, asked about this dispute, said that both sides of it were right. He said that a world in which no one ever said no would be the Queen's world. And a world in which everyone always said no would be a world in which nothing was ever built. The free peoples, he said, had to live somewhere between the two, and they would never agree on where. He said that the disagreement was the point. He said that the Queen's world was the only world in which there were no disagreements, and that this was the most frightening thing about it.

Chapter X: The Lord of Gondolin and the Fire Beneath the Mountain

In the eighteen hundred and fifteenth year, the alliance tried to cross the Misty Mountains.

It had been wandering in the wild lands north of Eriador for twenty-five years, since the fall of Lindon. It had grown, slowly, as the exiles of the Dominion came to it: the Faithful who fled Númenor in the years after the burning of Rómenna, the Dwarves who would not kneel, the Men of the North who hated the thorn-groves, the few orcs who had been freed from the groves by the alliance and the Ents and who had nowhere else to go. The alliance did not know what to do with the orcs. Many of its soldiers would not march beside them. Olórin insisted that they be fed and sheltered, and the alliance fed and sheltered them, and did not trust them, and the orcs did not trust the alliance, and the historian has the testimony of one of them, a young orc named Grishak who came West in the very last days of the war, who said that the alliance had treated him better than the Queen and worse than anyone should treat anyone, and that he had never decided whether to be grateful.

By the eighteen hundred and fifteenth year, the alliance numbered perhaps fifteen thousand, and it could no longer live in the wild lands north of Eriador, because the Queen's orchards had pressed north to the very edge of the Ettenmoors. Gil-galad decided to take it east, over the Misty Mountains by the Redhorn Pass, into the lands east of the Anduin, where Thranduil and the Silvan Elves were waiting and the Queen's dominion was thinnest. The Queen learned of it through Míriel's far-seeing eyes. And for the first time since she had bound it, she called the Balrog.

It came up out of the deep places beneath Khazad-dûm, through the mines and the great halls where the stone kings sat on their thrones, and out through the East-gate, and up onto the Redhorn Pass in a storm of fire and shadow, and it met the alliance at the summit of the pass, where the road ran narrow between the cliffs. The alliance's vanguard broke before it. Hundreds of the alliance's soldiers died in the first hour. The rest fell back down the western road, and the Balrog came after them, and it would have destroyed the whole host of the alliance on the western slopes of the Redhorn if Glorfindel had not stood in the road.

The historian has the testimony of the Faithful who saw it, and of Durin the Younger, who was near, and of Olórin, who was nearer. They say that Glorfindel stood alone in the narrow road with his sword in his hand and the light of the Blessed Realm about him, and that the Balrog stopped before him, and that the two of them stood facing each other for a long moment, the Balrog in its fire and shadow and the lord of Gondolin in his light. Olórin said that the Balrog knew him. It had been in Gondolin, in the First Age, and it had seen him fall from the cliff of Cirith Thoronath with its kinsman in his arms. And Glorfindel knew it. He said something to it, Olórin said, in a tongue that only the Maiar and the dead would understand. Then the Balrog raised its whip of flame, and Glorfindel raised his sword, and they fought.

They fought for most of a day on the summit of the Redhorn Pass. The historian will not describe the fight, because no one who saw it could. The Faithful said that it was like watching the sun fight the night. Durin said that the mountain itself shook. Olórin said only that it was the greatest single combat he had seen in Middle-earth since the First Age, and that he did not think either of them could win it. Neither of them did. At sunset, with both of them wounded and the snow of the pass burned black for a league around them, the Balrog suddenly lowered its whip and turned and went back down the eastern road toward Khazad-dûm, and the alliance's soldiers who saw it said that it moved as though it had been called. Glorfindel did not follow. He sank down in the burned snow with his sword across his knees, and Durin and Olórin went to him, and he said that he had very nearly had it. He said that next time he would.

The historians of the West have argued about why the Queen called the Balrog back. Some say she was afraid of losing it. Some say she did not want to destroy the alliance, only to turn it back from the pass, which she had done. Olórin, asked about it, said that he had felt the One on the other side of Narya that night, warm and attentive, and that he believed the Queen had called the Balrog back because the One had told her to. He said that the One had seen Glorfindel on the Redhorn, and had seen what Glorfindel was, a lord of the Elves come back from the dead, wearing the light of the Blessed Realm, and that the One had wanted to keep him alive. He said that he did not know why. The historian, who knows how this history ends, does.

The alliance did not cross the Redhorn Pass. It went north instead, the long way, around the northern end of the Misty Mountains past the burned ruins of Gundabad, and came down into the vales of the upper Anduin in the eighteen hundred and seventeenth year, where Thranduil and the Silvan Elves were waiting. It had lost three thousand of its soldiers on the Redhorn. It had also learned that the Queen's Balrog could be met and held, and that there was one Elf in Middle-earth who could hold it, and the soldiers of the alliance began to say that they had a champion. The historian records this, because the soldiers were right. They had a champion. And the Queen knew it. And so did the Ring.

Chapter XI: The Harfoots Who Would Not Be Freed

When the alliance came down into the vales of the upper Anduin, it came into the country of the Harfoots, and the historian must record what happened there, because the annals of the alliance have tried to forget it.

The Harfoots had stopped wandering in the years of the Dominion. They had built holes in the green hills along the Anduin, with round doors and gardens, and they had eaten the bread of the Dominion every day for a hundred years, and they had grown strong and plump and contented, and they had never once been hungry. They loved the Queen. They did not know much about her. They knew that she was the Lady of the golden wood, and that she had given them bread, and that before her coming they had starved, and that since her coming they had not. When the alliance came into their country, ragged and hungry and carrying its wounded, the Harfoots took it in, because the Harfoots had always taken in strangers, since the days when they had found a man in a fallen star. They fed the alliance. They nursed its wounded. And then they asked it what it was doing there.

Olórin told them. He had lived among the Harfoots once, long ago, before he knew who he was, and he loved them, and he told them the truth. He told them that the Lady of the golden wood had the Ring of the Dark Lord, and that she was using it to rule the world, and that the bread they ate grew on the bones of orcs, and that the alliance was fighting to take the Ring from her and destroy it and give the world back its freedom. The Harfoots listened politely. When he was finished, an old Harfoot woman named Poppy Proudfellow, who had known Olórin when he was the stranger and had been a girl in the Harfoot caravans when they were still hungry, asked him a question. She asked him what the Harfoots would eat, when the world had its freedom back.

Olórin did not answer her. The historian has his testimony, and he says that he could not.

The alliance stayed in the country of the Harfoots for a season, resting, and in that season some of the Harfoots began to send messages to the golden wood. They did not mean any harm. They were frightened. They had heard what Olórin told them, and they believed that the alliance meant to take away the Lady's bread, and they believed that if the Lady's bread were taken away, their children would starve as their grandparents had starved. They sent word to the Queen of where the alliance was camped, and how many it numbered, and where its wounded lay. The Queen's knights came in the autumn of the eighteen hundred and eighteenth year. The alliance escaped across the Anduin with most of its strength, because Thranduil's scouts saw the knights coming, but it lost its wounded, who could not be moved. The Queen's knights did not kill them. They carried them to Lothlórien and healed them, and offered them bread, and most of them took it.

The annals of the alliance call the Harfoots traitors. Olórin does not. He told the loremasters that the Harfoots had done exactly what anyone would do, which was to protect their children from the thing they feared most, and that the thing they feared most was hunger, because they remembered it, and the alliance had never given them any reason to fear anything else. He said that the alliance had come into their country and told them that it would take away their bread for the sake of a freedom they had never asked for and did not understand, and that the Harfoots had chosen bread. He said that he did not think they had chosen wrongly. He said that he did not think they had chosen rightly either. He said that this was what the Queen had done to the world: she had made it so that every choice was a choice between bread and freedom, and that most people, when you made them choose between bread and freedom, would choose bread. He said that this was not because they were wicked. It was because they were hungry, or remembered being hungry, and the Queen knew it. He said that the Dark Lord had never understood this. The Queen understood it perfectly.

The historian adds only that Poppy Proudfellow came West in the very last days of the war, as a servant of the alliance, and that she told the loremasters of Avallónë that she had been one of the Harfoots who sent word to the golden wood, and that she had never regretted it, and that she had joined the alliance afterward anyway. The loremasters asked her why. She said that she had watched the Queen's knights carry the alliance's wounded to the golden wood, and that she had seen one of the wounded, a young man of the Faithful, look back at the Harfoot holes as he was carried away, and that he had not looked angry. He had looked sorry for them. She said that she had not been able to stop thinking about it. She said that she still did not know what she thought about freedom, but that she had decided she would rather be on the side of the people who were sorry for her than the side of the people who were sure of her.

Chapter XII: The Oath at Erech

In the eighteen hundred and twenty-third year, Isildur son of Elendil went south into the White Mountains, alone, to ask the Men of the mountains for help.

The Men of the White Mountains were a strange people, old and proud, who had lived in the valleys of the mountains since before the Edain came into the West. They had served the Dark Lord once, in the war against Eriador, because their king's kinsman had worn one of the Nine, and they had been ashamed of it ever since. When the Queen destroyed the Nine on the Withered Heath, their king had sent his daughter Meneth to Lothlórien as a pledge of his people's loyalty, and Meneth had received one of the Rings of Varda, and the Men of the mountains had been the Queen's subjects for a hundred years. They ate her bread. They sent their sons to her hosts. And they were not happy, because they had served one master already and been ashamed of it, and they did not trust masters.

Isildur came to them because Olórin had told him that the Men of the mountains were the only people in the South who had not knelt gladly, and because the alliance needed a foothold south of the mountains, near the havens of the Faithful at Pelargir, where the remnant of the Faithful who had fled Númenor after the burning of Rómenna were still holding out. He came to the king of the mountains at Erech, where there was a great black stone that the Men of the mountains held sacred, and he asked them to swear to the alliance. The king said that his daughter wore the Queen's ring. Isildur said that his sister wore the Queen's ring too, and that so did the woman he had loved, and that he was asking anyway. The king said that his people had sworn themselves to the Dark Lord once, and to the Queen since, and that they would not swear themselves to anyone a third time unless they could be sure that the oath would be kept on both sides. Isildur said that he would keep it. He said that if the Men of the mountains swore to him, he would be their lord, and that he would never ask them to fight for anything he did not fight for himself, and that he would never kneel to the Queen while they followed him.

The king of the mountains swore. He swore on the black stone of Erech, with his lords and his people around him, that the Men of the White Mountains would follow Isildur son of Elendil and fight beside him against the Queen until the end. And Isildur swore too, on the same stone, that he would never kneel to her. The historians of the West have recorded both oaths, because both would be tested. One of them would be kept. The historian, who knows how this history ends, would give a great deal to be able to say that it was Isildur's.

Meneth, the king's daughter, was in Lothlórien when her father swore. The historians of the West have the testimony of Celebrimbor, who saw her when the news came. He said that she stood on the green hill with the light of her ring about her, very still, and that the Queen came to her and asked her whether she wished to go to her father. Meneth said that she did not. She said that her father had chosen the alliance and she had chosen the Queen, and that this was what freedom was, and that the Queen should be glad of it. Celebrimbor said that the Queen looked at her for a long moment and then said that she was glad of it. He said that he did not think she was lying. He said that he had begun, by then, to be unable to tell.

Chapter XIII: The Champion

In the eighteen hundred and thirty-fifth year, Pharazôn came to the green hill in Lothlórien to take the Ring.

He had been the Queen's Champion for a hundred and thirty-five years. He had commanded her hosts at the battle of the ruins and the siege of Lindon. He had burned Rómenna, and she had not punished him. He had won her every victory in the War of the Weeds, and she had not given him a ring. He had grown old, for a Númenórean, though the bread of the Dominion had slowed his aging, and he had watched the Daughters of Varda shine at her side, young forever, while he went grey. And in the last years, the annals of her court record, the Queen had stopped consulting him. The alliance was broken and wandering in the wild lands east of the Anduin. The Dominion was secure. She no longer needed a Champion. She no longer needed the human face of her rule, because her rule no longer needed to be made palatable to anyone. Pharazôn saw this. He was not a stupid man. He had been the cleverest man in Númenor for three hundred years, and he understood, at last, that he had been used. He had knelt first on the field of the Gwathló because he had believed that he was using her. He had been wrong from the beginning.

The One knew it too. The historians of the West have pieced together, from the testimony of Celebrimbor and from the things the Queen said afterward, what happened in the mind of Pharazôn in the last year of his life. The One began to speak to him. It had been watching him since the night the ninth Ring of Varda was given out, and it had kept him alive when the Queen might have punished him, and now it began to tell him things. It told him that the Queen was weak. It told him that she was a woman of the Elves, sentimental and doubtful, who lay awake at night and wept for Elrond and called the Balrog back from the Redhorn when she might have won. It told him that he was a man of Númenor, of the line of Elros, a king's son, and that he would know how to use the Ring as she had never dared to use it. It told him that if he took it from her, he would never grow old again. It told him that the Queen's beauty was a trick, and that if he looked at her without fear, he would see through it. He believed it. The historian thinks he wanted to believe it more than he had ever wanted anything.

He came to the green hill on a spring evening, alone, with a knife hidden in his sleeve. The Queen was sitting under the golden trees at the summit of the hill, and she looked up as he came, and the historians of the West have the testimony of Celebrimbor, who was there, that she smiled at him as though she had been expecting him. She had. Míriel had seen the One's voice in him, a darkness in the light of his spirit, weeks before. The Queen had done nothing about it. She had waited. Celebrimbor said afterward that he did not know whether she had waited because she hoped Pharazôn would change his mind, or because she wanted to see what he would do.

Pharazôn came to her and knelt, as he had knelt on the field of the Gwathló, and as he knelt he drew the knife from his sleeve. And then he looked up at her face.

Celebrimbor was the only witness, and his account is brief. He said that the Queen did not move. She did not raise her hand, or speak, or draw on the power of the rings in any way he could see. She simply looked at Pharazôn, as he knelt before her with the knife in his hand, and let him look at her. And Pharazôn wept. Celebrimbor said that he had never seen a man weep like that. He wept as though everything he had ever wanted had been shown to him and taken away in the same instant. He wept as though he had understood, all at once, how beautiful she was, and how far beyond him, and how small and grey and old he had become, and how he had wasted his whole long life wanting something that he could never have and that would never have wanted him. He wept for a long time, kneeling on the grass with the knife in his hand and his face turned up to hers, and she looked down at him and did nothing. Then he turned the knife on himself. He died with his eyes open, still looking at her, with the tears still streaming down his face.

The Queen did not speak for a long time afterward. When she did, she asked Celebrimbor whether she had done that. He said that he did not know. He asked her whether she had meant to. She said that she did not know either. She said that she had looked at Pharazôn kneeling before her with a knife in his hand and had felt nothing at all, not fear and not anger and not pity, and that the Ring on her hand had been very warm, and that she had felt something go out of her toward him, through her eyes, like light going out of a lamp, and that she had not tried to stop it. She said that she had not known she could do that. She said that she did not think she had done it. She thought the Ring had.

Celebrimbor told the loremasters of Avallónë that this was the moment he understood what the One had made of her. It had taken her beauty, which had been the beauty of the Noldor, the beauty of someone who had seen the light of the Trees, and it had made of it a weapon. She did not need to raise her hand against anyone any longer. She did not need the Balrog, or her hosts, or the Daughters of Varda. She had only to let someone look at her. And the most frightening thing about it, Celebrimbor said, was that she had not chosen it. It had been done to her, and through her, and she had felt nothing while it happened. He said that he had made rings for her for a hundred and twenty years believing that he was helping her save the world. He said that he went back to his forge that night and sat before his anvil until dawn, and did not work, and understood for the first time that he had been helping the Ring.

Her court saw what had happened. Pharazôn's body was found on the green hill in the morning, with the knife in his heart and the tears dried on his face, and no wound on him that anyone had made but himself. The lords of the King's Men, who had followed Pharazôn for three hundred years, came to Lothlórien to bury him, and they looked at the Queen as they came, and none of them could hold her gaze. The historians of the West have recorded that no one at her court ever plotted against her again. Not because they loved her more, though many of them did. Because they were afraid to look at her face.

Míriel went home to Númenor in the summer of the eighteen hundred and thirty-fifth year, and took up the throne that had been hers before Pharazôn, and ruled the island as its queen for the rest of the Dominion. She was shining by then, a pale radiance like moonlight, and her face was very still, and she could see the light inside every living thing on the island. The people of Númenor loved her and feared her, and called her the Witch-Queen when she could not hear, and she always could. She ruled them well. The annals of the Faithful, which came West in the last days of the war, record that there was no crime on Númenor in the years of her reign, and no hunger, and no sickness, and no dissent. They record that there was also no laughter in the streets of Armenelos after dark. The historian does not know whether that was a fair trade. He suspects the people of Númenor did not know either.

Chapter XIV: The Last Free Lands

In the forty years that followed the death of Pharazôn, the alliance lost everything it had.

The historian will not describe each battle, because there were too many, and because they all ended the same way. The alliance would gather in some wild place the Queen had not yet tended, and the Queen's hosts would come, and the Daughters of Varda would walk before them, and the alliance's soldiers would kneel and weep and let them pass, and the alliance would break and flee to some other wild place. The Faithful at Pelargir held out until the eighteen hundred and fortieth year, when the Queen's fleet came up the Anduin from Umbar and the Daughters of Varda came down from the White Mountains, and the havens burned. The remnant of the Faithful fled north up the Anduin to join Elendil. The Men of the White Mountains, who had sworn to Isildur at Erech, fought beside him in the valleys of the mountains for twelve years, until the Queen's hosts came into the valleys and the thorn-groves took root along the rivers, and then they went east with him, because they had sworn to follow him, and they kept their oaths. The Dwarves of Durin held the passes of the Grey Mountains until the eighteen hundred and forty-fifth year, when the Queen's knights, coming back from the last of the dragon hunts, came down on them from the North, and then they went east too. Thranduil and the Silvan Elves held the eastern eaves of the Greenwood until the eighteen hundred and fiftieth year, when the Entwives came through the forest at last, and then they went east as well.

They went east because there was nowhere else to go. The Queen's dominion stretched from the Blue Mountains to the Sea of Rhûn and from the Grey Mountains to the bay of Umbar. Everywhere it stretched, the orchards grew and the thorn-groves stood and the bread of the Dominion fed the Queen's people. There was no wild land left that she had not tended, except two. One was the Old Forest, where the master of the house by the river sang to the orc-children and would not let the alliance in, because he would not take sides. The other was the land east of the Anduin, beyond the mountains of shadow and the mountains of ash, where the mountain of fire stood on the plain of Gorgoroth and nothing grew.

The Queen's power could not reach Mordor. The historians of the West have puzzled over why, and Olórin has given them the best answer they have. He said that the Queen's power was the power of growth and preservation, the power of Nenya joined to the power of the One, and that it worked by making living things grow as she wished them to. But there was nothing living in Mordor. The ash had poisoned the soil for leagues around the mountain. The rivers ran with fire. There was nothing there for her power to take hold of, no seed to make grow, no root to make deep, no living thing to preserve. The Entwives could not plant their thorns in it. The bread of the Dominion could not be grown in it. Even the Daughters of Varda, walking into it with the light of their rings going before them, found that the light did not spread, but hung about them in the ash like a lantern in a fog. Mordor was the one land in Middle-earth the Queen could not tend, because there was nothing in it to tend.

The only green thing that had ever grown there was her garden on the slopes of the Ered Lithui, and that had withered when she left.

In the eighteen hundred and fifty-fifth year, the alliance came to the Black Gate. It had perhaps twelve thousand left: the Elves of Lindon under Gil-galad, with Glorfindel at his side; the Faithful of Elendil, with Isildur and Anárion; the Men of the White Mountains, following Isildur as they had sworn; the Dwarves of Durin and Disa; the Silvan Elves of Thranduil; the few orcs who had been freed from the thorn-groves; and Olórin, with Narya on a chain around his neck. The Ents had not come. They were too slow and too sad. The Avari had not come. They had promised, but they had not come. The alliance stood before the Black Gate in the grey light of an autumn morning, ragged and starving and wounded, and looked at the dead land beyond it, and Gil-galad said that it was a prison. Elendil said that it was the only place left in the world where they could not be found. Olórin said nothing. He was looking at the Dark Tower, on its spur of the mountains, across the plain of Gorgoroth. The historian has his testimony. He said that he could feel the One on the other side of Narya, closer than it had ever been, and warmer, and that it was not on the Queen's hand any longer that he felt it. It was in the Tower. It was in the shadow that lived in the Tower. The One had two masters, and one of them was waiting.

The Black Gate stood open. No one guarded it. The alliance went through it into Mordor, and across the plain of Gorgoroth through the ash, toward the mountains on the far side of the plain where they might make a camp. As they went, they began to see orcs. Not the orcs of the Queen's thorn-groves, half-swallowed and dying, but orcs who were whole, and armed, and watching them from the rocks. There were hundreds of them. Then there were thousands. They did not attack. They came down out of the rocks and stood along the road through the ash and watched the alliance go by, and the alliance's soldiers gripped their weapons and did not know what to do. At the head of the orcs, on a rock above the road, stood a tall figure with a face that had once been the face of an Elf, and the historians of the West have the testimony of Olórin, who recognized him. It was Adar.

He had gathered them. In the hundred and fifty years since the purge of his people in the shadow of the mountain, he had wandered the wild lands east of the Anduin, and gathered every orc who fled the Queen's thorn-groves, band by band and clan by clan, and brought them here, to the only land in Middle-earth where the thorn-groves could not grow. There were more of them than the alliance had imagined. The historians of the West estimate that Adar had gathered perhaps forty thousand orcs in Mordor by the eighteen hundred and fifty-fifth year: the last free orcs in the world, the survivors of the Queen's purges, with their young and their old. They had been living in the ash for a century, eating whatever they could find, and the alliance, which had spent eighty years fighting for them, had never once come to find them.

Adar looked down at the alliance from his rock for a long time. Then he spoke, in the common tongue of the West, so that all of them could hear. The historian has his words from the testimony of Olórin and of several of the alliance's survivors, and they all agree. He said: I told her once that my children had names, and that she would learn them all. She never did. You never did either. Then he turned and pointed across the plain of Gorgoroth toward the Dark Tower, where a light was burning in the highest window, a red light like an eye. He said: But he knows them. He has always known them. He has been waiting for you.

So ended the War of the Weeds, in the eighteen hundred and fifty-fifth year of the Second Age, with the last of the free peoples of the West standing in the ash of the Black Land among the last of the free orcs, under the window of the Dark Tower, with nowhere left to go. They had fought for eighty years for the right of the peoples of Middle-earth to choose their own fate, and they had lost. The world had chosen the Queen. It had chosen her gladly, and for good reasons, and it would not thank anyone who tried to take her away. The alliance knew this. Some of its soldiers had begun to wonder whether the world was right. And now, in the last free land, the only one left who could help them was the one being in the history of Middle-earth whom no one, in any age, had ever been able to trust.

In the next book of this history, they would trust him anyway.

Here ends the fifth book of The Queen Unfading.

 
Read more...

Join the writers on Write.as.

Start writing or create a blog